The Diagnosticity of Argument Diagrams

Can argument diagrams be used to diagnose and predict argument performance? Argumentation is a complex domain with robust and often contradictory theories about the structure and scope of valid arguments. Argumentation is central to advanced problem solving in many domains and is a core feature of day-to-day discourse. Argumentation is quite literally, all around us, and yet is rarely taught explicitly. Novices often have difficulty parsing and constructing arguments particularly in written and verbal form. Such formats obscure key argumentative moves and often mask the strengths and weaknesses of the argument structure with complicated phrasing or simple sophistry. Argument diagrams have a long history in the philosophy of argument and have been seen increased application as instructional tools. Argument diagrams reify important argument structures, avoid the serial limitations of text, and are amenable to automatic processing. This thesis addresses the question posed above. In it I show that diagrammatic models of argument can be used to predict students' essay grades and that automatically-induced models can be competitive with human grades. In the course of this analysis I survey analytical tools such as Augmented Graph Grammars that can be applied to formalize argument analysis, and detail a novel Augmented Graph Grammar formalism and implementation used in the study. I also introduce novel machine learning algorithms for regression and tolerance reduction. This work makes contributions to research on Education, Intelligent Tutoring Systems, Machine Learning, Educational Datamining, Graph Analysis, and online grading

Adaptive Rückmeldungen im intelligenten Tutorensystem LARGO

The Intelligent Tutoring System LARGO is designed to help law students learn argumentation skills. The approach implemented in LARGO uses transcripts of oral arguments as learning resources: Students annotate them and create graphical representations of the argument flow. The system encourages students to reflect upon arguments proposed by the attorneys and helps students detect possible weaknesses in their analysis of the dispute. Technically, graph grammar and collaborative filtering algorithms are employed to detect these weaknesses. This article describes how “usage contexts” are determined and used to create adaptive feedback in LARGO. On the basis of a controlled study with the system that took place with law students at the University of Pittsburgh, we discuss to what extent the automatically calculated usage contexts can predict student’s learning gains

Planning gamification strategies based on user characteristics and DM : a gender-based case study.

Gamification frameworks can aid in gamification planning for education. Most frameworks, however, do not provide ways to select, relate or recommend how to use game elements, to gamify a certain educational task. Instead, most provide a "one-size-fits-all" approach covering all learners, without considering different user characteristics, such as gender. Therefore, this work aims to adopt a data-driven approach to provide a set of game element recommendations, based on user preferences, that could be used by teachers and instructors to gamify learning activities. We analysed data from a novel survey of 733 people (male=569 and female=164), collecting information about user preferences regarding game elements. Our results suggest that the most important rules were based on four (out of nineteen) types of game elements: Objectives, Levels, Progress and Choice. From the perspective of user gender, for the female sample, the most interesting rule associated Objectives with Progress, Badges and Information (confidence=0.97), whilst the most interesting rule for the male sample associated also Objectives with Progress, Renovation and Choice (confidence=0.94). These rules and our descriptive analysis provides recommendations on how game elements can be used in educational scenarios.Comment: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1UI28N2UtrOfL06k2mzHIUdPcgQtdfmy9/view?usp=sharin