4 research outputs found
Estimating the effectiveness of routine asymptomatic PCR testing at different frequencies for the detection of SARS-CoV-2 infections
Background
Routine asymptomatic testing using RT-PCR of people who interact with vulnerable populations, such as medical staff in hospitals or care workers in care homes, has been employed to help prevent outbreaks among vulnerable populations. Although the peak sensitivity of RT-PCR can be high, the probability of detecting an infection will vary throughout the course of an infection. The effectiveness of routine asymptomatic testing will therefore depend on testing frequency and how PCR detection varies over time.
Methods
We fitted a Bayesian statistical model to a dataset of twice weekly PCR tests of UK healthcare workers performed by self-administered nasopharyngeal swab, regardless of symptoms. We jointly estimated times of infection and the probability of a positive PCR test over time following infection; we then compared asymptomatic testing strategies by calculating the probability that a symptomatic infection is detected before symptom onset and the probability that an asymptomatic infection is detected within 7 days of infection.
Results
We estimated that the probability that the PCR test detected infection peaked at 77% (54–88%) 4 days after infection, decreasing to 50% (38–65%) by 10 days after infection. Our results suggest a substantially higher probability of detecting infections 1–3 days after infection than previously published estimates. We estimated that testing every other day would detect 57% (33–76%) of symptomatic cases prior to onset and 94% (75–99%) of asymptomatic cases within 7 days if test results were returned within a day.
Conclusions
Our results suggest that routine asymptomatic testing can enable detection of a high proportion of infected individuals early in their infection, provided that the testing is frequent and the time from testing to notification of results is sufficiently fast
SARS-CoV-2 detection by a clinical diagnostic RT-LAMP assay [version 1; peer review: 1 approved with reservations]
The ongoing pandemic of SARS-CoV-2 calls for rapid and cost-effective
methods to accurately identify infected individuals. The vast majority
of patient samples is assessed for viral RNA presence by RT-qPCR. Our
biomedical research institute, in collaboration between partner
hospitals and an accredited clinical diagnostic laboratory, established
a diagnostic testing pipeline that has reported on more than 252,000
RT-qPCR results since its commencement at the beginning of April
2020. However, due to ongoing demand and competition for critical
resources, alternative testing strategies were sought. In this work, we
present a clinically-validated procedure for high-throughput SARSCoV-2 detection by RT-LAMP in 25 minutes that is robust, reliable,
repeatable, sensitive, specific, and inexpensive
cmmid/pcr-profile
A Github repository containing code to reproduce the figures and analysis from a pre-print titled "Estimating effectiveness of frequent PCR testing at different intervals for detection of SARS-CoV-2 infections"