Algorithms for Secretary Problems on Graphs and Hypergraphs

We examine several online matching problems, with applications to Internet advertising reservation systems. Consider an edge-weighted bipartite graph G, with partite sets L, R. We develop an 8-competitive algorithm for the following secretary problem: Initially given R, and the size of L, the algorithm receives the vertices of L sequentially, in a random order. When a vertex l \in L is seen, all edges incident to l are revealed, together with their weights. The algorithm must immediately either match l to an available vertex of R, or decide that l will remain unmatched. Dimitrov and Plaxton show a 16-competitive algorithm for the transversal matroid secretary problem, which is the special case with weights on vertices, not edges. (Equivalently, one may assume that for each l \in L, the weights on all edges incident to l are identical.) We use a similar algorithm, but simplify and improve the analysis to obtain a better competitive ratio for the more general problem. Perhaps of more interest is the fact that our analysis is easily extended to obtain competitive algorithms for similar problems, such as to find disjoint sets of edges in hypergraphs where edges arrive online. We also introduce secretary problems with adversarially chosen groups. Finally, we give a 2e-competitive algorithm for the secretary problem on graphic matroids, where, with edges appearing online, the goal is to find a maximum-weight acyclic subgraph of a given graph.Comment: 15 pages, 2 figure

The Post-Agreement Negotiation Process: The Problems of Ratifying International Environmental Agreements

National ratification of international environmental agreements is a prime example of post-agreement negotiations. It is often the first subprocess in a larger process of sustained negotiations that occur after international accords are concluded, focused on implementation of those accords. Certainly, implementation of negotiated agreements involves legal, political, verification, and enforcement activities at both domestic and international levels. Many of these activities, including ratification, are characterized by negotiations between various stakeholders to reach mutually beneficial and acceptable means to achieve national implementation of, and compliance with, treaty provisions. This paper places ratification negotiations within the larger conceptual context of post-agreement negotiations, with the goal of understanding and explaining problems of treaty compliance. An empirical analysis is conducted to assess the impact of various inherent and situational factors on problems in the ratification process. Ultimately, we are interested in identifying ways of improving the international negotiation process that initiated these later problems in implementation

Single-Sink Network Design with Vertex Connectivity Requirements

We study single-sink network design problems in undirected graphs with vertex connectivity requirements. The input to these problems is an edge-weighted undirected graph $G=(V,E)$, a sink/root vertex $r$, a set of terminals $T subseteq V$, and integer $k$. The goal is to connect each terminal $t in T$ to $r$ via $k$ emph{vertex-disjoint} paths. In the {em connectivity} problem, the objective is to find a min-cost subgraph of $G$ that contains the desired paths. There is a $2$-approximation for this problem when $k le 2$ cite{FleischerJW} but for $k ge 3$, the first non-trivial approximation was obtained in the recent work of Chakraborty, Chuzhoy and Khanna cite{ChakCK08}; they describe and analyze an algorithm with an approximation ratio of $O(k^{O(k^2)}log^4 n)$ where $n=|V|$. In this paper, inspired by the results and ideas in cite{ChakCK08}, we show an $O(k^{O(k)}log |T|)$-approximation bound for a simple greedy algorithm. Our analysis is based on the dual of a natural linear program and is of independent technical interest. We use the insights from this analysis to obtain an $O(k^{O(k)}log |T|)$-approximation for the more general single-sink {em rent-or-buy} network design problem with vertex connectivity requirements. We further extend the ideas to obtain a poly-logarithmic approximation for the single-sink {em buy-at-bulk} problem when $k=2$ and the number of cable-types is a fixed constant; we believe that this should extend to any fixed $k$. We also show that for the non-uniform buy-at-bulk problem, for each fixed $k$, a small variant of a simple algorithm suggested by Charikar and Kargiazova cite{CharikarK05} for the case of $k=1$ gives an $2^{O(sqrt{log |T|})}$ approximation for larger $k$. These results show that for each of these problems, simple and natural algorithms that have been developed for $k=1$ have good performance for small $k > 1$

Pruning 2-Connected Graphs

Given an edge-weighted undirected graph $G$ with a specified set of terminals, let the emph{density} of any subgraph be the ratio of its weight/cost to the number of terminals it contains. If $G$ is 2-connected, does it contain smaller 2-connected subgraphs of density comparable to that of $G$? We answer this question in the affirmative by giving an algorithm to emph{prune} $G$ and find such subgraphs of any desired size, at the cost of only a logarithmic increase in density (plus a small additive factor). We apply the pruning techniques to give algorithms for two NP-Hard problems on finding large 2-vertex-connected subgraphs of low cost; no previous approximation algorithm was known for either problem. In the kv problem, we are given an undirected graph $G$ with edge costs and an integer $k$; the goal is to find a minimum-cost 2-vertex-connected subgraph of $G$ containing at least $k$ vertices. In the bv problem, we are given the graph $G$ with edge costs, and a budget $B$; the goal is to find a 2-vertex-connected subgraph $H$ of $G$ with total edge cost at most $B$ that maximizes the number of vertices in $H$. We describe an $O(log n log k)$ approximation for the kv problem, and a bicriteria approximation for the bv problem that gives an $O(frac{1}{eps}log^2 n)$ approximation, while violating the budget by a factor of at most $3+eps$