The effects of limited rebuild buffer and track buffers on rebuild time in raid5

Redundant Arrays of Independent Disks (RAID) are very popular for creating large, reliable storage systems. A RAID array consists of multiple independent disks that achieve fault tolerance by parity coding. The contents on a failed disk can be reconstructed on demand by reading and exciusive-ORing the corresponding blocks on surviving disks. Upon disk failure, the array enters rebuild mode when it begins to systematically reconstruct the data of the failed disk on a spare disk, provided one is available. The fundamental element of rebuild is the Rebuild Unit (RU). Surviving disks engaged in rebuild, process user requests at a higher priority. Since, not all RUs are available at the same time, available RUs must be stored in a buffer, called the rebuild buffer, which is a part of the disk array controller cache. Most studies assume that this buffer is infinite. However, with the advent of large sized disks, it is increasingly difficult to provide buffers large enough that do not prove to be bottlenecks. This work studies the effect of a limited rebuild buffer on the rebuild time in an effort to estimate its effect on the Mean Time to Data Loss (MTTDL) of the array. Finally, this work studies the idea of using track buffers which aim to improve the rebuild time by reducing the number of times a track has to be read in order to be completely rebuilt

RAID Organizations for Improved Reliability and Performance: A Not Entirely Unbiased Tutorial (1st revision)

RAID proposal advocated replacing large disks with arrays of PC disks, but as the capacity of small disks increased 100-fold in 1990s the production of large disks was discontinued. Storage dependability is increased via replication or erasure coding. Cloud storage providers store multiple copies of data obviating for need for further redundancy. Varitaions of RAID based on local recovery codes, partial MDS reduce recovery cost. NAND flash Solid State Disks - SSDs have low latency and high bandwidth, are more reliable, consume less power and have a lower TCO than Hard Disk Drives, which are more viable for hyperscalers.Comment: Submitted to ACM Computing Surveys. arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:2306.0876

Studies of disk arrays tolerating two disk failures and a proposal for a heterogeneous disk array

There has been an explosion in the amount of generated data in the past decade. Online access to these data is made possible by large disk arrays, especially in the RAID (Redundant Array of Independent Disks) paradigm. According to the RAID level a disk array can tolerate one or more disk failures, so that the storage subsystem can continue operating with disk failure(s). RAID 5 is a single disk failure tolerant array which dedicates the capacity of one disk to parity information. The content on the failed disk can be reconstructed on demand and written onto a spare disk. However, RAID5 does not provide enough protection for data since the data loss may occur when there is a media failure (unreadable sectors) or a second disk failure during the rebuild process. Due to the high cost of downtime in many applications, two disk failure tolerant arrays, such as RAID6 and EVENODD, have become popular. These schemes use 2/N of the capacity of the array for redundant information in order to tolerate two disk failures. RM2 is another scheme that can tolerate two disk failures, with slightly higher redundancy ratio. However, the performance of these two disk failure tolerant RAID schemes is impaired, since there are two check disks to be updated for each write request. Therefore, their performance, especially when there are disk failure(s), is of interest. In the first part of the dissertation, the operations for the RAID5, RAID6, EVENODD and RM2 schemes are described. A cost model is developed for these RAID schemes by analyzing the operations in various operating modes. This cost model offers a measure of the volume of data being transmitted, and provides adevice-independent comparison of the efficiency of these RAID schemes. Based on this cost model, the maximum throughput of a RAID scheme can be obtained given detailed disk characteristic and RAID configuration. Utilizing M/G/1 queuing model and other favorable modeling assumptions, a queuing analysis to obtain the mean read response time is described. Simulation is used to validate analytic results, as well as to evaluate the RAID systems in analytically intractable cases. The second part of this dissertation describes a new disk array architecture, namely Heterogeneous Disk Array (HDA). The HDA is motivated by a few observations of the trends in storage technology. The HDA architecture allows a disk array to have two forms of heterogeneity: (1) device heterogeneity, i.e., disks of different types can be incorporated in a single HDA; and (2) RAID level heterogeneity, i.e., various RAID schemes can coexist in the same array. The goal of this architecture is (1) utilizing the extra resource (i.e. bandwidth and capacity) introduced by new disk drives in an automated and efficient way; and (2) using appropriate RAID levels to meet the varying availability requirements for different applications. In HDA, each new object is associated with an appropriate RAID level and the allocation is carried out in a way to keep disk bandwidth and capacity utilizations balanced. Design considerations for the data structures of HDA metadata are described, followed by the actual design of the data structures and flowcharts for the most frequent operations. Then a data allocation algorithm is described in detail. Finally, the HDA architecture is prototyped based on the DASim simulation toolkit developed at NJIT and simulation results of an HDA with two RAID levels (RAID 1 and RAIDS) are presented

Data allocation in disk arrays with multiple raid levels

There has been an explosion in the amount of generated data, which has to be stored reliably because it is not easily reproducible. Some datasets require frequent read and write access. like online transaction processing applications. Others just need to be stored safely and read once in a while, as in data mining. This different access requirements can be solved by using the RAID (redundant array of inexpensive disks) paradigm. i.e., RAIDi for the first situation and RAID5 for the second situation. Furthermore rather than providing two disk arrays with RAID 1 and RAID5 capabilities, a controller can be postulated to emulate both. It is referred as a heterogeneous disk array (HDA). Dedicating a subset of disks to RAID 1 results in poor disk utilization, since RAIDi vs RAID5 capacity and bandwidth requirements are not known a priori. Balancing disk loads when disk space is shared among allocation requests, referred to as virtual arrays - VAs poses a difficult problem. RAIDi disk arrays have a higher access rate per gigabyte than RAID5 disk arrays. Allocating more VAs while keeping disk utilizations balanced and within acceptable bounds is the goal of this study. Given its size and access rate a VA\u27s width or the number of its Virtual Disks -VDs is determined. VDs allocations on physical disks using vector-packing heuristics, with disk capacity and bandwidth as the two dimensions are shown to be the best. An allocation is acceptable if it does riot exceed the disk capacity and overload disks even in the presence of disk failures. When disk bandwidth rather than capacity is the bottleneck, the clustered RAID paradigm is applied, which offers a tradeoff between disk space and bandwidth. Another scenario is also considered where the RAID level is determined by a classification algorithm utilizing the access characteristics of the VA, i.e., fractions of small versus large access and the fraction of write versus read accesses. The effect of RAID 1 organization on its reliability and performance is studied too. The effect of disk failures on the X-code two disk failure tolerant array is analyzed and it is shown that the load across disks is highly unbalanced unless in an NxN array groups of N stripes are randomly rotated

Rebuild performance enhancement using onboard caching and delayed vacation termination in clustered raid 5

The Clustered Raid 5 (CRAID5) architecture with a parity group size(G) smaller than the number of disks(N) increases the load by the declustering ratio denoted by α = (G -1)/(N -1), which can be lesser than that in Raid 5 while switching to, and subsequently operating in rebuild mode. The Nearly Random Permutation (NRP) layout provides the flexibility to vary the declustering ratio (α) for a given N, and the Vacationing Server Model (VSM) of processing the rebuild requests provides acceptable rebuild and user response times. The rebuild performance and the user response time can be improved by introducing an onboard buffer in the disks, which caches a single track upon arrival of a rebuild request while in rebuild mode. Such an enhancement is proposed, and the architecture is described along with an analysis using the DASim simulation toolkit developed at NJIT. Also proposed is the delayed termination of vacations with two user requests as this improves the rebuild performance with a negligible negative impact on user response time. Finally, the effect of limiting the rebuild buffer on the rebuild performance is presented in the context of three different disk utilizations and declustering ratios

Scalability of RAID systems

RAID systems (Redundant Arrays of Inexpensive Disks) have dominated backend storage systems for more than two decades and have grown continuously in size and complexity. Currently they face unprecedented challenges from data intensive applications such as image processing, transaction processing and data warehousing. As the size of RAID systems increases, designers are faced with both performance and reliability challenges. These challenges include limited back-end network bandwidth, physical interconnect failures, correlated disk failures and long disk reconstruction time. This thesis studies the scalability of RAID systems in terms of both performance and reliability through simulation, using a discrete event driven simulator for RAID systems (SIMRAID) developed as part of this project. SIMRAID incorporates two benchmark workload generators, based on the SPC-1 and Iometer benchmark specifications. Each component of SIMRAID is highly parameterised, enabling it to explore a large design space. To improve the simulation speed, SIMRAID develops a set of abstraction techniques to extract the behaviour of the interconnection protocol without losing accuracy. Finally, to meet the technology trend toward heterogeneous storage architectures, SIMRAID develops a framework that allows easy modelling of different types of device and interconnection technique. Simulation experiments were first carried out on performance aspects of scalability. They were designed to answer two questions: (1) given a number of disks, which factors affect back-end network bandwidth requirements; (2) given an interconnection network, how many disks can be connected to the system. The results show that the bandwidth requirement per disk is primarily determined by workload features and stripe unit size (a smaller stripe unit size has better scalability than a larger one), with cache size and RAID algorithm having very little effect on this value. The maximum number of disks is limited, as would be expected, by the back-end network bandwidth. Studies of reliability have led to three proposals to improve the reliability and scalability of RAID systems. Firstly, a novel data layout called PCDSDF is proposed. PCDSDF combines the advantages of orthogonal data layouts and parity declustering data layouts, so that it can not only survivemultiple disk failures caused by physical interconnect failures or correlated disk failures, but also has a good degraded and rebuild performance. The generating process of PCDSDF is deterministic and time-efficient. The number of stripes per rotation (namely the number of stripes to achieve rebuild workload balance) is small. Analysis shows that the PCDSDF data layout can significantly improve the system reliability. Simulations performed on SIMRAID confirm the good performance of PCDSDF, which is comparable to other parity declustering data layouts, such as RELPR. Secondly, a system architecture and rebuilding mechanism have been designed, aimed at fast disk reconstruction. This architecture is based on parity declustering data layouts and a disk-oriented reconstruction algorithm. It uses stripe groups instead of stripes as the basic distribution unit so that it can make use of the sequential nature of the rebuilding workload. The design space of system factors such as parity declustering ratio, chunk size, private buffer size of surviving disks and free buffer size are explored to provide guidelines for storage system design. Thirdly, an efficient distributed hot spare allocation and assignment algorithm for general parity declustering data layouts has been developed. This algorithm avoids conflict problems in the process of assigning distributed spare space for the units on the failed disk. Simulation results show that it effectively solves the write bottleneck problem and, at the same time, there is only a small increase in the average response time to user requests