211 research outputs found
Untangled: A Complete Dynamic Topological Logic
Dynamic topological logic () is a trimodal logic designed for
reasoning about dynamic topological systems. It was shown by Fern\'andez-Duque
that the natural set of axioms for is incomplete, but he
provided a complete axiomatisation in an extended language. In this paper, we
consider dynamic topological logic over scattered spaces, which are topological
spaces where every nonempty subspace has an isolated point. Scattered spaces
appear in the context of computational logic as they provide semantics for
provability and enjoy definable fixed points. We exhibit the first sound and
complete dynamic topological logic in the original trimodal language. In
particular, we show that the version of based on the class of
scattered spaces is finitely axiomatisable over the original language, and that
the natural axiomatisation is sound and complete
Dynamic Topological Logic of Metric Spaces
Dynamic Topological Logic (DT L) is a modal framework for reasoning
about dynamical systems, that is, pairs hX; fi where X is a topological
space and f : X ! X a continuous function.
In this paper we consider the case where X is a metric space. We rst
show that any formula which can be satis ed on an arbitrary dynamic
topological system can be satis ed on one based on a metric space; in
fact, this space can be taken to be countable and have no isolated points.
Since any metric space with these properties is homeomorphic to the set of
rational numbers, it follows that any formula can be satis ed on a system
based on Q.
We then show that the situation changes when considering complete
metric spaces, by exhibiting a formula which is not valid in general but is
valid on the class of systems based on a complete metric space. While we
do not attempt to give a full characterization of the set of valid formulas
on this class we do give a relative completeness result; any formula which
is satis able on a dynamical system based on a complete metric space is
also satis ed on one based on the Cantor spac
The intuitionistic temporal logic of dynamical systems
A dynamical system is a pair , where is a topological space and
is continuous. Kremer observed that the language of
propositional linear temporal logic can be interpreted over the class of
dynamical systems, giving rise to a natural intuitionistic temporal logic. We
introduce a variant of Kremer's logic, which we denote , and show
that it is decidable. We also show that minimality and Poincar\'e recurrence
are both expressible in the language of , thus providing a
decidable logic expressive enough to reason about non-trivial asymptotic
behavior in dynamical systems
Non-finite axiomatizability of Dynamic Topological Logic
Dynamic topological logic (DTL) is a polymodal logic designed for reasoning
about {\em dynamic topological systems. These are pairs (X,f), where X is a
topological space and f:X->X is continuous. DTL uses a language L which
combines the topological S4 modality [] with temporal operators from linear
temporal logic.
Recently, I gave a sound and complete axiomatization DTL* for an extension of
the logic to the language L*, where is allowed to act on finite sets of
formulas and is interpreted as a tangled closure operator. No complete
axiomatization is known over L, although one proof system, which we shall call
, was conjectured to be complete by Kremer and Mints.
In this paper we show that, given any language L' between L and L*, the set
of valid formulas of L' is not finitely axiomatizable. It follows, in
particular, that KM is incomplete.Comment: arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1201.5162 by other author
Towards Semantic Modeling of Contradictions and Disagreements: A Case Study of Medical Guidelines
We introduce a formal distinction between contradictions and disagreements in
natural language texts, motivated by the need to formally reason about
contradictory medical guidelines. This is a novel and potentially very useful
distinction, and has not been discussed so far in NLP and logic. We also
describe a NLP system capable of automated finding contradictory medical
guidelines; the system uses a combination of text analysis and information
retrieval modules. We also report positive evaluation results on a small corpus
of contradictory medical recommendations.Comment: 5 pages, 1 figure, accepted at 12th International Conference on
Computational Semantics (IWCS-2017
- …