Eficácia da estimulação transcraniana com corrente contínua de longo prazo em nível domiciliar sobre o córtex pré-frontal dorsolateral esquerdo na fibromialgia : um ensaio clínico randomizado

Introdução: Estimulação transcraniana com corrente contínua (ETCC) é um método não invasivo de estimulação cerebral que modifica o potencial de repouso da membrana neuronal através de uma corrente elétrica de baixa intensidade. Trata-se de uma técnica neuromodulatória aplicável ao contexto terapêutico de disfunções do sistema nervoso implicados na fisiopatologia da dor e transtornos neuropsiquiátricos, com baixo custo, mínimos efeitos adversos e fácil aplicação. A ETCC tem se mostrado eficaz no tratamento de dores crônicas incluindo a fibromialgia (FM) em curto prazo. Seu uso se sustenta na melhor compreensão dos mecanismos fisiopatológicos dessa síndrome, os quais incluem processos de desinibição em nível cortical e infracortical, demonstrado por medidas neurofisiológicas como facilitação e desinibição, assim como redução da potência dos sistemas modulatórios descendentes da dor, além de alterações nas vias nociceptivas periféricas, como as fibras nervosas finas. No entanto, essa alteração isolada não foi previamente associada à disfunção no sistema de modulação descendente da dor (SMDD), observado na FM. As áreas de aplicação da ETCC dependem do objetivo terapêutico. O córtex motor primário (M1) é o alvo mais estudado e com maior contingente de evidências para o tratamento da dor e reabilitação motora, enquanto o córtex pré-frontal dorsolateral esquerdo (DLPFC) tem sido eficaz na depressão e melhora dos componentes psicoafetivos dos pacientes com dor crônica. Seu principal limitador prático é a necessidade de ir ao centro de atendimento durante dias consecutivos, pois o efeito terapêutico sustentado da ETCC necessita repetição das sessões Objetivos: Esta tese está constituída por dois estudos. O primeiro objetiva examinar se a disfunção de fibras finas que ocorre em pacientes com FM está ligada a um mau funcionamento do sistema modulador descendente da dor. No segundo, o objetivo é avaliar a eficácia do uso em longo prazo da ETCC em nível domiciliar na FM, com o objetivo de facilitar o uso e permitir a disponibilização desta técnica a pacientes do Sistema Único de Saúde. Estudo I: No primeiro estudo avaliamos se a disfunção de fibras nervosas finas periféricas está ligada a um mau funcionamento do sistema modulador descendente da dor (SMD) na FM. Métodos: Foi realizado um estudo exploratório no qual 41 mulheres com FM e 28 voluntárias saudáveis foram submetidas a testes psicofísicos que avaliaram a função de fibras sensitivas envolvidas na nocicepção. O teste quantitativo sensorial (QST) foi utilizado para medir o limiar perceptivo térmico (HTT), o limiar de dor térmica (HPT) e o limiar de tolerância à dor térmica (HPTo), bem como avaliar a mudança na Escala Numérica de Dor (NPS0-10) durante uma tarefa de modulação da dor condicionada (CPM-task). A algometria foi utilizada para determinar o limiar de pressão de dor (PPT). Escalas para avaliação de catastrofização, ansiedade, depressão e distúrbios do sono também foram aplicadas. O fator neurotrófico derivado do cérebro (BDNF) foi medido como um marcador de neuroplasticidade. Realizamos modelos de regressão linear multivariada por grupo (saudáveis e FM) para estudar a relação entre a função do SMD e sua relação com as medidas psicofísicas. Resultados: As amostras diferiram em seu perfil psicológico, e nas medidas psicofísicas, o grupo e pacientes com FM apresentou menor sensibilidade e limiares de dor. Na FM, mas não nos saudáveis, os modelos de regressão revelaram que o HTT estava relacionado ao BDNF e ao CPM-Task (Hotelling's Trace = 1,80, P<0,001, poder=0,94, R2=0,64). HTT foi correlacionado positivamente com a CPM-task (B = 0,98, P= 0,004, Partial-ƞ2=0,25), e ao HPT (B=1,61, P=0,008, parcial -ƞ2= 0,21). No entanto PPT não foi correlacionado com o HTT. Na FM a relação do BDNF com CPM-Task teve uma relação negativa (B=-0,04, P=0,043, parcial-ƞ2=0,12) e a HPT foi diretamente proporcional (B= - 0,08, P=0,03, parcial-ƞ2 = 0,14). O BDNF não influenciou no modelo. E os efeitos adversos relatados foram maiores no grupo ativo (17,8%) em comparação com o grupo sham (6,6%). Conclusão: A disfunção sensorial periférica está associada positivamente à disfunção do sistema modulatório descendente da dor e aos níveis séricos de BDNF na FM, o que não ocorre em indivíduos saudáveis. Estudo II: O segundo estudo teve como objetivo avaliar a eficácia do uso domiciliar de 60 sessões da ETCC-ativa e ETCC-simulada aplicadas sobre a área DLPFC esquerda, nas pacientes com diagnóstico de FM. Métodos: Foi realizado um ensaio clínico randomizado, duplo cego, em paralelo, controlado com ETCC-simulada em 20 mulheres com diagnóstico de fibromialgia. A estimulação foi realizada durante cinco dias consecutivos na semana, durante 30 min, com a intensidade de 2 mA, por 12 semanas, totalizando 60 sessões. As pacientes receberam treinamento para uso do equipamento especialmente desenvolvido para uso domiciliar e mantinham contato com o pesquisador responsável por meio de mensagem de texto diariamente. Os efeitos foram medidos por meio da escala visual de dor (EAV) durante o curso de 12 semanas de tratamento, bem como o uso de analgésicos e possíveis eventos adversos, diariamente. Foram avaliados os níveis de depressão, catastrofismo e capacidade funcional para tarefas diárias, QST para verificar limiar de dor e tolerância ao calor, PPT e dosagem dos níveis séricos de BDNF no início, após 30 sessões e no final do tratamento. Um modelo linear misto com efeitos fixos foi usado para comparar mudanças nos escores de dor na EAV ao longo do tratamento. Resultados: A ETCC ativa domiciliar reduziu os escores de dor pela EAV (p<0.001) quando comparado ao sham, com uma redução média de dor de 64% (p<0.001). Além disso, ETCC ativa reduziu significativamente a incapacidade relacionada a dor [B-PCP:S escore total (p=0.023);-ƞ2=0.61]. Também reduziu os escores nas medidas clínicas de depressão, catastrofismo e qualidade do sono [BDI-II, PCS e PSQI (p<0.05)]. No entanto, ETCC ativa aumentou os escores na algometria (PPT) e tolerância térmica (HPTo) (p<0.01). O BDNF não influenciou no modelo. Os efeitos adversos relatados foram maiores no grupo ativo (17,8%) em comparação com o grupo sham (6,6%). Conclusão: A ETCC para uso domiciliar mostrou-se segura e eficaz na redução da dor, incapacidade relacionada a dor, sintomas depressivos e catastróficos e redução do uso de analgésicos. O conjunto de dados desta tese sugere que em pacientes fibromiálgicas, o nível de disfunção do sistema modulador descendente da dor está relacionado ao nível de disfunção de fibras nervosas finas periféricas envolvidas na nocicepção. Além disso, a ETCC de longo prazo em fibromiálgicas foi eficaz na melhora dos sintomas disfuncionais relacionados à dor crônica e se mostrou adequada para uso domiciliar.Introduction: Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) is a noninvasive method of brain stimulation that modifies the resting potential of the neuronal membrane through a low intensity electrical current. It is a neuromodulatory technique to the therapeutic context of dysfunctions of the nervous system implicit in physiotherapy and neuropsychological disorders, with low cost, adverse effects and easy application. tDCS has been effective without a chronic fight process, including fibromyalgia (FM), in which the processes of disinhibition are cortical and infracortical, demonstrated by neurophysiological as intracortical facilitation and desinhibition, as well as reduction of the power of the systems descending pain modulators. In addition, studies have shown a severity of inhibition of central positive correlation with BDNF (Brain Derived Neurotrophic Factor) levels and seems to have some relation to the peripheral nociceptive pathways, as the areas of application of the stimulation depend on the primary motor cortex (M1) is the most studied target and the largest contingent of selection for the treatment of pain and motor reaction, while the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) was effective in the treatment of depression and psychoaffective components in cases of patients with the chronic condition. Although tDCS has been successful in treating FM, its main limiter is a need for the service center for consecutive days as it has cumulative effect. In fact, the erasure of the sessions guaranteed the therapeutic effect of the ETCC. The application of measures on consecutive days motivated the study of its value when applied at the household level, in order to allow the large-scale treatment technique to be adopted in the Unified Health System. This is proved by two studies. The first objective is to examine whether a fine-fiber dysfunction that occurs in patients with FM is linked to an operation of the pain-modulating system. Neuropathy of long nerve fibers has been implicated by a descriptor of pain, neurophysiological and psychophysiological neurophysiology, as well as skin biopsy studies. However, this comparison was not associated with dysfunction in the descending pain system (DPMS) not on FM. Objective did the study explore the association of dysfunction of small fibers with the DPMS and other substitutes for nociceptive changes in FM. In the second, the term is a measure of long-term use of ETCC at household level in FM Study I: In this first study evaluating the presence of nerve and peripheral fiber failure, it is linked to the functioning of the descending pain modulator system (DPMS) in FM Methods: It was performed an exploratory study with 41 FM women and 28 healthy volunteers whose were evaluated in psychophysical tests that evaluated a function of sensory fibers involved in nociception. The quantitative sensory test (QST) was used to measure the Heat thermal threshold (HTT), the heat pain threshold (HPT) and the thermal pain tolerance (HPTo), as well as the numerical scale of pain (NPS0 -10 ) over a task of modulation of conditioned pain (CPM-task). Algometry was used to determine the pain pressure threshold (PPT). Scales for evaluation of catastrophic, anxiety, depression and sleep disorders were also applied. Brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) was measured as a marker of neuroplasticity. Multivariate linear regression models by group (health and FM) for a relationship between a descending modulatory system function and its relationship with psychophysical measures. Results: The samples differed in their psychological profile, and in the psychophysical measures, the group and the patients with FM had lower sensitivity and pain thresholds. At FM, regression models revealed that HTT was related to BDNF and CPM-Task (Hotelling's Trace = 1.80, P <0.001, power = 0.94, R2 = 0.64). HTT was positively correlated with a CPM task (B = 0.98, P = 0.004, partial-ƞ2 = 0.25), and HPT (B = 1.61, P = 0.008, partial -ƞ2 = 0.21) . However PPT was not correlated with HTT. In FM, the relationship of BDNF with CPM, a negative relation was found (B = -0.04, P = 0.043, partial- = 2 = 0.12) and HPT was proportionally (B = -0.08, P = 0.03, partial-ƞ2 = 0.14). BDNF did not influence the model. And the adverse effects reported were higher in the active group (17.8%) compared to the sham group (6.6%). Conclusion: Peripheral sensory dysfunction is positively associated with the modulating dysfunction of BDNF levels in FM, which does not occur in isolated individuals. Study II: The second study had the purpose of evaluating the home use of 60 sessions of atDCS and s-tDCS on a left DLPFC area in patients with FM. Methods: A randomized, double-blind, parallel-sham controlled study in 20 women with FM. Stimulation was performed for five consecutive days in the week for 30 min at the intensity of 2 mA for 12 weeks, totaling 60 sessions. Patients were trained to use equipment specially designed for home use and maintained contact with the researcher responsible through daily text message. The effects were measured through visual pain scale (VAS) daily during the course of 12 weeks of treatment, as well as the use of analgesics and possible adverse events daily. The levels of depression, catastrophism and disability for daily tasks were assessed. The QST was used to check pain threshold and tolerance to heat, an algometry was used to check pressure pain threshold (PPT) and blood collection was performed to evaluate serum BDNF levels at baseline, after 30 sessions and at the end of treatment. A Mixed Linear Model with fixed effects was used to compare changes in pain scores in VAS throughout the treatment. Results: Home-based tDCS reduced dairy pain VAS scores (p<0.001), with cumulative mean pain drop of 64% (p<0.001). Furthermore, active home-based tDCS reduced significantly disability due to pain [B-PCP:S total scores (p=0.023; partial-ƞ2=0.61]. And also reduced scores in clinical measures like depression scores, catastrophizing pain scores and sleep quality scores [BDI-II and PCS (p<0.05), PSQI (p<0.05)]. However, active homebased tDCS enhance scores in algometry (PPT) and heat pain tolerance (HPTo) (p<0.01). Conclusion: Home-based anodal tDCS applied over the DLPFC in FM had a baseline neuroplasticity-dependent reduction effect on pain. In addition, it improved the disability due to pain, depressive symptoms and pain catastrophizing. It reduced the analgesic use and increased pressure and heat pain tolerance

Insights about the neuroplasticity state on the effect of intramuscular electrical stimulation in pain and disability associated with Chronic Myofascial Pain Syndrome (MPS) : a double-blind, randomized, sham-controlled trial

Background: There is limited evidence concerning the effect of intramuscular electrical stimulation (EIMS) on the neural mechanisms of pain and disability associated with chronic Myofascial Pain Syndrome (MPS). Objectives: To provide new insights into the EIMS long-term effect on pain and disability related to chronic MPS (primary outcomes). To assess if the neuroplasticity state at baseline could predict the long-term impact of EIMS on disability due to MPS we examined the relationship between the serum brain-derived-neurotrophic-factor (BDNF) and by motor evoked potential (MEP). Also, we evaluated if the EIMS could improve the descending pain modulatory system (DPMS) and the cortical excitability measured by transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) parameters. Methods: We included 24 right-handed female with chronic MPS, 19-65 years old. They were randomically allocated to receive ten sessions of EIMS, 2 Hz at the cervical paraspinal region or a sham intervention (n = 12). Results: A mixed model analysis of variance revealed that EIMS decreased daily pain scores by -73.02% [95% confidence interval (CI) = -95.28 to -52.30] and disability due to pain -43.19 (95%CI, -57.23 to -29.39) at 3 months of follow up. The relative risk for using analgesics was 2.95 (95% CI, 1.36 to 6.30) in the sham group. In the EIMS and sham, the change on the Numerical Pain Scale (NPS0-10) throughout CPM-task was -2.04 (0.79) vs. -0.94 (1.18), respectively, (P = 0.01). EIMS reduced the MEP -28.79 (-53.44 to -4.15), while improved DPMS and intracortical inhibition. The MEP amplitude before treatment [(Beta = -0.61, (-0.58 to -0.26)] and a more significant change from pre- to post-treatment on serum BDNF) (Beta = 0.67; CI95% = 0.07 to 1.26) were predictors to EIMS effect on pain and disability due to pain. Conclusion: These findings suggest that a bottom-up effect induced by the EIMS reduced the analgesic use, improved pain, and disability due to chronic MPS. This effect might be mediated by an enhancing of corticospinal inhibition as seen by an increase in IC and a decrease in MEP amplitude. Likewise, the MEP amplitude before treatment and the changes induced by the EIMS in the serum BDNF predicted it's long-term clinical impact on pain and disability due MPS. The trial is recorded in ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT02381171

Longer cortical silent period length is associated to binge eating disorder : an exploratory study

Introduction: Although binge eating disorder (BED) is an eating disorder and obesity is a clinical disease, it is known that both conditions present overlapped symptoms related to, at least partially, the disruption of homeostatic and hedonistic eating behavior pathways. Therefore, the understanding of neural substrates, such as the motor cortex excitability assessed by transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS), might provide new insights into the pathophysiology of BED and obesity. Objectives: (i) To compare, among BED, obesity, ex-obese, and HC (healthy control) subjects, the cortical excitability indexed by TMS measures, such as CSP (cortical silent period; primary outcome), SICI (intracortical inhibition), and ICF (intracortical facilitation; secondary outcome). (ii) To explore the relationship of the CSP, eating behavior (e.g., restraint, disinhibition, and hunger), depressive symptoms, and sleep quality among the four groups (BED, obesity, ex-obese, and HC). Methods: Fifty-nine women [BED (n = 13), obese (n = 20), ex-obese (n = 12), and HC (n = 14)] comprise the total sample for this study. Assessments: cortical excitability measures (CSP, SICI, and ICF), inhibition response task by the Go/No-go paradigm, and instruments to assess the eating psychopathology (Three-Factor Eating Questionnaire, Eating Disorder Examination Questionnaire, and Binge Eating Scale) were used. Results: A MANCOVA analysis revealed that the mean of CSP was longer in the BED group compared with other three groups: 24.10% longer than the obesity group, 25.98% longer than the HC group, and 25.41% longer than the ex-obese group. Pearson's correlations evidenced that CSP was positively associated with both eating concern and binge eating scores. Conclusion: The findings point out that BED patients present longer CSP, which might suggest an upregulation of intracortical inhibition. Additionally, CSP was positively correlated with Binge Eating Scale and eating concern scores. Further studies are needed

Association of anxiety with intracortical inhibition and descending pain modulation in chronic myofascial pain syndrome

Background: This study aimed to answer three questions related to chronic myofascial pain syndrome (MPS): 1) Is the motor cortex excitability, as assessed by transcranial magnetic stimulation parameters (TMS), related to state-trait anxiety? 2) Does anxiety modulate corticospinal excitability changes after evoked pain by Quantitative Sensory Testing (QST)? 3) Does the state-trait anxiety predict the response to pain evoked by QST if simultaneously receiving a heterotopic stimulus [Conditional Pain Modulation (CPM)]? We included females with chronic MPS (n = 47) and healthy controls (n = 11), aged 19 to 65 years. Motor cortex excitability was assessed by TMS, and anxiety was assessed based on the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory. The disability related to pain (DRP) was assessed by the Profile of Chronic Pain scale for the Brazilian population (B:PCP:S), and the psychophysical pain measurements were measured by the QST and CPM. Results: In patients, trait-anxiety was positively correlated to intracortical facilitation (ICF) at baseline and after QST evoked pain (β = 0.05 and β = 0.04, respectively) and negatively correlated to the cortical silent period (CSP) (β = -1.17 and β = -1.23, respectively) (P <0.05 for all comparisons). After QST evoked pain, the DRP was positively correlated to ICF (β = 0.02) (P < 0.05). Pain scores during CPM were positively correlated with trait-anxiety when it was concurrently with high DRP (β = 0.39; P = 0.02). Controls’ cortical excitability remained unchanged after QST. Conclusions: These findings suggest that, in chronic MPS, the imbalance between excitatory and inhibitory descending systems of the corticospinal tract is associated with higher trait-anxiety concurrent with higher DRP

Intramuscular electrical stimulus potentiates the motor cortex modulation effects on pain and descending inhibitory systems in knee osteoarthritis : a randomized, factorial, sham-controlled study

Background: Neuroplastic changes in nociceptive pathways contribute to severity of symptoms in knee osteoarthritis (KOA). A new look at neuroplastic changes management includes modulation of the primary motor cortex by transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS). Objectives: We investigated whether tDCS combined with intramuscular electrical stimulation (EIMS) would be more efficacious than a sham (s) intervention (s-tDCS/s-EIMS) or a single active(a)-tDCS/s-EIMS intervention and/or s-tDCS/a-EIMS in the following domains: pain measures (visual analog scale [VAS] score and descending pain modulatory system [DPMS], and outcomes, and analgesic use, disability, and pain pressure threshold (PPT) for secondary outcomes. Registration: The trial is registered in Clinical trials.gov: NCT01747070. Methods: Sixty women with KOA, aged 50–75 years old, randomly received five sessions of one of the four interventions (a-tDCS/a-EIMS, s-tDCS/s-EIMS, a-tDCS/s-EIMS, and s-tDCS/a- EIMS). tDCS was applied over the primary motor cortex (M1), for 30 minutes at 2 mA and the EIMS paraspinal of L1–S2. Results: A generalized estimating equation model revealed the main effect of the a-tDCS/a- EIMS in the VAS pain scores at end treatment compared with the other three groups (P<0.0001). There existed a significant effect of time and a significant interaction between group and time (P<0.01 for both). The delta-(Δ) pain score on VAS in the a-tDCS/a-EIMS group was –3.59, 95% CI: –4.10 to –2.63. The (Δ) pain scores on VAS in the other three groups were: a-tDCS/s- EIMS=−2.13, 95% CI: −2.48 to –1.64; s-tDCS/a-EIMS=−2.25, 95% CI: −2.59 to –1.68; s-tDCS/s-EIMS MR =–1.77, 95% CI: –2.08 to –1.38. The a-tDCS/a-EIMS led to better effect in DPMS, PPT, analgesic use, and disability related to pain. Conclusion: This study provides additional evidence regarding additive clinical effects to improve pain measures and descending pain inhibitory controls when the neuromodulation of the primary motor cortex with tDCS is combined with a bottom-up modulation with EIMS in KOA. Also, it improved the ability to walk due to reduced pain and reduced analgesic use

Potency of descending pain modulatory system is linked with peripheral sensory dysfunction in fibromyalgia : An exploratory study

Fibromyalgia (FM) is characterized by chronic widespread pain whose pathophysiological mechanism is related to central and peripheral nervous system dysfunction. Neuropathy of small nerve fibers has been implicated due to related pain descriptors, psychophysical pain, and neurophysiological testing, as well as skin biopsy studies. Nevertheless, this alteration alone has not been previously associated to the dysfunction in the descending pain modulatory system (DPMS) that is observed in FM. We hypothesize that they associated, thus, we conducted a cross-sectional exploratory study. To explore small fiber dysfunction using quantitative sensory testing (QST) is associated with the DPMS and other surrogates of nociceptive pathways alterations in FM. We run a cross-sectional study and recruited 41 women with FM, and 28 healthy female volunteers. We used the QST to measure the thermal heat threshold (HTT), heat pain threshold (HPT), heat pain tolerance (HPT), heat pain tolerance (HPTo), and conditional pain modulation task (CPM-task). Algometry was used to determine the pain pressure threshold (PPT). Scales to assess catastrophizing, anxiety, depression, and sleep disturbances were also applied. Serum brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) was measured as a marker of neuroplasticity. We run multivariate linear regression models by group to study their relationships. Samples differed in their psychophysical profile, where FM presented lower sensitivity and pain thresholds. In FM but not in the healthy subjects, regression models revealed that serum BDNF was related to HTT and CPM-Task (Hotelling Trace=1.80, P<.001, power=0.94, R2=0.64). HTT was directly related to CPM-Task (B=0.98, P=.004, partial-n2=0.25), and to HPT (B=1.61, P=.008, partial n2=0.21), but not to PPT. Meanwhile, BDNF relationship to CPM-Task was inverse (B=–0.04, P=.043, partial-n2=0.12), and to HPT was direct (B=–0.08, P=.03, partial-n2=0.14). These findings high spot that in FM the disinhibition of the DPMS is positively correlated with the dysfunction in peripheral sensory neurons assessed by QST and conversely with serum BDNF. Abbreviations: ACR = American College of Rheumatology, BDI-II = Beck Depression Inventory, BDNF = brain-derived neurotrophic factor, BP-PCS = Brazilian Portuguese Catastrophizing Scale, CPM-task = conditional pain modulation task, DPMS = descending pain modulatory system, ELISA = Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay, FIQ = Fibromyalgia Impact Questionnaire, FM = Fibromyalgia, HCPA = Hospital de Clinicas de Porto Alegre, HPT = heat pain threshold, HPTO = heat pain tolerance, HTT = thermal heat threshold, LTD = long term depression, NGF = neural growth factor, NMDA = N-methyl-D-aspartate, NPS = numerical pain scale, NRM = nucleus raphe magnus, PKC = Protein kinase C, PPT = pain pressure threshold, PSQI = Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index, QST = quantitative sensory testing, STAI = State-Trait Anxiety Inventory, STT = spinothalamic tract, tDCS = transcranial direct