Rigorous numerical approaches in electronic structure theory

Electronic structure theory concerns the description of molecular properties according to the postulates of quantum mechanics. For practical purposes, this is realized entirely through numerical computation, the scope of which is constrained by computational costs that increases rapidly with the size of the system. The significant progress made in this field over the past decades have been facilitated in part by the willingness of chemists to forego some mathematical rigour in exchange for greater efficiency. While such compromises allow large systems to be computed feasibly, there are lingering concerns over the impact that these compromises have on the quality of the results that are produced. This research is motivated by two key issues that contribute to this loss of quality, namely i) the numerical errors accumulated due to the use of finite precision arithmetic and the application of numerical approximations, and ii) the reliance on iterative methods that are not guaranteed to converge to the correct solution. Taking the above issues in consideration, the aim of this thesis is to explore ways to perform electronic structure calculations with greater mathematical rigour, through the application of rigorous numerical methods. Of which, we focus in particular on methods based on interval analysis and deterministic global optimization. The Hartree-Fock electronic structure method will be used as the subject of this study due to its ubiquity within this domain. We outline an approach for placing rigorous bounds on numerical error in Hartree-Fock computations. This is achieved through the application of interval analysis techniques, which are able to rigorously bound and propagate quantities affected by numerical errors. Using this approach, we implement a program called Interval Hartree-Fock. Given a closed-shell system and the current electronic state, this program is able to compute rigorous error bounds on quantities including i) the total energy, ii) molecular orbital energies, iii) molecular orbital coefficients, and iv) derived electronic properties. Interval Hartree-Fock is adapted as an error analysis tool for studying the impact of numerical error in Hartree-Fock computations. It is used to investigate the effect of input related factors such as system size and basis set types on the numerical accuracy of the Hartree-Fock total energy. Consideration is also given to the impact of various algorithm design decisions. Examples include the application of different integral screening thresholds, the variation between single and double precision arithmetic in two-electron integral evaluation, and the adjustment of interpolation table granularity. These factors are relevant to both the usage of conventional Hartree-Fock code, and the development of Hartree-Fock code optimized for novel computing devices such as graphics processing units. We then present an approach for solving the Hartree-Fock equations to within a guaranteed margin of error. This is achieved by treating the Hartree-Fock equations as a non-convex global optimization problem, which is then solved using deterministic global optimization. The main contribution of this work is the development of algorithms for handling quantum chemistry specific expressions such as the one and two-electron integrals within the deterministic global optimization framework. This approach was implemented as an extension to an existing open source solver. Proof of concept calculations are performed for a variety of problems within Hartree-Fock theory, including those in i) point energy calculation, ii) geometry optimization, iii) basis set optimization, and iv) excited state calculation. Performance analyses of these calculations are also presented and discussed

Space-Related Applications of Intelligent Control: Which Algorithm to Choose? (Theoretical Analysis of the Problem)

For a space mission to be successful it is vitally important to have a good control strategy. For example, with the Space Shuttle it is necessary to guarantee the success and smoothness of docking, the smoothness and fuel efficiency of trajectory control, etc. For an automated planetary mission it is important to control the spacecraft's trajectory, and after that, to control the planetary rover so that it would be operable for the longest possible period of time. In many complicated control situations, traditional methods of control theory are difficult or even impossible to apply. In general, in uncertain situations, where no routine methods are directly applicable, we must rely on the creativity and skill of the human operators. In order to simulate these experts, an intelligent control methodology must be developed. The research objectives of this project were: to analyze existing control techniques; to find out which of these techniques is the best with respect to the basic optimality criteria (stability, smoothness, robustness); and, if for some problems, none of the existing techniques is satisfactory, to design new, better intelligent control techniques

Interval-Based Projection Method for Under-Constrained Numerical Systems

International audienceThis paper presents an interval-based method that follows the branch-and-prune scheme to compute a verified paving of a projection of the solution set of an under-constrained system. Benefits of this algorithm include anytime solving process, homogeneous verification of inner boxes, and applicability to generic problems, allowing any number of (possibly nonlinear) equality and inequality constraints. We present three key improvements of the algorithm dedicated to projection problems: (i) The verification process is enhanced in order to prove faster larger boxes in the projection space. (ii) Computational effort is saved by pruning redundant portions of the solution set that would project identically. (iii) A dedicated branching strategy allows reducing the number of treated boxes. Experimental results indicate that various applications can be modeled as projection problems and can be solved efficiently by the proposed method