Two-echelon freight transport optimisation: unifying concepts via a systematic review

Multi-echelon distribution schemes are one of the most common strategies adopted by the transport companies in an aim of cost reduction, but their identification in scientific literature is not always easy due to a lack of unification. This paper presents the main concepts of two-echelon distribution via a systematic review, in the specific a meta-narrative analysis, in order to identify and unify the main concepts, issues and methods that can be helpful for scientists and transport practitioners. The problem of system cost optimisation in two-echelon freight transport systems is defined. Moreover, the main variants are synthetically presented and discussed. Finally, future research directions are proposed.location-routing problems, multi-echelon distribution, cross-docking, combinatorial optimisation, systematic review.

Two-echelon freight transport optimisation: unifying concepts via a systematic review

Multi-echelon distribution schemes are one of the most common strategies adopted by the transport companies in an aim of cost reduction, but their identification in scientific literature is not always easy due to a lack of unification. This paper presents the main concepts of two-echelon distribution via a systematic review, in the specific a meta-narrative analysis, in order to identify and unify the main concepts, issues and methods that can be helpful for scientists and transport practitioners. The problem of system cost optimisation in two-echelon freight transport systems is defined. Moreover, the main variants are synthetically presented and discussed. Finally, future research directions are proposed

The design of effective and robust supply chain networks

Tableau d’honneur de la Faculté des études supérieures et postdoctorales, 2009-2010Pour faire face aux risques associés aux aléas des opérations normales et aux périls qui menacent les ressources d'un réseau logistique, une méthodologie générique pour le design de réseaux logistiques efficaces et robustes en univers incertain est développée dans cette thèse. Cette méthodologie a pour objectif de proposer une structure de réseau qui assure, de façon durable, la création de valeur pour l'entreprise pour faire face aux aléas et se prémunir contre les risques de ruptures catastrophiques. La méthodologie s'appuie sur le cadre de prise de décision distribué de Schneeweiss et l'approche de modélisation mathématique qui y est associée intègre des éléments de programmation stochastique, d'analyse de risque et de programmation robuste. Trois types d'événements sont définis pour caractériser l'environnement des réseaux logistiques: des événements aléatoires (ex. la demande, les coûts et les taux de changes), des événements hasardeux (ex. les grèves, les discontinuités d'approvisionnement des fournisseurs et les catastrophes naturelles) et des événements profondément incertains (ex. les actes de sabotage, les attentats et les instabilités politiques). La méthodologie considère que l'environnement futur de l'entreprise est anticipé à l'aide de scénarios, générés partiellement par une méthode Monte-Carlo. Cette méthode fait partie de l'approche de solution et permet de générer des replications d'échantillons de petites tailles et de grands échantillons. Elle aide aussi à tenir compte de l'attitude au risque du décideur. L'approche générique de solution du modèle s'appuie sur ces échantillons de scénarios pour générer des designs alternatifs et sur une approche multicritère pour l'évaluation de ces designs. Afin de valider les concepts méthodologiques introduits dans cette thèse, le problème hiérarchique de localisation d'entrepôts et de transport est modélisé comme un programme stochastique avec recours. Premièrement, un modèle incluant une demande aléatoire est utilisé pour valider en partie la modélisation mathématique du problème et étudier, à travers plusieurs anticipations approximatives, la solvabilité du modèle de design. Une approche de solution heuristique est proposée pour ce modèle afin de résoudre des problèmes de taille réelle. Deuxièmement, un modèle incluant les aléas et les périls est utilisé pour valider l'analyse de risque, les stratégies de resilience et l'approche de solution générique. Plusieurs construits mathématiques sont ajoutés au modèle de base afin de refléter différentes stratégies de resilience et proposer un modèle de décision sous risque incluant l'attitude du décideur face aux événements extrêmes. Les nombreuses expérimentations effectuées, avec les données d'un cas réaliste, nous ont permis de tester les concepts proposés dans cette thèse et d'élaborer une méthode de réduction de complexité pour le modèle générique de design sans compromettre la qualité des solutions associées. Les résultats obtenus par ces expérimentations ont pu confirmer la supériorité des designs obtenus en appliquant la méthodologie proposée en termes d'efficacité et de robustesse par rapport à des solutions produites par des approches déterministes ou des modèles simplifiés proposés dans la littérature

Shipment consolidation and distribution models in the international supply chain

With the increasing competition in global trade, buying and transporting items effectively in the international network are critical and challenging problems for many companies. The objective of this study is to design a cost-effective consolidation and distribution method to transport shipments in a global network. In the dissertation, we investigate an integrated consolidation problem in the international supply chain, where a US manufacturing company buys multiple items from China. A proactive order consolidation strategy is proposed. Different from current practices, our approach consolidates items in China considering inland transportation in US. This strategy is modeled to minimize the total costs by effectively loading items into an ocean container considering subsequent inland transportation cost and handling cost given container capacity and packing constraints. Two difficult combinatorial optimization problems, such as a mode selection problem and a three-dimensional bin packing problem, are combined into the model. Due to the problem complexity, approximation algorithms are proposed to solve the model. The basic model is extended to consider the inland multi-stop delivery and multi-period planning horizon. Several solution methodologies are developed and evaluated to solve large-scale problems. Based on the numerical results, it is observed that our proposed methods could achieve up to 30% cost savings compared with the current shipping practices. The algorithms we developed could obtain the good implementable solution in a reasonable time for real-world problems

Inter-firm collaboration in transportation

Dans la littérature académique et professionnelle relative au transport de marchandise, il y a longtemps que les méthodes de planification avancées ont été identifiées comme un moyen de dégager des économies grâce à une efficacité accrue des opérations de transport. Plus récemment, la collaboration interentreprises dans la planification du transport a été étudiée comme une source de gain supplémentaire en efficacité et, par conséquent, une opportunité pour dégager de nouvelles économies pour les collaborateurs. Cependant, la mise en œuvre d'une collaboration interentreprises en transports soulève un certain nombre d’enjeux. Cette thèse aborde trois thèmes centraux de la collaboration interentreprises et démontre les contributions via des études de cas dans l’industrie forestière et du meuble. Premièrement, les moyens technologiques pour soutenir une collaboration en planification du transport sont étudiés. Un système d’aide à la décision supportant la collaboration en transport forestier est présenté. Deuxièmement, le partage entre les collaborateurs du coût commun en transport est étudié. Une méthode de répartition du coût de transport tenant compte de l'impact - l’augmentation du coût de transport - des exigences inégales entre des collaborateurs est proposée. Troisièmement, la création de groupes collaboratifs - des coalitions - dans un ensemble de collaborateurs potentiel est étudiée. Un modèle réseau pour la formation d’une coalition selon les intérêts d’un sous-ensemble de collaborateurs adoptant ou pas un comportement opportuniste est détaillé. De plus, pour soutenir l'étude des thèmes précédents, la thèse comprend deux revues de la littérature. Premièrement, une revue sur les méthodes de planification et les systèmes d’aide à la décision en transport forestier est présenté. Deuxièmement, à travers la proposition d'un cadre pour créer et gérer une collaboration en transport et, plus généralement en logistique, une revue de travaux sur le transport et la logistique collaborative est offerte.In the academic and professional literature on freight transportation, computer-based planning methods have a long time ago been identified as a means to achieve cost reduction through enhanced transportation operations efficiency. More recently, inter-firm collaboration in transportation planning has been investigated as a means to provide further gains in efficiency and, in turn, to achieve additional cost reduction for the collaborators. However, implementation of inter-firm collaboration in transportation raises a number of issues. This thesis addresses three central themes in inter-firm collaboration and exemplifies the contributions in case studies involving collaboration in furniture and forest transportation. First, technological means to enable collaboration in transportation planning are studied. Embedding a computer-based planning method for truck routing, a decision support system enabling collaborative transportation is presented. Second, sharing the common transportation cost among collaborators is studied. A cost allocation method taking into account the impact – an increase of the transportation cost – of uneven requirements among collaborators is proposed. Third, building collaborating groups (i.e. coalitions) among a set of potential collaborators is studied. A network model for coalition formation by a subset of self-interested collaborators adopting or not an opportunistic behaviour is detailed. Moreover, to support the study of the aforementioned themes, the thesis includes two literature reviews. First, a survey on planning methods and decision support systems for vehicle routing problem in forest transportation is presented. Second, through the proposition of a framework for building and managing collaboration in transportation and, more generally in logistics, a survey of works on collaborative transportation and logistics is given

Service level, cost and environmental optimization of collaborative transportation

Less than truckload is an important type of road-based transportation. Based on real data and on a collaboration with industry, we show that a collaborative approach between companies offers important benefits. We propose to develop partnerships between shipping companies and to synchronize their shipments. Four operational collaborative schemes with different objectives are developed. The first one focuses on minimizing shipping costs for shippers. The second and third ones minimize the carrier’s costs and the environmental cost, respectively. The fourth one is a combination of all three. The results of our computational experiments demonstrate that collaboration lead to significant cost reductions

A Review on Quantitative Approaches for Dock Door Assignment in Cross-Docking

Cross docking is a relatively new technique in supply chain operations. It offers limited storage time to maximize the efficiency of goods transshipment. Efficient operation of a cross docking system requires an appropriate coordination of inbound and outbound flows, accurate planning and dynamic scheduling.  The planning strategies at cross docking terminals, which are receiving growing attention today, are the truck-to-door assignment and destination to door assignment problems. This paper provides a comprehensive literature review of quantitative approaches in dock door assignment problems of cross docking planning. The contributions of this paper are to identify the gap of knowledge in operational levels mainly in dock door assignment and to point out the future research direction in cross docking

Resource allocation in service and logistics systems

Resource allocation is a problem commonly encountered in strategic planning, where a typical objective is to minimize the associated cost or maximize the resulting profit. It is studied analytically and numerically for service and logistics systems in this dissertation, with the major resource being people, services or trucks. First, a staffing level problem is analyzed for large-scale single-station queueing systems. The system manager operates an Erlang-C queueing system with a quality-of-service (QoS) constraint on the probability that a customer is queued. However, in this model, the arrival rate is uncertain in the sense that even the arrival-rate distribution is not completely known to the manager. Rather, the manager has an estimate of the support of the arrival-rate distribution and the mean. The goal is to determine the number of servers needed to satisfy the quality of service constraint. Two models are explored. First, the constraint is enforced on an overall delay probability, given the probability that different feasible arrival-rate distributions are selected. In the second case, the constraint has to be satisfied by every possible distribution. For both problems, asymptotically optimal solutions are developed based on Halfin-Whitt type scalings. The work is followed by a discussion on solution uniqueness with a joint QoS constraint and a given arrival-rate distribution in multi-station systems. Second, an extension to Naor’s analysis on the joining or balking problem in observable M=M=1 queues and its variant in unobservable M=M=1 queues is presented to incorporate parameter uncertainty. The arrival-rate distribution is known to all, but the exact arrival rate is unknown in both cases. The optimal joining strategies are obtained and compared from the perspectives of individual customers, the social optimizer and the profit maximizer, where differences are recognized between the results for systems with deterministic and stochastic arrival rates. Finally, an integrated ordering and inbound shipping problem is formulated for an assembly plant with a large number of suppliers. The objective is to minimize the annual total cost with a static strategy. Potential transportation modes include full truckload shipping and less than truckload shipping, the former of which allows customized routing while the latter does not. A location-based model is applied in search of near-optimal solutions instead of an exact model with vehicle routing, and numerical experiments are conducted to investigate the insights of the problem.Operations Research and Industrial Engineerin