Improving processor efficiency through thermal modeling and runtime management of hybrid cooling strategies

One of the main challenges in building future high performance systems is the ability to maintain safe on-chip temperatures in presence of high power densities. Handling such high power densities necessitates novel cooling solutions that are significantly more efficient than their existing counterparts. A number of advanced cooling methods have been proposed to address the temperature problem in processors. However, tradeoffs exist between performance, cost, and efficiency of those cooling methods, and these tradeoffs depend on the target system properties. Hence, a single cooling solution satisfying optimum conditions for any arbitrary system does not exist. This thesis claims that in order to reach exascale computing, a dramatic improvement in energy efficiency is needed, and achieving this improvement requires a temperature-centric co-design of the cooling and computing subsystems. Such co-design requires detailed system-level thermal modeling, design-time optimization, and runtime management techniques that are aware of the underlying processor architecture and application requirements. To this end, this thesis first proposes compact thermal modeling methods to characterize the complex thermal behavior of cutting-edge cooling solutions, mainly Phase Change Material (PCM)-based cooling, liquid cooling, and thermoelectric cooling (TEC), as well as hybrid designs involving a combination of these. The proposed models are modular and they enable fast and accurate exploration of a large design space. Comparisons against multi-physics simulations and measurements on testbeds validate the accuracy of our models (resulting in less than 1C error on average) and demonstrate significant reductions in simulation time (up to four orders of magnitude shorter simulation times). This thesis then introduces temperature-aware optimization techniques to maximize energy efficiency of a given system as a whole (including computing and cooling energy). The proposed optimization techniques approach the temperature problem from various angles, tackling major sources of inefficiency. One important angle is to understand the application power and performance characteristics and to design management techniques to match them. For workloads that require short bursts of intense parallel computation, we propose using PCM-based cooling in cooperation with a novel Adaptive Sprinting technique. By tracking the PCM state and incorporating this information during runtime decisions, Adaptive Sprinting utilizes the PCM heat storage capability more efficiently, achieving 29\% performance improvement compared to existing sprinting policies. In addition to the application characteristics, high heterogeneity in on-chip heat distribution is an important factor affecting efficiency. Hot spots occur on different locations of the chip with varying intensities; thus, designing a uniform cooling solution to handle worst-case hot spots significantly reduces the cooling efficiency. The hybrid cooling techniques proposed as part of this thesis address this issue by combining the strengths of different cooling methods and localizing the cooling effort over hot spots. Specifically, the thesis introduces LoCool, a cooling system optimizer that minimizes cooling power under temperature constraints for hybrid-cooled systems using TECs and liquid cooling. Finally, the scope of this work is not limited to existing advanced cooling solutions, but it also extends to emerging technologies and their potential benefits and tradeoffs. One such technology is integrated flow cell array, where fuel cells are pumped through microchannels, providing both cooling and on-chip power generation. This thesis explores a broad range of design parameters including maximum chip temperature, leakage power, and generated power for flow cell arrays in order to maximize the benefits of integrating this technology with computing systems. Through thermal modeling and runtime management techniques, and by exploring the design space of emerging cooling solutions, this thesis provides significant improvements in processor energy efficiency.2018-07-09T00:00:00

Overcoming the Challenges for Multichip Integration: A Wireless Interconnect Approach

The physical limitations in the area, power density, and yield restrict the scalability of the single-chip multicore system to a relatively small number of cores. Instead of having a large chip, aggregating multiple smaller chips can overcome these physical limitations. Combining multiple dies can be done either by stacking vertically or by placing side-by-side on the same substrate within a single package. However, in order to be widely accepted, both multichip integration techniques need to overcome significant challenges. In the horizontally integrated multichip system, traditional inter-chip I/O does not scale well with technology scaling due to limitations of the pitch. Moreover, to transfer data between cores or memory components from one chip to another, state-of-the-art inter-chip communication over wireline channels require data signals to travel from internal nets to the peripheral I/O ports and then get routed over the inter-chip channels to the I/O port of the destination chip. Following this, the data is finally routed from the I/O to internal nets of the target chip over a wireline interconnect fabric. This multi-hop communication increases energy consumption while decreasing data bandwidth in a multichip system. On the other hand, in vertically integrated multichip system, the high power density resulting from the placement of computational components on top of each other aggravates the thermal issues of the chip leading to degraded performance and reduced reliability. Liquid cooling through microfluidic channels can provide cooling capabilities required for effective management of chip temperatures in vertical integration. However, to reduce the mechanical stresses and at the same time, to ensure temperature uniformity and adequate cooling competencies, the height and width of the microchannels need to be increased. This limits the area available to route Through-Silicon-Vias (TSVs) across the cooling layers and make the co-existence and co-design of TSVs and microchannels extreamly challenging. Research in recent years has demonstrated that on-chip and off-chip wireless interconnects are capable of establishing radio communications within as well as between multiple chips. The primary goal of this dissertation is to propose design principals targeting both horizontally and vertically integrated multichip system to provide high bandwidth, low latency, and energy efficient data communication by utilizing mm-wave wireless interconnects. The proposed solution has two parts: the first part proposes design methodology of a seamless hybrid wired and wireless interconnection network for the horizontally integrated multichip system to enable direct chip-to-chip communication between internal cores. Whereas the second part proposes a Wireless Network-on-Chip (WiNoC) architecture for the vertically integrated multichip system to realize data communication across interlayer microfluidic coolers eliminating the need to place and route signal TSVs through the cooling layers. The integration of wireless interconnect will significantly reduce the complexity of the co-design of TSV based interconnects and microchannel based interlayer cooling. Finally, this dissertation presents a combined trade-off evaluation of such wireless integration system in both horizontal and vertical sense and provides future directions for the design of the multichip system

GreenCool: An Energy-Efficient Liquid Cooling Design Technique for 3-D MPSoCs Via Channel Width Modulation

Liquid cooling using interlayer microchannels has appeared as a viable and scalable packaging technology for 3-D multiprocessor system-on-chips (MPSoCs). Microchannel-based liquid cooling, however, can substantially increase the on-chip thermal gradients, which are undesirable for reliability, performance, and cooling efficiency. In this paper, we present GreenCool, an optimal design methodology for liquid-cooled 3-D MPSoCs. GreenCool simultaneously minimizes the cooling energy for a given system while maintaining thermal gradients and peak temperatures under safe limits. This is accomplished by tuning the heat transfer characteristics of the microchannels using channel width modulation. Channel width modulation is compatible with the current process technologies and incurs minimal additional fabrication costs. Through an extensive set of experiments, we show that channel width modulation is capable of complementing and enhancing the benefits of temperature-aware floorplanning. We also experiment with a 16-core 3-D system with stacked dynamic random-access memory, for which GreenCool improves energy efficiency by up to 53% with respect to no channel modulation

Perspective Chapter: Smart Liquid Cooling Solutions for Advanced Microelectronic Systems

Thermal management is today a primary focus in the electronics industry due to the continuous increase of power density in chips increasingly smaller in size, which has become a critical issue in fast-growing industries such as data centers. As air-cooling fails to meet the high heat extraction demands of this sector, liquid cooling emerges as a promising alternative. Nevertheless, advanced microelectronic components require a cooling system that not only reduces the energetic consumption but also enhances the thermal performance by minimizing the thermal resistance and ensuring high-temperature uniformities, especially under variable heat load scenarios with high heat dissipating hotspot regions, where conventional liquid cooling solutions prove inefficient. This chapter provides an overview of different passive heat transfer enhancement techniques of micro heat sinks from the literature, focusing on intelligent and adaptive solutions designed to optimize the cooling performance based on local and instantaneous cooling requirements for non-uniform and time-dependent power distribution maps

Temperature-Aware Design and Management for 3D Multi-Core Architectures

Vertically-integrated 3D multiprocessors systems-on-chip (3D MPSoCs) provide the means to continue integrating more functionality within a unit area while enhancing manufacturing yields and runtime performance. However, 3D MPSoCs incur amplified thermal challenges that undermine the corresponding reliability. To address these issues, several advanced cooling technologies, alongside temperature-aware design-time optimizations and run-time management schemes have been proposed. In this monograph, we provide an overall survey on the recent advances in temperature-aware 3D MPSoC considerations. We explore the recent advanced cooling strategies, thermal modeling frameworks, design-time optimizations and run-time thermal management schemes that are primarily targeted for 3D MPSoCs. Our aim of proposing this survey is to provide a global perspective, highlighting the advancements and drawbacks on the recent state-of-the-ar

Architectural-Physical Co-Design of 3D CPUs with Micro-Fluidic Cooling

The performance, energy efficiency and cost improvements due to traditional technology scaling have begun to slow down and present diminishing returns. Underlying reasons for this trend include fundamental physical limits of transistor scaling, the growing significance of quantum effects as transistors shrink, and a growing mismatch between transistors and interconnects regarding size, speed and power. Continued Moore's Law scaling will not come from technology scaling alone, and must involve improvements to design tools and development of new disruptive technologies such as 3D integration. 3D integration presents potential improvements to interconnect power and delay by translating the routing problem into a third dimension, and facilitates transistor density scaling independent of technology node. Furthermore, 3D IC technology opens up a new architectural design space of heterogeneously-integrated high-bandwidth CPUs. Vertical integration promises to provide the CPU architectures of the future by integrating high performance processors with on-chip high-bandwidth memory systems and highly connected network-on-chip structures. Such techniques can overcome the well-known CPU performance bottlenecks referred to as memory and communication wall. However the promising improvements to performance and energy efficiency offered by 3D CPUs does not come without cost, both in the financial investments to develop the technology, and the increased complexity of design. Two main limitations to 3D IC technology have been heat removal and TSV reliability. Transistor stacking creates increases in power density, current density and thermal resistance in air cooled packages. Furthermore the technology introduces vertical through silicon vias (TSVs) that create new points of failure in the chip and require development of new BEOL technologies. Although these issues can be controlled to some extent using thermal-reliability aware physical and architectural 3D design techniques, high performance embedded cooling schemes, such as micro-fluidic (MF) cooling, are fundamentally necessary to unlock the true potential of 3D ICs. A new paradigm is being put forth which integrates the computational, electrical, physical, thermal and reliability views of a system. The unification of these diverse aspects of integrated circuits is called Co-Design. Independent design and optimization of each aspect leads to sub-optimal designs due to a lack of understanding of cross-domain interactions and their impacts on the feasibility region of the architectural design space. Co-Design enables optimization across layers with a multi-domain view and thus unlocks new high-performance and energy efficient configurations. Although the co-design paradigm is becoming increasingly necessary in all fields of IC design, it is even more critical in 3D ICs where, as we show, the inter-layer coupling and higher degree of connectivity between components exacerbates the interdependence between architectural parameters, physical design parameters and the multitude of metrics of interest to the designer (i.e. power, performance, temperature and reliability). In this dissertation we present a framework for multi-domain co-simulation and co-optimization of 3D CPU architectures with both air and MF cooling solutions. Finally we propose an approach for design space exploration and modeling within the new Co-Design paradigm, and discuss the possible avenues for improvement of this work in the future

Modeling and Dynamic Management of 3D Multicore Systems with Liquid Cooling

Three-dimensional (3D) circuits reduce communication delay in multicore SoCs, and enable efficient integration of cores, memories, sensors, and RF devices. However, vertical integration of layers exacerbates the reliability and thermal problems, and cooling efficiency becomes a limiting factor. Liquid cooling is a solution to overcome the accelerated thermal problems imposed by multi-layer architectures. In this paper, we first provide a 3D thermal simulation model including liquid cooling, supporting both fixed and variable fluid injection rates. Our model has been integrated in HotSpot to study the impact on multicore SoCs. We design and evaluate several dynamic management policies that complement liquid cooling. Our results for 3D multicore SoCs, which are based on a 3D version of UltraSPARC T1, show that thermal management approaches that combine liquid cooling with proactive task allocation are extremely effective in preventing temperature problems. Our proactive management technique provides an additional 75% average reduction in hot spots in comparison to applying only liquid cooling. Furthermore, for systems capable of varying the coolant flow rate at runtime, our feedback controller increases the improvement to 95% on average

A semi-analytical approach for optimized design of microchannel liquid-cooled ICs

The development of embedded and interlayer liquid cooling in integrated circuits (ICs) using silicon microchannels has gained interest in the recent years owing to the rise of on-chip heat uses that aggravate thermal reliability issues of the emerging 3D stacked ICs. Further development of such devices and their translation to commercial applications depend largely on the availability of tools and methodologies that can enable the "temperature-aware" design of liquid- cooled microprocessors and 2D/3D multiprocessor systems-on-chip (MPSoCs). Recently, two optimal design methods have been proposed for liquid-cooled microchannel ICs: one to minimize on-chip temperature gradients and the other, called GreenCool, to maximize energy eciency in the coolant pumping eort. Both these methods rely upon the concept of channel width modulation to modify the thermal behaviour of a microchannel liquid-cooled heat sink. At the heart of both these methods is a new semi-analytical mathematical model for heat transfer in liquid-cooled ICs. Such a mathematical model enables the application of gradient descent approaches, such as non-linear programming, in the search for the most optimally performing channel design in a huge multi-dimensional design space. In this paper, we thoroughly quantify the impact and efficiency of the semi-analytical model, combined with non-linear programming, when compared against several numerical optimization mechanisms. Our experimental evaluation shows that non-linear programming, alongside the semi-analytical model, is up to 23x faster than conventional randomized/heuristic design approaches such as genetic algorithms and simulated annealing using fully-numerical thermal models