The biochemically defined Super Relaxed state of myosin – a paradox

The biochemical SRX (super relaxed) state of myosin has been defined as a low ATPase activity state. This state can conserve energy when the myosin is not recruited for muscle contraction. The SRX state has been correlated with a structurally defined ordered (verses disordered) state of muscle thick filaments. The two states may be linked via a common interacting head motif (IHM) where the two heads of heavy meromyosin (HMM), or myosin, fold back onto each other and form additional contacts with S2 and the thick filament. Experimental observations of the SRX, IHM, and the ordered form of thick filaments, however, do not always agree, and result in a series of unresolved paradoxes. To address these paradoxes, we have reexamined the biochemical measurements of the SRX state for porcine cardiac HMM. In our hands, the commonly employed mantATP displacement assay was unable to quantify the population of the SRX state with all data fitting very well by a single exponential. We further show that Mavacamten inhibits the basal ATPases of both porcine ventricle HMM and S1 (Ki, 0.32 and 1.76 μM respectively) while dATP activates HMM cooperatively without any evidence of a SRX state. A combination of our experimental observations and theories suggests that the displacement of mantATP in purified proteins is not a reliable assay to quantify the SRX population. This means that while the structurally defined IHM and ordered thick filaments clearly exist, great care must be employed when using the mantATP displacement assay

Elucidating the mechanism of Danicamtiv on force, kinetics, and myosin structure and function

Myosin modulators are a novel class of small molecules that alter cardiac contractility. Omecamtiv mecarbil, the first identified myosin activator, showed only modest clinical benefits in systolic heart failure patients. Thus, there is an urgency to develop alternative myosin activators. Danicamtiv (Dani) has emerged as a potential candidate; however, a detailed mechanism is not known. Here, we aim to elucidate the mechanism of Dani on contractile function in pig cardiac muscle. Demembranated ventricular tissues show a significant 0.1 pCa unit increase in calcium sensitivity and 10% increase in maximal force after incubation in 1 µM Dani. The most potent effects occur in submaximal calcium concentrations, leading to a flattening of the force-calcium relationship, suggesting decreased cooperativity. Maximal rates of tension redevelopment are decreased by approximately 60% with Dani. Isolated cardiac myofibrils provide details about contractile kinetics. Experiments with 1 µM Dani show a 49% decrease in fast-phase relaxation kinetics. Slow-phase isometric relaxation exhibits 47% slower crossbridge detachment rate and 34% longer thin filament deactivation. Next, we assess ATP utilization in the crossbridge cycle. Filament sliding velocity slows 55% on addition of 0.5 µM Dani, similar to the effect of ADP on velocity. The effects of Dani and ADP are not additive suggesting a similar mode of action. ATP binding is unaltered up to 10 µM Dani using stopped flow spectroscopy. Results of X-ray diffraction studies of porcine myocardium at rest show an increase in equatorial intensity ratio (I1,1/I1,0) in response to 50 µM Dani, reflecting an increased proximity of myosin heads to the thin filament. In conclusion, we hypothesize that Dani primes the thick filament for activation and alters relaxation through inhibited ATP hydrolysis product release. Future studies will test these hypotheses

Danicamtiv increases myosin recruitment and alters cross-bridge cycling in cardiac muscle

Background: Modulating myosin function is a novel therapeutic approach in patients with cardiomyopathy. Danicamtiv is a novel myosin activator with promising preclinical data that is currently in clinical trials. While it is known that danicamtiv increases force and cardiomyocyte contractility without affecting calcium levels, detailed mechanistic studies regarding its mode of action are lacking. Methods: Permeabilized porcine cardiac tissue and myofibrils were used for X-ray diffraction and mechanical measurements. A mouse model of genetic dilated cardiomyopathy was used to evaluate the ability of danicamtiv to correct the contractile deficient. Results: Danicamtiv increased force and calcium sensitivity via increasing the number of myosins in the on state and slowing cross-bridge turnover. Our detailed analysis showed that inhibition of ADP release results in decreased cross-bridge turnover with cross bridges staying attached longer and prolonging myofibril relaxation. Danicamtiv corrected decreased calcium sensitivity in demembranated tissue, abnormal twitch magnitude and kinetics in intact cardiac tissue, and reduced ejection fraction in the whole organ. Conclusions: As demonstrated by the detailed studies of Danicamtiv, increasing myosin recruitment and altering crossbridge cycling are 2 mechanisms to increase force and calcium sensitivity in cardiac muscle. Myosin activators such as Danicamtiv can treat the causative hypocontractile phenotype in genetic dilated cardiomyopath

The modulation of myosin function: How small molecules and sarcomeric mutations impact actomyosin interactions

Thesis (Ph.D.)--University of Washington, 2023The subcellular mechanisms that regulate striated muscle function have been studied by biophysicists and physiologists for over a century. Numerous scientists have made significant findings in the field of muscle biology with fundamental discoveries regarding sarcomeric specific proteins, lattice-spacing architecture, and mechanisms of sarcomeric regulation. With these essential findings as the foundation of our field, there are still many sarcomere-based mechanisms of regulation that remain unresolved. The body of work presented here is aimed at extending the knowledge of sarcomeric contraction and regulation by leveraging recent advances in structural, mechanical, and biochemical assays utilized in the field of muscle biology. Specifically, the presented studies demonstrate an integrated approach to elucidating the myofilament specific processes that underlie striated muscle function by addressing (1) the underlying regulatory role of myosin through differences in structural recruitment and biochemical cycling, (2) the structural and biochemical pathways that small molecules alter sarcomeric proteins as mechanisms of therapy for individuals with congenital heart failure, and (3) underlying mechanisms of dysfunction in hypercontractile models of striated muscle diseases.The presented work focuses primarily on the thick filament protein myosin and the regulatory role the protein plays in sarcomeric function. In comparison to the vastly studied thin filament, significantly less is known about the modulation of sarcomeric function through myosin. First, we assessed the structural organization and position of myosin within the sarcomere and compared those results to sophisticated biochemical measurements of nucleotide turnover kinetics. We show that the diffraction-based measurements of myosin recruitment as a parameter for myosin regulation is independent from biochemical regulation of myosin head cycling kinetics. Second, we determined the mechanistic pathway of a novel myosin-specific small molecule as a therapeutic agent in hypo-contractile models of cardiac diseases. We show how inotropic interventions can modulate myosin cycling and recruitment through product release inhibition; a mechanistic pathway that can rescue a transgenic murine model harboring a loss-of-function troponin mutation that causes dilated cardiomyopathy. Lastly, we utilize a transgenic porcine model harboring the first reported familial hypertrophic cardiomyopathy mutation to describe how perturbations in specific regions of myosin can lead to sarcomeric dysfunction. We show that isolated protein measurements do not fully recapitulate the phenotypic disease expression observed in myofibril-level and tissue-level preparations, suggesting that certain myosin mutations require the interaction of other sarcomeric proteins to manifest. To summarize, the work presented here expands the understanding of sarcomeric regulation though myosin specific pathways. We address topics ranging from basic molecular regulation of sarcomeric function to fundamental mechanistic pathways of different diseases and novel sarcomere-specific therapeutic agents

A molecular scale investigation of the mechanisms of contractile dysfunction for the hypertrophic cardiomyopathy MYH7 G256E mutation

Genetic sequencing enables the pinpointing of specific genetic mutations correlated with striated muscle diseases. However, such associations do not describe mechanistic relationships between specific mutations and clinical phenotypes. To address this, we use CRISPR-edited human induced pluripotent stem cell-derived cardiomyocytes (hiPSC-CMs) as a model system to probe how mutations in β-myosin heavy chain (MHC) lead to cardiac muscle disease. Preliminary data show that the specific force generation and activation rate of mutant G256E myofibrils is greater than isogenic control myofibrils. During relaxation, the initial, slow phase kinetics were decreased, indicating slower cross-bridge detachment rate. Additionally, stopped-flow mant-ATP assays on isolated myofibrils showed slower ATP binding for the G256E mutation, supporting delayed relaxation observed in myofibrils. Overall, these data suggest a hypercontractile phenotype with impaired early relaxation for the G256E mutation. To understand the molecular structure basis of these effects we have used molecular dynamics simulations of wild type and mutant β-MHC. In post-rigor (M.ATP) and rigor state simulations, we observed reduced stability in the transducer region of β-myosin, due to weakened hydrogen bonds between neighboring β-sheet strands as well as significant changes in local contacts. Pairing these in silico data with our in vitro data, our results suggest that the G256E mutation affects the transducer region of myosin such that it alters communication between the nucleotide binding pocket and the actin binding surface during the acto-myosin chemo-mechanical cycle, leading to hypercontractility and slowed relaxation

The effect of small molecule myosin modulators on ATP turnover in pig cardiac HMM using stopped flow spectroscopy

Myosin modulators are a novel class of pharmaceutical agents designed to treat patients with cardiomyopathies by directly modulating cardiac myosin function in the sarcomere. Compounds including omecamtiv mecarbil (OM), danicamtiv (Dani), and deoxy-ATP (dATP) have previously been shown to increase myofibril ATPase activity while mavacamten (Mava) reduced ATPase activity. In the absence of actin, ATPase activity is a combination of the direct effects of nucleotide binding and the equilibrium between the high activity (DRX) and low activity (SRX) states of myosin. In this study, we investigate how these small molecules affect the single turnover kinetics of pig cardiac heavy meromyosin (pcHMM) in the absence of actin. pcHMM bound to fluorescent mant.ATP or mant.dATP is rapidly mixed with a high concentration of unlabeled ATP. The rate constant for replacement of mant.ADP by ATP defines the turnover of mant.ATP. Preliminary titration experiments demonstrate that OM, Dani, and Mava all inhibit ATP turnover with an IC50 of 0.59 µM, 3.5 µM, and 0.276 µM, respectively. 100% dATP increases the ATP turnover by 100%. These experiments indicate that each myosin modulator differentially alters cardiac HMM activity. We will discuss how each modulator affects ATP turnover by a direct effect on catalytic activity vs an effect on the amount of HMM in the super-relaxed population

Epicardially Placed Bioengineered Cardiomyocyte Xenograft in Immune-Competent Rat Model of Heart Failure

BackgroundHuman induced pluripotent stem cell-derived cardiomyocytes (hiPSC-CMs) are under preclinical investigation as a cell-based therapy for heart failure post-myocardial infarction. In a previous study, tissue-engineered cardiac grafts were found to improve hosts' cardiac electrical and mechanical functions. However, the durability of effect, immune response, and in vitro properties of the tissue graft remained uncharacterized. This present study is aimed at confirming the graft therapeutic efficacy in an immune-competent chronic heart failure (CHF) model and providing evaluation of the in vitro properties of the tissue graft.MethodshiPSC-CMs and human dermal fibroblasts were cultured into a synthetic bioabsorbable scaffold. The engineered grafts underwent epicardial implantation in infarcted immune-competent male Sprague-Dawley rats. Plasma samples were collected throughout the study to quantify antibody titers. At the study endpoint, all cohorts underwent echocardiographic, hemodynamic, electrophysiologic, and histopathologic assessments.ResultsThe epicardially placed tissue graft therapy improved (p < 0.05) in vivo and ex vivo cardiac function compared to the untreated CHF cohort. Total IgM and IgG increased for both the untreated and graft-treated CHF cohorts. An immune response to the grafts was detected after seven days in graft-treated CHF rats only. In vitro, engineered grafts exhibited responsiveness to beta-adrenergic receptor agonism/antagonism and SERCA inhibition and elicited complex molecular profiles.ConclusionsThis hiPSC-CM-derived cardiac graft improved systolic and diastolic cardiac function in immune-competent CHF rats. The improvements were detectable at seven weeks post-graft implantation despite an antibody response beginning at week one and peaking at week three. This suggests that non-integrating cell-based therapy delivered by a bioengineered tissue graft for ischemic cardiomyopathy is a viable treatment option

MYBPC3-c.772G>A mutation results in haploinsufficiency and altered myosin cycling kinetics in a patient induced stem cell derived cardiomyocyte model of hypertrophic cardiomyopathy

Approximately 40% of hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) mutations are linked to the sarcomere protein cardiac myosin binding protein-C (cMyBP-C). These mutations are either classified as missense mutations or truncation mutations. One mutation whose nature has been inconsistently reported in the literature is the MYBPC3-c.772G > A mutation. Using patient-derived human induced pluripotent stem cells differentiated to cardiomyocytes (hiPSC-CMs), we have performed a mechanistic study of the structure-function relationship for this MYBPC3-c.772G > A mutation versus a mutation corrected, isogenic cell line. Our results confirm that this mutation leads to exon skipping and mRNA truncation that ultimately suggests ∼20% less cMyBP-C protein (i.e., haploinsufficiency). This, in turn, results in increased myosin recruitment and accelerated myofibril cycling kinetics. Our mechanistic studies suggest that faster ADP release from myosin is a primary cause of accelerated myofibril cross-bridge cycling due to this mutation. Additionally, the reduction in force generating heads expected from faster ADP release during isometric contractions is outweighed by a cMyBP-C phosphorylation mediated increase in myosin recruitment that leads to a net increase of myofibril force, primarily at submaximal calcium activations. These results match well with our previous report on contractile properties from myectomy samples of the patients from whom the hiPSC-CMs were generated, demonstrating that these cell lines are a good model to study this pathological mutation and extends our understanding of the mechanisms of altered contractile properties of this HCM MYBPC3-c.772G > A mutation

Cardiac myosin activation with 2-deoxy-ATP via increased electrostatic interactions with actin

The naturally occurring nucleotide 2-deoxy-adenosine 5'-triphosphate (dATP) can be used by cardiac muscle as an alternative energy substrate for myosin chemomechanical activity. We and others have previously shown that dATP increases contractile force in normal hearts and models of depressed systolic function, but the structural basis of these effects has remained unresolved. In this work, we combine multiple techniques to provide structural and functional information at the angstrom-nanometer and millisecond time scales, demonstrating the ability to make both structural measurements and quantitative kinetic estimates of weak actin-myosin interactions that underpin sarcomere dynamics. Exploiting dATP as a molecular probe, we assess how small changes in myosin structure translate to electrostatic-based changes in sarcomere function to augment contractility in cardiac muscle. Through Brownian dynamics simulation and computational structural analysis, we found that deoxy-hydrolysis products [2-deoxy-adenosine 5'-diphosphate (dADP) and inorganic phosphate (Pi)] bound to prepowerstroke myosin induce an allosteric restructuring of the actin-binding surface on myosin to increase the rate of cross-bridge formation. We then show experimentally that this predicted effect translates into increased electrostatic interactions between actin and cardiac myosin in vitro. Finally, using small-angle X-ray diffraction analysis of sarcomere structure, we demonstrate that the proposed increased electrostatic affinity of myosin for actin causes a disruption of the resting conformation of myosin motors, resulting in their repositioning toward the thin filament before activation. The dATP-mediated structural alterations in myosin reported here may provide insight into an improved criterion for the design or selection of small molecules to be developed as therapeutic agents to treat systolic dysfunction