How to make a greedy heuristic for the asymmetric traveling salesman problem competitive

It is widely confirmed by many computational experiments that a greedy type heuristics for the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) produces rather poor solutions except for the Euclidean TSP. The selection of arcs to be included by a greedy heuristic is usually done on the base of cost values. We propose to use upper tolerances of an optimal solution to one of the relaxed Asymmetric TSP (ATSP) to guide the selection of an arc to be included in the final greedy solution. Even though it needs time to calculate tolerances, our computational experiments for the wide range of ATSP instances show that tolerance based greedy heuristics is much more accurate an faster than previously reported greedy type algorithms

Iterative Patching and the Asymmetric Traveling Salesman Problem

Although Branch and Bound (BnB) methods are among the most widely used techniques for solving hard problems, it is still a challenge to make these methods smarter. In this paper, we investigate iterative patching, a technique in which a fixed patching procedure is applied at each node of the BnB search tree for the Asymmetric Traveling Salesman Problem. Computational experiments show that iterative patching results in general in search trees that are smaller than the usual classical BnB trees, and that solution times are lower for usual random and sparse instances. Furthermore, it turns out that, on average, iterative patching with the Contract-or-Patch procedure of Glover, Gutin, Yeo and Zverovich (2001) and the Karp-Steele procedure are the fastest, and that ?iterative? Modified Karp-Steele patching generates the smallest search trees.

Advanced analysis of branch and bound algorithms

Als de code van een cijferslot zoek is, kan het alleen geopend worden door alle cijfercom­binaties langs te gaan. In het slechtste geval is de laatste combinatie de juiste. Echter, als de code uit tien cijfers bestaat, moeten tien miljard mogelijkheden bekeken worden. De zogenaamde 'NP-lastige' problemen in het proefschrift van Marcel Turkensteen zijn vergelijkbaar met het 'cijferslotprobleem'. Ook bij deze problemen is het aantal mogelijkheden buitensporig groot. De kunst is derhalve om de zoekruimte op een slimme manier af te tasten. Bij de Branch and Bound (BnB) methode wordt dit gedaan door de zoekruimte op te splitsen in kleinere deelgebieden. Turkensteen past de BnB methode onder andere toe bij het handelsreizigersprobleem, waarbij een kortste route door een verzameling plaatsen bepaald moet worden. Dit probleem is in algemene vorm nog steeds niet opgelost. De economische gevolgen kunnen groot zijn: zo staat nog steeds niet vast of bijvoorbeeld een routeplanner vrachtwagens optimaal laat rondrijden. De huidige BnB-methoden worden in dit proefschrift met name verbeterd door niet naar de kosten van een verbinding te kijken, maar naar de kostentoename als een verbinding niet gebruikt wordt: de boventolerantie.

Regional Search for the Resource Constrained Assignment Problem

The resource constrained assignment problem (RCAP) is to find a minimal cost partition of the nodes of a directed graph into cycles such that a resource constraint is fulfilled. The RCAP has its roots in rolling stock rotation optimization where a railway timetable has to be covered by rotations, i.e., cycles. In that context, the resource constraint corresponds to maintenance constraints for rail vehicles. Moreover, the RCAP generalizes variants of the vehicle routing problem (VRP). The paper contributes an exact branch and bound algorithm for the RCAP and, primarily, a straightforward algorithmic concept that we call regional search (RS). As a symbiosis of a local and a global search algorithm, the result of an RS is a local optimum for a combinatorial optimization problem. In addition, the local optimum must be globally optimal as well if an instance of a problem relaxation is computed. In order to present the idea for a standardized setup we introduce an RS for binary programs. But the proper contribution of the paper is an RS that turns the Hungarian method into a powerful heuristic for the resource constrained assignment problem by utilizing the exact branch and bound. We present computational results for RCAP instances from an industrial cooperation with Deutsche Bahn Fernverkehr AG as well as for VRP instances from the literature. The results show that our RS provides a solution quality of 1.4 % average gap w.r.t. the best known solutions of a large test set. In addition, our branch and bound algorithm can solve many RCAP instances to proven optimality, e.g., almost all asymmetric traveling salesman and capacitated vehicle routing problems that we consider