A comparative study of clinical trial and real-world data in patients with diabetic kidney disease

A growing body of research is focusing on real-world data (RWD) to supplement or replace randomized controlled trials (RCTs). However, due to the disparities in data generation mechanisms, differences are likely and necessitate scrutiny to validate the merging of these datasets. We compared the characteristics of RCT data from 5734 diabetic kidney disease patients with corresponding RWD from electronic health records (EHRs) of 23,523 patients. Demographics, diagnoses, medications, laboratory measurements, and vital signs were analyzed using visualization, statistical comparison, and cluster analysis. RCT and RWD sets exhibited significant differences in prevalence, longitudinality, completeness, and sampling density. The cluster analysis revealed distinct patient subgroups within both RCT and RWD sets, as well as clusters containing patients from both sets. We stress the importance of validation to verify the feasibility of combining RCT and RWD, for instance, in building an external control arm. Our results highlight general differences between RCT and RWD sets, which should be considered during the planning stages of an RCT-RWD study. If they are, RWD has the potential to enrich RCT data by providing first-hand baseline data, filling in missing data or by subgrouping or matching individuals, which calls for advanced methods to mitigate the differences between datasets.Peer reviewe

Umbilical cord blood DNA methylation in children who later develop type 1 diabetes

Abstract Aims/hypothesis: Distinct DNA methylation patterns have recently been observed to precede type 1 diabetes in whole blood collected from young children. Our aim was to determine whether perinatal DNA methylation is associated with later progression to type 1 diabetes. Methods: Reduced representation bisulphite sequencing (RRBS) analysis was performed on umbilical cord blood samples collected within the Finnish Type 1 Diabetes Prediction and Prevention (DIPP) Study. Children later diagnosed with type 1 diabetes and/or who tested positive for multiple islet autoantibodies (n = 43) were compared with control individuals (n = 79) who remained autoantibody-negative throughout the DIPP follow-up until 15 years of age. Potential confounding factors related to the pregnancy and the mother were included in the analysis. Results: No differences in the umbilical cord blood methylation patterns were observed between the cases and controls at a false discovery rate <0.05. Conclusions/interpretation: Based on our results, differences between children who progress to type 1 diabetes and those who remain healthy throughout childhood are not yet present in the perinatal DNA methylome. However, we cannot exclude the possibility that such differences would be found in a larger dataset