Automatic generation of synthetic workloads for multicore systems

textWhen designing a computer system, benchmark programs are used with cycle accurate performance/power simulators and HDL level simulators to evaluate novel architectural enhancements, perform design space exploration, understand the worst-case power characteristics of various designs and find performance bottlenecks. This research effort is directed towards automatically generating synthetic benchmarks to tackle three design challenges: 1) For most of the simulation related purposes, full runs of modern real world parallel applications like the PARSEC, SPLASH suites cannot be used as they take machine weeks of time on cycle accurate and HDL level simulators incurring a prohibitively large time cost 2) The second design challenge is that, some of these real world applications are intellectual property and cannot be shared with processor vendors for design studies 3) The most significant problem in the design stage is the complexity involved in fixing the maximum power consumption of a multicore design, called the Thermal Design Power (TDP). In an effort towards fixing this maximum power consumption of a system at the most optimal point, designers are used to hand-crafting possible code snippets called power viruses. But, this process of trying to manually write such maximum power consuming code snippets is very tedious. All of these aforementioned challenges has lead to the resurrection of synthetic benchmarks in the recent past, serving as a promising solution to all the challenges. During the design stage of a multicore system, availability of a framework to automatically generate system-level synthetic benchmarks for multicore systems will greatly simplify the design process and result in more confident design decisions. The key idea behind such an adaptable benchmark synthesis framework is to identify the key characteristics of real world parallel applications that affect the performance and power consumption of a real program and create synthetic executable programs by varying the values for these characteristics. Firstly, with such a framework, one can generate miniaturized synthetic clones for large target (current and futuristic) parallel applications enabling an architect to use them with slow low-level simulation models (e.g., RTL models in VHDL/Verilog) and helps in tailoring designs to the targeted applications. These synthetic benchmark clones can be distributed to architects and designers even if the original applications are intellectual property, when they are not publicly available. Lastly, such a framework can be used to automatically create maximum power consuming code snippets to be able to help in fixing the TDP, heat sinks, cooling system and other power related features of the system. The workload cloning framework built using the proposed synthetic benchmark generation methodology is evaluated to show its superiority over the existing cloning methodologies for single-core systems by generating miniaturized clones for CPU2006 and ImplantBench workloads with only an average error of 2.9% in performance for up to five orders of magnitude of simulation speedup. The correlation coefficient predicting the sensitivity to design changes is 0.95 and 0.98 for performance and power consumption. The proposed framework is evaluated by cloning parallel applications implemented based on p-threads and OpenMP in the PARSEC benchmark suite. The average error in predicting performance is 4.87% and that of power consumption is 2.73%. The correlation coefficient predicting the sensitivity to design changes is 0.92 for performance. The efficacy of the proposed synthetic benchmark generation framework for power virus generation is evaluation on SPARC, Alpha and x86 ISAs using full system simulators and also using real hardware. The results show that the power viruses generated for single-core systems consume 14-41% more power compared to MPrime on SPARC ISA. Similarly, the power viruses generated for multicore systems consume 45-98%, 40-89% and 41-56% more power than PARSEC workloads, running multiple copies of MPrime and multithreaded SPECjbb respectively.Electrical and Computer Engineerin

Modeling Energy Consumption of High-Performance Applications on Heterogeneous Computing Platforms

Achieving Exascale computing is one of the current leading challenges in High Performance Computing (HPC). Obtaining this next level of performance will allow more complex simulations to be run on larger datasets and offer researchers better tools for data processing and analysis. In the dawn of Big Data, the need for supercomputers will only increase. However, these systems are costly to maintain because power is expensive. Thus, a better understanding of power and energy consumption is required such that future hardware can benefit. Available power models accurately capture the relationship to the number of cores and clock-rate, however the relationship between workload and power is less understood. Thus, investigation and analysis of power measurements has been a focal point in this work with the aim to improve the general understanding of energy consumption in the context of HPC. This dissertation investigates power and energy consumption of many different parallel applications on several hardware platforms while varying a number of execution characteristics. Multicore and manycore hardware devices are investigated in homogeneous and heterogeneous computing environments. Further, common techniques for reducing power and energy consumption are employed to each of these devices. Well-known power and performance models have been combined to form the Execution-Phase model, which may be used to quantify energy contributions based on execution phase and has been used to predict energy consumption to within 10%. However, due to limitations in the measurement procedure, a less intrusive approach is required. The Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD) and Hilbert-Huang Transform analysis technique has been applied in innovative ways to model, analyze, and visualize power and energy measurements. EMD is widely used in other research areas, including earthquake, brain-wave, speech recognition, and sea-level rise analysis and this is the first it has been applied to power traces to analyze the complex interactions occurring within HPC systems. Probability distributions may be used to represent power and energy traces, thereby providing an alternative means of predicting energy consumption while retaining the fact that power is not constant over time. Further, these distributions may be used to define the cost of a workload for a given computing platform

Energy Demand Response for High-Performance Computing Systems

The growing computational demand of scientific applications has greatly motivated the development of large-scale high-performance computing (HPC) systems in the past decade. To accommodate the increasing demand of applications, HPC systems have been going through dramatic architectural changes (e.g., introduction of many-core and multi-core systems, rapid growth of complex interconnection network for efficient communication between thousands of nodes), as well as significant increase in size (e.g., modern supercomputers consist of hundreds of thousands of nodes). With such changes in architecture and size, the energy consumption by these systems has increased significantly. With the advent of exascale supercomputers in the next few years, power consumption of the HPC systems will surely increase; some systems may even consume hundreds of megawatts of electricity. Demand response programs are designed to help the energy service providers to stabilize the power system by reducing the energy consumption of participating systems during the time periods of high demand power usage or temporary shortage in power supply. This dissertation focuses on developing energy-efficient demand-response models and algorithms to enable HPC system\u27s demand response participation. In the first part, we present interconnection network models for performance prediction of large-scale HPC applications. They are based on interconnected topologies widely used in HPC systems: dragonfly, torus, and fat-tree. Our interconnect models are fully integrated with an implementation of message-passing interface (MPI) that can mimic most of its functions with packet-level accuracy. Extensive experiments show that our integrated models provide good accuracy for predicting the network behavior, while at the same time allowing for good parallel scaling performance. In the second part, we present an energy-efficient demand-response model to reduce HPC systems\u27 energy consumption during demand response periods. We propose HPC job scheduling and resource provisioning schemes to enable HPC system\u27s emergency demand response participation. In the final part, we propose an economic demand-response model to allow both HPC operator and HPC users to jointly reduce HPC system\u27s energy cost. Our proposed model allows the participation of HPC systems in economic demand-response programs through a contract-based rewarding scheme that can incentivize HPC users to participate in demand response

Power efficient job scheduling by predicting the impact of processor manufacturing variability

Modern CPUs suffer from performance and power consumption variability due to the manufacturing process. As a result, systems that do not consider such variability caused by manufacturing issues lead to performance degradations and wasted power. In order to avoid such negative impact, users and system administrators must actively counteract any manufacturing variability. In this work we show that parallel systems benefit from taking into account the consequences of manufacturing variability when making scheduling decisions at the job scheduler level. We also show that it is possible to predict the impact of this variability on specific applications by using variability-aware power prediction models. Based on these power models, we propose two job scheduling policies that consider the effects of manufacturing variability for each application and that ensure that power consumption stays under a system-wide power budget. We evaluate our policies under different power budgets and traffic scenarios, consisting of both single- and multi-node parallel applications, utilizing up to 4096 cores in total. We demonstrate that they decrease job turnaround time, compared to contemporary scheduling policies used on production clusters, up to 31% while saving up to 5.5% energy.Postprint (author's final draft

A Survey of Prediction and Classification Techniques in Multicore Processor Systems

In multicore processor systems, being able to accurately predict the future provides new optimization opportunities, which otherwise could not be exploited. For example, an oracle able to predict a certain application\u27s behavior running on a smart phone could direct the power manager to switch to appropriate dynamic voltage and frequency scaling modes that would guarantee minimum levels of desired performance while saving energy consumption and thereby prolonging battery life. Using predictions enables systems to become proactive rather than continue to operate in a reactive manner. This prediction-based proactive approach has become increasingly popular in the design and optimization of integrated circuits and of multicore processor systems. Prediction transforms from simple forecasting to sophisticated machine learning based prediction and classification that learns from existing data, employs data mining, and predicts future behavior. This can be exploited by novel optimization techniques that can span across all layers of the computing stack. In this survey paper, we present a discussion of the most popular techniques on prediction and classification in the general context of computing systems with emphasis on multicore processors. The paper is far from comprehensive, but, it will help the reader interested in employing prediction in optimization of multicore processor systems