More insight into the fate of biomedical meeting abstracts: a systematic review

BACKGROUND: It has been estimated that about 45% of abstracts that are accepted for presentation at biomedical meetings will subsequently be published in full. The acceptance of abstracts at meetings and their fate after initial rejection are less well understood. We set out to estimate the proportion of abstracts submitted to meetings that are eventually published as full reports, and to explore factors that are associated with meeting acceptance and successful publication. METHODS: Studies analysing acceptance of abstracts at biomedical meetings or their subsequent full publication were searched in MEDLINE, OLDMEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, CINAHL, BIOSIS, Science Citation Index Expanded, and by hand searching of bibliographies and proceedings. We estimated rates of abstract acceptance and of subsequent full publication, and identified abstract and meeting characteristics associated with acceptance and publication, using logistic regression analysis, survival-type analysis, and meta-analysis. RESULTS: Analysed meetings were held between 1957 and 1999. Of 14945 abstracts that were submitted to 43 meetings, 46% were accepted. The rate of full publication was studied with 19123 abstracts that were presented at 234 meetings. Using survival-type analysis, we estimated that 27% were published after two, 41% after four, and 44% after six years. Of 2412 abstracts that were rejected at 24 meetings, 27% were published despite rejection. Factors associated with both abstract acceptance and subsequent publication were basic science and positive study outcome. Large meetings and those held outside the US were more likely to accept abstracts. Abstracts were more likely to be published subsequently if presented either orally, at small meetings, or at a US meeting. Abstract acceptance itself was strongly associated with full publication. CONCLUSIONS: About one third of abstracts submitted to biomedical meetings were published as full reports. Acceptance at meetings and publication were associated with specific characteristics of abstracts and meetings

Resección de hemivértebra con técnica de eggshell en cifoescoliosis congénita: resultados en niños entre uno y siete años Ressecção de hemivertébra com a técnica de eggshell em cifoescoliose congênita: resultados em crianças com idade entre um e sete anos Hemivertebrae resection with eggshell procedure for congenital kyphoscoliosis: results in children aged from one to seven years

INTRODUCCIÓN: La hemivértebra es la causa de 50% de las cifoescoliosis congénitas y en general requiere tratamiento quirúrgico. OBJETIVO: evaluar los resultados clínicos y radiológicos de la resección de hemivértebra con técnica de eggshell en niños entre uno y siete años. DISEÑO DEL ESTUDIO: análisis retrospectivo de pacientes sometidos a resección de hemivértebra con técnica de eggshell. MÉTODOS: entre Enero del 2006 y Junio del 2008, siete hemivértebras fueron resecadas en siete pacientes consecutivos, entre uno y siete años de edad. Se revisó retrospectivamente las fichas clínicas y radiografías. La edad promedio al momento de la cirugía fue 3,2 años (rango de uno a siete años) y el seguimiento promedio fue de 17 meses (rango 7 a 35 meses). Se registró ángulo de Cobb de la escoliosis y cifosis en el preoperatorio y al término del seguimiento, tiempo operatorio, transfusión de glóbulos rojos y complicaciones. RESULTADOS: el ángulo preoperatorio promedio de la escoliosis fue 35° y 19° al término del seguimiento, con un 40% de corrección. El ángulo preoperatorio promedio de la cifosis fue 42° y 25° al término del seguimiento, con un 33% de corrección. Cuatro pacientes necesitaron transfusión de glóbulos rojos, promedio 1,25 unidades. El tiempo quirúrgico promedio fue 225 minutos. Dos pacientes presentaron complicaciones, una rotura dural y una fractura pedicular. No se presentaron complicaciones neurológicas. Todos los pacientes presentaban fusión sólida al término del seguimiento. CONCLUSIÓN: la resección de hemivértebra con técnica de eggshell es un procedimiento seguro, que permite una excelente e inmediata corrección de la cifoescoliosis congénita, la que se mantiene en el corto plazo.<br>INTRODUÇÃO: A hemivértebra associa-se a 50% das cifoescolioses congênitas e geralmente requer tratamento cirúrgico. OBJETIVO: avaliar os resultados clínicos e radiológicos da ressecção da hemivértebra, utilizando a técnica de eggshell em crianças entre um e sete anos. FORMA DO ESTUDO: análise retrospectiva dos pacientes submetidos à ressecção de hemivértebra com a técnica eggshell. MÉTODOS: Entre Janeiro de 2006 e Junho de 2008, sete hemivértebras foram ressecadas em sete pacientes consecutivos, entre um e sete anos de idade. Realizou-se análise retrospectiva dos prontuários e exames radiográficos. A média de idade no momento da cirurgia foi de 3,2 anos (variação entre um a sete anos) e o seguimento médio foi de 17 meses (variação de 7 a 35 meses). Registrou-se ângulo de Cobb na escoliose e cifose no pré-operatório e no término do seguimento, o tempo operatório, transfusão de glóbulos vermelhos e complicações. RESULTADOS: o ângulo pré-operatório médio da escoliose foi de 35° e 19° no término do seguimento, com um 40% de correção. O ângulo pré-operatório médio da cifose foi de 42° e 25° no término do seguimento, com 33% de correção. Quatro pacientes precisaram de transfusão de glóbulos vermelhos, 1,25 unidades como média. O tempo cirúrgico médio foi de 225 minutos. Dois pacientes apresentaram complicações, uma rotura dural e uma fratura pedicular. Não houve complicações neurológicas. Todos os pacientes apresentaram sólida fusão no término do seguimento. CONCLUSÃO: a ressecção de hemivértebra utilizando a técnica de eggshell é um procedimento seguro que permite uma excelente e imediata correção da cifoescoliose congênita, a qual é mantida no curto prazo.<br>INTRODUCTION: Hemivertebrae is associated with 50% of the congenital kyphoscoliosis and surgical treatment is usually required. OBJECTIVE: to evaluate clinical and radiographic results of hemivertebra resection with an eggshell procedure in children aged from one to seven years old. STUDY DESIGN: retrospective review of patients who underwent hemivertebrae resection with an eggshell procedure. METHODS: from January 2006 to June 2008, seven hemivertebrae were resected in seven consecutive patients aged one to seven years old. A retrospective chart and a radiographic review were performed. The mean age at surgery was 3,2 years (range from one to seven years). The mean follow-up was 17 months (range from 7 to 35 months). Cobb's angle in the coronal and sagittal planes preoperative and at follow-up, operating time, transfusion requirements and complications were analyzed. RESULTS: the mean pre-operative scoliosis Cobb's angle was 35° and the average at follow-up was 19°. The mean correction at follow-up was 40%. The average of the pre-operative kyphosis Cobb's angle was 42° and average at follow-up was 25°. Rate of correction at follow-up was 33%. Four patients required transfusion, with an average of 1,25 blood units. The average of operating time was 225 minutes. Complications were encountered in two patients; one dural tear and one pedicular fracture. No neurological complications. All patients achieved solid fusion at follow-up. CONCLUSION: hemivertebra resection with the eggshell procedure is a safe surgical technique and provides an excellent and immediate correction of congenital kyphoscoliosis at short term follow-up

Do we publish what we preach? Analysis of the European Society for Surgery of the Shoulder and Elbow Congress publication rates

BACKGROUND: Scientific congresses have become the most expedient method to communicate novel findings on any research topic. However, an important question is whether this information will be published in peer-reviewed journals. Our aim was to determine the publication rate of the abstracts presented at the European Society for Surgery of the Shoulder and Elbow Congress and analyze factors that may influence this rate. METHODS: A total of 398 abstracts reported in the Abstract Book from the 2008 European Society for Surgery of the Shoulder and Elbow Congress were examined and categorized by oral and poster presentations, topic, and the number of authors listed. A search in PubMed and Google Scholar for subsequent peer-reviewed publications was performed in September 2015. The time to publication after the meeting had been held; the type of journal and its impact factor at the time to publication were recorded for those abstracts that reached peer-reviewed journal publication. RESULTS: The overall publication rate for the 2008 European Society for Surgery of the Shoulder and Elbow oral and poster presentations was 45.20% after 7 years. The mean time to publication was 18.53 months, and the mean impact factor value was 2.32. Oral presentations were significantly better represented in journals than posters (64.40 vs. 35.40%, p < 0.001). Abstracts with a greater number of authors listed had better publication rates (p < 0.001). CONCLUSION: Less than half of the oral presentations and posters at the 21st European Society for Surgery of the Shoulder and Elbow Congress were published in peer-reviewed journals. Oral presentations with a higher number of authors had an increased likelihood of being published

Surgical management of severe rigid tuberculous kyphosis of dorsolumbar spine

To assess the effectiveness of deformity correction and safety of the two major corrective spinal surgical procedures, 35 patients, aged 14–47 years, were placed into two groups according to procedures performed. Sixteen patients (group A) had four-stage procedures including initial halo-pelvic distraction after anterior release and a subsequent three procedural steps plus brace. Nineteen patients (group B) had one-set two-stage procedures: wire segmental stabilisation in eight cases and rod/hook and/or pedicle screw stabilisation in 11 cases. Average preoperative kyphosis in group A was 88° and postoperative at zero, three, six, and 18 months were 29˚, 33˚, 35˚ and 35˚, respectively, while those of group B were 86˚ preoperative and postoperative 27˚, 31˚, 33˚, and 33˚, respectively. Neural complication developed in five cases: one in group A and four in group B. It was concluded that the one-set two-stage procedure is more efficient, time-saving, and cost-effective, though it is highly challenging with relatively high rates of neural complication