The modern interpretation of the Wittig reaction mechanism

The mechanism of the Wittig reaction has long been a contentious issue in organic chemistry. Even now, more than 50 years after its announcement, its presentation in many modern undergraduate textbooks is either overly simplified or entirely inaccurate. In this review, we gather together the huge body of evidence that has been amassed to show that the Li salt-free Wittig reactions of non-stabilised, semi-stabilised and stabilised ylides all occur under kinetic control by a common mechanism in which oxaphosphetane (OPA) is the first-formed and only intermediate. The numerous recent significant additions to the subject – including computational studies and experimental material pertinent to both steps of the reaction (OPA formation and its decomposition) are discussed in detail, and the currently accepted explanations for the source of the stereoselectivity in Wittig reactions are given. We also present the other mechanistic proposals that have been made during the history of the Wittig reaction, and show how they are unable to account for all of the experimental evidence that is now available. Details of certain experimental facts to do with Wittig reactions in the presence of Li cation are also included, although the precise mechanistic details of such reactions are yet to be established conclusively. We make the case that a clear distinction should henceforth be made between the unknown “Li-present” and the now well-established “Li salt-free” Wittig mechanisms

The mechanism of phosphonium ylide alcoholysis and hydrolysis: concerted addition of the O-H bond across the P=C bond

The previous work on the hydrolysis and alcoholysis reactions of phosphonium ylides is summarized and reviewed in the context of their currently accepted mechanisms. Several experimental facts relating to ylide hydrolysis and to salt and ylide alcoholysis are shown to conflict with those mechanisms. In particular, we demonstrate that the pK(a) values of water and alcohols are too high in organic media to bring about protonation of ylide. Therefore, we propose concerted addition of the water or alcohol O-H bond across the ylide P=C bond. In support of this, we provide NMR spectroscopic evidence for equilibrium between ylide and aclohol that does not require the involvement of phosphonium hydroxide. We report the first P-alkoxyphosphorane to be characterised by NMR spectroscopy that does not undergo exchange on an NMR timescale. Two-dimensional NMR spectroscopic techniques have been applied to the characterisation to P-alkoxyphosphoranes for the first time

First ever observation of the intermediate of phosphonium salt and ylide hydrolysis: P-hydroxytetraorganophosphorane

P-Hydroxytetraorganophosphorane, the long-postulated intermediate in phosphonium salt and ylide hydrolysis, has been observed and characterised by low temperature NMR, finally definitively establishing its involvement in these reactions. The results require modification of the previously accepted mechanism for ylide hydrolysis: P-hydroxy-tetraorganophosphorane is generated directly by 4-centre reaction of ylide with water

Investigations on the operation of stereochemical drift in the Wittig reaction by NMR and variable-temperature NMR spectroscopy of oxaphosphetane intermediates and their quench products

Within the currently accepted mechanism of the Li‐salt‐free Wittig reaction, the phenomenon of stereochemical drift remains the one remaining “loose end” in an otherwise internally consistent explanation of a large body of diverse observations. The term describes the nonstereospecific decomposition of the oxaphosphetane (OPA) intermediate in reactions of certain alkylides with certain aldehydes. In this paper, it is shown that the previous examples in which drift occurs are not merely isolated aberrations from the observed norm, but rather that there is a general phenomenon in reactions of ethylides with benzaldehydes. Variable‐temperature NMR (VTNMR) spectroscopy was used to establish that the amount and diastereomeric ratio of the OPA intermediates do not change below a certain temperature. At and above the temperature at which OPA decomposition to alkene and phosphine oxide begins to occur, the alkene shows a different diastereomeric ratio to the OPA, which indicates the occurrence of stereochemical drift. In one example, owing to an apparent remarkable coincidence of rates, the diastereomeric ratio of the OPA does not change above the decomposition temperature, even though stereochemical drift occurs in the formation of the alkene product. An alternative mechanism for drift involving its catalysis by aldehyde was not confirmed. Drift was also shown not to occur in similar Wittig reactions of structurally related longer‐chain alkylides by stereospecific decomposition of OPA intermediates generated from β‐hydroxyphosphonium salts (β‐HPSs). The extremely useful (and generally applicable) NMR techniques, 1H–31P HMBC and selective 1H{31P}, which we have utilised to establish kinetic diastereomeric ratios, are described in full for the first time. Details of the determination of the relative stereochemistry of two β‐HPSs (derived from acid quenching of OPAs) by X‐ray crystallography are also given