43 research outputs found
Are intuitions about moral relevance susceptible to framing effects?
Various studies have reported that moral intuitions about the permissibility of acts are subject to framing effects. This paper reports the results of a series of experiments which further examine the susceptibility of moral intuitions to framing effects. The main aim was to test recent speculation that intuitions about the moral relevance of certain properties of cases might be relatively resistent to framing effects. If correct, this would provide a certain type of moral intuitionist with the resources to resist challenges to the reliability of moral intuitions based on such framing effects. And, fortunately for such intuitionists, although the results canât be used to mount a strident defence of intuitionism, the results do serve to shift the burden of proof onto those who would claim that intuitions about moral relevance are problematically sensitive to framing effects
Plex: Towards Reliability using Pretrained Large Model Extensions
A recent trend in artificial intelligence is the use of pretrained models for
language and vision tasks, which have achieved extraordinary performance but
also puzzling failures. Probing these models' abilities in diverse ways is
therefore critical to the field. In this paper, we explore the reliability of
models, where we define a reliable model as one that not only achieves strong
predictive performance but also performs well consistently over many
decision-making tasks involving uncertainty (e.g., selective prediction, open
set recognition), robust generalization (e.g., accuracy and proper scoring
rules such as log-likelihood on in- and out-of-distribution datasets), and
adaptation (e.g., active learning, few-shot uncertainty). We devise 10 types of
tasks over 40 datasets in order to evaluate different aspects of reliability on
both vision and language domains. To improve reliability, we developed ViT-Plex
and T5-Plex, pretrained large model extensions for vision and language
modalities, respectively. Plex greatly improves the state-of-the-art across
reliability tasks, and simplifies the traditional protocol as it improves the
out-of-the-box performance and does not require designing scores or tuning the
model for each task. We demonstrate scaling effects over model sizes up to 1B
parameters and pretraining dataset sizes up to 4B examples. We also demonstrate
Plex's capabilities on challenging tasks including zero-shot open set
recognition, active learning, and uncertainty in conversational language
understanding.Comment: Code available at https://goo.gle/plex-cod
Inappropriate stereotypical inferences? An adversarial collaboration in experimental ordinary language philosophy
This paper trials new experimental methods for the analysis of natural language reasoning and the (re)development of critical ordinary language philosophy in the wake of J.L. Austin. Philosophical arguments and thought experiments are strongly shaped by default pragmatic inferences, including stereotypical inferences. Austin suggested that contextually inappropriate stereotypical inferences are at the root of some philosophical paradoxes and problems, and that these can be resolved by exposing those verbal fallacies. This paper builds on recent efforts to empirically document inappropriate stereotypical inferences that may drive philosophical arguments. We demonstrate that previously employed questionnaire-based output measures do not suffice to exclude relevant confounds. We then report an experiment that combines reading time measurements with plausibility ratings. The study seeks to provide evidence of inappropriate stereotypical inferences from appearance verbs that have been suggested to lie at the root of the influential âargument from illusionâ. Our findings support a diagnostic reconstruction of this argument. They provide the missing component for proof of concept for an experimental implementation of critical ordinary language philosophy that is in line with the ambitions of current âevidentialâ experimental philosophy