A Metacognition-Based Digital Problem-Solving Worksheet: a Design-Based Research: An Empirical Study Focused on Automotive Fault Diagnosis Learning for Indonesian Prospective Automotive Vocational Teachers

Vocational teachers need to equip their students with meaningful and relevant required workplace competencies. As a result, vocational teachers should always stay updated on their knowledge and skills regarding the development of science and technology in the world of work. More specifically, in the automotive vocational expertise domain, problem-solving abilities become the crucial skills students need to master. Hence, equipping prospective automotive vocational teachers with sustainable learning and problem-solving abilities is indispensable. In this case, the metacognition theory could facilitate students with learning-how-to-learn activities, which is an essential skill for sustainable learning and learning to teach and equip them with problem-solving abilities. Therefore, bringing the metacognition theory, supported by other relevant theories, into teaching and learning activities would be beneficial in dealing with those issues. This study aimed to design and develop a metacognition-based digital problem-solving worksheet. This digital worksheet was expected to facilitate students with learning-how-to-learn activities and equip them with problem-solving abilities effectively. There were four main research objectives and questions in this study, which were related to; 1) the practical problem that needs to be addressed, 2) the didactic design, 3) the usability, and 4) the effectiveness of the digital worksheet. Design-based research was used to answer the research questions. This is a multi-methods research design, which means many methods exist to achieve the research aim and objectives. This research design comprised six stages; analysis and exploration (stage 1), design and construction (stage 2), evaluation and reflection (stage 3), analysis and exploration (stage 4), design and construction (stage 5), and evaluation and reflection (stage 6). Stage 1 was used to explore the practical problem as the answer to the first research question. Stages 2 up to 5 were used to formulate the digital worksheet's didactic design as the answer to the second research question. Stage 6 was used to evaluate the usability and effectiveness of the digital worksheet as the answer to the third and fourth research questions, respectively. Firstly, in answering the first research question, three semi-structured interviews were used as the data collection techniques in the first research stage. The findings of this stage stated that sustainable learning, learning to teach, and problem-solving abilities became the needed competencies prospective automotive vocational teachers need to master. Additionally, the findings stated that automotive fault diagnosis learning was the highest-order thinking subject that had a practical problem on it. The quality of the instructional toolkit for this subject required to be improved since the existing toolkit was a conventional observation sheet and still allowed students to conduct trial-and-error stages. This was the practical problem that this research would address. Secondly, in answering the second research question, a focus group discussion, expert-based evaluations, user-based evaluations (formative usability evaluation), and final revisions were used in the second, third, fourth, and fifth research stages, respectively. The focus group discussion aimed to discuss the materials needed to develop the digital worksheet. Following that, expert-based evaluations and user-based evaluations were conducted to evaluate the initial digital worksheet based on the experts' and users' perspectives, respectively. Several revisions were done based on those evaluation results, and the digital worksheet's final didactic design was finally realized. The findings of the didactic design stated that the worksheet was in a digital form and used blended learning with flipped classroom strategy, so students need to have three different learning times; 1) before, 2) during, and 3) after classroom activities. Furthermore, constructivism learning theory, adult learning theory, metacognition theory, experiential learning theory, and reflection theory became the fundamental theoretical knowledge basis for developing this digital worksheet. Moreover, problem-based learning, automotive fault diagnosis procedures, and worksheet stages became the digital worksheet development's fundamental practical knowledge basis. There were seven stages that students need to do during the problem-solving learning; 1) introduction, 2) observing, 3) collecting information, 4) analyzing, 5) testing, 6) rectifying, and 7) checking all systems. There were many steps in every stage above, and many instructions and self-reflection questions in every single step. Additionally, in every step, the teachers had an opportunity to give feedback on the student's work, and the students could have discussions with other students at the end of every stage. The self-reflection questions on every instruction, the teacher's feedback on every step, and the discussion results at every stage were used to regulate the students' self-cognition. Thirdly, in answering the third and fourth research questions, a questionnaire survey and an experimental study were used as the final research stage, respectively. First, the survey of summative usability evaluation consisted of four elements: usefulness, ease of use, ease of learning, and satisfaction. The findings of this evaluation stated that the usability level and those elements' usability levels were all in very high categories. Additionally, it could be determined that the usefulness, ease of use, and ease of learning significantly influenced the students' satisfaction simultaneously and independently, except for the variable of ease of learning. Second, the effectiveness findings stated that the digital worksheet significantly effectively facilitated students' learning-how-to-learn activities and equipped them with problem-solving abilities.:ABSTRACT (EXECUTIVE SUMMARY) ABSTRAKT (ZUSAMMENFASSUNG) ACKNOWLEDGMENTS AND DEDICATION TABLE OF CONTENT LIST OF FIGURES LIST OF TABLES LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY 1.1. Introductory of the Chapter 1.2. Research Background, State of the Art, and Motivation 1.3. Research Empirical Problems and Context Justification 1.4. Research Rationale 1.5. Research Aim and Objectives 1.6. Research Questions 1.7. Research Scope and Context Limitations 1.8. Research Significance 1.9. Definitions of the Important Terms 1.10. List of the Research Project Publication 1.11. Summary of the Chapter CHAPTER 2. LITERATURE REVIEW 2.1 Introductory of the Chapter 2.2 Literature Review – Contextual Domain 2.2.1 Vocational Education 2.2.2 Education System in Indonesia 2.2.3 Vocational Education (SMK-MAK) in Indonesia 2.2.4 Problems and Challenges of Vocational Education in Indonesia 2.2.5 Vocational Teachers 2.2.6 Vocational Teacher Education 2.3 Literature Review – Theoretical and Conceptual Domain 2.3.1 Constructivism and Adult Learning Theory 2.3.2 Metacognition Theory – Metacognitive Learning Strategies (Learning-How-to-Learn) 2.3.3 Experiential Learning Theory - Reflection Theory 2.3.4 Problem-Based Learning Method – Problem-Solving Ability 2.3.5 Blended Learning Technique – Flipped Classroom Learning Strategy 2.3.6 Instructional Media and Technology – Learning Worksheet 2.3.7 Usability Evaluation in Instructional Media and Technology 2.3.8 The Research Theoretical and Conceptual Framework 2.4 Literature Review – Methodological Domain 2.4.1 Research Methodologies in Instructional Media and Technology Development 2.4.2 Design-Based Research 2.5 Research Hypotheses 2.6 Summary of the Chapter CHAPTER 3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 3.1. Introductory of the Chapter 3.2. Research Paradigm, Philosophy, and Research Type 3.3. Research Design, Strategies, and Methods 3.4. Research Context and Participants 3.5. Research Data Collection Techniques and the Tools 3.5.1. Stage 1 – Semi-Structured Interview and the Protocol 3.5.2. Stages 2 & 4 – Focus Group and the Protocols 3.5.3. Stage 3 – Expert-Based Evaluation and the Questionnaires 3.5.4. Stages 4 & 6 – Survey and the USE Questionnaire 3.5.5. Stage 6 – Experimental Study and the Assessment Tools 3.6. Research Data Analysis Techniques 3.6.1. Stage 1 – Semi-Structured Interview 3.6.2. Stage 2 – Focus Group Discussion 3.6.3. Stage 3 – Expert-Based Evaluation (Survey Questionnaire) 3.6.4. Stage 4 – User-Based Evaluation (Survey Questionnaire and Focus Group Interview) 3.6.5. Stage 6 – Usability Evaluation (Survey Questionnaire) 3.6.6. Stage 6 – Effectiveness Evaluation (Experimental Study) 3.7. Summary of the Chapter CHAPTER 4. RESEARCH FINDINGS 4.1. Introductory of the Chapter 4.2. Finding 1: The Practical Problem 4.2.1. Stage 1 – First Semi-Structured Interview 4.2.2. Stage 1 – Second Semi-Structured Interview 4.2.3. Stage 1 – Third Semi-Structured Interview 4.3. Finding 2: The Didactic Design 4.3.1. Stage 2 – Focus Group Discussion 4.3.2. Stage 3 – Expert-Based Evaluation 4.3.3. Stage 4 – User-Based Evaluation 4.3.4. Stage 5 – Final Revision (The Didactic Design) 4.4. Finding 3: The Usability 4.5. Finding 4: The Effectiveness 4.5.1. Stage 6 – The Effectiveness Evaluation in Facilitating Students with Leaning-How-to-Learn Activities 4.5.2. Stage 6 – The Effectiveness Evaluation in Equipping Students with Problem-Solving Abilities 4.6. Summary of the Chapter CHAPTER 5. RESEARCH DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION 5.1. Introductory of the Chapter 5.2. Discussion 1 – The Practical Problem 5.3. Discussion 2 – The Didactic Design 5.4. Discussion 3 – The Usability 5.5. Discussion 4 – The Effectiveness 5.6. Overall Discussion – The Research Findings' Interpretations and Implications in Intercultural-Global Contexts and Theoretical Design Principles 5.6.1. The Research Findings' Interpretations and Implications in Intercultural-Global Contexts 5.6.2. The Research Findings' Interpretations and Implications in Theoretical Insights and Design Principles 5.7. Research Conclusion 5.8. Research Limitations and Further Research 5.9. Summary of the Chapter REFERENCES STATEMENT OF AUTHORSHIP APPENDICE

Microteaching in Pakistan: Perspectives of Novice Higher Education Faculty about the Contribution of Microteaching to their Learning and Practice

This mixed-methods research documents the self-reports of novice higher education faculty of Pakistan about the contribution of the microteaching module of Master Trainer Faculty Professional Development Program (MT-FPDP) as well as the factors that either supported or hindered faculty in using their new knowledge and skills. My literature review on microteaching, which until recently had been a neglected field for two decades, includes higher education development needs as ‘adults-teaching-adults,’ microteaching as a response to novice teaching issues, and a contextual analysis of the model in different settings. I analyze and interpret the findings using a conceptual framework that synthesizes adult learning, self-efficacy, and reflective practices. This research finds that the opportunities to practice their teaching skills, with an intentional reflective feedback mechanism, allowed the novice faculty to prepare themselves in a safe and collaborative environment during MT-FPDP. However, microteaching content, activities, and supplementary material were neither closely relevant to varied teaching contexts of Pakistan nor appropriate in its application at the higher education level. Moreover, the lack of supervisors’ expertise to facilitate the microteaching processes, and mentor the novices discouraged the participation. Despite these hindrances, the novices reported behavior modification, self-efficacy, and use of reflective practices in their classrooms. However, discouraging organizational culture/policies, lack of collegial, administrative, and technical support, and geopolitical factors are the primary barriers to the implementation of the knowledge and skills. The Heads of Department (HoDs)/Deans confirmed the carryover from MT-FPDP to classroom teaching, and acknowledged these institutional supports and barriers. This research argues that the microteaching content and model must be adapted to the context of Pakistan, and the microteaching skills should be prioritized based on the higher education faculty needs. The Learning Innovation Division (LID) of the Pakistan Higher Education Commission (HEC) needs to appoint expert, unbiased, and culturally sensitive supervisors who can provide novices more self-directed, transformative, and reflective learning opportunities during MT-FPDP. LID/HEC should provide avenues for collaboration and coordination by establishing the informal “communities of practice” to foster collegial support within an institution and within a province

English Skills Based Microteaching: An Effective Model in Enhancing English Student Teachers’ Teaching Skills

Building basic teaching and English skills for student teachers need appropriate and effective teaching model. The current study aimed at designing a model of Micro-teaching Based-English Skill for undergraduates English program at State Islamic University. Research and Development type was used to develop the model. The subjects of this study were seven groups of students (each consist of 12 students) and seven lecturers.  Two groups were cluster randomly selected participate in this study. Pre-test and post-test design of experimental research model has been used without the control group and followed by treatment for 8 weeks prior to their teaching practice in the nearby schools. Data were taken from observations, questionnaires, and test.  The results showed that Micro-teaching Based-English Skill model was appropriate for the lecturers and students. The students’ basic teaching and their English skills were better improved. Therefore, this model is suggested to be implemented provided that both English skills and pedagogical one were the major expectation to be reached

A Practice-Teaching Program Model For Teacher Training Centers In Iran

Problem. It is the researcher\u27s opinion that most of the educational administrators in Iran have not fully realized the significance of practice teaching programs in developing and providing competent teachers. As a result, there is no planned design, no guidelines, no model to perform and fulfill the practice-teaching experience, i.e., the absence of a consistent program that includes a practice-teaching component. Purpose. The main purpose of this study is to develop a viable practice-teaching program appropriate for teacher preparation in Iran. Procedure. This study is descriptive research that typically employs observation, interview, and survey methods. Observation and tentative design were applied by the researcher at Teacher Training Centers in Iran in 1970. Interviews and surveys were arranged in selected California educational institutions. These institutions included: (a) two University of California (UC) campuses, (b) two California State University (CSU) campuses, and (c) a private college and a university. Findings. In California, the Ryan Act requires: (1) full-day student teaching for one full public-school semester; (2) a student teaching assignment at two different levels; (3) one student teaching assignment must be in a school where the ethnic population is significantly different from that of the student teacher. In the student teaching process, there are three main interrelated agents: (1) student teacher, (2) co-operating teacher, and (3) University or College supervisor. Preparation of competent teachers is mainly based on the result of the functions of these three agents. Conclusion. Practice-teaching, according to the proposed model for Iran, can be defined as a gradual induction process that includes six interrelated phases: (1) observing, (2) participating, (3) assistant teaching, (4) bit teaching, (5) initial teaching, and concentrated teaching. Recommendations. An effective division with an organizational structure for practice-teaching prorams should be devised. (1) An affiliated school on campus with some cooperating schools be chosen. (2) The best teachers for professional education should be selected. (3) The most competent supervisors and cooperating teachers be selected. (4) An adequate practice-teaching committee be established to investigate student-teacher competencies. (5) Regular conferences with supervisors and cooperating teachers be held

Enriching student learning through video-annotated peer feedback activity: a guide

Despite the growing research base on the use of video annotation in education, little is known on how to coherently structure a video-annotated peer feedback activity to engage students. Eventhough some studies have outlined the guidelines for conducting video-based annotation practice, little has been published with the focus on video-annotated peer feedback. To explore this under-investigated realm, the current review was conducted. In order to identify studies to be included in this review, a strategy for literature search was initially developed. This was followed by the selection and categorization of relevant studies. This paper thus provides a succinct overview of the essential steps involved in conducting a video-annotated peer feedback learning activity. Most importantly, it has resulted in a guide that outlines those essential stages and steps, thus providing insights into adaptation for use in education

Pre-University Teachers’ Teaching Skills

The Pre-University (PU) stage of education is significant for students as it is the connecting bridge between school and professional life. Therefore, this stage must instill the essential skills within students which will facilitate the students to pursue higher education or apply for the field of work. To achieve the development of students with the required skills to be independent and skilled, it is imperative for the teacher to use teaching skills in the precise manner. Teaching skills is the vital link necessary to translate the teachers’ theoretical knowledge to the students thereby promoting effective learning by the students. This study focuses on the missing and much needed teaching skills which are deemed important for a Pre-University teacher of the 21st century. The researchers also suggest a great demand and necessity for training Pre-University teachers to enhance their teaching skills required for the successful development of the 21st century learners. Keywords: Teaching skills, Pre-University teacher

CercleS 2022

CHAIRPERSON Manuel Moreira da Silva, Instituto Politécnico do Porto, Portugal EDITORS Ana Gonçalves, Estoril Higher Institute for Tourism and Hotel Studies, Portugal Célia Tavares, Instituto Politécnico do Porto, Portugal Joaquim Guerra, Universidade do Algarve, Portugal Luciana Oliveira, Instituto Politécnico do Porto, Portugal Manuel Moreira da Silva, Instituto Politécnico do Porto, Portugal Ricardo Soares, Instituto Politécnico do Porto, PortugalCercleS 2022 The Future of Language Education in an Increasingly Digital World: Embracing ChangeN/