AppCon: Mitigating evasion attacks to ML cyber detectors

Adversarial attacks represent a critical issue that prevents the reliable integration of machine learning methods into cyber defense systems. Past work has shown that even proficient detectors are highly affected just by small perturbations to malicious samples, and that existing countermeasures are immature. We address this problem by presenting AppCon, an original approach to harden intrusion detectors against adversarial evasion attacks. Our proposal leverages the integration of ensemble learning to realistic network environments, by combining layers of detectors devoted to monitor the behavior of the applications employed by the organization. Our proposal is validated through extensive experiments performed in heterogeneous network settings simulating botnet detection scenarios, and consider detectors based on distinct machine-and deep-learning algorithms. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of AppCon in mitigating the dangerous threat of adversarial attacks in over 75% of the considered evasion attempts, while not being affected by the limitations of existing countermeasures, such as performance degradation in non-adversarial settings. For these reasons, our proposal represents a valuable contribution to the development of more secure cyber defense platforms

Dynamic adversarial mining - effectively applying machine learning in adversarial non-stationary environments.

While understanding of machine learning and data mining is still in its budding stages, the engineering applications of the same has found immense acceptance and success. Cybersecurity applications such as intrusion detection systems, spam filtering, and CAPTCHA authentication, have all begun adopting machine learning as a viable technique to deal with large scale adversarial activity. However, the naive usage of machine learning in an adversarial setting is prone to reverse engineering and evasion attacks, as most of these techniques were designed primarily for a static setting. The security domain is a dynamic landscape, with an ongoing never ending arms race between the system designer and the attackers. Any solution designed for such a domain needs to take into account an active adversary and needs to evolve over time, in the face of emerging threats. We term this as the ‘Dynamic Adversarial Mining’ problem, and the presented work provides the foundation for this new interdisciplinary area of research, at the crossroads of Machine Learning, Cybersecurity, and Streaming Data Mining. We start with a white hat analysis of the vulnerabilities of classification systems to exploratory attack. The proposed ‘Seed-Explore-Exploit’ framework provides characterization and modeling of attacks, ranging from simple random evasion attacks to sophisticated reverse engineering. It is observed that, even systems having prediction accuracy close to 100%, can be easily evaded with more than 90% precision. This evasion can be performed without any information about the underlying classifier, training dataset, or the domain of application. Attacks on machine learning systems cause the data to exhibit non stationarity (i.e., the training and the testing data have different distributions). It is necessary to detect these changes in distribution, called concept drift, as they could cause the prediction performance of the model to degrade over time. However, the detection cannot overly rely on labeled data to compute performance explicitly and monitor a drop, as labeling is expensive and time consuming, and at times may not be a possibility altogether. As such, we propose the ‘Margin Density Drift Detection (MD3)’ algorithm, which can reliably detect concept drift from unlabeled data only. MD3 provides high detection accuracy with a low false alarm rate, making it suitable for cybersecurity applications; where excessive false alarms are expensive and can lead to loss of trust in the warning system. Additionally, MD3 is designed as a classifier independent and streaming algorithm for usage in a variety of continuous never-ending learning systems. We then propose a ‘Dynamic Adversarial Mining’ based learning framework, for learning in non-stationary and adversarial environments, which provides ‘security by design’. The proposed ‘Predict-Detect’ classifier framework, aims to provide: robustness against attacks, ease of attack detection using unlabeled data, and swift recovery from attacks. Ideas of feature hiding and obfuscation of feature importance are proposed as strategies to enhance the learning framework\u27s security. Metrics for evaluating the dynamic security of a system and recover-ability after an attack are introduced to provide a practical way of measuring efficacy of dynamic security strategies. The framework is developed as a streaming data methodology, capable of continually functioning with limited supervision and effectively responding to adversarial dynamics. The developed ideas, methodology, algorithms, and experimental analysis, aim to provide a foundation for future work in the area of ‘Dynamic Adversarial Mining’, wherein a holistic approach to machine learning based security is motivated

A Framework for Meta-heuristic Parameter Performance Prediction Using Fitness Landscape Analysis and Machine Learning

The behaviour of an optimization algorithm when attempting to solve a problem depends on the values assigned to its control parameters. For an algorithm to obtain desirable performance, its control parameter values must be chosen based on the current problem. Despite being necessary for optimal performance, selecting appropriate control parameter values is time-consuming, computationally expensive, and challenging. As the quantity of control parameters increases, so does the time complexity associated with searching for practical values, which often overshadows addressing the problem at hand, limiting the efficiency of an algorithm. As primarily recognized by the no free lunch theorem, there is no one-size-fits-all to problem-solving; hence from understanding a problem, a tailored approach can substantially help solve it. To predict the performance of control parameter configurations in unseen environments, this thesis crafts an intelligent generalizable framework leveraging machine learning classification and quantitative characteristics about the problem in question. The proposed parameter performance classifier (PPC) framework is extensively explored by training 84 high-accuracy classifiers comprised of multiple sampling methods, fitness types, and binning strategies. Furthermore, the novel framework is utilized in constructing a new parameter-free particle swarm optimization (PSO) variant called PPC-PSO that effectively eliminates the computational cost of parameter tuning, yields competitive performance amongst other leading methodologies across 99 benchmark functions, and is highly accessible to researchers and practitioners. The success of PPC-PSO shows excellent promise for the applicability of the PPC framework in making many more robust parameter-free meta-heuristic algorithms in the future with incredible generalization capabilities

Why is Machine Learning Security so hard?

The increase of available data and computing power has fueled a wide application of machine learning (ML). At the same time, security concerns are raised: ML models were shown to be easily fooled by slight perturbations on their inputs. Furthermore, by querying a model and analyzing output and input pairs, an attacker can infer the training data or replicate the model, thereby harming the owner’s intellectual property. Also, altering the training data can lure the model into producing specific or generally wrong outputs at test time. So far, none of the attacks studied in the field has been satisfactorily defended. In this work, we shed light on these difficulties. We first consider classifier evasion or adversarial examples. The computation of such examples is an inherent problem, as opposed to a bug that can be fixed. We also show that adversarial examples often transfer from one model to another, different model. Afterwards, we point out that the detection of backdoors (a training-time attack) is hindered as natural backdoor-like patterns occur even in benign neural networks. The question whether a pattern is benign or malicious then turns into a question of intention, which is hard to tackle. A different kind of complexity is added with the large libraries nowadays in use to implement machine learning. We introduce an attack that alters the library, thereby decreasing the accuracy a user can achieve. In case the user is aware of the attack, however, it is straightforward to defeat. This is not the case for most classical attacks described above. Additional difficulty is added if several attacks are studied at once: we show that even if the model is configured for one attack to be less effective, another attack might perform even better. We conclude by pointing out the necessity of understanding the ML model under attack. On the one hand, as we have seen throughout the examples given here, understanding precedes defenses and attacks. On the other hand, an attack, even a failed one, often yields new insights and knowledge about the algorithm studied.This work was supported by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) through funding for the Center for IT-Security,Privacy and Accountability (CISPA) (FKZ: 16KIS0753

Generative Methods, Meta-learning, and Meta-heuristics for Robust Cyber Defense

Cyberspace is the digital communications network that supports the internet of battlefield things (IoBT), the model by which defense-centric sensors, computers, actuators and humans are digitally connected. A secure IoBT infrastructure facilitates real time implementation of the observe, orient, decide, act (OODA) loop across distributed subsystems. Successful hacking efforts by cyber criminals and strategic adversaries suggest that cyber systems such as the IoBT are not secure. Three lines of effort demonstrate a path towards a more robust IoBT. First, a baseline data set of enterprise cyber network traffic was collected and modelled with generative methods allowing the generation of realistic, synthetic cyber data. Next, adversarial examples of cyber packets were algorithmically crafted to fool network intrusion detection systems while maintaining packet functionality. Finally, a framework is presented that uses meta-learning to combine the predictive power of various weak models. This resulted in a meta-model that outperforms all baseline classifiers with respect to overall accuracy of packets, and adversarial example detection rate. The National Defense Strategy underscores cybersecurity as an imperative to defend the homeland and maintain a military advantage in the information age. This research provides both academic perspective and applied techniques to to further the cybersecurity posture of the Department of Defense into the information age