Barriers and enablers in the management of tuberculosis treatment in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: a qualitative study

Tuberculosis (TB) is an infectious disease which causes about two million deaths each year. In 1993, the World Health Organization (WHO) declared TB to be a “Global Emergency” due to an increasing number of TB cases and a rise in multidrug resistant cases in the developed world. Treatment interruption was considered one of the major challenges. WHO introduced the current TB control program DOTS (directly observed treatment, short course) as the tool to control the disease. To prevent further development of resistance against anti-TB drugs it was decided to observe each patient taking their daily dose of medication. The overall aim of this thesis is to explore how patients and health workers perceive and manage TB symptoms and treatment in a high-endemic and a low-endemic setting in the era of DOT(S). The data is based on fieldwork, including in-depth interviews and focus groups with TB patients and health workers, in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia (2001-2002) and in Oslo/Akershus, Norway (2007-2008). We found that people’s interpretation and management of TB symptoms is influenced by cultural, social and economic factors. TB was, in both contexts, associated with poverty, and subsequently with a disease that affects certain countries or certain segments of a population. TB was viewed as a severe disease in both contexts, but there was variation between individuals to what extent one considered oneself as a likely victim. In the absence of circumstantial causes, such as poverty, patients in a lowendemic setting like Norway, found it difficult to understand why they had developed the disease. There was scarce knowledge about the fact that the disease could be latent. Awareness of early symptoms, such as persistent cough, was low in both contexts. Perceptions of vulnerability, together with the presence or absence of socio-economic barriers or enablers influenced at what time patients would seek help. The study suggests that health personnel lacked awareness or misinterpreted early symptoms of TB. In Ethiopia, lay categorizations of early TB symptoms converged with diagnostic practices in parts of the professional health sector. The diagnostic process could endure for many months after patients’ first contact with the health services. Similarly, in Norway, we found that patients’ interpretations of early symptoms often were confirmed in the meeting with health personnel. The consequences were prolonged diagnostic processes. The study shows that patients’ ability to manage TB treatment is a product of dynamic processes, in which social and economic costs and other burdens interplay over time. A decision to interrupt treatment can be shaped by past struggles and accrued costs; in which seems financially, socially or emotionally unbearable at the moment of treatment interruption. The burdens related to DOT could also be significant, in patients who did not interrupt treatment. Patients in both Ethiopia and Norway experienced an authoritarian and rigid practice of DOT, which made it difficult to simultaneously attend to demands related to treatment and demands related to other areas of life. The most vulnerable patients, such as those without permanent jobs, suffered from high economic, social and emotional costs. In conclusion, health personal need more knowledge about typical and atypical symptoms of TB. In low-endemic settings doctors need to be trained to adjust their level of suspicion to the migration history of the patient. In high-endemic settings one should be aware that health personnel may understand and manage TB within a traditional perspective. Patients in both high- and low-endemic contexts need concrete information about the cause of TB, how it is transmitted, how symptoms can be manifested, how the disease can progress and how it can be cured. The study indicates that inequalities that predispose for TB may be reinforced in the patient’s interaction with the health services due to a rigid, disempowering practice of DOT. Subsequently, DOT per se may add to the chain of structural barriers that patients have to overcome to access and complete treatment. To ensure that TB patients complete treatment one must address the coexisting and interacting crises that follow a TB diagnosis. This could require TB programs to adopt a more holistic approach. Measures that secure early diagnosis may reduce some of the physical, psycho-social and economic costs patients face while undergoing treatment. Measures that empower patients to participate in their own health care may avoid disempowering and humiliating practices

Impact of Socioeconomic Status, Race and Ethnicity, and Geography on Prenatal Detection of Hypoplastic Left Heart Syndrome and Transposition of the Great Arteries

BackgroundPrenatal detection (PND) has benefits for infants with hypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS) and transposition of the great arteries (TGA), but associations between sociodemographic and geographic factors with PND have not been sufficiently explored. This study evaluated whether socioeconomic quartile (SEQ), public insurance, race and ethnicity, rural residence, and distance of residence (distance and driving time from a cardiac surgical center) are associated with the PND or timing of PND, with a secondary aim to analyze differences between the United States and Canada.MethodsIn this retrospective cohort study, fetuses and infants <2 months of age with HLHS or TGA admitted between 2012 and 2016 to participating Fetal Heart Society Research Collaborative institutions in the United States and Canada were included. SEQ, rural residence, and distance of residence were derived using maternal census tract from the maternal address at first visit. Subjects were assigned a SEQ z score using the neighborhood summary score or Canadian Chan index and separated into quartiles. Insurance type and self-reported race and ethnicity were obtained from medical charts. We evaluated associations among SEQ, insurance type, race and ethnicity, rural residence, and distance of residence with PND of HLHS and TGA (aggregate and individually) using bivariate analysis with adjusted associations for confounding variables and cluster analysis for centers.ResultsData on 1862 subjects (HLHS: n=1171, 92% PND; TGA: n=691, 58% PND) were submitted by 21 centers (19 in the United States). In the United States, lower SEQ was associated with lower PND in HLHS and TGA, with the strongest association in the lower SEQ of pregnancies with fetal TGA (quartile 1, 0.78 [95% CI, 0.64-0.85], quartile 2, 0.77 [95% CI, 0.64-0.93], quartile 3, 0.83 [95% CI, 0.69-1.00], quartile 4, reference). Hispanic ethnicity (relative risk, 0.85 [95% CI, 0.72-0.99]) and rural residence (relative risk, 0.78 [95% CI, 0.64-0.95]) were also associated with lower PND in TGA. Lower SEQ was associated with later PND overall; in the United States, rural residence and public insurance were also associated with later PND.ConclusionsWe demonstrate that lower SEQ, Hispanic ethnicity, and rural residence are associated with decreased PND for TGA, with lower SEQ also being associated with decreased PND for HLHS. Future work to increase PND should be considered in these specific populations