Automated classification of three-dimensional reconstructions of coral reefs using convolutional neural networks

© The Author(s), 2020. This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License. The definitive version was published in Hopkinson, B. M., King, A. C., Owen, D. P., Johnson-Roberson, M., Long, M. H., & Bhandarkar, S. M. Automated classification of three-dimensional reconstructions of coral reefs using convolutional neural networks. PLoS One, 15(3), (2020): e0230671, doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0230671.Coral reefs are biologically diverse and structurally complex ecosystems, which have been severally affected by human actions. Consequently, there is a need for rapid ecological assessment of coral reefs, but current approaches require time consuming manual analysis, either during a dive survey or on images collected during a survey. Reef structural complexity is essential for ecological function but is challenging to measure and often relegated to simple metrics such as rugosity. Recent advances in computer vision and machine learning offer the potential to alleviate some of these limitations. We developed an approach to automatically classify 3D reconstructions of reef sections and assessed the accuracy of this approach. 3D reconstructions of reef sections were generated using commercial Structure-from-Motion software with images extracted from video surveys. To generate a 3D classified map, locations on the 3D reconstruction were mapped back into the original images to extract multiple views of the location. Several approaches were tested to merge information from multiple views of a point into a single classification, all of which used convolutional neural networks to classify or extract features from the images, but differ in the strategy employed for merging information. Approaches to merging information entailed voting, probability averaging, and a learned neural-network layer. All approaches performed similarly achieving overall classification accuracies of ~96% and >90% accuracy on most classes. With this high classification accuracy, these approaches are suitable for many ecological applications.This study was funded by grants from the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation (BMH, BR2014-049; https://sloan.org), and the National Science Foundation (MHL, OCE-1657727; https://www.nsf.gov). The funders had no role in the study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript

Overview of ImageCLEFcoral 2019 task

Understanding the composition of species in ecosystems on a large scale is key to developing effective solutions for marine conservation, hence there is a need to classify imagery automatically and rapidly. In 2019, ImageCLEF proposed for the first time the ImageCLEFcoral task. The task requires participants to automatically annotate and localize benthic substrate (such as hard coral, soft coral, algae and sponge) in a collection of images originating from a growing, large-scale dataset from coral reefs around the world as part of monitoring programmes. In its first edition, five groups participated submitting 20 runs using a variety of machine learning and deep learning approaches. Best runs achieved 0.24 in the annotation and localisation subtask and 0.04 on the pixel-wise parsing subtask in terms of MAP 0.5 IoU scores which measures the Mean Average Precision (MAP) when using the performance measure of Intersection over Union (IoU) bigger to 0.5 of the ground truth

Semantic Segmentation for Real-World Applications

En visión por computador, la comprensión de escenas tiene como objetivo extraer información útil de una escena a partir de datos de sensores. Por ejemplo, puede clasificar toda la imagen en una categoría particular o identificar elementos importantes dentro de ella. En este contexto general, la segmentación semántica proporciona una etiqueta semántica a cada elemento de los datos sin procesar, por ejemplo, a todos los píxeles de la imagen o, a todos los puntos de la nube de puntos. Esta información es esencial para muchas aplicaciones de visión por computador, como conducción, aplicaciones médicas o robóticas. Proporciona a los ordenadores una comprensión sobre el entorno que es necesaria para tomar decisiones autónomas.El estado del arte actual de la segmentación semántica está liderado por métodos de aprendizaje profundo supervisados. Sin embargo, las condiciones del mundo real presentan varias restricciones para la aplicación de estos modelos de segmentación semántica. Esta tesis aborda varios de estos desafíos: 1) la cantidad limitada de datos etiquetados disponibles para entrenar modelos de aprendizaje profundo, 2) las restricciones de tiempo y computación presentes en aplicaciones en tiempo real y/o en sistemas con poder computacional limitado, y 3) la capacidad de realizar una segmentación semántica cuando se trata de sensores distintos de la cámara RGB estándar.Las aportaciones principales en esta tesis son las siguientes:1. Un método nuevo para abordar el problema de los datos anotados limitados para entrenar modelos de segmentación semántica a partir de anotaciones dispersas. Los modelos de aprendizaje profundo totalmente supervisados lideran el estado del arte, pero mostramos cómo entrenarlos usando solo unos pocos píxeles etiquetados. Nuestro enfoque obtiene un rendimiento similar al de los modelos entrenados con imágenescompletamente etiquetadas. Demostramos la relevancia de esta técnica en escenarios de monitorización ambiental y en dominios más generales.2. También tratando con datos de entrenamiento limitados, proponemos un método nuevo para segmentación semántica semi-supervisada, es decir, cuando solo hay una pequeña cantidad de imágenes completamente etiquetadas y un gran conjunto de datos sin etiquetar. La principal novedad de nuestro método se basa en el aprendizaje por contraste. Demostramos cómo el aprendizaje por contraste se puede aplicar a la tarea de segmentación semántica y mostramos sus ventajas, especialmente cuando la disponibilidad de datos etiquetados es limitada logrando un nuevo estado del arte.3. Nuevos modelos de segmentación semántica de imágenes eficientes. Desarrollamos modelos de segmentación semántica que son eficientes tanto en tiempo de ejecución, requisitos de memoria y requisitos de cálculo. Algunos de nuestros modelos pueden ejecutarse en CPU a altas velocidades con alta precisión. Esto es muy importante para configuraciones y aplicaciones reales, ya que las GPU de gama alta nosiempre están disponibles.4. Nuevos métodos de segmentación semántica con sensores no RGB. Proponemos un método para la segmentación de nubes de puntos LiDAR que combina operaciones de aprendizaje eficientes tanto en 2D como en 3D. Logra un rendimiento de segmentación excepcional a velocidades realmente rápidas. También mostramos cómo mejorar la robustez de estos modelos al abordar el problema de sobreajuste y adaptaciónde dominio. Además, mostramos el primer trabajo de segmentación semántica con cámaras de eventos, haciendo frente a la falta de datos etiquetados.Estas contribuciones aportan avances significativos en el campo de la segmentación semántica para aplicaciones del mundo real. Para una mayor contribución a la comunidad cientfíica, hemos liberado la implementación de todas las soluciones propuestas.----------------------------------------In computer vision, scene understanding aims at extracting useful information of a scene from raw sensor data. For instance, it can classify the whole image into a particular category (i.e. kitchen or living room) or identify important elements within it (i.e., bottles, cups on a table or surfaces). In this general context, semantic segmentation provides a semantic label to every single element of the raw data, e.g., to all image pixels or to all point cloud points.This information is essential for many applications relying on computer vision, such as AR, driving, medical or robotic applications. It provides computers with understanding about the environment needed to make autonomous decisions, or detailed information to people interacting with the intelligent systems. The current state of the art for semantic segmentation is led by supervised deep learning methods.However, real-world scenarios and conditions introduce several challenges and restrictions for the application of these semantic segmentation models. This thesis tackles several of these challenges, namely, 1) the limited amount of labeled data available for training deep learning models, 2) the time and computation restrictions present in real time applications and/or in systems with limited computational power, such as a mobile phone or an IoT node, and 3) the ability to perform semantic segmentation when dealing with sensors other than the standard RGB camera.The general contributions presented in this thesis are following:A novel approach to address the problem of limited annotated data to train semantic segmentation models from sparse annotations. Fully supervised deep learning models are leading the state-of-the-art, but we show how to train them by only using a few sparsely labeled pixels in the training images. Our approach obtains similar performance than models trained with fully-labeled images. We demonstrate the relevance of this technique in environmental monitoring scenarios, where it is very common to have sparse image labels provided by human experts, as well as in more general domains. Also dealing with limited training data, we propose a novel method for semi-supervised semantic segmentation, i.e., when there is only a small number of fully labeled images and a large set of unlabeled data. We demonstrate how contrastive learning can be applied to the semantic segmentation task and show its advantages, especially when the availability of labeled data is limited. Our approach improves state-of-the-art results, showing the potential of contrastive learning in this task. Learning from unlabeled data opens great opportunities for real-world scenarios since it is an economical solution. Novel efficient image semantic segmentation models. We develop semantic segmentation models that are efficient both in execution time, memory requirements, and computation requirements. Some of our models able to run in CPU at high speed rates with high accuracy. This is very important for real set-ups and applications since high-end GPUs are not always available. Building models that consume fewer resources, memory and time, would increase the range of applications that can benefit from them. Novel methods for semantic segmentation with non-RGB sensors.We propose a novel method for LiDAR point cloud segmentation that combines efficient learning operations both in 2D and 3D. It surpasses state-of-the-art segmentation performance at really fast rates. We also show how to improve the robustness of these models tackling the overfitting and domain adaptation problem. Besides, we show the first work for semantic segmentation with event-based cameras, coping with the lack of labeled data. To increase the impact of this contributions and ease their application in real-world settings, we have made available an open-source implementation of all proposed solutions to the scientific community.<br /

Automating the Boring Stuff: A Deep Learning and Computer Vision Workflow for Coral Reef Habitat Mapping

High-resolution underwater imagery provides a detailed view of coral reefs and facilitates insight into important ecological metrics concerning their health. In recent years, anthropogenic stressors, including those related to climate change, have altered the community composition of coral reef habitats around the world. Currently the most common method of quantifying the composition of these communities is through benthic quadrat surveys and image analysis. This requires manual annotation of images that is a time-consuming task that does not scale well for large studies. Patch-based image classification using Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) can automate this task and provide sparse labels, but they remain computationally inefficient. This work extended the idea of automatic image annotation by using Fully Convolutional Networks (FCNs) to provide dense labels through semantic segmentation. Presented here is an improved version of Multilevel Superpixel Segmentation (MSS), an existing algorithm that repurposes the sparse labels provided to an image by automatically converting them into the dense labels necessary for training a FCN. This improved implementation—Fast-MSS—is demonstrated to perform considerably faster than the original without sacrificing accuracy. To showcase the applicability to benthic ecologists, this algorithm was independently validated by converting the sparse labels provided with the Moorea Labeled Coral (MLC) dataset into dense labels using Fast-MSS. FCNs were then trained and evaluated by comparing their predictions on the test images with the corresponding ground-truth sparse labels, setting the baseline scores for the task of semantic segmentation. Lastly, this study outlined a workflow using the methods previously described in combination with Structure-from-Motion (SfM) photogrammetry to classify the individual elements that make up a 3-D reconstructed model to their respective semantic groups. The contributions of this thesis help move the field of benthic ecology towards more efficient monitoring of coral reefs through entirely automated processes by making it easier to compute the changes in community composition using 2-D benthic habitat images and 3-D models

ImageCLEFcoral task: Coral reef image annotation and localisation

This paper presents an overview of the ImageCLEFcoral 2022 task that was organised as part of the Conference and Labs of the Evaluation Forum - CLEF Labs 2022. The task addresses the problem of automatically segmenting and labelling a collection of underwater images that can be used in combination to create 3D models for the monitoring of coral reefs. The training data set contains images from four Worldwide geographical locations and the test data set contains images from only one of these locations. Therefore the participants could train on a subset of geographically similar images, which has been shown in previous editions of this task to be beneficial to performance. These images are grouped into image sets that can be used to create a 3D model of the environment using photogrammetry. The training dataset contained 1,374 images and 31,517 polygon objects. The test dataset comprises 200 images and 6,319 polygon objects. 6 teams registered to the ImageCLEFcoral 2022 task, of which 2 teams submitted 11 runs. Participants’ entries showed that although automatic annotation of benthic substrates was possible, improving on the baselines set in previous years will be difficult

Developing deep learning methods for aquaculture applications

Alzayat Saleh developed a computer vision framework that can aid aquaculture experts in analyzing fish habitats. In particular, he developed a labelling efficient method of training a CNN-based fish-detector and also developed a model that estimates the fish weight directly from its image

Internet of Underwater Things and Big Marine Data Analytics -- A Comprehensive Survey

The Internet of Underwater Things (IoUT) is an emerging communication ecosystem developed for connecting underwater objects in maritime and underwater environments. The IoUT technology is intricately linked with intelligent boats and ships, smart shores and oceans, automatic marine transportations, positioning and navigation, underwater exploration, disaster prediction and prevention, as well as with intelligent monitoring and security. The IoUT has an influence at various scales ranging from a small scientific observatory, to a midsized harbor, and to covering global oceanic trade. The network architecture of IoUT is intrinsically heterogeneous and should be sufficiently resilient to operate in harsh environments. This creates major challenges in terms of underwater communications, whilst relying on limited energy resources. Additionally, the volume, velocity, and variety of data produced by sensors, hydrophones, and cameras in IoUT is enormous, giving rise to the concept of Big Marine Data (BMD), which has its own processing challenges. Hence, conventional data processing techniques will falter, and bespoke Machine Learning (ML) solutions have to be employed for automatically learning the specific BMD behavior and features facilitating knowledge extraction and decision support. The motivation of this paper is to comprehensively survey the IoUT, BMD, and their synthesis. It also aims for exploring the nexus of BMD with ML. We set out from underwater data collection and then discuss the family of IoUT data communication techniques with an emphasis on the state-of-the-art research challenges. We then review the suite of ML solutions suitable for BMD handling and analytics. We treat the subject deductively from an educational perspective, critically appraising the material surveyed.Comment: 54 pages, 11 figures, 19 tables, IEEE Communications Surveys & Tutorials, peer-reviewed academic journa

Deep learning for internet of underwater things and ocean data analytics

The Internet of Underwater Things (IoUT) is an emerging technological ecosystem developed for connecting objects in maritime and underwater environments. IoUT technologies are empowered by an extreme number of deployed sensors and actuators. In this thesis, multiple IoUT sensory data are augmented with machine intelligence for forecasting purposes

Image Labels Are All You Need for Coarse Seagrass Segmentation

Seagrass meadows serve as critical carbon sinks, but estimating the amount of carbon they store requires knowledge of the seagrass species present. Underwater and surface vehicles equipped with machine learning algorithms can help to accurately estimate the composition and extent of seagrass meadows at scale. However, previous approaches for seagrass detection and classification have required supervision from patch-level labels. In this paper, we reframe seagrass classification as a weakly supervised coarse segmentation problem where image-level labels are used during training (25 times fewer labels compared to patch-level labeling) and patch-level outputs are obtained at inference time. To this end, we introduce SeaFeats, an architecture that uses unsupervised contrastive pre-training and feature similarity, and SeaCLIP, a model that showcases the effectiveness of large language models as a supervisory signal in domain-specific applications. We demonstrate that an ensemble of SeaFeats and SeaCLIP leads to highly robust performance. Our method outperforms previous approaches that require patch-level labels on the multi-species 'DeepSeagrass' dataset by 6.8% (absolute) for the class-weighted F1 score, and by 12.1% (absolute) for the seagrass presence/absence F1 score on the 'Global Wetlands' dataset. We also present two case studies for real-world deployment: outlier detection on the Global Wetlands dataset, and application of our method on imagery collected by the FloatyBoat autonomous surface vehicle.Comment: 10 pages, 4 figures, additional 3 pages of supplementary materia