Exponential Space Improvement for minwise Based Algorithms

In this paper we introduce a general framework that exponentially improves the space, the degree of independence, and the time needed by min-wise based algorithms. The authors, in SODA 2011, we introduced an exponential time improvement for min-wise based algorithms by defining and constructing an almost k-min-wise independent family of hash functions. Here we develop an alternative approach that achieves both exponential time and exponential space improvement. The new approach relaxes the need for approximately min-wise hash functions, hence gets around the Omega(log(1/epsilon)) independence lower bound in [Patrascu 2010]. This is done by defining and constructing a d-k-min-wise independent family of hash functions. Surprisingly, for most cases only 8-wise independence is needed for the additional improvement. Moreover, as the degree of independence is a small constant, our function can be implemented efficiently. Informally, under this definition, all subsets of size d of any fixed set X have an equal probability to have hash values among the minimal k values in X, where the probability is over the random choice of hash function from the family. This property measures the randomness of the family, as choosing a truly random function, obviously, satisfies the definition for d=k=|X|. We define and give an efficient time and space construction of approximately d-k-min-wise independent family of hash functions for the case where d=2, as this is sufficient for the additional exponential improvement. We discuss how this construction can be used to improve many min-wise based algorithms. To our knowledge such definitions, for hash functions, were never studied and no construction was given before. As an example we show how to apply it for similarity and rarity estimation over data streams. Other min-wise based algorithms, can be adjusted in the same way

Bottom-k and Priority Sampling, Set Similarity and Subset Sums with Minimal Independence

We consider bottom-k sampling for a set X, picking a sample S_k(X) consisting of the k elements that are smallest according to a given hash function h. With this sample we can estimate the relative size f=|Y|/|X| of any subset Y as |S_k(X) intersect Y|/k. A standard application is the estimation of the Jaccard similarity f=|A intersect B|/|A union B| between sets A and B. Given the bottom-k samples from A and B, we construct the bottom-k sample of their union as S_k(A union B)=S_k(S_k(A) union S_k(B)), and then the similarity is estimated as |S_k(A union B) intersect S_k(A) intersect S_k(B)|/k. We show here that even if the hash function is only 2-independent, the expected relative error is O(1/sqrt(fk)). For fk=Omega(1) this is within a constant factor of the expected relative error with truly random hashing. For comparison, consider the classic approach of kxmin-wise where we use k hash independent functions h_1,...,h_k, storing the smallest element with each hash function. For kxmin-wise there is an at least constant bias with constant independence, and it is not reduced with larger k. Recently Feigenblat et al. showed that bottom-k circumvents the bias if the hash function is 8-independent and k is sufficiently large. We get down to 2-independence for any k. Our result is based on a simply union bound, transferring generic concentration bounds for the hashing scheme to the bottom-k sample, e.g., getting stronger probability error bounds with higher independence. For weighted sets, we consider priority sampling which adapts efficiently to the concrete input weights, e.g., benefiting strongly from heavy-tailed input. This time, the analysis is much more involved, but again we show that generic concentration bounds can be applied.Comment: A short version appeared at STOC'1