Dimensionality Reduction of Quality Objectives for Web Services Design Modularization

With the increasing use of service-oriented Architecture (SOA) in new software development, there is a growing and urgent need to improve current practice in service-oriented design. To improve the design of Web services, the search for Web services interface modularization solutions deals, in general, with a large set of conflicting quality metrics. Deciding about which and how the quality metrics are used to evaluate generated solutions are always left to the designer. Some of these objectives could be correlated or conflicting. In this paper, we propose a dimensionality reduction approach based on Non-dominated Sorting Genetic Algorithm (NSGA-II) to address the Web services re-modularization problem. Our approach aims at finding the best-reduced set of objectives (e.g. quality metrics) that can generate near optimal Web services modularization solutions to fix quality issues in Web services interface. The algorithm starts with a large number of interface design quality metrics as objectives (e.g. coupling, cohesion, number of ports, number of port types, and number of antipatterns) that are reduced based on the nonlinear correlation information entropy (NCIE).The statistical analysis of our results, based on a set of 22 real world Web services provided by Amazon and Yahoo, confirms that our dimensionality reduction Web services interface modularization approach reduced significantly the number of objectives on several case studies to a minimum of 2 objectives and performed significantly better than the state-of-the-art modularization techniques in terms of generating well-designed Web services interface for users.Master of ScienceSoftware Engineering, College of Engineering & Computer ScienceUniversity of Michigan-Dearbornhttps://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/145687/1/Thesis Report_Hussein Skaf.pdfDescription of Thesis Report_Hussein Skaf.pdf : Thesi

Intelligent Web Services Architecture Evolution Via An Automated Learning-Based Refactoring Framework

Architecture degradation can have fundamental impact on software quality and productivity, resulting in inability to support new features, increasing technical debt and leading to significant losses. While code-level refactoring is widely-studied and well supported by tools, architecture-level refactorings, such as repackaging to group related features into one component, or retrofitting files into patterns, remain to be expensive and risky. Serval domains, such as Web services, heavily depend on complex architectures to design and implement interface-level operations, provided by several companies such as FedEx, eBay, Google, Yahoo and PayPal, to the end-users. The objectives of this work are: (1) to advance our ability to support complex architecture refactoring by explicitly defining Web service anti-patterns at various levels of abstraction, (2) to enable complex refactorings by learning from user feedback and creating reusable/personalized refactoring strategies to augment intelligent designers’ interaction that will guide low-level refactoring automation with high-level abstractions, and (3) to enable intelligent architecture evolution by detecting, quantifying, prioritizing, fixing and predicting design technical debts. We proposed various approaches and tools based on intelligent computational search techniques for (a) predicting and detecting multi-level Web services antipatterns, (b) creating an interactive refactoring framework that integrates refactoring path recommendation, design-level human abstraction, and code-level refactoring automation with user feedback using interactive mutli-objective search, and (c) automatically learning reusable and personalized refactoring strategies for Web services by abstracting recurring refactoring patterns from Web service releases. Based on empirical validations performed on both large open source and industrial services from multiple providers (eBay, Amazon, FedEx and Yahoo), we found that the proposed approaches advance our understanding of the correlation and mutual impact between service antipatterns at different levels, revealing when, where and how architecture-level anti-patterns the quality of services. The interactive refactoring framework enables, based on several controlled experiments, human-based, domain-specific abstraction and high-level design to guide automated code-level atomic refactoring steps for services decompositions. The reusable refactoring strategy packages recurring refactoring activities into automatable units, improving refactoring path recommendation and further reducing time-consuming and error-prone human intervention.Ph.D.College of Engineering & Computer ScienceUniversity of Michigan-Dearbornhttps://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/142810/1/Wang Final Dissertation.pdfDescription of Wang Final Dissertation.pdf : Dissertatio

Model Transformation Modularization as a Many-Objective Optimization Problem

Model transformation programs are iteratively refined, restructured, and evolved due to many reasons such as fixing bugs and adapting existing transformation rules to new metamodels version. Thus, modular design is a desirable property for model transformations as it can significantly improve their evolution, comprehensibility, maintainability, reusability, and thus, their overall quality. Although language support for modularization of model transformations is emerging, model transformations are created as monolithic artifacts containing a huge number of rules. To the best of our knowledge, the problem of automatically modularizing model transformation programs was not addressed before in the current literature. These programs written in transformation languages, such as ATL, are implemented as one main module including a huge number of rules. To tackle this problem and improve the quality and maintainability of model transformation programs, we propose an automated search-based approach to modularize model transformations based on higher-order transformations. Their application and execution is guided by our search framework which combines an in-place transformation engine and a search-based algorithm framework. We demonstrate the feasibility of our approach by using ATL as concrete transformation language and NSGA-III as search algorithm to find a trade-off between different well-known conflicting design metrics for the fitness functions to evaluate the generated modularized solutions. To validate our approach, we apply it to a comprehensive dataset of model transformations. As the study shows, ATL transformations can be modularized automatically, efficiently, and effectively by our approach. We found that, on average, the majority of recommended modules, for all the ATL programs, by NSGA-III are considered correct with more than 84% of precision and 86% of recall when compared to manual solutions provided by active developers. The statistical analysis of our experiments over several runs shows that NSGA-III performed significantly better than multi-objective algorithms and random search. We were not able to compare with existing model transformations modularization approaches since our study is the first to address this problem. The software developers considered in our experiments confirm the relevance of the recommended modularization solutions for several maintenance activities based on different scenarios and interviews.Comisión Interministerial de Ciencia y Tecnología TIN2015-70560-RJunta de Andalucía P12-TIC-186

Personalized Web Services Interface Design Using Interactive Computational Search

Most of successful Web services evolve through a process of continuous change due to several reasons such as improving the quality, fixing bugs and adding new features. However, this evolution process may weaken the design of the Web service’s interface by including a large number of non-cohesive operations and make it unnecessarily complex for users to find relevant operations to be used by their services-based systems. In this thesis, we propose a remodularization recommendation approach that dynamically adapts and interactively suggests a possible modularization of the Web services interface design to users/developers and takes their feedback into consideration. Our approach uses an interactive multi-criteria decision making algorithm, based on interactive NSGA-II, to find a set of good design interface modularization solutions that find a trade-off between improving several interface design quality metrics (e.g. coupling, cohesion, number of portTypes and number of antipatterns), maximizing the reuse of user-interface interaction history patterns identified from previous releases and satisfying the interaction constraints learnt from the user feedback during the execution of the algorithm while minimizing the deviation from the initial design. We evaluated our approach on a set of 22 real-world Web services, provided by Amazon and Yahoo. Statistical analysis of our experiments shows that our dynamic interactive Web services interface modularization approach performed significantly better than the state-of-the-art modularization techniques.Master of Science (MS)Software Engineering, College of Engineering & Computer ScienceUniversity of Michigan-Dearbornhttps://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/140766/1/Thesis Report__Fun Jirigesi.pdfDescription of Thesis Report__Fun Jirigesi.pdf : Master's Thesi

Interactive Refactoring of Web Service Interfaces

https://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/140399/1/Transaction FInal Rev 3.pd

An Empirical Study of Cohesion and Coupling: Balancing Optimisation and Disruption

Search based software engineering has been extensively applied to the problem of finding improved modular structures that maximise cohesion and minimise coupling. However, there has, hitherto, been no longitudinal study of developers’ implementations, over a series of sequential releases. Moreover, results validating whether developers respect the fitness functions are scarce, and the potentially disruptive effect of search-based remodularisation is usually overlooked. We present an empirical study of 233 sequential releases of 10 different systems; the largest empirical study reported in the literature so far, and the first longitudinal study. Our results provide evidence that developers do, indeed, respect the fitness functions used to optimise cohesion/coupling (they are statistically significantly better than arbitrary choices with p << 0.01), yet they also leave considerable room for further improvement (cohesion/coupling can be improved by 25% on average). However, we also report that optimising the structure is highly disruptive (on average more than 57% of the structure must change), while our results reveal that developers tend to avoid such disruption. Therefore, we introduce and evaluate a multi-objective evolutionary approach that minimises disruption while maximising cohesion/coupling improvement. This allows developers to balance reticence to disrupt existing modular structure, against their competing need to improve cohesion and coupling. The multi-objective approach is able to find modular structures that improve the cohesion of developers’ implementations by 22.52%, while causing an acceptably low level of disruption (within that already tolerated by developers)

Search-Based Information Systems Migration: Case Studies on Refactoring Model Transformations

Information systems are built to last for decades; however, the reality suggests otherwise. Companies are often pushed to modernize their systems to reduce costs, meet new policies, improve the security, or to be more competitive. Model-driven engineering (MDE) approaches are used in several successful projects to migrate systems. MDE raises the level of abstraction for complex systems by relying on models as first-class entities. These models are maintained and transformed using model transformations (MT), which are expressed by means of transformation rules to transform models from source to target meta-models. The migration process for information systems may take years for large systems. Thus, many changes are going to be introduced to the transformations to reflect the new business requirements, fix bugs, or to meet the updated metamodels. Therefore, the quality of MT should be continually checked and improved during the evolution process to avoid future technical debts. Most MT programs are written as one large module due to the lack of refactoring/modularization and regression testing tools support. In object-oriented systems, composition and modularization are used to tackle the issues of maintainability and testability. Moreover, refactoring is used to improve the non-functional attributes of the software, making it easier and faster for developers to work and manipulate the code. Thus, we proposed an intelligent computational search approach to automatically modularize MT. Furthermore, we took inspiration from a well-defined quality assessment model for object-oriented design to propose a quality assessment model for MT in particular. The results showed a 45% improvement in the developer’s speed to detect or fix bugs, and developers made 40% less errors when performing a task with the optimized version. Since refactoring operations changes the transformation, it is important to apply regression testing to check their correctness and robustness. Thus, we proposed a multi-objective test case selection technique to find the best trade-off between coverage and computational cost. Results showed a drastic speed-up of the testing process while still showing a good testing performance. The survey with practitioners highlighted the need of such maintenance and evolution framework to improve the quality and efficiency of the existing migration process.Ph.D.College of Engineering & Computer ScienceUniversity of Michigan-Dearbornhttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/149153/1/Bader Alkhazi Final Dissertation.pdfDescription of Bader Alkhazi Final Dissertation.pdf : Restricted to UM users only

Entropy-driven global best selection in particle swarm optimization for many-objective software package restructuring

Many real-world optimization problems usually require a large number of conflicting objectives to be optimized simultaneously to obtain solution. It has been observed that these kinds of many-objective optimization problems (MaOPs) often pose several performance challenges to the traditional multi-objective optimization algorithms. To address the performance issue caused by the different types of MaOPs, recently, a variety of many-objective particle swarm optimization (MaOPSO) has been proposed. However, external archive maintenance and selection of leaders for designing the MaOPSO to real-world MaOPs are still challenging issues. This work presents a MaOPSO based on entropy-driven global best selection strategy (called EMPSO) to solve the many-objective software package restructuring (MaOSPR) problem. EMPSO makes use of the entropy and quality indicator for the selection of global best particle. To evaluate the performance of the proposed approach, we applied it over the five MaOSPR problems. We compared it with eight variants of MaOPSO, which are based on eight different global best selection strategies. The results indicate that the proposed EMPSO is competitive with respect to the existing global best selection strategies based on variants of MaOPSO approaches.publishedVersio