125 research outputs found
Hilbert's Metamathematical Problems and Their Solutions
This dissertation examines several of the problems that Hilbert discovered in the foundations of mathematics, from a metalogical perspective. The problems manifest themselves in four different aspects of Hilbert’s views: (i) Hilbert’s axiomatic approach to the foundations of mathematics; (ii) His response to criticisms of set theory; (iii) His response to intuitionist criticisms of classical mathematics; (iv) Hilbert’s contribution to the specification of the role of logical inference in mathematical reasoning. This dissertation argues that Hilbert’s axiomatic approach was guided primarily by model theoretical concerns. Accordingly, the ultimate aim of his consistency program was to prove the model-theoretical consistency of mathematical theories. It turns out that for the purpose of carrying out such consistency proofs, a suitable modification of the ordinary first-order logic is needed. To effect this modification, independence-friendly logic is needed as the appropriate conceptual framework. It is then shown how the model theoretical consistency of arithmetic can be proved by using IF logic as its basic logic.
Hilbert’s other problems, manifesting themselves as aspects (ii), (iii), and (iv)—most notably the problem of the status of the axiom of choice, the problem of the role of the law of excluded middle, and the problem of giving an elementary account of quantification—can likewise be approached by using the resources of IF logic. It is shown that by means of IF logic one can carry out Hilbertian solutions to all these problems. The two major results concerning aspects (ii), (iii) and (iv) are the following: (a) The axiom of choice is a logical principle; (b) The law of excluded middle divides metamathematical methods into elementary and non-elementary ones. It is argued that these results show that IF logic helps to vindicate Hilbert’s nominalist philosophy of mathematics. On the basis of an elementary approach to logic, which enriches the expressive resources of ordinary first-order logic, this dissertation shows how the different problems that Hilbert discovered in the foundations of mathematics can be solved
Is game semantics necessary?
We discuss the extent to which game semantics is implicit in the formalism of
linear logic and in the intuitions underlying linear logic
Dependence Logic with Generalized Quantifiers: Axiomatizations
We prove two completeness results, one for the extension of dependence logic
by a monotone generalized quantifier Q with weak interpretation, weak in the
meaning that the interpretation of Q varies with the structures. The second
result considers the extension of dependence logic where Q is interpreted as
"there exists uncountable many." Both of the axiomatizations are shown to be
sound and complete for FO(Q) consequences.Comment: 17 page
Structural completeness in propositional logics of dependence
In this paper we prove that three of the main propositional logics of
dependence (including propositional dependence logic and inquisitive logic),
none of which is structural, are structurally complete with respect to a class
of substitutions under which the logics are closed. We obtain an analogues
result with respect to stable substitutions, for the negative variants of some
well-known intermediate logics, which are intermediate theories that are
closely related to inquisitive logic
On Quasi-Interpretations, Blind Abstractions and Implicit Complexity
Quasi-interpretations are a technique to guarantee complexity bounds on
first-order functional programs: with termination orderings they give in
particular a sufficient condition for a program to be executable in polynomial
time, called here the P-criterion. We study properties of the programs
satisfying the P-criterion, in order to better understand its intensional
expressive power. Given a program on binary lists, its blind abstraction is the
nondeterministic program obtained by replacing lists by their lengths (natural
numbers). A program is blindly polynomial if its blind abstraction terminates
in polynomial time. We show that all programs satisfying a variant of the
P-criterion are in fact blindly polynomial. Then we give two extensions of the
P-criterion: one by relaxing the termination ordering condition, and the other
one (the bounded value property) giving a necessary and sufficient condition
for a program to be polynomial time executable, with memoisation.Comment: 18 page
Infinity
This essay surveys the different types of infinity that occur in pure and applied mathematics, with emphasis on: 1. the contrast between potential infinity and actual infinity; 2. Cantor's distinction between transfinite sets and absolute infinity; 3. the constructivist view of infinite quantifiers and the meaning of constructive proof; 4. the concept of feasibility and the philosophical problems surrounding feasible arithmetic; 5. Zeno's paradoxes and modern paradoxes of physical infinity involving supertasks
- …