Radio Frequency Fingerprinting Techniques through Preamble Modification in IEEE 802.11b

Wireless local area networks are particularly vulnerable to cyber attacks due to their contested transmission medium. Access point spoofing, route poisoning, and cryptographic attacks are some of the many mature threats faced by wireless networks. Recent work investigates physical-layer features such as received signal strength or radio frequency fingerprinting to identify and localize malicious devices. This thesis demonstrates a novel and complementary approach to exploiting physical-layer differences among wireless devices that is more energy efficient and invariant with respect to the environment than traditional fingerprinting techniques. Specifically, this methodology exploits subtle design differences among different transceiver hardware types. A software defined radio captures packets with standard-length IEEE 802.11b preambles, manipulates the recorded preambles by shortening their length, then replays the altered packets toward the transceivers under test. Wireless transceivers vary in their ability to receive packets with preambles shorter than the standard. By analyzing differences in packet reception with respect to preamble length, this methodology distinguishes amongst eight transceiver types from three manufacturers. All tests to successfully enumerate the transceivers achieve accuracy rates greater than 99%, while transmitting less than 60 test packets. This research extends previous work illustrating RF fingerprinting techniques through IEEE 802.15.4 wireless protocols. The results demonstrate that preamble manipulation is effective for multi-factor device authentication, network intrusion detection, and remote transceiver type fingerprinting in IEEE 802.11b

Improved Wireless Security through Physical Layer Protocol Manipulation and Radio Frequency Fingerprinting

Wireless networks are particularly vulnerable to spoofing and route poisoning attacks due to the contested transmission medium. Traditional bit-layer defenses including encryption keys and MAC address control lists are vulnerable to extraction and identity spoofing, respectively. This dissertation explores three novel strategies to leverage the wireless physical layer to improve security in low-rate wireless personal area networks. The first, physical layer protocol manipulation, identifies true transceiver design within remote devices through analysis of replies in response to packets transmitted with modified physical layer headers. Results herein demonstrate a methodology that correctly differentiates among six IEEE 802.15.4 transceiver classes with greater than 99% accuracy, regardless of claimed bit-layer identity. The second strategy, radio frequency fingerprinting, accurately identifies the true source of every wireless transmission in a network, even among devices of the same design and manufacturer. Results suggest that even low-cost signal collection receivers can achieve greater than 90% authentication accuracy within a defense system based on radio frequency fingerprinting. The third strategy, based on received signal strength quantification, can be leveraged to rapidly locate suspicious transmission sources and to perform physical security audits of critical networks. Results herein reduce mean absolute percentage error of a widely-utilized distance estimation model 20% by examining signal strength measurements from real-world networks in a military hospital and a civilian hospital

Detecting Impersonation Attacks in a Static WSN

The current state of security found in the IoT domain is highly flawed, a major problem being that the cryptographic keys used for authentication can be easily extracted and thus enable a myriad of impersonation attacks. In this MSc thesis a study is done of an authentication mechanism called device fingerprinting. It is a mechanism which can derive the identity of a device without relying on device identity credentials and thus detect credential-based impersonation attacks. A proof of concept has been produced to showcase how a fingerprinting system can be designed to function in a resource constrained IoT environment. A novel approach has been taken where several fingerprinting techniques have been combined through machine learning to improve the system’s ability to deduce the identity of a device. The proof of concept yields high performant results, indicating that fingerprinting techniques are a viable approach to achieve security in an IoT system

Speaking the Local Dialect: Exploiting differences between IEEE 802.15.4 Receivers with Commodity Radios for fingerprinting, targeted attacks, and WIDS evasion

Producing IEEE 802.15.4 PHY-frames reliably accepted by some digital radio receivers, but rejected by others---depending on the receiver chip\u27s make and model---has strong implications for wireless security. Attackers could target specific receivers by crafting shaped charges, attack frames that appear valid to the intended target and are ignored by all other recipients. By transmitting in the unique, slightly non-compliant dialect of the intended receivers, attackers would be able to create entire communication streams invisible to others, including wireless intrusion detection and prevention systems (WIDS/WIPS). These scenarios are no longer theoretic. We present methods of producing such IEEE 802.15.4 frames with commodity digital radio chips widely used in building inexpensive 802.15.4-conformant devices. Typically, PHY-layer fingerprinting requires software-defined radios that cost orders of magnitude more than the chips they fingerprint; however, our methods do not require a software-defined radio and use the same inexpensive chips. Knowledge of such differences, and the ability to fingerprint them is crucial for defenders. We investigate new methods of fingerprinting IEEE 802.15.4 devices by exploring techniques to differentiate between multiple 802.15.4-conformant radio-hardware manufacturers and firmware distributions. Further, we point out the implications of these results for WIDS, both with respect to WIDS evasion techniques and countering such evasion

A Practical Wireless Exploitation Framework for Z-Wave Networks

Wireless Sensor Networks (WSN) are a growing subset of the emerging Internet of Things (IoT). WSNs reduce the cost of deployment over wired alternatives; consequently, use is increasing in home automation, critical infrastructure, smart metering, and security solutions. Few published works evaluate the security of proprietary WSN protocols due to the lack of low-cost and effective research tools. One such protocol is ITU-T G.9959-based Z-Wave, which maintains wide acceptance within the IoT market. This research utilizes an open source toolset, presented herein, called EZ-Wave to identify methods for exploiting Z-Wave devices and networks using Software-Defined Radios (SDR). Herein, techniques enabling active network reconnaissance, including network enumeration and device interrogation, are presented. Furthermore, a fuzzing framework is presented and utilized to identify three packet malformations resulting in anomalous device behavior. Finally, a method for classifying the three most common Z-Wave transceivers with \u3e99% accuracy using preamble manipulation is identified and tested

A Misuse-Based Intrusion Detection System for ITU-T G.9959 Wireless Networks

Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) provide low-cost, low-power, and low-complexity systems tightly integrating control and communication. Protocols based on the ITU-T G.9959 recommendation specifying narrow-band sub-GHz communications have significant growth potential. The Z-Wave protocol is the most common implementation. Z-Wave developers are required to sign nondisclosure and confidentiality agreements, limiting the availability of tools to perform open source research. This work discovers vulnerabilities allowing the injection of rogue devices or hiding information in Z-Wave packets as a type of covert channel attack. Given existing vulnerabilities and exploitations, defensive countermeasures are needed. A Misuse-Based Intrusion Detection System (MBIDS) is engineered, capable of monitoring Z-Wave networks. Experiments are designed to test the detection accuracy of the system against attacks. Results from the experiments demonstrate the MBIDS accurately detects intrusions in a Z-Wave network with a mean misuse detection rate of 99%. Overall, this research contributes new Z-Wave exploitations and an MBIDS to detect rogue devices and packet injection attacks, enabling a more secure Z-Wave network

Defense in Depth of Resource-Constrained Devices

The emergent next generation of computing, the so-called Internet of Things (IoT), presents significant challenges to security, privacy, and trust. The devices commonly used in IoT scenarios are often resource-constrained with reduced computational strength, limited power consumption, and stringent availability requirements. Additionally, at least in the consumer arena, time-to-market is often prioritized at the expense of quality assurance and security. An initial lack of standards has compounded the problems arising from this rapid development. However, the explosive growth in the number and types of IoT devices has now created a multitude of competing standards and technology silos resulting in a highly fragmented threat model. Tens of billions of these devices have been deployed in consumers\u27 homes and industrial settings. From smart toasters and personal health monitors to industrial controls in energy delivery networks, these devices wield significant influence on our daily lives. They are privy to highly sensitive, often personal data and responsible for real-world, security-critical, physical processes. As such, these internet-connected things are highly valuable and vulnerable targets for exploitation. Current security measures, such as reactionary policies and ad hoc patching, are not adequate at this scale. This thesis presents a multi-layered, defense in depth, approach to preventing and mitigating a myriad of vulnerabilities associated with the above challenges. To secure the pre-boot environment, we demonstrate a hardware-based secure boot process for devices lacking secure memory. We introduce a novel implementation of remote attestation backed by blockchain technologies to address hardware and software integrity concerns for the long-running, unsupervised, and rarely patched systems found in industrial IoT settings. Moving into the software layer, we present a unique method of intraprocess memory isolation as a barrier to several prevalent classes of software vulnerabilities. Finally, we exhibit work on network analysis and intrusion detection for the low-power, low-latency, and low-bandwidth wireless networks common to IoT applications. By targeting these areas of the hardware-software stack, we seek to establish a trustworthy system that extends from power-on through application runtime

Extending Critical Infrastructure Element Longevity using Constellation-based ID Verification

This work supports a technical cradle-to-grave protection strategy aimed at extending the useful lifespan of Critical Infrastructure (CI) elements. This is done by improving mid-life operational protection measures through integration of reliable physical (PHY) layer security mechanisms. The goal is to improve existing protection that is heavily reliant on higher-layer mechanisms that are commonly targeted by cyberattack. Relative to prior device ID discrimination works, results herein reinforce the exploitability of constellation-based PHY layer features and the ability for those features to be practically implemented to enhance CI security. Prior work is extended by formalizing a device ID verification process that enables rogue device detection demonstration under physical access attack conditions that include unauthorized devices mimicking bit-level credentials of authorized network devices. The work transitions from distance-based to probability-based measures of similarity derived from empirical Multivariate Normal Probability Density Function (MVNPDF) statistics of multiple discriminant analysis radio frequency fingerprint projections. Demonstration results for Constellation-Based Distinct Native Attribute (CB-DNA) fingerprinting of WirelessHART adapters from two manufacturers includes 1) average cross-class percent correct classification of %C \u3e 90% across 28 different networks comprised of six authorized devices, and 2) average rogue rejection rate of 83.4% ≤ RRR ≤ 99.9% based on two held-out devices serving as attacking rogue devices for each network (a total of 120 individual rogue attacks). Using the MVNPDF measure proved most effective and yielded nearly 12% RRR improvement over a Euclidean distance measure

Adaptable hardware fingerprinting for radio data links and avionics buses in adversarial settings

Despite their substantially different purposes, a common issue both for many legacy data links and many onboard data buses used in aviation is a lack of authentication and thus a vulnerability to spoofing and message manipulation attacks. This problem has been discussed at length for some prominent technologies of both sorts (e.g., ADS-B, ARINC 429) but is common in many more cases (e.g., ACARS, CPDLC, MIL-STD- 1553, RS-485). For ground data links, attacks can take place over-the-air, while for onboard buses an attacker requires some physical access to an aircraft. Yet, in both cases an attacker’s goal is to obtain control of a transceiver on the communication channel. As such, hardware fingerprinting methods are useful in both contexts. Prior work has applied such methods to specific protocols. We now propose a transferable fingerprinting scheme that has applicability in both contexts, describe our experiences in applying it for each and evaluate its performance in benign and malicious conditions. As replacing legacy communication links with newer, more secure protocols is practically challenging, the improvements to practical deployment offered by our system represent a meaningful benefit for real deployment efforts