On the Measurement of Quantum Work: Operational Aspects

Work is one of the cornerstones of classical thermodynamics. However, a direct transfer of this concept to quantum systems has proved problematic, especially for non-equilibrium processes. Unlike in the classical case, quantum work cannot be defined unambiguously. Depending on the specific setting and the imposed assumptions, different definitions are well motivated. In particular, in quantum thermodynamics, a clear distinction must be made between the measurement, storage, and use of work, since these three facets of the concept are not necessarily compatible with each other. The present thesis is mainly concerned with the measurement aspect. With the help of illustrative scenarios several approaches to quantum work measurements, their advantages and drawbacks are discussed. The focus will be on the question to what extent quantumness plays a decisive role in such scenarios, both in a qualitative and quantitative sense. Based on the gedankenexperiment of a Szilárd machine a criterion is proposed which can be used to verify genuine quantum correlations between the work medium in a heat engine and its thermal environment. In a Szilárd scenario a Maxwell's demon determines the state of the work medium and uses this information to extract work. We split this model into a bipartite setting. The demon only has access to the environment and, thus, can only indirectly measure the state of the work medium. By sharing the acquired information with another agent, the latter can extract work. The question of the quantumness of the experiment can then be reduced to the question of the maximum attainable work in the context of a suitable quantum steering scenario. For the constructed setting a bound for the work output achievable for classical correlations between the engine and the environment is derived. Work extraction beyond this classical limit thus proves the quantum nature of the machine. The verification of non-classical correlations by means of quantum steering is motivated by the fact that such a scenario reflects the typical asymmetry of a thermodynamic setup. While the machine itself is considered to be controllable and characterized in detail, no requirements are imposed on the correlated environment and the measurements performed on it. Consequently, this verification of a truly quantum heat engine is semi-device-independent. In a second scenario, the compatibility of average work and work fluctuations in a driven system is discussed. Fluctuation theorems play an important role in classical non-equilibrium thermodynamics. The best-known example is the Jarzynski equality. This equation establishes a connection between the free energy difference of two equilibrium states and the fluctuating work measured in a non-equilibrium process. A transfer of the Jarzynski equality to quantum systems succeeds most simply if the work definition is based on a so-called two-point measurement scheme. This approach determines the work as the difference of two projective energy measurements. The disadvantage of this definition is the unavoidable disturbance of the quantum state by the measurement, which makes a determination of the correct average work impossible. By means of a generalized two-point measurement scheme, it is shown how this contradiction between fluctuating and average work can be overcome. The approach is based on the concept of joint measurability. Unsharp measurements with a smaller disturbance of the quantum state can be measured jointly and allow for the determination of the correct average work. Nevertheless, the connection between measured fluctuations and the change of free energy can be preserved by means of a modified Jarzynski equality, as elucidated in this thesis. Even though the two-point measurement scheme - both in its projective form and in the generalized variant presented in this thesis - satisfies a Jarzynski equality, the operationality and the associated experimental significance are to be assessed differently than in the classical case. In classical thermodynamics, the Jarzynski relation can be used practically to determine, for example, the change of free energy in RNA molecules. However, it is crucial for such an experiment that the non-equilibrium work can actually be measured without requiring detailed knowledge of the system under consideration. In contrast, the two-point measurement scheme defines work as the energy difference of the system between the beginning and the end of the process. Crucially, for the measurement of these energies the Hamiltonians have to be known and the free energy difference could therefore be calculated directly from this knowledge without reference to the Jarzynski equality. Thus, the operationality of the quantum Jarzynski relation differs fundamentally from its classical counterpart. In this thesis we develop a measurement scheme which, in principle, allows us to employ a quantum version of the Jarzynski equation without knowledge of the Hamiltonians. The crucial point is to include the apparatus that drives the system out of equilibrium in the quantum picture and to define the work measurement on that very apparatus. Such a work measurement can only be meaningfully defined as a quantum expectation value and work fluctuations cannot directly be measured, in contrast to the classical case. The work along a classical microstate trajectory can be determined in a single run. The trajectory itself does not need to be known for this purpose; its existence is sufficient. Quantum trajectories do not exist unless they are objectified by a measurement. It is shown how measurements on the environment of the system can provide information about the trajectories. A conditioning of the measured work on these trajectories then allows for the determination of work fluctuations in the quantum system. For these fluctuations an inequality is conjectured whose limit is given by the classical Jarzynski equation. Numerical results support the conjecture. A proof is still missing. By means of the presented framework, the free energy difference of a quantum system can, in principle, be determined without knowledge of the underlying Hamiltonian. However, as is shown, this requires an optimization over several external parameters, since the inequality in general provides only an upper bound. Thus, the operationality of the model enforces a quantum disadvantage. The methods presented in this thesis can be applied to various scenarios in quantum thermodynamics. Especially the framework for work measurements on an external apparatus offers an alternative to common approaches when the system under investigation and especially its Hamiltonian is not known in advance. The focus on operationality will help to better understand to what extend the work quantities defined and measured in quantum thermodynamic systems differ from the classical concept of work

Analytical Estimates of Proton Acceleration in Laser-produced Turbulent Plasmas

Poster presented at the 2018 Defence and Security Doctoral Symposium.With the advent of high power lasers, new opportunities have opened up for simulating astrophysical processes in the laboratory. We show that 2nd-order Fermi acceleration can be directly investigated at the National Ignition Facility, Livermore. This requires measuring the momentum-space diffusion of 3 MeV protons produced within a turbulent plasma generated by a laser. Treating Fermi acceleration as a biased diffusion process, we show analytically that a measurable broadening of the initial proton distribution is then expected for particles exiting the plasma

Ruling out light axions: the writing is on the wall

We revisit the domain wall problem for QCD axion models with more than one quark charged under the Peccei-Quinn symmetry. Symmetry breaking during or after inflation results in the formation of a domain wall network which would cause cosmic catastrophe if it comes to dominate the Universe. The network may be made unstable by invoking a `tilt' in the axion potential due to Planck scale suppressed non-renormalisable operators. Alternatively the random walk of the axion field during inflation can generate a `bias' favouring one of the degenerate vacua, but we find that this mechanism is in practice irrelevant. Consideration of the axion abundance generated by the decay of the wall network then requires the Peccei-Quinn scale to be rather low -- thus ruling out e.g. the DFSZ axion with mass below 11 meV, where most experimental searches are in fact focussed.Comment: 22 pages, 4 figures; Updated with additional citations, clarifications & comments - conclusion essentially unchange

Ruling out light axions: the writing is on the wall

We revisit the domain wall problem for QCD axion models with more than one quark charged under the Peccei-Quinn symmetry. Symmetry breaking during or after inflation results in the formation of a domain wall network which would cause cosmic catastrophe if it comes to dominate the Universe. The network may be made unstable by invoking a ‘tilt’ in the axion potential due to Planck scale suppressed non-renormalisable operators. Alternatively the random walk of the axion field during inflation can generate a ‘bias’ favouring one of the degenerate vacua, but we find that this mechanism is in practice irrelevant. Consideration of the axion abundance generated by the decay of the wall network then requires the Peccei-Quinn scale to be rather low — thus e.g. ruling out the DFSZ axion with mass below ∼ 11 meV, where most experimental searches are in fact focused

Work as an external quantum observable and an operational quantum work fluctuation theorem

We propose a definition of externally measurable quantum work in driven systems. Work is given as a quantum observable on a control device which is forcing the system and can be determined without knowledge of the system Hamiltonian $H_\mathcal{S}$. We argue that quantum work fluctuation theorems which rely on the knowledge of $H_\mathcal{S}$ are of little practical relevance, contrary to their classical counterparts. Using our framework, we derive a fluctuation theorem which is operationally accessible and could in principle be implemented in experiments to determine bounds on free energy differences of unknown systems

Quantum Steering on IBMQ

We use contemporary quantum computers to experimentally investigate quantum steering ofan open quantum system by measurements on its environment. On three IBMQ processors wedistinguish a qubit as the open system and perform pairwise interactions with multiple environmentancillas, following a collision model approach. Different measurement strategies on the ancillaslead to different state ensembles of the open system, which are reconstructed by employing statetomography. The amount of steering within the resulting assemblages is quantified with the help of asemidefinite program. We successfully observe the presence of quantum steering in our experimentalsimulations, and can discriminate the different performance qualities and noise levels of the selectedquantum devices

Analytical estimates of proton acceleration in laser-produced turbulent plasmas

With the advent of high power lasers, new opportunities have opened up for simulating astrophysical processes in the laboratory. We show that 2nd-order Fermi acceleration can be directly investigated at the National Ignition Facility, Livermore. This requires measuring the momentum-space diffusion of 3 MeV protons produced within a turbulent plasma generated by a laser. Treating Fermi acceleration as a biased diffusion process, we show analytically that a measurable broadening of the initial proton distribution is then expected for particles exiting the plasma.Comment: 7 pages, 6 figures; Added missing plasma parameters in Table 1, improved consideration of additional broadenin