Farmers Engaged in Deliberative Practice; An Ethnographic Exploration of the Mosaic of Concerns in Livestock Agriculture

A plethora of ethical issues in livestock agriculture has emerged to public attention in recent decades, of which environmental and animal welfare concerns are but two, albeit prominent, themes. For livestock agriculture to be considered sustainable, somehow these interconnected themes need to be addressed. Ethical debate on these issues has been extensive, but mostly started from and focused on single issues. The views of farmers in these debates have been largely absent, or merely figured as interests, instead of being considered morally worthwhile themselves. In this paper the relevance for ethical debates of the ways farmers discuss and engage with moral concerns is explored. The variety of norms that figure in contemporary farming practices is sketched in its multifarious complexity, illustrated by ethnographic fieldwork, and systematized in terms of “orders of worth.” Reviewing the practical arguments and commitments of farmers within this framework reveals that farming practices are subject to mixed motives, in which an amalgam of types of concerns play a role. Recognition of the peculiarly entangled nature of the ethics of farming practices could counter the tendency in policy making, technological innovation, and ethical thought to compartmentalize our moral landscape. Understanding farming practice as the integration of a mosaic of concerns in the light of a variety of moral experiences would foster public appreciation of positions of farmers in debates on improving the sustainability and societal acceptability of livestock agricultur

Animal deliberation : the co-evolution of technology and ethics on the farm

cum laude graduatio

"Neem het dier serieus als individu"

Ethiek op de boerderij komt het beste uit de verf door samen met dieren nieuwe technologie te ontwikkelen. Filosoof Clemens Driessen, de man van het varkensspel Pig Chase, promoveerde afgelopen week cum laude op Animal deliberation, the co-evolution of technology and ethics on the farm. Resource stelt er een paar vragen over

Animal Deliberation

While much has been written on environmental politics on the one hand, and animal ethics and welfare on the other, animal politics, as the interface of the two, is underexamined. There are key political implications in the increase of animal protection laws, the rights of nature, and political parties and movements dedicated to animals. What are the implications of the increasing attention and popularity of ethical discourses on animal welfare and animal rights for politics and political philosophy? What is the animal's place in environmental political thought – and in 21st Century political philosophy per se? What can, rather than should, politics do for animals – what institutions and practices are suitable and desirable? Can animal ethics learn from animal politics

Een kleine filosofie van de visstick

Veel mensen beschouwen vissen als slijmerige en gedachteloze wezens. Als gevolg daarvan wordt de vis vaak vergeten in de ethiek. Maar vissen zijn meer dan zwemmende eiwitbronnen, stelt Clemens Driessen. Zijn voorstel: een ethiek van ontzag, speciaal voor de vis