The effectiveness of advice solicitation and social peers in an energy recommender system

In face-to-face interactions, advice acceptance depends on how it is presented, as well as a number of social factors. For example, some persons are inclined to accept advice from an expert if they possess little domain knowledge. In contrast, if such advice is unsolicited, persons might only accept advice from a trusted source, such as a family member. Whether these mechanisms also play a role in the recommender context is unknown, even though advice solicitation may be particularly important in domains where a recommender user seeks behavioral change (e.g. energy conservation, healthy eating). This study examines the role of advice solicitation (i.e. whether one asks for advice or simply receives it) and advice source (i.e. either explained in social terms or not) in our 'Saving Aid' energy recommender system. Through a web-based user study with 252 participants, we find that allowing users to solicit advice themselves increases their perceived level of trust with our energy recommender system, compared to users that are presented unsolicited advice. In turn, we find that trust positively affects user satisfaction levels, as well as the number of chosen energy-saving measures. We discuss how system designers should consider how advice is presented and in which context.</p

A survey of recommender systems for energy efficiency in buildings: Principles, challenges and prospects

Recommender systems have significantly developed in recent years in parallel with the witnessed advancements in both internet of things (IoT) and artificial intelligence (AI) technologies. Accordingly, as a consequence of IoT and AI, multiple forms of data are incorporated in these systems, e.g. social, implicit, local and personal information, which can help in improving recommender systems' performance and widen their applicability to traverse different disciplines. On the other side, energy efficiency in the building sector is becoming a hot research topic, in which recommender systems play a major role by promoting energy saving behavior and reducing carbon emissions. However, the deployment of the recommendation frameworks in buildings still needs more investigations to identify the current challenges and issues, where their solutions are the keys to enable the pervasiveness of research findings, and therefore, ensure a large-scale adoption of this technology. Accordingly, this paper presents, to the best of the authors' knowledge, the first timely and comprehensive reference for energy-efficiency recommendation systems through (i) surveying existing recommender systems for energy saving in buildings; (ii) discussing their evolution; (iii) providing an original taxonomy of these systems based on specified criteria, including the nature of the recommender engine, its objective, computing platforms, evaluation metrics and incentive measures; and (iv) conducting an in-depth, critical analysis to identify their limitations and unsolved issues. The derived challenges and areas of future implementation could effectively guide the energy research community to improve the energy-efficiency in buildings and reduce the cost of developed recommender systems-based solutions.Comment: 35 pages, 11 figures, 1 tabl

The interplay between food knowledge, nudges, and preference elicitation methods determines the evaluation of a recipe recommender system

Domain knowledge can affect how a user evaluates different aspects of a recommender system. Recipe recommendations might be difficult to understand, as some health aspects are implicit. The appropriateness of a recommender’s preference elicitation (PE) method, whether users rate individual items or item attributes, may depend on the user’s knowledge level. We present an online recipe recommender experiment. Users (&#x1d441;=360) with varying levels of subjective food knowledge faced different cognitive digital nudges (i.e., food labels) and PE methods. In a 3 (recipes annotated with no labels, Multiple Traffic Light (MTL) labels, or full nutrition labels) x2 (PE method : content-based PE or knowledge-based) between-subjects design. We observed a main effect of knowledge-based PE on the healthiness of chosen recipes, while MTL label only helped marginally. A Structural Equation Model analysis revealed that the interplay between user knowledge and the PE method reduced the perceived effort of using the system and in turn, affected choice difficulty and satisfaction. Moreover, the evaluation of health labels depends on a user’s level of food knowledge. Our findings emphasize the importance of user characteristics in the evaluation of food recommenders and the merit of interface and inter action aspects

Exploring the effects of natural language justifications in food recommender systems

Users of food recommender systems typically prefer popular recipes, which tend to be unhealthy. To encourage users to select healthier recommendations by making more informed food decisions, we introduce a methodology to generate and present a natural language justification that emphasizes the nutritional content, or health risks and benefits of recommended recipes. We designed a framework that takes a user and two food recommendations as input and produces an automatically generated natural language justification as output, which is based on the user’s characteristics and the recipes’ features. In doing so, we implemented and evaluated eight different justification strategies through two different justification styles (e.g., comparing each recipe’s food features) in an online user study (N = 503). We compared user food choices for two personalized recommendation approaches, popularity-based vs our health-aware algorithm, and evaluated the impact of presenting natural language justifications. We showed that comparative justifications styles are effective in supporting choices for our healthy-aware recommendations, confirming the impact of our methodology on food choices

Real-time recommendations for energy-efficient appliance usage in households

According to several studies, the most influencing factor in a household\u27s energy consumption is user behavior. Changing user behavior to improve energy usage leads to efficient energy consumption, saving money for the consumer and being more friendly for the environment. In this work we propose a framework that aims at assisting households in improving their energy usage by providing real-time recommendations for efficient appliance use. The framework allows for the creation of household-specific and appliance-specific energy consumption profiles by analyzing appliance usage patterns. Based on the household profile and the actual electricity use, real-time recommendations notify users on the appliances that can be switched off in order to reduce consumption. For instance, if a consumer forgets their A/C on at a time that it is usually off (e.g., when there is no one at home), the system will detect this as an outlier and notify the consumer. In the ideal scenario, a household has a smart meter monitoring system installed, that records energy consumption at the appliance level. This is also reflected in the datasets available for evaluating such systems. However, in the general case, the household may only have one main meter reading. In this case, non-intrusive load monitoring (NILM) techniques, which monitor a house\u27s energy consumption using only one meter, and data mining algorithms that disaggregate the consumption into appliance level, can be employed. In this paper, we propose an end-to-end solution to this problem, starting with the energy disaggregation process, and the creation of user profiles that are then fed to the pattern mining and recommendation process, that through an intuitive UI allows users to further refine their energy consumption preferences and set goals. We employ the UK-DALE (UK Domestic Appliance-Level Electricity) dataset for our experimental evaluations and the proof-of-concept implementation. The results show that the proposed framework accurately captures the energy consumption profiles of each household and thus the generated recommendations are matching the actual household energy habits and can help reduce their energy consumption by 2–17%

Supporting Personalized Music Exploration through a Genre Exploration Recommender

Recommender systems have been largely focused on the task of predicting users' current preferences and finding the most relevant items that users currently like. However, this approach is not sufficient as users may want to explore and develop new preferences, for example about a new genre. Allowing users to explore new preferences has many advantages, such as helping users to stay away from the so-called ``filter bubbles'', supporting new preference exploration and development, and promoting under-explored niche tastes, in addition to the mainstream preferences. Therefore, in this dissertation, we explore how recommender systems can be leveraged to support users' new preference exploration in the context of music genre exploration. The research takes a multidisciplinary approach in which we explore music recommendation algorithms and interactive exploration interface design for supporting music genre exploration, paired with insights from individual's music preference evolution and theories on decision making (such as digital nudges). For this purpose, we propose a music genre exploration tool and refine the tool over subsequent studies. We evaluate the music genre exploration tool with multiple single-session user-centric studies and one longitudinal user study on the long-term effectiveness of the tool to drive new preference exploration with various types of users’ objective behavior and their subjective user experience. From the studies, we find that users perceived the music genre exploration tool to be a new and helpful way to explore and develop new music tastes. By allowing users to make trade-offs between their current preferences and the new music genre they want to explore, the music genre exploration helps users make an easy personalized first step out of their comfort zone and towards the new preferences. The newly designed interactive exploration interface of the music exploration tool improves the usability and helpfulness of genre exploration by improving transparency, controllability and understandability. We further investigate individual differences during musical preference evolution by checking individuals' musical preference consistency and identify a relevant personal factor associated with this consistency (i.e., musical expertise). Our findings suggest that users with different musical expertise tend to show different musical exploration behavior. We further enhance the exploration tool with digital nudges to see if digital nudges can promote more exploration from users, and based on insights on individual differences, how this differs among individuals with different expertise levels. Based on our findings, we discuss opportunities and implications for future recommender systems to support new preference exploration and development

Techno-economic assessment of building energy efficiency systems using behavioral change: A case study of an edge-based micro-moments solution

Energy efficiency based on behavioral change has attracted increasing interest in recent years, although, solutions in this area lack much needed techno-economic analysis. That is due to the absence of both prospective studies and consumer awareness. To close such gap, this paper proposes the first techno-economic assessment of a behavioral change-based building energy efficiency solution, to the best of the authors' knowledge. From the one hand, the technical assessment is conducted through (i) introducing a novel edge-based energy efficiency solution; (ii) analyzing energy data using machine learning tools and micro-moments, and producing intelligent, personalized, and explainable action recommendations; and (iii) proceeding with a technical evaluation of four application scenarios, i.e., data collection, data analysis and anomaly detection, recommendation generation, and data visualization. On the other hand, economic assessment is performed by examining the marketability potential of the proposed solution via a market and research analysis of behavioral change-based systems for energy efficiency applications. Also, various factors impacting the commercialization of the final product are investigated before providing recommended actions to ensure its potential marketability via conducting a Go/No-Go evaluation. In conclusion, the proposed solution is designed at a low cost and can save up to 28%-68% of the consumed energy, which results in a Go decision to commercialize the technology. 2021 Elsevier LtdThis paper was made possible by National Priorities Research Program (NPRP) grant No. 10-0130-170288 from the Qatar National Research Fund (a member of Qatar Foundation). The statements made herein are solely the responsibility of the authors.Scopu

Scale-Score: Investigation of a Meta yet Multi-level Label to Support Nutritious and Sustainable Food Choices When Online Grocery Shopping

Food consumption is one of the biggest contributors to climate change. However, online grocery shoppers often lack the time, motivation, or knowledge to contemplate a food's environmental impact. At the same time, they are concerned with their own well-being. To empower grocery shoppers in making nutritionally and environmentally informed decisions, we investigate the efficacy of the Scale-Score, a label combining nutritional and environmental information to highlight a product's benefit to both the consumer's and the planet's health, without obscuring either information. We conducted an online survey to understand user needs and requirements regarding a joint food label, we developed an open-source mock online grocery environment, and assessed label efficacy. We find that the Scale-Score supports nutritious purchases, yet needs improving regarding sustainability support. Our research shows first insights into design considerations and performance of a combined yet disjoint food label, potentially altering the label design space.Comment: Work in progress. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:2309.0323