The Paradoxical Impacts of the Minimum Wage Implementation on Ready-made Garment (RMG) Workers: A Qualitative Study

There is no regular mandated increase in minimum wages for workers employed in the Bangladesh ready-made garment (RMG) industry. Workers in the past have relied on optional bonuses added to their monthly incomes to supplement their wages. However, a new minimum wage implemented in January 2019 in the Bangladesh RMG sector increased wages for many workers who are known to work under poor and exploitative working conditions. Qualitative in-depth interviews were conducted with fifteen currently employed RMG workers (female: 13, male: 2), which led to data saturation. The participants were purposively recruited from both export processing zone (EPZ) and non-EPZ factories located in Dhaka and Chattogram, the two largest cities of Bangladesh where the majority of RMG factories are situated. Transcribed interviews were analysed thematically. The findings revealed that working hours, production targets, work pressure, and workplace abuse have an impact on workers' health and well-being. In line with the Marxist notion of the "accumulation of capital", we argue that due to the profit maximization mindset of RMG owners and international brands, workers have not received the potential benefit of the newly implemented minimum wage as their conditions have been changed in other ways to offset the increase in salary. The article contributes to understanding how factory owners' profit maximization mindset dispossessed workers from receiving the real benefits of the newly implemented minimum wage and forced them to continue working within exploitative working environments. The study shows that the impact of minimum wages on poverty reduction is unlikely and outlines the need for RMG labor market reform

Middle Eastern mothers in Sweden, their experiences of the maternal health service and their partner's involvement

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>Traditional patterns relating to how to handle pregnancy and birth are often challenged due to migration. The purpose of this study was to describe Middle Eastern mothers' experiences of the maternal health care services in Sweden and the involvement of their male partner.</p> <p>Methods</p> <p>Thirteen immigrant mothers from the Middle East who had used the maternal health services in Sweden were interviewed using focus group discussions and individual interviews. These were taped, transcribed and analysed according to Content analysis.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>The four main categories that developed were:</p> <p>• Access to the professional midwife</p> <p>• Useful counselling</p> <p>• Stable motherhood in transition</p> <p>• Being a family living in a different culture</p> <p>Conclusion</p> <p>According to the respondents in this study, understanding the woman's native language or her culture was not vital to develop a good relationship with the midwife. Instead the immigrant woman developed trust in the midwife based on the knowledge and the empathy the midwife imparted.</p> <p>Increasing the amount of first trimester antenatal visits could avoid spontaneous visits to the emergency clinic. There was a greater need for involvement and support by the father during the perinatal period, such as caring for older children and carrying out household chores since the mothers' earlier female network was often lost.</p> <p>Clinical implications</p> <p>There is a need to involve immigrant parents in the available parental education in order to prepare them for parenthood in their new country as well as to explore their altered family situation. Collecting immigrant women and their partner's, experiences of maternal health care services offers a possibility to improve the existing care, both in content, access and availability where the timing of visits and content require further evaluation.</p

A qualitative study of the working conditions in the readymade garment industry and the impact on workers’ health and wellbeing

Objectives: There has been debate regarding the working conditions for employees of the Bangladesh readymade garment (RMG) industry since the 1980s. Little is known how the existing working conditions of the Bangladesh RMG sector impact workers' health and overall wellbeing, which remains the key aim of this study. Methods: The study adopted a qualitative descriptive design. Twenty-seven RMG workers (female: 21, male: 6) were purposively recruited for focus groups (FGs) from both the Export Processing Zone (EPZ) and non-EPZ factories located in Dhaka and Chattogram, the two largest cities in Bangladesh. FGs were audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim. Inductive thematic analysis was performed to review the transcribed data and to identify themes. Results: The study identified that the existing working conditions impacted workers' health and wellbeing severely. These conditions mainly comprise of inadequate workplace facilities (lack of pure drinking water, unavailability of qualified doctors, and fabricated signage of childcare facilities) and poor working environments (lack of hygienic practices, unavailability of safety equipment, sexual harassment, mandatory nights shifts, inappropriate sitting arrangements, and workplaces as death traps). All the female workers reported experience of verbal or sexual harassment at least once inside the factories also noted anxiety and feeling unsafe while working during night shifts. These conditions are presented within the socioeconomic conditions of Bangladesh. Conclusions: This study contributes to understanding the nexus between factory owners' profit maximization mindset and workplace conditions in relation to workers' health and wellbeing status. Strict monitoring of the workplace conditions of Bangladesh RMG factories is warranted

Health vulnerabilities of readymade garment (RMG) workers: a systematic review

Abstract Background There is a paucity of literature that addresses the health vulnerabilities of readymade garment (RMG) workers in South and Southeast Asian regions. Therefore, the aim of this systematic review is to identify the distinctive types of health vulnerabilities along with the causes and consequences of these vulnerabilities of the RMG workers in South and Southeast Asian regions. Methods Systematic review search methods were applied utilising the PRISMA protocol. Literature published between July 2007 to June 2017 on health vulnerabilities of the RMG workers of South and Southeast Asian countries were identified through electronic databases and manual searches. Results A total number of 19 studies (16 quantitative studies, 3 mixed-method studies) were included from the primary 17,001 papers identified. The quality of these studies was assessed by using the EPHPP (effective public health practice project) and the CASP (critical appraisal skills programme) tools. From the identified studies, 14 were considered ‘strong,’ with the remainder assessed as ‘moderate’ quality. The findings reported in these studies suggest that RMG workers of South and Southeast Asian countries are prone to several health vulnerabilities which include physical and psychological issues. Further, many of these health vulnerabilities arise from the nature of the RMG workplace, and include unhygienic and unsafe working environments, hazardous conditions of the factories, and lack of safety equipment. Conclusions This systematic review suggests that RMG workers’ health vulnerabilities are an emerging area of inquiry that needs to be better understood and solutions identified. Little is currently known about the distinctive types of health vulnerabilities of the RMG workers of these countries, other than Bangladesh and India, due to the lack of robust studies in other South and Southeast Asian countries. Although the health vulnerabilities of the Bangladeshi and Indian RMG workers have been previously highlighted, the health vulnerabilities arising from sudden disasters in the sector remain a neglected issue

The Current Health and Wellbeing of the Survivors of the Rana Plaza Building Collapse in Bangladesh: A Qualitative Study

This study aims to identify the ongoing physical and psychological health vulnerabilities of the readymade garment (RMG) factory workers involved in the Rana Plaza building collapse in 2013, along with their experiences within the current socioeconomic and political contexts of Bangladesh. Seventeen Rana Plaza survivors participated in unstructured, face-to-face, in-depth interviews. Interviews were thematically analyzed using Haddon’s matrix to examine pre-event, event, and post-event injury experiences. The collapse of the Rana Plaza building resulted in significant physical and emotional trauma for those who survived the event. The majority of the participants were forced to attend work on the day of the collapse. Participants reported physical health complaints related to bone injuries/fractures and amputation, severe headache, kidney problems, and functional difficulties. In addition to the reported physical health issues, the participants revealed psychological health issues including trauma, depression and suicidal ideation, sleep disorders, anxiety, and sudden anger. Participants described barriers to their potential for re-employment in the RMG sector and outlined their limited access to free healthcare for follow-up treatment. Those who survived the collapse of the Rana Plaza building continue to experience significant adverse physical and emotional outcomes related to the disaster. Yet, they have little recourse to ensure the availability of adequate health care and rehabilitation. Given the international reliance on the Bangladeshi RMG industry, continued pressure to ensure care is provided for these survivors, and to reduce the risk of future disasters, is necessary

Prevalence and risk factors of physical and psychological health among readymade garment workers in Bangladesh

Objective. Poor health outcomes of Bangladeshi readymade garment (RMG) workers tend to be associated with a variety of occupational factors. This study aimed to investigate the prevalence of, and risk factors associated with, the physical and psychological health outcomes of Bangladeshi RMG workers. Methods. Responses to a cross-sectional survey from a convenience sample of 411 adult Bangladeshi RMG workers (mean age = 26.24 years; SD 6.40 years; female = 80%) were analysed using bivariate and multivariate (logistic regression models) analyses. Results. More than half of the participants reported headaches (61.6%) and colds/flu (51.3%), followed by fever (37.2%), diarrhoea (32.8%), bodily pain (29.9%) and respiratory infections (20.9%). For psychological health, stress (69.1%), anxiety (66.2%) and boredom (64.5%) were most prevalent, followed by sleeplessness (51.3%), depression (48.2%) and fear (34.3%). RMG workers from the factories located in Chattogram (a peripheral region compared to Dhaka) reported poorer physical and psychological health outcomes than those working in factories in Dhaka (the capital city of Bangladesh). Overall, compared to males, female RMG workers were more likely to be vulnerable to both physical and psychological health outcomes. Conclusion. Improvement in workplace conditions and safety programmes is needed to safeguard the overall health outcomes of Bangladeshi RMG workers

Health Vulnerabilities of the Readymade Garment (RMG) Workers of Bangladesh

The Bangladesh readymade garment (RMG) sector commenced in the 1980s and is now ranked second in clothing supply for international brands globally. This sector has created employment opportunities for more than four million workers, mainly female, with little or no education or previous skill. The sector is also considered a significant economic industry for Bangladesh accounting for 83 percent of the country’s total export earnings. Despite creating huge job opportunities and making enormous contributions to the national economy, the Bangladesh RMG sector is marred by poor working conditions, employees’ health and safety concerns, and workplace rights-related issues. One key example of the poor working conditions is frequent disasters, such as the physical collapse of Rana Plaza in 2013, killing more than 1130 workers, and the fire in Tazreen Fashion in 2012, where more than 112 garment workers died. Many thousands have sustained injuries from these disasters and regular workplace injuries continue to be reported. Further, workers’ daily working conditions remain unsafe and pose continuing hazards for the workforce. Since Bangladesh RMG sector continues to expand to meet international clothing demands, it is timely to explore in what conditions the global fashions are made along with the impacts of those conditions on workers’ health and wellbeing. This thesis provides empirical data which examined why and how the currently employed RMG workers were vulnerable to different types of physical and psychological health issues. In addition, the research explores the impacts of a catastrophic event, structural changes in relation to wages, and the COVID-19 pandemic on RMG workers. A mixed-method approach, with multiple methods of inquiry, which drew on the principles of pragmatism, was used across five separate yet interconnected studies. Study 1 presents findings from three focus groups (female: 21; male: 16) that aimed to explore the current working conditions, with a further focus on differences experienced by male and female RMG workers. The study found that RMG working conditions comprise a lack of available workplace facilities and safety measures, which eventually impact workers’ health and safety. Study 2 comprising a cross-sectional survey of 411 RMG workers (mean age=26.24 years, SD=6.40, female=80%) based in both Dhaka and Chattogram, the two largest cities with the highest density of RMG factories, examined the prevalence and risk factors of physical and psychological health. Results demonstrated that stress, anxiety, and boredom were prevalent among nearly two-thirds of the respondents, while headaches and colds were prevalent among more than half of the respondents. Overall, working conditions, workplace environments, the nature of RMG work, demographic characteristics, and geographical locations were significant risk factors for workers’ health illnesses. Three additional studies were undertaken to determine how sudden changes impacted RMG workers’ health and wellbeing. In-depth interviews, in Study 3, were conducted with Rana Plaza survivors to examine the long-term impacts of this disaster on them. The study found that Rana Plaza collapse resulted in significant physical (bone injuries/fractures and amputation, severe headache, kidney problems, and functional difficulties) and emotional trauma, depression, and suicidal ideation for those who survived this catastrophic event. In-depth interviews in Study 4 were undertaken to understand the impact of a newly implemented minimum wage structure on the currently employed RMG workers. The study found that working hours, production targets, work pressure, and workplace abuses have been increased alongside the new wage structure. Finally, Study 5 investigated the impact of COVID-19 finding the pandemic will have long-lasting effects on the RMG workers, especially related to their health issues, financial hardship, and inability to pay for essentials such as food, and future employment opportunities. This multi-method, multi-study research contributes to an overall understanding of Bangladeshi RMG workers’ vulnerability to physical and psychological health illnesses. Specifically, identification of high prevalence rates of both physical and psychological health illnesses and modifiable risk factors, various health risks and safety concerns in relation to factory location (Dhaka vs Chattogram) and factory type (Export Processing Zone (EPZ) vs non-EPZ), add new knowledge to the existing literature. The findings of this research provide a holistic view of the challenges of RMG workers and can inform future policy development to ensure their health and safety at work. However, utilising the Marxist notion of ‘accumulation of capital’, the findings are also understood within the cultural conditions of Bangladesh, which severely impede any likely improvement in workplace safety for RMG workers within Bangladesh. Advocacy for such changes will be required through international pressure via clothing supply chains. This research will assist in informing the global evidence base to assist in such efforts