38 research outputs found
Bridging the gap between general probabilistic theories and the device-independent framework for nonlocality and contextuality
Characterizing quantum correlations in terms of information-theoretic
principles is a popular chapter of quantum foundations. Traditionally, the
principles adopted for this scope have been expressed in terms of conditional
probability distributions, specifying the probability that a black box produces
a certain output upon receiving a certain input. This framework is known as
"device-independent". Another major chapter of quantum foundations is the
information-theoretic characterization of quantum theory, with its sets of
states and measurements, and with its allowed dynamics. The different
frameworks adopted for this scope are known under the umbrella term "general
probabilistic theories". With only a few exceptions, the two programmes on
characterizing quantum correlations and characterizing quantum theory have so
far proceeded on separate tracks, each one developing its own methods and its
own agenda. This paper aims at bridging the gap, by comparing the two
frameworks and illustrating how the two programmes can benefit each other.Comment: 61 pages, no figures, published versio
Bell non-locality and Kochen-Specker contextuality: How are they connected?
Bell non-locality and Kochen-Specker (KS) contextuality are logically
independent concepts, fuel different protocols with quantum vs classical
advantage, and have distinct classical simulation costs. A natural question is
what are the relations between these concepts, advantages, and costs. To
address this question, it is useful to have a map that captures all the
connections between Bell non-locality and KS contextuality in quantum theory.
The aim of this work is to introduce such a map. After defining the
theory-independent notions of Bell non-locality and KS contextuality for ideal
measurements, we show that, in quantum theory, due to Neumark's dilation
theorem, every matrix of quantum Bell non-local correlations can be mapped to
an identical matrix of KS contextual correlations produced in a scenario with
identical relations of compatibility but where measurements are ideal and no
space-like separation is required. A more difficult problem is identifying
connections in the opposite direction. We show that there are "one-to-one" and
partial connections between KS contextual correlations and Bell non-local
correlations for some KS contextuality scenarios, but not for all of them.
However, there is also a method that transforms any matrix of KS contextual
correlations for quantum systems of dimension into a matrix of Bell
non-local correlations between two quantum subsystems each of them of dimension
. We collect all these connections in map and list some problems which can
benefit from this map.Comment: 13 pages, 2 figure
Almost Quantum Correlations are Inconsistent with Specker's Principle
Ernst Specker considered a particular feature of quantum theory to be
especially fundamental, namely that pairwise joint measurability of sharp
measurements implies their global joint measurability
(https://vimeo.com/52923835). To date, Specker's principle seemed incapable of
singling out quantum theory from the space of all general probabilistic
theories. In particular, its well-known consequence for experimental
statistics, the principle of consistent exclusivity, does not rule out the set
of correlations known as almost quantum, which is strictly larger than the set
of quantum correlations. Here we show that, contrary to the popular belief,
Specker's principle cannot be satisfied in any theory that yields almost
quantum correlations.Comment: 17 pages + appendix. 5 colour figures. Comments welcom
Quantum correlations from simple assumptions
We address the problem of deriving the set of quantum correlations for every
Bell and Kochen-Specker (KS) contextuality scenario from simple assumptions. We
show that the correlations that are possible according to quantum theory are
equal to those possible under the assumptions that there is a nonempty set of
correlations for every KS scenario and a statistically independent realization
of any two KS experiments. The proof uses tools of the graph-theoretic approach
to correlations and deals with Bell nonlocality and KS contextuality in a
unified way.Comment: 15 pages, 7 figure
Necessary and sufficient condition for contextuality from incompatibility
Measurement incompatibility is the most basic resource that distinguishes
quantum from classical physics. Contextuality is the critical resource behind
the power of some models of quantum computation and is also a necessary
ingredient for many applications in quantum information. A fundamental problem
is thus identifying when incompatibility produces contextuality. Here, we show
that, given a structure of incompatibility characterized by a graph in which
nonadjacent vertices represent incompatible ideal measurements, the necessary
and sufficient condition for the existence of a quantum realization producing
contextuality is that this graph contains induced cycles of size larger than
three.Comment: 7 pages, 1 figur
Quantum Apices: Identifying Limits of Entanglement, Nonlocality, & Contextuality
This work develops analytic methods to quantitatively demarcate quantum
reality from its subset of classical phenomenon, as well as from the superset
of general probabilistic theories. Regarding quantum nonlocality, we discuss
how to determine the quantum limit of Bell-type linear inequalities. In
contrast to semidefinite programming approaches, our method allows for the
consideration of inequalities with abstract weights, by means of leveraging the
Hermiticity of quantum states. Recognizing that classical correlations
correspond to measurements made on separable states, we also introduce a
practical method for obtaining sufficient separability criteria. We
specifically vet the candidacy of driven and undriven superradiance as schema
for entanglement generation. We conclude by reviewing current approaches to
quantum contextuality, emphasizing the operational distinction between nonlocal
and contextual quantum statistics. We utilize our abstractly-weighted linear
quantum bounds to explicitly demonstrate a set of conditional probability
distributions which are simultaneously compatible with quantum contextuality
while being incompatible with quantum nonlocality. It is noted that this novel
statistical regime implies an experimentally-testable target for the Consistent
Histories theory of quantum gravity.Comment: Doctoral Thesis for the University of Connecticu
General Bayesian theories and the emergence of the exclusivity principle
We construct a general Bayesian framework that can be used to organize
beliefs and to update them when new information becomes available. The
framework includes classical, quantum, and other alternative models of Bayesian
reasoning that may arise in future physical theories. It is only based on the
rule of conditional probabilities and the requirement that the agent's beliefs
are consistent across time. From these requirements, we show that ideal
experiments within every Bayesian theory must satisfy the exclusivity
principle, which is a key to explain quantum correlations. As a consequence,
the limits to the strength of correlations set by the exclusivity principle can
be interpreted as the ultimate limits set by Bayesian consistency. It is an
open question whether Bayesian reasoning alone is sufficient to recover all of
quantum theory.Comment: 4+ 4 pages, no figure