Multiobjective Design and Innovization of Robust Stormwater Management Plans

In the United States, states are federally mandated to develop watershed management plans to mitigate pollution from increased impervious surfaces due to land development such as buildings, roadways, and parking lots. These plans require a major investment in water retention infrastructure, known as structural Best Management Practices (BMPs). However, the discovery of BMP configurations that simultaneously minimize implementation cost and pollutant load is a complex problem. While not required by law, an additional challenge is to find plans that not only meet current pollutant load targets, but also take into consideration anticipated changes in future precipitation patterns due to climate change. In this dissertation, a multi-scale, multiobjective optimization method is presented to tackle these three objectives. The method is demonstrated on the Bartlett Brook mixed-used impaired watershed in South Burlington, VT. New contributions of this work include: (A) A method for encouraging uniformity of spacing along the non-dominated front in multiobjective evolutionary optimization. This method is implemented in multiobjective differential evolution, is validated on standard benchmark biobjective problems, and is shown to outperform existing methods. (B) A procedure to use GIS data to estimate maximum feasible BMP locations and sizes in subwatersheds. (C) A multi-scale decomposition of the watershed management problem that precalculates the optimal cost BMP configuration across the entire range of possible treatment levels within each subwatershed. This one-time pre-computation greatly reduces computation during the evolutionary optimization and enables formulation of the problem as real-valued biobjective global optimization, thus permitting use of multiobjective differential evolution. (D) Discovery of a computationally efficient surrogate for sediment load. This surrogate is validated on nine real watersheds with different characteristics and is used in the initial stages of the evolutionary optimization to further reduce the computational burden. (E) A lexicographic approach for incorporating the third objective of finding non-dominated solutions that are also robust to climate change. (F) New visualization methods for discovering design principles from dominated solutions. These visualization methods are first demonstrated on simple truss and beam design problems and then used to provide insights into the design of complex watershed management plans. It is shown how applying these visualization methods to sensitivity data can help one discover solutions that are robust to uncertain forcing conditions. In particular, the visualization method is applied to discover new design principles that may make watershed management plans more robust to climate change

A Hybrid MOEA/D-TS for Solving Multi-Objective Problems

In many real-world applications, various optimization problems with conflicting objectives are very common. In this paper we employ Multi-Objective Evolutionary Algorithm based on Decomposition (MOEA/D), a newly developed method, beside Tabu Search (TS) accompaniment to achieve a new manner for solving multi-objective optimization problems (MOPs) with two or three conflicting objectives. This improved hybrid algorithm, namely MOEA/D-TS, uses the parallel computing capacity of MOEA/D along with the neighborhood search authority of TS for discovering Pareto optimal solutions. Our goal is exploiting the advantages of evolutionary algorithms and TS to achieve an integrated method to cover the totality of the Pareto front by uniformly distributed solutions. In order to evaluate the capabilities of the proposed method, its performance, based on the various metrics, is compared with SPEA, COMOEATS and SPEA2TS on well-known Zitzler-Deb-Thiele’s ZDT test suite and DTLZ test functions with separable objective functions. According to the experimental results, the proposed method could significantly outperform previous algorithms and produce fully satisfactory results

Multiobjective Simulation Optimization Using Enhanced Evolutionary Algorithm Approaches

In today\u27s competitive business environment, a firm\u27s ability to make the correct, critical decisions can be translated into a great competitive advantage. Most of these critical real-world decisions involve the optimization not only of multiple objectives simultaneously, but also conflicting objectives, where improving one objective may degrade the performance of one or more of the other objectives. Traditional approaches for solving multiobjective optimization problems typically try to scalarize the multiple objectives into a single objective. This transforms the original multiple optimization problem formulation into a single objective optimization problem with a single solution. However, the drawbacks to these traditional approaches have motivated researchers and practitioners to seek alternative techniques that yield a set of Pareto optimal solutions rather than only a single solution. The problem becomes much more complicated in stochastic environments when the objectives take on uncertain (or noisy ) values due to random influences within the system being optimized, which is the case in real-world environments. Moreover, in stochastic environments, a solution approach should be sufficiently robust and/or capable of handling the uncertainty of the objective values. This makes the development of effective solution techniques that generate Pareto optimal solutions within these problem environments even more challenging than in their deterministic counterparts. Furthermore, many real-world problems involve complicated, black-box objective functions making a large number of solution evaluations computationally- and/or financially-prohibitive. This is often the case when complex computer simulation models are used to repeatedly evaluate possible solutions in search of the best solution (or set of solutions). Therefore, multiobjective optimization approaches capable of rapidly finding a diverse set of Pareto optimal solutions would be greatly beneficial. This research proposes two new multiobjective evolutionary algorithms (MOEAs), called fast Pareto genetic algorithm (FPGA) and stochastic Pareto genetic algorithm (SPGA), for optimization problems with multiple deterministic objectives and stochastic objectives, respectively. New search operators are introduced and employed to enhance the algorithms\u27 performance in terms of converging fast to the true Pareto optimal frontier while maintaining a diverse set of nondominated solutions along the Pareto optimal front. New concepts of solution dominance are defined for better discrimination among competing solutions in stochastic environments. SPGA uses a solution ranking strategy based on these new concepts. Computational results for a suite of published test problems indicate that both FPGA and SPGA are promising approaches. The results show that both FPGA and SPGA outperform the improved nondominated sorting genetic algorithm (NSGA-II), widely-considered benchmark in the MOEA research community, in terms of fast convergence to the true Pareto optimal frontier and diversity among the solutions along the front. The results also show that FPGA and SPGA require far fewer solution evaluations than NSGA-II, which is crucial in computationally-expensive simulation modeling applications

How to Evaluate Solutions in Pareto-based Search-Based Software Engineering? A Critical Review and Methodological Guidance

With modern requirements, there is an increasing tendency of considering multiple objectives/criteria simultaneously in many Software Engineering (SE) scenarios. Such a multi-objective optimization scenario comes with an important issue -- how to evaluate the outcome of optimization algorithms, which typically is a set of incomparable solutions (i.e., being Pareto non-dominated to each other). This issue can be challenging for the SE community, particularly for practitioners of Search-Based SE (SBSE). On one hand, multi-objective optimization could still be relatively new to SE/SBSE researchers, who may not be able to identify the right evaluation methods for their problems. On the other hand, simply following the evaluation methods for general multi-objective optimization problems may not be appropriate for specific SE problems, especially when the problem nature or decision maker's preferences are explicitly/implicitly available. This has been well echoed in the literature by various inappropriate/inadequate selection and inaccurate/misleading use of evaluation methods. In this paper, we first carry out a systematic and critical review of quality evaluation for multi-objective optimization in SBSE. We survey 717 papers published between 2009 and 2019 from 36 venues in seven repositories, and select 95 prominent studies, through which we identify five important but overlooked issues in the area. We then conduct an in-depth analysis of quality evaluation indicators/methods and general situations in SBSE, which, together with the identified issues, enables us to codify a methodological guidance for selecting and using evaluation methods in different SBSE scenarios.Comment: This paper has been accepted by IEEE Transactions on Software Engineering, available as full OA: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/925218

Exact and Heuristic Algorithms for Energy-Efficient Scheduling

The combined increase of energy demand and environmental pollution at a global scale is entailing a rethinking of the production models in sustainable terms. As a consequence, energy suppliers are starting to adopt strategies that flatten demand peaks in power plants by means of pricing policies that stimulate a change in the consumption practices of customers. A representative example is the Time-of-Use (TOU)-based tariffs policy, which encourages electricity usage at off-peak hours by means of low prices, while penalizing peak hours with higher prices. To avoid a sharp increment of the energy supply costs, manufacturing industry must carefully reschedule the production process, by shifting it towards less expensive periods. The TOU-based tariffs policy induces an implicit partitioning of the time horizon of the production into a set of time slots, each associated with a non-negative cost that becomes a part of the optimization objective. This thesis focuses on a representative bi-objective energy-efficient job scheduling problem on parallel identical machines under TOU-based tariffs by delving into the description of its inherent properties, mathematical formulations, and solution approaches. Specifically, the thesis starts by reviewing the flourishing literature on the subject, and providing a useful framework for theoreticians and practitioners. Subsequently, it describes the considered problem and investigates its theoretical properties. In the same chapter, it presents a first mathematical model for the problem, as well as a possible reformulation that exploits the structure of the solution space so as to achieve a considerable increase in compactness. Afterwards, the thesis introduces a sophisticated heuristic scheme to tackle the inherent hardness of the problem, and an exact algorithm that exploits the mathematical models. Then, it shows the computational efficiency of the presented solution approaches on a wide test benchmark. Finally, it presents a perspective on future research directions for the class of energy-efficient scheduling problems under TOU-based tariffs as a whole

Multiobjective Optimal Formulations for Bus Fleet Size of Public Transit under Headway-Based Holding Control

In recent years, with the development of advanced technologies for data collection, real-time bus control strategies have been implemented to improve the daily operation of transit systems, especially headway-based holding control which is a proven strategy to reduce bus bunching and improve service reliability for high-frequency bus routes, with the concept of regulating headways between successive buses. This hot topic has inspired the reconsideration of the traditional issue of fleet size optimization and the integrated bus holding control strategy. The traditional headway-based control method only focused on the regulation of bus headways, without considering the number of buses on the route. The number of buses is usually assumed as a given in advance and the task of the control method is to regulate the headways between successive buses. They did not consider the bus fleet size problem integrated with headway-based holding control method. Therefore, this work has presented a set of optimal control formulations to minimize the costs for the passengers and the bus company through calculating the optimal number of buses and the dynamic holding time, taking into account the randomness of passenger arrivals. A set of equations were formulated to obtain the operation of the buses with headway-based holding control or the schedule-based control method. The objective was to minimize the total cost for the passengers and the bus company in the system, and a Monte Carlo simulation based solution method was subsequently designed to solve the optimization model. The effects of this optimization method were tested under different operational settings. A comparison of the total costs was conducted between the headway-based holding control and the schedule-based holding control. It was found that the model was capable of reducing the costs of the bus company and passengers through utilizing headway-based bus holding control combined with optimization of the bus fleet size. The proposed optimization model could minimize the number of buses on the route for a guaranteed service level, alleviating the problem of redundant bus fleet sizes caused by bus bunching in the traditional schedule-based control method. Document type: Articl

Generalized Lorenz-Mie theory : application to scattering and resonances of photonic complexes

Les structures photoniques complexes permettent de façonner la propagation lumineuse à l’échelle de la longueur d’onde au moyen de processus de diffusion et d’interférence. Cette fonctionnalité à l’échelle nanoscopique ouvre la voie à de multiples applications, allant des communications optiques aux biosenseurs. Cette thèse porte principalement sur la modélisation numérique de structures photoniques complexes constituées d’arrangements bidimensionnels de cylindres diélectriques. Deux applications sont privilégiées, soit la conception de dispositifs basés sur des cristaux photoniques pour la manipulation de faisceaux, de même que la réalisation de sources lasers compactes basées sur des molécules photoniques. Ces structures optiques peuvent être analysées au moyen de la théorie de Lorenz-Mie généralisée, une méthode numérique permettant d’exploiter la symétrie cylindrique des diffuseurs sous-jacents. Cette dissertation débute par une description de la théorie de Lorenz-Mie généralisée, obtenue des équations de Maxwell de l’électromagnétisme. D’autres outils théoriques utiles sont également présentés, soit une nouvelle formulation des équations de Maxwell-Bloch pour la modélisation de milieux actifs appelée SALT (steady state ab initio laser theory). Une description sommaire des algorithmes d’optimisation dits métaheuristiques conclut le matériel introductif de la thèse. Nous présentons ensuite la conception et l’optimisation de dispositifs intégrés permettant la génération de faisceaux d’amplitude, de phase et de degré de polarisation contrôlés. Le problème d’optimisation combinatoire associé est solutionné numériquement au moyen de deux métaheuristiques, l’algorithme génétique et la recherche tabou. Une étude théorique des propriétés de micro-lasers basés sur des molécules photoniques – constituées d’un arrangement simple de cylindres actifs – est finalement présentée. En combinant la théorie de Lorenz-Mie et SALT, nous démontrons que les propriétés physiques de ces lasers, plus spécifiquement leur seuil, leur spectre et leur profil d’émission, peuvent être affectés de façon nontriviale par les paramètres du milieu actif sous-jacent. Cette conclusion est hors d’atteinte de l’approche établie qui consiste à calculer les étatsméta-stables de l’équation de Helmholtz et leur facteur de qualité. Une perspective sur la modélisation de milieux photoniques désordonnés conclut cette dissertation.Complex photonic media mold the flow of light at the wavelength scale using multiple scattering and interference effects. This functionality at the nano-scale level paves the way for various applications, ranging from optical communications to biosensing. This thesis is mainly concerned with the numerical modeling of photonic complexes based on twodimensional arrays of cylindrical scatterers. Two applications are considered, namely the use of photonic-crystal-like devices for the design of integrated beam shaping elements, as well as active photonic molecules for the realization of compact laser sources. These photonic structures can be readily analyzed using the 2D Generalized Lorenz-Mie theory (2D-GLMT), a numerical scheme which exploits the symmetry of the underlying cylindrical structures. We begin this thesis by presenting the electromagnetic theory behind 2D-GLMT.Other useful frameworks are also presented, including a recently formulated stationary version of theMaxwell-Bloch equations called steady-state ab initio laser theory (SALT).Metaheuristics, optimization algorithms based on empirical rules for exploring large solution spaces, are also discussed. After laying down the theoretical content, we proceed to the design and optimization of beam shaping devices based on engineered photonic-crystal-like structures. The combinatorial optimization problem associated to beam shaping is tackled using the genetic algorithm (GA) as well as tabu search (TS). Our results show the possibility to design integrated beam shapers tailored for the control of the amplitude, phase and polarization profile of the output beam. A theoretical and numerical study of the lasing characteristics of photonic molecules – composed of a few coupled optically active cylinders – is also presented. Using a combination of 2D-GLMT and SALT, it is shown that the physical properties of photonic molecule lasers, specifically their threshold, spectrum and emission profile, can be significantly affected by the underlying gain medium parameters. These findings are out of reach of the established approach of computing the meta-stable states of the Helmholtz equation and their quality factor. This dissertation is concluded with a research outlook concerning themodeling of disordered photonicmedia