Influence of Short-Term Glucocorticoid Therapy on Regulatory T Cells In Vivo

Background: Pre- and early clinical studies on patients with autoimmune diseases suggested that induction of regulatory T(Treg) cells may contribute to the immunosuppressive effects of glucocorticoids(GCs). Objective: We readdressed the influence of GC therapy on Treg cells in immunocompetent human subjects and naı¨ve mice. Methods: Mice were treated with increasing doses of intravenous dexamethasone followed by oral taper, and Treg cells in spleen and blood were analyzed by FACS. Sixteen patients with sudden hearing loss but without an inflammatory disease received high-dose intravenous prednisolone followed by stepwise dose reduction to low oral prednisolone. Peripheral blood Treg cells were analyzed prior and after a 14 day GC therapy based on different markers. Results: Repeated GC administration to mice for three days dose-dependently decreased the absolute numbers of Treg cells in blood (100 mg dexamethasone/kg body weight: 2.861.86104 cells/ml vs. 336116104 in control mice) and spleen (dexamethasone: 2.861.96105/spleen vs. 956226105/spleen in control mice), which slowly recovered after 14 days taper in spleen but not in blood. The relative frequency of FOXP3+ Treg cells amongst the CD4+ T cells also decreased in a dose dependent manner with the effect being more pronounced in blood than in spleen. The suppressive capacity of Treg cells was unaltered by GC treatment in vitro. In immunocompetent humans, GCs induced mild T cell lymphocytosis. However, it did not change the relative frequency of circulating Treg cells in a relevant manner, although there was some variation depending on the definition of the Treg cells (FOXP3+: 4.061.5% vs 3.461.5%*; AITR+: 0.660.4 vs 0.560.3%, CD127low: 4.061.3 vs 5.063.0%* and CTLA4+: 13.8611.5 vs 15.6612.5%; * p,0.05). Conclusion: Short-term GC therapy does not induce the hitherto supposed increase in circulating Treg cell frequency, neither in immunocompetent humans nor in mice. Thus, it is questionable that the clinical efficacy of GCs is achieved by modulating Treg cell numbers

Regulatory T-cells and glucocorticoids – in healthy humans and in patients with adrenocortical carcinoma

Das Nebennierenkarzinom ist eine seltene Erkrankung mit einer limitierten Prognose. Bei zahlreichen Tumorentitäten wurde gezeigt, dass das Immunsystem entscheidenden Einfluss auf den Erkrankungsverlauf und die Prognose hat. Aufgrund der geringen Prävalenz gab es entsprechende Studien beim Nebennierenkarzinom bisher nicht. Dabei lag die Vermutung nahe, dass die Interaktion Tumor - Immunsystem beim Nebennierenkarzinom besonders ausgeprägt ist, da dieses häufig Glukokortikoide sezerniert, die bekanntermaßen stark die unterschiedlichen Immunzellen beeinflussen. Im ersten Teil der Arbeit zeigte sich, dass Patienten mit Nebennierenkarzinom (n=163) im Vergleich zu gesunden Probanden (n=19) eine signifikant erhöhte Frequenz regulatorischer T-Zellen im peripheren Blut aufweisen (9,25% vs. 4,4%). Das Ausmaß des Glukokortikoid-Exzesses dagegen hatte keinen signifikanten Einfluss auf die Anzahl dieser Immunzellen. Bezogen auf die Prognose war eine größere Anzahl regulatorischer T-Zellen im Blut mit einer schlechteren Prognose beim Nebennierenkarzinom assoziiert (HR für Tod: 1,8854 (95% CI 1,088-3,158), p=0,023). Bei der Analyse des Tumorimmuninfiltrats (n=58) zeigte sich, dass Nebennierenkarzinome, ihre Rezidive und Metastasen durch CD8 positive zytotoxische T-Zellen, CD4 positive T-Helfer-Zellen, FoxP3 positive regulatorische T-Zellen und CD209 positive dendritische Zellen infiltriert werden. Insgesamt ist die Anzahl der Immunzellen im Tumor allerdings als relativ gering anzusehen. In der Korrelation des Immuninfiltrats mit dem Gesamt- und Rezidiv-freien Überleben zeigten sich keine signifikanten Ergebnisse. Es zeigte sich lediglich bei den T-Helferzellen ein leichter Trend zu einem längeren Überleben, je größer das Immuninfiltrat war (HR für Tod 0,63 (95% CI: 0,305-1,291), p=0,205). Im zweiten Teil der Arbeit wurde speziell die Rolle von Glukokortikoiden in vivo auf regulatorische T-Zellen untersucht. Hierbei zeigte sich in einem Mausmodell, entgegen der Hypothese, dass Glukokortikoide Treg induzieren, dass die Behandlung gesunder Mäuse mit Dexamethason zu einem dosisabhängigen Abfall der absoluten Zahl der regulatorischen T-Zellen führte (z. B. im Blut nach 3 Tagen: 1,3x104 in der 0,8 mg/kg Kohorte vs. 0,07x104 in der 100 mg/kg Kohorte), und sich dies auch bei der relativen Zahl der FOXP3-positiven T-Zellen bestätigte. Ähnlich fielen dann auch die Ergebnisse bei immunkompetenten Menschen aus. Hierbei kam es durch die 14-tägige Steroidgabe zwar zu einer milden T-Zell-Lymphozytose, allerdings war keine relevante Veränderung der Anzahl der zirkulierenden regulatorischen T-Zellen zu erkennen; insbesondere kein Anstieg der Selben (z. B. Anteil der FOXP3-positiven T-Zellen 4,0% vs. 3,4%; p<0.05). Damit widerlegen diese in vivo Daten die weitläufige Vermutung, dass eine kurzfristige Glukokortikoid-Gabe zu einer Induktion von regulatorischen T-Zellen führt. Zusammenfassend zeigt diese Arbeit, dass - wie bei anderen Tumoren auch - regulatorische T-Zellen bei Patienten mit Nebennierenkarzinom gehäuft vorkommen. Allerdings spielt hierbei der Glukokortikoid-Exzess der Tumore scheinbar keine wesentliche Rolle. Diese fehlende Interaktion zwischen den Steroiden und dieser Immunzell-Subpopulation bestätigt sich dann auch bei den in vivo Arbeiten an gesunden Mäusen und Menschen. Aus diesem Grund ist der Einfluss von Glukokortikoiden auf regulatorische T-Zellen zumindest teilweise neu zu bewerten.Adrenocortical carcinoma (ACC) is a rare disease with a limited prognosis. Numerous tumour entities showed that the immune system has significant influence on course of disease and prognosis. There were no appropriate studies dealing with ACC so far due to the low prevalence. Thereby the assumption is suggested that the interaction between tumour and immune system in ACC are particularly distinct as it frequently secretes glucocorticoids which, as is known, strongly influences the different immune cells. In the first part of the thesis it became apparent that patients with ACC (n=163), compared to healthy subjects (n=19), had a significantly increased frequency of regulatory T-cells (Treg) in peripheral blood (9.25 % vs. 4.4 %). The extent of glucocorticoid excess in contrast had no significant influence on the number of these immune cells. With regard to the prognosis, a higher number of Treg in blood was associated with a poorer prognosis at ACC (HR for death 1.8854 (95 % Cl 1.088-3.158), p=0.023). The analysis showed that ACC, their recurrences and metastasis were infiltrated by CD8 positive cytotoxic T-cells, CD4 positive T-helper cells, FoxP3 positive regulatory T-cells and CD209 positive dendritic cells. However, the number of immune cells in the tumour was relatively small. In the correlation of the infiltrating immune cells with the overall and progression-free survival no significant differences were discerned. There was only a slight tendency towards a longer survival, the larger the number of infiltrating CD4-cells was (HR for death 0.63 (95 % Cl 0.305-1.291), p=0.205). In the second part of the thesis, the role of glucocorticoids in vivo on Treg was analysed. In a mouse model treatment of healthy mice with dexamethasone led to a dose-dependent decrease of the absolute number of Treg (e.g. in blood after 3 days: 1.3x104 in the 0.8 mg/kg cohort vs. 0.07x104 in the 100 mg/kg cohort), contrary to the hypothesis that glucocorticoids induce Treg. This also was confirmed at relative number of FoxP3-positive T-cells. Immunocompetent people achieved similar results. 14-day steroid application resulted in a mild T-cell lymphocytosis. However, there was no relevant alteration in the number of circulating Treg, especially no increase of them (e.g. proportion of FoxP3-positive T-cells 4.0 % vs. 3.4 %, p<0.05). Thereby these in vivo data disproved the common assumption that a short-term glucocorticoid application leads to an induction of regulatory T-cells. To conclude, this thesis showed that -as with other tumours- Treg occur cumulatively in patients with ACC. Nonetheless, the glucocorticoid-excess seemingly played no considerable role. This failing interaction between steroids and this immune cell-subpopulation is proven in in vivo works with healthy mice and humans. For this reason, the influence of glucocorticoids on Treg has to be revaluated partially

Modulation of CD4⁺ T cells and T_reg cells by GCs in mice.

<p>Peripheral blood (A, C, E) and spleen (B, D, E) cells from C57BL/6 mice were analyzed by flow cytometry before, 3 days after IP treatment with different dosages of dexamethasone and 14 days after IP treatment with 100 mg/kg dexamethasone followed by oral taper. The absolute numbers of CD4⁺ T cells (A, B) and CD4⁺CD25^highFOXP3⁺ T_reg cells (C, D) were assessed and the relative frequency of T_reg cells amongst all CD4⁺ T cells was calculated (E, F); *p<0.05, **p<0.01.</p

Effect of GC on the function of T_reg cells <i>in vitro</i>.

<p>T_h cells (5×10⁴ cells / well) were incubated with T_reg cells at different ratios in the presence of irradiated APC (30 Gy, 10⁵ cells / well) and Con A (2,5 µg / ml) for 48 hrs, either with dexamethasone (dex, 5 nM) or without it (con). Resting T_h cells as well as T_h and T_reg cells stimulated with Con A served as controls. Proliferation was determined by ³H-TdR incorporation during an additional 16 hrs culture period (A), IL-2 levels were directly measured in the supernatants by ELISA (B). All values were normalized to stimulated T_h cells treated with or without Dex, respectively. In both panels the combined data of three independent experiments are depicted.</p

Lymphocyte counts and percentages in the blood and spleen of mice before and after GC therapy <i>in vivo</i>.

<p>* =  as subpopulation of CD4⁺CD25^high cells.</p><p>‡ =  % out of CD4⁺ cells ± SD.</p

Flow cytometric analysis of T_reg cells according to different markers.

<p>Peripheral blood from one representative hearing-loss patient treated for 3 days (A, C, E, G) and 14 days (B, D, F, H) with glucocorticoid regimen was analyzed for the presence of regulatory T cells according to the following markers: CD4⁺ CD25^high and FOXP3⁺ (A, B), AITR⁺ (C, D) CD127_low (E, F) and CTLA4⁺ (G, H). Only CD4⁺ cells are depicted and the percentages indicate the relative frequency of T_reg cells within this subpopulation.</p

Modulation of CD4⁺ T cells and T_reg cells by GCs in humans.

<p>Peripheral blood cells from acute hearing loss patients before and 14 days after prednisolone treatment were analyzed by flow cytometry and the absolute numbers (A, C, E, G, I) and the frequency (B, D, F, H, J) of CD4⁺ T cells (A, B) and T_reg cells (CD4⁺CD25^high and FOXP3⁺ (C, D), AITR⁺ (E, F), CD127^low (G, H) or CTLA4⁺ (I, J)) were assessed; *p<0.05, ***p<0.001.</p