9 research outputs found
A Review on Segmentation of Knee Articular Cartilage: from Conventional Methods Towards Deep Learning
In this paper, we review the state-of-the-art approaches for knee articular cartilage segmentation from conventional techniques to deep learning (DL) based techniques. Knee articular cartilage segmentation on magnetic resonance (MR) images is of great importance in early diagnosis of osteoarthritis (OA). Besides, segmentation allows estimating the articular cartilage loss rate which is utilised in clinical practice for assessing the disease progression and morphological changes. Topics covered include various image processing algorithms and major features of different segmentation techniques, feature computations and the performance evaluation metrics. This paper is intended to provide researchers with a broad overview of the currently existing methods in the field, as well as to highlight the shortcomings and potential considerations in the application at clinical practice. The survey showed that the state-of-the-art techniques based on DL outperforms the other segmentation methods. The analysis of the existing methods reveals that integration of DL-based algorithms with other traditional model-based approaches have achieved the best results (mean Dice similarity cofficient (DSC) between 85:8% and 90%)
Recommended from our members
Quantitative Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Analysis of Articular Cartilage and Osteoarthritis
MRI plays an important role in the continuing search for a sensitive osteoarthritis (OA) imaging biomarker able to detect early, pre-morphological alterations in cartilage composition. Determining the compositional recovery pattern of cartilage following acute joint loading could potentially present a more sensitive biomarker for defining cartilage health [1]. However, only a limited amount of studies have assessed both the immediate effect of joint loading on cartilage, as well as its post-loading recovery. In addition, when assessing the compositional responses of cartilage to joint loading, previous studies usually did not incorporate the measurement error of the used quantitative MRI technique into their analysis. Therefore, an uncertainty persists whether or not compositional MRI techniques are sensitive enough to measure changes in water and macromolecular content of cartilage, or if previous studies were merely measuring noise. Consequently, an objective of this thesis is to increase our understanding of and reliability in quantitative T2 and T1ρ relaxation time mapping to detect compositional responses of cartilage following a joint loading activity.
Furthermore, to obtain the quantitative morphological and compositional measures of cartilage, detailed region-specific delineation of cartilage is required. This delineation (or segmentation) of cartilage is laborious and time-consuming as it is usually performed manually by an expert observer. Many new advances in image analysis, particularly those in convolutional neural networks (CNNs) and deep learning, have enabled a time-efficient semi- or fully-automated alternative to this process [2, 3]. This thesis explores the utility of deep CNNs generated segmentations for accurate surface-based analysis of cartilage morphology and composition from knee MRIs as well as of cortical bone thickness from knee CTs.
Chapter 1 will provide an introduction into the structure and biomechanics of articular cartilage and the role of MRI in imaging the degenerative joint disorder, osteoarthritis as well as the effects of different joint loading activities on cartilage morphology and composition.
Chapter 2 explains the principle of MRI and the pulse sequences used in the following chapter for the morphometric and compositional assessment of articular cartilage.
Chapter 3 describes the use of 3D Cartilage Surface Mapping (3D-CaSM) [3] to assess variations in cartilage T1ρ and T2 relaxation times of young, healthy participants following a mild, unilateral stepping activity. By evaluating and incorporating the intrasessional repeatability of the T1ρ and T2 mapping techniques, I aim to highlight those cartilage areas experiencing exercise-induced compositional changes greater than measurement error.
A significant amount of time is needed to manually segment the regions-of-interest required to perform the 3D-CaSM used in Chapter 3. Therefore, in Chapter 4, I assessed the use of deep convolutional neural networks for automating the segmentation process for multiple knee joint tissues simultaneous and increase the time-efficiency for evaluating knee MR datasets. I evaluated the use of a conditional Generative Adversarial Network (cGAN) as a potentially improved method for automated segmentation compared to the widely used convolutional neural network, U-Net.
In Chapter 5 I combined the 3D-CaSM and automated segmentation methods presented in Chapters 3 and 4, respectively to assess the use of fully automatic segmentations of femoral and tibial bone-cartilage structures for accurate surface-based analysis of cartilage morphology and composition on knee MR images. This was performed on publicly available data from the Osteoarthritis Initiative, a multicentre observational study with expert manual segmentations provided by the Zuse Institute in Berlin.
Chapter 6 describes an automated pipeline for subchondral cortical bone thickness mapping from knee CT data. I developed a method of using automated segmentations of articular cartilage and bone from knee MRI data to determine the periarticular bone surface which is covered by cartilage. This surface was then used to perform cortical bone thickness measurements on corresponding CT data. I validated this pipeline using data from the EU-funded, multi-centre observational study called Applied Private-Public partneRship enabling OsteoArthritis Clinical Headway (APPROACH).
Chapter 7 summarises the main conclusions and contributions of the works presented in this thesis as well as providing directions for future work.PhD Studentship funded by GlaxoSmithKlin
Analysis of MRI for Knee Osteoarthritis using Machine Learning
Approximately 8.5 million people in the UK (13.5% of the population) have osteoarthritis (OA) in one or both knees, with more than 6 million people in the UK suffering with painful osteoarthritis of the knee. In addition, an ageing population implies that an estimated 17 million people (twice as many as in 2012) are likely to be living with OA by 2030. Despite this, there exists no disease modifying drugs for OA and structural OA in MRI is poorly characterised.
This motivates research to develop biomarkers and tools to aid osteoarthritis diagnosis from MRI of the knee. Previously many solutions for learning biomarkers have relied upon hand-crafted features to characterise and diagnose osteoarthritis from MRI. The methods proposed in this thesis are scalable and use machine learning to characterise large populations of the OAI dataset, with one experiment applying an algorithm to over 10,000 images. Studies of this size enable subtle characteristics of the dataset to be learnt and model many variations within a population.
We present data-driven algorithms to learn features to predict OA from the appearance of the articular cartilage. An unsupervised manifold learning algorithm is used to compute a low dimensional representation of knee MR data which we propose as an imaging marker of OA. Previous metrics introduced for OA diagnosis are loosely based on the research communities intuition of the structural causes of OA progression, including morphological measures of the articular cartilage such as the thickness and volume. We demonstrate that there is a strong correlation between traditional morphological measures of the articular cartilage and the biomarkers identified using the manifold learning algorithm that we propose (R 2 = 0.75). The algorithm is extended to create biomarkers for different regions and sequences. A combination of these markers is proposed to yield a diagnostic imaging biomarker with superior performance. The diagnostic biomarkers presented are shown to improve upon hand-crafted morphological measure of disease status presented in the literature, a linear discriminant analysis (LDA) classification for early stage diagnosis of knee osteoarthritis results with an AUC of 0.9.
From the biomarker discovery experiments we identified that intensity based affine registration of knee MRIs is not sufficiently robust for large scale image analysis, approximately 5% of these registrations fail. We have developed fast algorithms to compute robust affine transformations of knee MRI, which enables accurate pairwise registrations in large datasets. We model the population of images as a non-linear manifold, a registration is defined by the shortest geodesic path over the manifold representation. We identify sources of error in our manifold representation and propose fast mitigation strategies by checking for consistency across the manifold and by utilising multiple paths. These mitigation strategies are shown to improve registration accuracy and can be computed in less than 2 seconds with current architecture.Open Acces