Distributed video coding for wireless video sensor networks: a review of the state-of-the-art architectures

Distributed video coding (DVC) is a relatively new video coding architecture originated from two fundamental theorems namely, Slepian–Wolf and Wyner–Ziv. Recent research developments have made DVC attractive for applications in the emerging domain of wireless video sensor networks (WVSNs). This paper reviews the state-of-the-art DVC architectures with a focus on understanding their opportunities and gaps in addressing the operational requirements and application needs of WVSNs

REGION-BASED ADAPTIVE DISTRIBUTED VIDEO CODING CODEC

The recently developed Distributed Video Coding (DVC) is typically suitable for the applications where the conventional video coding is not feasible because of its inherent high-complexity encoding. Examples include video surveillance usmg wireless/wired video sensor network and applications using mobile cameras etc. With DVC, the complexity is shifted from the encoder to the decoder. The practical application of DVC is referred to as Wyner-Ziv video coding (WZ) where an estimate of the original frame called "side information" is generated using motion compensation at the decoder. The compression is achieved by sending only that extra information that is needed to correct this estimation. An error-correcting code is used with the assumption that the estimate is a noisy version of the original frame and the rate needed is certain amount of the parity bits. The side information is assumed to have become available at the decoder through a virtual channel. Due to the limitation of compensation method, the predicted frame, or the side information, is expected to have varying degrees of success. These limitations stem from locationspecific non-stationary estimation noise. In order to avoid these, the conventional video coders, like MPEG, make use of frame partitioning to allocate optimum coder for each partition and hence achieve better rate-distortion performance. The same, however, has not been used in DVC as it increases the encoder complexity. This work proposes partitioning the considered frame into many coding units (region) where each unit is encoded differently. This partitioning is, however, done at the decoder while generating the side-information and the region map is sent over to encoder at very little rate penalty. The partitioning allows allocation of appropriate DVC coding parameters (virtual channel, rate, and quantizer) to each region. The resulting regions map is compressed by employing quadtree algorithm and communicated to the encoder via the feedback channel. The rate control in DVC is performed by channel coding techniques (turbo codes, LDPC, etc.). The performance of the channel code depends heavily on the accuracy of virtual channel model that models estimation error for each region. In this work, a turbo code has been used and an adaptive WZ DVC is designed both in transform domain and in pixel domain. The transform domain WZ video coding (TDWZ) has distinct superior performance as compared to the normal Pixel Domain Wyner-Ziv (PDWZ), since it exploits the ' spatial redundancy during the encoding. The performance evaluations show that the proposed system is superior to the existing distributed video coding solutions. Although the, proposed system requires extra bits representing the "regions map" to be transmitted, fuut still the rate gain is noticeable and it outperforms the state-of-the-art frame based DVC by 0.6-1.9 dB. The feedback channel (FC) has the role to adapt the bit rate to the changing ' statistics between the side infonmation and the frame to be encoded. In the unidirectional scenario, the encoder must perform the rate control. To correctly estimate the rate, the encoder must calculate typical side information. However, the rate cannot be exactly calculated at the encoder, instead it can only be estimated. This work also prbposes a feedback-free region-based adaptive DVC solution in pixel domain based on machine learning approach to estimate the side information. Although the performance evaluations show rate-penalty but it is acceptable considering the simplicity of the proposed algorithm. vii

Improved rate-adaptive codes for distributed video coding

The research work is partially funded by the STEPS Malta.This scholarship is partly financed by the European Union - European Social Fund (ESF 1.25).Distributed Video Coding (DVC) is a coding paradigm which shifts the major computational intensive tasks from the encoder to the decoder. Temporal correlation is exploited at the decoder by predicting the Wyner-Ziv (WZ) frames from the adjacent key frames. Compression is then achieved by transmitting just the parity information required to correct the predicted frame and recover the original frame. This paper proposes an algorithm which identifies most of the unreliable bits in the predicted bit planes, by considering the discrepancies in the previously decoded bit plane. The design of the used Low Density Parity Check (LDPC) codes is then biased to provide better protection to the unreliable bits. Simulation results show that, for the same target quality, the proposed scheme can reduce the WZ bit rates by up to 7% compared to traditional schemes.peer-reviewe

Modified distribution of correlation noise for improved Wyner-Ziv video coding performance

This research work was partially funded by the Strategic Educational Pathways Scholarship Scheme (STEPS-Malta) and by European Union - European Social Fund (ESF 1.25).Despite theorems predicting that Distributed Video Coding can achieve the same performance as traditional predictive video coding schemes, the coding efficiency of practical architectures is still far from these bounds. This is attributed to the poor Side Information (SI) estimated at the decoder and to the inability of the channel codes to recover the source at the Slepian-Wolf (SW) limits. This paper tackles the latter issue by recovering the SI bit-planes starting from the most unreliable bit of each coefficient. Most of the mismatch in SI is thus accumulated within the first decoded bit-planes, leaving the last bit-planes with very few or no mismatch. Low-Density Parity-Check Accumulate (LDPCA) codes can then benefit from such compact distribution of correlation noise since they offer a smaller percentage error, from the SW bounds, when mismatch is accumulated in few higher entropy bit-planes. Furthermore, with this setup, most of the last bit-planes can be recovered very effectively using just 8-bit or 16-bit Cyclic Redundancy Codes. Experimental results show that the proposed scheme can reduce the Wyner-Ziv bit-rates by up to 21% compared to the DISCOVER codec.peer-reviewe

Research and developments of distributed video coding

This thesis was submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy and awarded by Brunel University.The recent developed Distributed Video Coding (DVC) is typically suitable for the applications such as wireless/wired video sensor network, mobile camera etc. where the traditional video coding standard is not feasible due to the constrained computation at the encoder. With DVC, the computational burden is moved from encoder to decoder. The compression efficiency is achieved via joint decoding at the decoder. The practical application of DVC is referred to Wyner-Ziv video coding (WZ) where the side information is available at the decoder to perform joint decoding. This join decoding inevitably causes a very complex decoder. In current WZ video coding issues, many of them emphasise how to improve the system coding performance but neglect the huge complexity caused at the decoder. The complexity of the decoder has direct influence to the system output. The beginning period of this research targets to optimise the decoder in pixel domain WZ video coding (PDWZ), while still achieves similar compression performance. More specifically, four issues are raised to optimise the input block size, the side information generation, the side information refinement process and the feedback channel respectively. The transform domain WZ video coding (TDWZ) has distinct superior performance to the normal PDWZ due to the exploitation in spatial direction during the encoding. However, since there is no motion estimation at the encoder in WZ video coding, the temporal correlation is not exploited at all at the encoder in all current WZ video coding issues. In the middle period of this research, the 3D DCT is adopted in the TDWZ to remove redundancy in both spatial and temporal direction thus to provide even higher coding performance. In the next step of this research, the performance of transform domain Distributed Multiview Video Coding (DMVC) is also investigated. Particularly, three types transform domain DMVC frameworks which are transform domain DMVC using TDWZ based 2D DCT, transform domain DMVC using TDWZ based on 3D DCT and transform domain residual DMVC using TDWZ based on 3D DCT are investigated respectively. One of the important applications of WZ coding principle is error-resilience. There have been several attempts to apply WZ error-resilient coding for current video coding standard e.g. H.264/AVC or MEPG 2. The final stage of this research is the design of WZ error-resilient scheme for wavelet based video codec. To balance the trade-off between error resilience ability and bandwidth consumption, the proposed scheme emphasises the protection of the Region of Interest (ROI) area. The efficiency of bandwidth utilisation is achieved by mutual efforts of WZ coding and sacrificing the quality of unimportant area. In summary, this research work contributed to achieves several advances in WZ video coding. First of all, it is targeting to build an efficient PDWZ with optimised decoder. Secondly, it aims to build an advanced TDWZ based on 3D DCT, which then is applied into multiview video coding to realise advanced transform domain DMVC. Finally, it aims to design an efficient error-resilient scheme for wavelet video codec, with which the trade-off between bandwidth consumption and error-resilience can be better balanced

TRANSFORM DOMAIN SLICE BASED DISTRIBUTED VIDEO CODING

Distributed video coding depends heavily on the virtual channel model. Due to the limitations of the side information estimation one stationary model does not properly describe the virtual channel. In this work the correlation noise is modelled per slice to obtain location-specific correlation noise model. The resulting delay from the lengthy Slepian-Wolf (SW) codec input is also reduced by reducing the length of SW codec input. The proposed solution does not impose any extra complexity, it utilizes the existing resources. The results presented here support the proposed algorithm

REGION-BASED ADAPTIVE DISTRIBUTED VIDEO CODING CODEC

The recently developed Distributed Video Coding (DVC) is typically suitable for the applications where the conventional video coding is not feasible because of its inherent high-complexity encoding. Examples include video surveillance usmg wireless/wired video sensor network and applications using mobile cameras etc. With DVC, the complexity is shifted from the encoder to the decoder. The practical application of DVC is referred to as Wyner-Ziv video coding (WZ) where an estimate of the original frame called "side information" is generated using motion compensation at the decoder. The compression is achieved by sending only that extra information that is needed to correct this estimation. An error-correcting code is used with the assumption that the estimate is a noisy version of the original frame and the rate needed is certain amount of the parity bits. The side information is assumed to have become available at the decoder through a virtual channel. Due to the limitation of compensation method, the predicted frame, or the side information, is expected to have varying degrees of success. These limitations stem from locationspecific non-stationary estimation noise. In order to avoid these, the conventional video coders, like MPEG, make use of frame partitioning to allocate optimum coder for each partition and hence achieve better rate-distortion performance. The same, however, has not been used in DVC as it increases the encoder complexity. This work proposes partitioning the considered frame into many coding units (region) where each unit is encoded differently. This partitioning is, however, done at the decoder while generating the side-information and the region map is sent over to encoder at very little rate penalty. The partitioning allows allocation of appropriate DVC coding parameters (virtual channel, rate, and quantizer) to each region. The resulting regions map is compressed by employing quadtree algorithm and communicated to the encoder via the feedback channel. The rate control in DVC is performed by channel coding techniques (turbo codes, LDPC, etc.). The performance of the channel code depends heavily on the accuracy of virtual channel model that models estimation error for each region. In this work, a turbo code has been used and an adaptive WZ DVC is designed both in transform domain and in pixel domain. The transform domain WZ video coding (TDWZ) has distinct superior performance as compared to the normal Pixel Domain Wyner-Ziv (PDWZ), since it exploits the ' spatial redundancy during the encoding. The performance evaluations show that the proposed system is superior to the existing distributed video coding solutions. Although the, proposed system requires extra bits representing the "regions map" to be transmitted, fuut still the rate gain is noticeable and it outperforms the state-of-the-art frame based DVC by 0.6-1.9 dB. The feedback channel (FC) has the role to adapt the bit rate to the changing ' statistics between the side infonmation and the frame to be encoded. In the unidirectional scenario, the encoder must perform the rate control. To correctly estimate the rate, the encoder must calculate typical side information. However, the rate cannot be exactly calculated at the encoder, instead it can only be estimated. This work also prbposes a feedback-free region-based adaptive DVC solution in pixel domain based on machine learning approach to estimate the side information. Although the performance evaluations show rate-penalty but it is acceptable considering the simplicity of the proposed algorithm. vii

Distributed Source Coding Techniques for Lossless Compression of Hyperspectral Images

This paper deals with the application of distributed source coding (DSC) theory to remote sensing image compression. Although DSC exhibits a significant potential in many application fields, up till now the results obtained on real signals fall short of the theoretical bounds, and often impose additional system-level constraints. The objective of this paper is to assess the potential of DSC for lossless image compression carried out onboard a remote platform. We first provide a brief overview of DSC of correlated information sources. We then focus on onboard lossless image compression, and apply DSC techniques in order to reduce the complexity of the onboard encoder, at the expense of the decoder's, by exploiting the correlation of different bands of a hyperspectral dataset. Specifically, we propose two different compression schemes, one based on powerful binary error-correcting codes employed as source codes, and one based on simpler multilevel coset codes. The performance of both schemes is evaluated on a few AVIRIS scenes, and is compared with other state-of-the-art 2D and 3D coders. Both schemes turn out to achieve competitive compression performance, and one of them also has reduced complexity. Based on these results, we highlight the main issues that are still to be solved to further improve the performance of DSC-based remote sensing systems

Improving the Rate-Distortion Performance in Distributed Video Coding

Distributed video coding is a coding paradigm, which allows encoding of video frames at a complexity that is substantially lower than that in conventional video coding schemes. This feature makes it suitable for some emerging applications such as wireless surveillance video and mobile camera phones. In distributed video coding, a subset of frames in the video sequence, known as the key frames, are encoded using a conventional intra-frame encoder, such as H264/AVC in the intra mode, and then transmitted to the decoder. The remaining frames, known as the Wyner-Ziv frames, are encoded based on the Wyner-Ziv principle by using the channel codes, such as LDPC codes. In the transform-domain distributed video coding, each Wyner-Ziv frame undergoes a 4x4 block DCT transform and the resulting DCT coefficients are grouped into DCT bands. The bitplaines corresponding to each DCT band are encoded by a channel encoder, for example an LDPCA encoder, one after another. The resulting error-correcting bits are retained in a buffer at the encoder and transmitted incrementally as needed by the decoder. At the decoder, the key frames are first decoded. The decoded key frames are then used to generate a side information frame as an initial estimate of the corresponding Wyner-Ziv frame, usually by employing an interpolation method. The difference between the DCT band in the side information frame and the corresponding one in the Wyner-Ziv frame, referred to as the correlation noise, is often modeled by Laplacian distribution. A soft-input information for each bit in the bitplane is obtained using this correlation noise model and the corresponding DCT band of the side information frame. The channel decoder then uses this soft-input information along with some error-correcting bits sent by the encoder to decode the bitplanes of each DCT band in each of the Wyner-Ziv frames. Hence, an accurate estimation of the correlation noise model parameter(s) and generation of high-quality side information are required for reliable soft-input information for the bitplanes in the decoder, which in turn leads to a more efficient decoding. Consequently, less error-correcting bits need to be transmitted from the encoder to the decoder to decode the bitplanes, leading to a better compression efficiency and rate-distortion performance. The correlation noise is not stationary and its statistics vary within each Wyner-Ziv frame and within its corresponding DCT bands. Hence, it is difficult to find an accurate model for the correlation noise and estimate its parameters precisely at the decoder. Moreover, in existing schemes the parameters of the correlation noise for each DCT band are estimated before the decoder starts to decode the bitplanes of that DCT band and they are not modified and kept unchanged during decoding process of the bitplanes. Another problem of concern is that, since side information frame is generated in the decoder using the temporal interpolation between the previously decoded frames, the quality of the side information frames is generally poor when the motions between the frames are non-linear. Hence, generating a high-quality side information is a challenging problem. This thesis is concerned with the study of accurate estimation of correlation noise model parameters and increasing in the quality of the side information from the standpoint of improving the rate-distortion performance in distributed video coding. A new scheme is proposed for the estimation of the correlation noise parameters wherein the decoder decodes simultaneously all the bitplanes of a DCT band in a Wyner-Ziv frame and then refines the parameters of the correlation noise model of the band in an iterative manner. This process is carried out on an augmented factor graph using a new recursive message passing algorithm, with the side information generated and kept unchanged during the decoding of the Wyner-Ziv frame. Extensive simulations are carried out showing that the proposed decoder leads to an improved rate-distortion performance in comparison to the original DISCOVER codec and in another DVC codec employing side information frame refinement, particularly for video sequences with high motion content. In the second part of this work, a new algorithm for the generation of the side information is proposed to refine the initial side information frame using the additional information obtained after decoding the previous DCT bands of a Wyner-Ziv frame. The simulations are carried out demonstrating that the proposed algorithm provides a performance superior to that of schemes employing the other side information refinement mechanisms. Finally, it is shown that incorporating the proposed algorithm for refining the side information into the decoder proposed in the first part of the thesis leads to a further improvement in the rate-distortion performance of the DVC codec