9,783 research outputs found
Rational Deployment of CSP Heuristics
Heuristics are crucial tools in decreasing search effort in varied fields of
AI. In order to be effective, a heuristic must be efficient to compute, as well
as provide useful information to the search algorithm. However, some well-known
heuristics which do well in reducing backtracking are so heavy that the gain of
deploying them in a search algorithm might be outweighed by their overhead.
We propose a rational metareasoning approach to decide when to deploy
heuristics, using CSP backtracking search as a case study. In particular, a
value of information approach is taken to adaptive deployment of solution-count
estimation heuristics for value ordering. Empirical results show that indeed
the proposed mechanism successfully balances the tradeoff between decreasing
backtracking and heuristic computational overhead, resulting in a significant
overall search time reduction.Comment: 7 pages, 2 figures, to appear in IJCAI-2011, http://www.ijcai.org
Recommended from our members
Experimental evaluation of preprocessing algorithms for constraint satisfaction problems
This paper presents an experimental evaluation of two orthogonal schemes for preprocessing constraint satisfaction problems (CSPs). The first of these schemes involves a class of local consistency techniques that includes directional arc consistency, directional path consistency, and adaptive consistency. The other scheme concerns the prearrangement of variables in a linear order to facilitate an efficient search. In the first series of experiments, we evaluated the effect of each of the local consistency techniques on backtracking and its common enhancement, backjumping. Surprizingly, although adaptive consistency has the best worst-case complexity bounds, we have found that it exhibits the worst performance, unless the constraint graph was very sparse. Directional arc consistency (followed by either backjumping or backtracking) and backjumping (without any pre-processing) outperformed all other techniques; moreover, the former dominated the latter in computationally intensive situations. The second series of experiments suggests that maximum cardinality and minimum width arc the best pre-ordering (i.e., static ordering) strategies, while dynamic search rearrangement is superior to all the preorderings studied
Decomposition Based Search - A theoretical and experimental evaluation
In this paper we present and evaluate a search strategy called Decomposition
Based Search (DBS) which is based on two steps: subproblem generation and
subproblem solution. The generation of subproblems is done through value
ranking and domain splitting. Subdomains are explored so as to generate,
according to the heuristic chosen, promising subproblems first.
We show that two well known search strategies, Limited Discrepancy Search
(LDS) and Iterative Broadening (IB), can be seen as special cases of DBS. First
we present a tuning of DBS that visits the same search nodes as IB, but avoids
restarts. Then we compare both theoretically and computationally DBS and LDS
using the same heuristic. We prove that DBS has a higher probability of being
successful than LDS on a comparable number of nodes, under realistic
assumptions. Experiments on a constraint satisfaction problem and an
optimization problem show that DBS is indeed very effective if compared to LDS.Comment: 16 pages, 8 figures. LIA Technical Report LIA00203, University of
Bologna, 200
Postponing Branching Decisions
Solution techniques for Constraint Satisfaction and Optimisation Problems
often make use of backtrack search methods, exploiting variable and value
ordering heuristics. In this paper, we propose and analyse a very simple method
to apply in case the value ordering heuristic produces ties: postponing the
branching decision. To this end, we group together values in a tie, branch on
this sub-domain, and defer the decision among them to lower levels of the
search tree. We show theoretically and experimentally that this simple
modification can dramatically improve the efficiency of the search strategy.
Although in practise similar methods may have been applied already, to our
knowledge, no empirical or theoretical study has been proposed in the
literature to identify when and to what extent this strategy should be used.Comment: 11 pages, 3 figure
Symmetry Breaking Constraints: Recent Results
Symmetry is an important problem in many combinatorial problems. One way of
dealing with symmetry is to add constraints that eliminate symmetric solutions.
We survey recent results in this area, focusing especially on two common and
useful cases: symmetry breaking constraints for row and column symmetry, and
symmetry breaking constraints for eliminating value symmetryComment: To appear in Proceedings of Twenty-Sixth Conference on Artificial
Intelligence (AAAI-12
- …