Comparison of single trial back-projected independent components with the averaged waveform for the extraction of biomarkers of auditory P300 EPs

The independent components analysis (ICA) of the auditory P300 evoked responses in the EEG of normal subjects is described. The purpose was to identify any features which might provide the basis for biomarkers for diseases, such as Alzheimer’s disease. Single trial P300s were analysed by ICA, the activations were back-projected to scalp electrodes, many artefactual components were removed automatically, and the back-projected independent components (BICs) were first clustered according to their amplitudes and latencies. Then these primary clusters were secondarily clustered according to the columns of their mixing matrices, which clusters together those BICs with the same scalp topographies and, therefore, source locations. The BICs comprising the P300s had simple shapes, approximating half-sinusoids. Trial- to-trial variations in the BICs were found, which explain why different averages have been reported. Both positive- and also negative-going BICs were identified, some associated with known peaks in the P300 waveform. Artefact-free, single trial P300 waveforms could be constructed from the BICs, but these are probably of less interest than the BICs themselves. The findings demonstrate that neither averaged P300s, nor single trial P300s, are reliable as biomarkers, but rather it will be necessary to investigate the BICs present in a number of single trial realizations.peer-reviewe

The independent components of auditory P300 and CNV evoked potentials derived from single-trial recordings.

The back-projected independent components (BICs) of single-trial, auditory P300 and contingent negative variation (CNV) evoked potentials (EPs) were derived using independent component analysis (ICA) and cluster analysis. The method was tested in simulation including a study of the electric dipole equivalents of the signal sources. P300 data were obtained from healthy and Alzheimer's disease (AD) subjects. The BICs were of approximately 100 ms duration and approximated positive- and negative-going half-sinusoids. Some positively and negatively peaking BICs constituting the P300 coincided with known peaks in the averaged P300. However, there were trial-to-trial differences in their occurrences, particularly where a positive or a negative BIC could occur with the same latency in different trials, a fact which would be obscured by averaging them. These variations resulted in marked differences in the shapes of the reconstructed, artefact-free, single-trial P300s. The latencies of the BIC associated with the P3b peak differed between healthy and AD subjects (p < 0.01). More reliable evidence than that obtainable from single-trial or averaged P300s is likely to be found by studying the properties of the BICs over a number of trials. For the CNV, BICs corresponding to both the orienting and the expectancy components were found

The independent components of auditory P300 and CNV evoked potentials derived from single-trial recordings

Summarization: The back-projected independent components (BICs) of single-trial, auditory P300 and contingent negative variation (CNV) evoked potentials (EPs) were derived using independent component analysis (ICA) and cluster analysis. The method was tested in simulation including a study of the electric dipole equivalents of the signal sources. P300 data were obtained from healthy and Alzheimer's disease (AD) subjects. The BICs were of approximately 100 ms duration and approximated positive- and negative-going half-sinusoids. Some positively and negatively peaking BICs constituting the P300 coincided with known peaks in the averaged P300. However, there were trial-to-trial differences in their occurrences, particularly where a positive or a negative BIC could occur with the same latency in different trials, a fact which would be obscured by averaging them. These variations resulted in marked differences in the shapes of the reconstructed, artefact-free, single-trial P300s. The latencies of the BIC associated with the P3b peak differed between healthy and AD subjects (p < 0.01). More reliable evidence than that obtainable from single-trial or averaged P300s is likely to be found by studying the properties of the BICs over a number of trials. For the CNV, BICs corresponding to both the orienting and the expectancy components were found.Παρουσιάστηκε στο: Physiological Measuremen