Decision Fusion and Reliability Control in Handwritten Digit Recognition System

In this paper, the cooperation of two feature families for handwritten digit recognition using a committee of Neural Network (NN) classifiers will be examined. Various cooperation schemes will be investigated and corresponding results will be presented. To improve the system reliability,we will upgrade the committee scheme using multistage classification based on rule-based and statistical cooperation. The rule-based cooperation enables an easy and efficient implementation of various rejection criteria while the statistical cooperation offers better possibility for fine-tuning of the recognition versus the reliability tradeoff. The final system has been implemented using rule-based reasoning with rejection criteria for classifier decision fusion and the generalized committee cooperation scheme for classification of the rejected digit patterns. The presented results show that we propose a successful approach for reliability control in committee classifier environment and indicate that a suitable cooperation of statistical and rule-based decision fusion is a promising approach in handwritten recognition systems

Adaptive combinations of classifiers with application to on-line handwritten character recognition

Classifier combining is an effective way of improving classification performance. User adaptation is clearly another valid approach for improving performance in a user-dependent system, and even though adaptation is usually performed on the classifier level, also adaptive committees can be very effective. Adaptive committees have the distinct ability of performing adaptation without detailed knowledge of the classifiers. Adaptation can therefore be used even with classification systems that intrinsically are not suited for adaptation, whether that be due to lack of access to the workings of the classifier or simply a classification scheme not suitable for continuous learning. This thesis proposes methods for adaptive combination of classifiers in the setting of on-line handwritten character recognition. The focal part of the work introduces adaptive classifier combination schemes, of which the two most prominent ones are the Dynamically Expanding Context (DEC) committee and the Class-Confidence Critic Combining (CCCC) committee. Both have been shown to be capable of successful adaptation to the user in the task of on-line handwritten character recognition. Particularly the highly modular CCCC framework has shown impressive performance also in a doubly-adaptive setting of combining adaptive classifiers by using an adaptive committee. In support of this main topic of the thesis, some discussion on a methodology for deducing correct character labeling from user actions is presented. Proper labeling is paramount for effective adaptation, and deducing the labels from the user's actions is necessary to perform adaptation transparently to the user. In that way, the user does not need to give explicit feedback on the correctness of the recognition results. Also, an overview is presented of adaptive classification methods for single-classifier adaptation in handwritten character recognition developed at the Laboratory of Computer and Information Science of the Helsinki University of Technology, CIS-HCR. Classifiers based on the CIS-HCR system have been used in the adaptive committee experiments as both member classifiers and to provide a reference level. Finally, two distinct approaches for improving the performance of committee classifiers further are discussed. Firstly, methods for committee rejection are presented and evaluated. Secondly, measures of classifier diversity for classifier selection, based on the concept of diversity of errors, are presented and evaluated. The topic of this thesis hence covers three important aspects of pattern recognition: on-line adaptation, combining classifiers, and a practical evaluation setting of handwritten character recognition. A novel approach combining these three core ideas has been developed and is presented in the introductory text and the included publications. To reiterate, the main contributions of this thesis are: 1) introduction of novel adaptive committee classification methods, 2) introduction of novel methods for measuring classifier diversity, 3) presentation of some methods for implementing committee rejection, 4) discussion and introduction of a method for effective label deduction from on-line user actions, and as a side-product, 5) an overview of the CIS-HCR adaptive on-line handwritten character recognition system.Luokittimien yhdistäminen komitealuokittimella on tehokas keino luokitustarkkuuden parantamiseen. Laskentatehon jatkuva kasvu tekee myös useiden luokittimien yhtäaikaisesta käytöstä yhä varteenotettavamman vaihtoehdon. Järjestelmän adaptoituminen (mukautuminen) käyttäjään on toinen hyvä keino käyttäjäriippumattoman järjestelmän tarkkuuden parantantamiseksi. Vaikka adaptaatio yleensä toteutetaan luokittimen tasolla, myös adaptiiviset komitealuokittimet voivat olla hyvin tehokkaita. Adaptiiviset komiteat voivat adaptoitua ilman yksityiskohtaista tietoa jäsenluokittimista. Adaptaatiota voidaan näin käyttää myös luokittelujärjestelmissä, jotka eivät ole itsessään sopivia adaptaatioon. Adaptaatioon sopimattomuus voi johtua esimerkiksi siitä, että luokittimen totetutusta ei voida muuttaa, tai siitä, että käytetään luokittelumenetelmää, joka ei sovellu jatkuvaan oppimiseen. Tämä väitöskirja käsittelee menetelmiä luokittimien adaptiiviseen yhdistämiseen käyttäen sovelluskohteena käsinkirjoitettujen merkkien on-line-tunnistusta. Keskeisin osa työtä esittelee uusia adaptiivisia luokittimien yhdistämismenetelmiä, joista kaksi huomattavinta ovat Dynamically Expanding Context (DEC) -komitea sekä Class-Confidence Critic Combining (CCCC) -komitea. Molemmat näistä ovat osoittautuneet kykeneviksi tehokkaaseen käyttäjä-adaptaatioon käsinkirjoitettujen merkkien on-line-tunnistuksessa. Erityisesti hyvin modulaarisella CCCC järjestelmällä on saatu hyviä tuloksia myös kaksinkertaisesti adaptiivisessa asetelmassa, jossa yhdistetään adaptiivisia jäsenluokittimia adaptiivisen komitean avulla. Väitöskirjan pääteeman tukena esitetään myös malli ja käytännön esimerkki siitä, miten käyttäjän toimista merkeille voidaan päätellä oikeat luokat. Merkkien todellisen luokan onnistunut päättely on elintärkeää tehokkaalle adaptaatiolle. Jotta adaptaatio voitaisiin suorittaa käyttäjälle läpinäkyvästi, merkkien todelliset luokat on kyettävä päättelemään käyttäjän toimista. Tällä tavalla käyttäjän ei tarvitse antaa suoraa palautetta tunnistustuloksen oikeellisuudesta. Työssä esitetään myös yleiskatsaus Teknillisen korkeakoulun Informaatiotekniikan laboratoriossa kehitettyyn adaptiiviseen käsinkirjoitettujen merkkien tunnistusjärjestelmään. Tähän järjestelmään perustuvia luokittimia on käytetty adaptiivisten komitealuokittimien kokeissa sekä jäsenluokittimina että vertailutasona. Lopuksi esitellään kaksi erillistä menetelmää komitealuokittimen tarkkuuden edelleen parantamiseksi. Näistä ensimmäinen on joukko menetelmiä komitealuokittimen rejektion (hylkäyksen) toteuttamiseksi. Toinen esiteltävä menetelmä on käyttää luokittimien erilaisuuden mittoja jäsenluokittimien valintaa varten. Ehdotetut uudet erilaisuusmitat perustuvat käsitteeseen, jota kutsumme virheiden erilaisuudeksi. Väitöskirjan aihe kattaa kolme hahmontunnistuksen tärkeää osa-aluetta: online-adaptaation, luokittimien yhdistämisen ja käytännön sovellusalana käsinkirjoitettujen merkkien tunnistuksen. Näistä kolmesta lähtökohdasta on kehitetty uudenlainen synteesi, joka esitetään johdantotekstissä sekä liitteenä olevissa julkaisuissa. Tämän väitöskirjan oleellisimmat kontribuutiot ovat siten: 1) uusien adaptiivisten komitealuokittimien esittely, 2) uudenlaisten menetelmien esittely luokittimien erilaisuuden mittaamiseksi, 3) joidenkin komitearejektiomenetelmien esittely, 4) pohdinnan ja erään toteutustavan esittely syötettyjen merkkien todellisen luokan päättelemiseksi käyttäjän toimista, sekä sivutuotteena 5) kattava yleiskatsaus CIS-HCR adaptiiviseen on-line käsinkirjoitettujen merkkien tunnistusjärjestelmään.reviewe

Individual and ensemble functional link neural networks for data classification

This study investigated the Functional Link Neural Network (FLNN) for solving data classification problems. FLNN based models were developed using evolutionary methods as well as ensemble methods. The outcomes of the experiments covering benchmark classification problems, positively demonstrated the efficacy of the proposed models for undertaking data classification problems

Static and dynamic selection of ensemble of classifiers

Nous présentons dans cette thèse plusieurs solutions novatrices pour tenter de solutionner trois problèmes fondamentaux reliés à la conception des ensembles de classifieurs: la génération des classificateurs, la sélection et la fusion. Une nouvelle fonction de fusion (Compound Diversity Function - CDF) basée sur la prise en compte de la performance individuelle des classificateurs et de la diversité entre pairs de classificateurs. Une nouvelle fonction de fusion basée sur les matrices de confusions "pairwise" (PFM), mieux adaptée pour la fusion des classificateurs en présence d'un grand nombre de classes. Une nouvelle méthode pour générer des ensembles de Mo- dèles de Markov Cachés (Hidden Markov Models - EoHMM) pour la reconnaissance des caractères manuscrits. Une solution novatrice repose sur le concept des Oracles associés aux données de la base de validation (KNORA). Une nouvelle approche pour la sélection des sous-espaces de représentation à partir d'une mesure de diversité évaluée entre les paires de partitions

NBS monograph

From Introduction: "This report is the first of a series intended to provide a selective overview of research and development efforts and requirements in the somewhat overlapping fields of the computer and information sciences and technologies. The projected series of reports will attempt to outline the probable range of R & D activities in the computer and information sciences and technologies through selective reviews of the literature and to develop a reasonable consensus with respect to the opinions of workers in these and potentially related fields as to areas of continuing R & D concern for research program planning or review in these areas.

Probabilistic multiple kernel learning

The integration of multiple and possibly heterogeneous information sources for an overall decision-making process has been an open and unresolved research direction in computing science since its very beginning. This thesis attempts to address parts of that direction by proposing probabilistic data integration algorithms for multiclass decisions where an observation of interest is assigned to one of many categories based on a plurality of information channels

Reconnaissance de l'écriture manuscrite en-ligne par approche combinant systèmes à vastes marges et modèles de Markov cachés

Handwriting recognition is one of the leading applications of pattern recognition and machine learning. Despite having some limitations, handwriting recognition systems have been used as an input method of many electronic devices and helps in the automation of many manual tasks requiring processing of handwriting images. In general, a handwriting recognition system comprises three functional components; preprocessing, recognition and post-processing. There have been improvements made within each component in the system. However, to further open the avenues of expanding its applications, specific improvements need to be made in the recognition capability of the system. Hidden Markov Model (HMM) has been the dominant methods of recognition in handwriting recognition in offline and online systems. However, the use of Gaussian observation densities in HMM and representational model for word modeling often does not lead to good classification. Hybrid of Neural Network (NN) and HMM later improves word recognition by taking advantage of NN discriminative property and HMM representational capability. However, the use of NN does not optimize recognition capability as the use of Empirical Risk minimization (ERM) principle in its training leads to poor generalization. In this thesis, we focus on improving the recognition capability of a cursive online handwritten word recognition system by using an emerging method in machine learning, the support vector machine (SVM). We first evaluated SVM in isolated character recognition environment using IRONOFF and UNIPEN character databases. SVM, by its use of principle of structural risk minimization (SRM) have allowed simultaneous optimization of representational and discriminative capability of the character recognizer. We finally demonstrate the various practical issues in using SVM within a hybrid setting with HMM. In addition, we tested the hybrid system on the IRONOFF word database and obtained favourable results.Nos travaux concernent la reconnaissance de l'écriture manuscrite qui est l'un des domaines de prédilection pour la reconnaissance des formes et les algorithmes d'apprentissage. Dans le domaine de l'écriture en-ligne, les applications concernent tous les dispositifs de saisie permettant à un usager de communiquer de façon transparente avec les systèmes d'information. Dans ce cadre, nos travaux apportent une contribution pour proposer une nouvelle architecture de reconnaissance de mots manuscrits sans contrainte de style. Celle-ci se situe dans la famille des approches hybrides locale/globale où le paradigme de la segmentation/reconnaissance va se trouver résolu par la complémentarité d'un système de reconnaissance de type discriminant agissant au niveau caractère et d'un système par approche modèle pour superviser le niveau global. Nos choix se sont portés sur des Séparateurs à Vastes Marges (SVM) pour le classifieur de caractères et sur des algorithmes de programmation dynamique, issus d'une modélisation par Modèles de Markov Cachés (HMM). Cette combinaison SVM/HMM est unique dans le domaine de la reconnaissance de l'écriture manuscrite. Des expérimentations ont été menées, d'abord dans un cadre de reconnaissance de caractères isolés puis sur la base IRONOFF de mots cursifs. Elles ont montré la supériorité des approches SVM par rapport aux solutions à bases de réseaux de neurones à convolutions (Time Delay Neural Network) que nous avions développées précédemment, et leur bon comportement en situation de reconnaissance de mots

Automatic Multilevel Feature Abstraction in Adaptable Machine Vision Systems

Vision is a complex task which can be accomplished with apparent ease by biological systems, but for which the design of artificial systems is difficult. Although machine vision systems can be successfully designed for a specific task, under certain conditions, they are likely to fail if circumstances change. This was the motivation for the research into ways in which systems can be self-designing and adaptable to new visual tasks. The research was conducted in three vital areas of concern for machine vision systems. The first area is finding a suitable architecture for forming an appropriate representation for the current task. The research investigated the application of Hypernetworks theory to building a multilevel, generally-applicable representation, through repeated application of a fundamental 'self-similarity' principle, that parts of objects assembled under a particular relation at one level, form whole objects at the next. Results show that this is potentially a powerful approach for autonomously generating an adaptable system-architecture suitable for multiple visual tasks. The second area is the autonomous extraction of suitable low-level features, which the research investigated through random generation of minimally-constrained pixel-configurations and algorithmic generation of homogeneous and heterogeneous polygons. The results suggest that, despite the simplicity of the features making them vulnerable to image transformations, these are promising approaches worth developing further. The third area is automatic feature selection. The research explored management of 'dimensionality' and of 'combinatorial explosion', as well as how to locate relevant features at multiple representation levels, in the context of 'emergence' of structure. Results indicate that this approach can find useful 'intermediate-level' constructs through analysis of the connectivity of the simplices representing objects at higher levels. The research concludes that the proposed novel approaches to tackling the above issues, in particular the application of hypernetworks to the formation of multilevel representations and the resulting emergence of higher-level structure, is fruitful