A Retrospective Analysis of the Fake News Challenge Stance Detection Task

The 2017 Fake News Challenge Stage 1 (FNC-1) shared task addressed a stance classification task as a crucial first step towards detecting fake news. To date, there is no in-depth analysis paper to critically discuss FNC-1's experimental setup, reproduce the results, and draw conclusions for next-generation stance classification methods. In this paper, we provide such an in-depth analysis for the three top-performing systems. We first find that FNC-1's proposed evaluation metric favors the majority class, which can be easily classified, and thus overestimates the true discriminative power of the methods. Therefore, we propose a new F1-based metric yielding a changed system ranking. Next, we compare the features and architectures used, which leads to a novel feature-rich stacked LSTM model that performs on par with the best systems, but is superior in predicting minority classes. To understand the methods' ability to generalize, we derive a new dataset and perform both in-domain and cross-domain experiments. Our qualitative and quantitative study helps interpreting the original FNC-1 scores and understand which features help improving performance and why. Our new dataset and all source code used during the reproduction study are publicly available for future research

Automatic stance detection on political discourse in Twitter

The majority of opinion mining tasks in natural language processing (NLP) have been focused on sentiment analysis of texts about products and services while there is comparatively less research on automatic detection of political opinion. Almost all previous research work has been done for English, while this thesis is focused on the automatic detection of stance (whether he or she is favorable or not towards important political topic) from Twitter posts in Catalan, Spanish and English. The main objective of this work is to build and compare automatic stance detection systems using supervised both classic machine and deep learning techniques. We also study the influence of text normalization and perform experiments with differentt methods for word representations such as TF-IDF measures for unigrams, word embeddings, tweet embeddings, and contextual character-based embeddings. We obtain state-of-the-art results in the stance detection task on the IberEval 2018 dataset. Our research shows that text normalization and feature selection is important for the systems with unigram features, and does not affect the performance when working with word vector representations. Classic methods such as unigrams and SVM classifier still outperform deep learning techniques, but seem to be prone to overfitting. The classifiers trained using word vector representations and the neural network models encoded with contextual character-based vectors show greater robustness

Semantic Sentiment Analysis of Twitter Data

Internet and the proliferation of smart mobile devices have changed the way information is created, shared, and spreads, e.g., microblogs such as Twitter, weblogs such as LiveJournal, social networks such as Facebook, and instant messengers such as Skype and WhatsApp are now commonly used to share thoughts and opinions about anything in the surrounding world. This has resulted in the proliferation of social media content, thus creating new opportunities to study public opinion at a scale that was never possible before. Naturally, this abundance of data has quickly attracted business and research interest from various fields including marketing, political science, and social studies, among many others, which are interested in questions like these: Do people like the new Apple Watch? Do Americans support ObamaCare? How do Scottish feel about the Brexit? Answering these questions requires studying the sentiment of opinions people express in social media, which has given rise to the fast growth of the field of sentiment analysis in social media, with Twitter being especially popular for research due to its scale, representativeness, variety of topics discussed, as well as ease of public access to its messages. Here we present an overview of work on sentiment analysis on Twitter.Comment: Microblog sentiment analysis; Twitter opinion mining; In the Encyclopedia on Social Network Analysis and Mining (ESNAM), Second edition. 201

Detecting Online Hate Speech Using Both Supervised and Weakly-Supervised Approaches

In the wake of a polarizing election, social media is laden with hateful content. Context accompanying a hate speech text is useful for identifying hate speech, which however has been largely overlooked in existing datasets and hate speech detection models. We provide an annotated corpus of hate speech with context information well kept. Then we propose two types of supervised hate speech detection models that incorporate context information, a logistic regression model with context features and a neural network model with learning components for context. Further, to address various limitations of supervised hate speech classification methods including corpus bias and huge cost of annotation, we propose a weakly supervised two-path bootstrapping approach for online hate speech detection by leveraging large-scale unlabeled data. This system significantly outperforms hate speech detection systems that are trained in a supervised manner using manually annotated data. Applying this model on a large quantity of tweets collected before, after, and on election day reveals motivations and patterns of inflammatory language

Automatic stance detection on political discourse in Twitter

The majority of opinion mining tasks in natural language processing (NLP) have been focused on sentiment analysis of texts about products and services while there is comparatively less research on automatic detection of political opinion. Almost all previous research work has been done for English, while this thesis is focused on the automatic detection of stance (whether he or she is favorable or not towards important political topic) from Twitter posts in Catalan, Spanish and English. The main objective of this work is to build and compare automatic stance detection systems using supervised both classic machine and deep learning techniques. We also study the influence of text normalization and perform experiments with differentt methods for word representations such as TF-IDF measures for unigrams, word embeddings, tweet embeddings, and contextual character-based embeddings. We obtain state-of-the-art results in the stance detection task on the IberEval 2018 dataset. Our research shows that text normalization and feature selection is important for the systems with unigram features, and does not affect the performance when working with word vector representations. Classic methods such as unigrams and SVM classifier still outperform deep learning techniques, but seem to be prone to overfitting. The classifiers trained using word vector representations and the neural network models encoded with contextual character-based vectors show greater robustness

Mapping (Dis-)Information Flow about the MH17 Plane Crash

Digital media enables not only fast sharing of information, but also disinformation. One prominent case of an event leading to circulation of disinformation on social media is the MH17 plane crash. Studies analysing the spread of information about this event on Twitter have focused on small, manually annotated datasets, or used proxys for data annotation. In this work, we examine to what extent text classifiers can be used to label data for subsequent content analysis, in particular we focus on predicting pro-Russian and pro-Ukrainian Twitter content related to the MH17 plane crash. Even though we find that a neural classifier improves over a hashtag based baseline, labeling pro-Russian and pro-Ukrainian content with high precision remains a challenging problem. We provide an error analysis underlining the difficulty of the task and identify factors that might help improve classification in future work. Finally, we show how the classifier can facilitate the annotation task for human annotators

Capturing stance dynamics in social media: open challenges and research directions

Social media platforms provide a goldmine for mining public opinion on issues of wide societal interest and impact. Opinion mining is a problem that can be operationalised by capturing and aggregating the stance of individual social media posts as supporting, opposing or being neutral towards the issue at hand. While most prior work in stance detection has investigated datasets that cover short periods of time, interest in investigating longitudinal datasets has recently increased. Evolving dynamics in linguistic and behavioural patterns observed in new data require adapting stance detection systems to deal with the changes. In this survey paper, we investigate the intersection between computational linguistics and the temporal evolution of human communication in digital media. We perform a critical review of emerging research considering dynamics, exploring different semantic and pragmatic factors that impact linguistic data in general, and stance in particular. We further discuss current directions in capturing stance dynamics in social media. We discuss the challenges encountered when dealing with stance dynamics, identify open challenges and discuss future directions in three key dimensions: utterance, context and influence

Corpus-based and Computational Analysis of Entity Framing

Entity Framing is the selection of aspects of an entity to promote a particular viewpoint towards that entity. Compared to issue framing, it has received little attention in Framing research, and it has also received very little attention in Natural Language Processing (NLP). We investigate Entity Framing of political figures on social media and the news through the selection of objectively verifiable attributes like name, title and background information. Despite indications that they signal the perceived status of the target and/or perceived solidarity with a target, naming and titling have not previously been quantitatively examined in terms of their relation to stance. In this thesis, we collect English and German tweets mentioning prominent politicians and show that naming variation relates positively to stance in a way that is suggestive of a framing effect mediated by respect. We show on the German corpus that this positive relation is impacted by differences in political orientation. Having provided the first quantitative evidence for the relation between stance and the mentioning of the objectively verifiable attributes name and title, we turn to engineering efforts towards automating detection of the selective mentioning of background information. By nature, whether certain information constitutes an instance of Entity Framing depends on the context in which that information is provided. Nevertheless, previous work on detection of framing through background information has not explored the role of context beyond the sentence. We experiment with computational methods for integrating three kinds of context: context from the same article, context from other publishers’ articles on the same event, and inclusion of texts from the same domain (but potentially different events). We find that integrating event context improves classification performance over a strong baseline. We additionally show through a series of performance tests that this improvement over the baseline holds specifically for instances that are likely to be more difficult to classify, as one would expect from a performance boost that is due to leveraging context. The result of these studies is a collection of new data sets, methods and findings with respect to Entity Framing, contributed in the hope that further computational research on this topic will be conducted, in order to improve our understanding of Entity Framing in general and of political figures in particular