Refining Automatically Extracted Knowledge Bases Using Crowdsourcing

Machine-constructed knowledge bases often contain noisy and inaccurate facts. There exists significant work in developing automated algorithms for knowledge base refinement. Automated approaches improve the quality of knowledge bases but are far from perfect. In this paper, we leverage crowdsourcing to improve the quality of automatically extracted knowledge bases. As human labelling is costly, an important research challenge is how we can use limited human resources to maximize the quality improvement for a knowledge base. To address this problem, we first introduce a concept of semantic constraints that can be used to detect potential errors and do inference among candidate facts. Then, based on semantic constraints, we propose rank-based and graph-based algorithms for crowdsourced knowledge refining, which judiciously select the most beneficial candidate facts to conduct crowdsourcing and prune unnecessary questions. Our experiments show that our method improves the quality of knowledge bases significantly and outperforms state-of-the-art automatic methods under a reasonable crowdsourcing cost

Engineering Crowdsourced Stream Processing Systems

A crowdsourced stream processing system (CSP) is a system that incorporates crowdsourced tasks in the processing of a data stream. This can be seen as enabling crowdsourcing work to be applied on a sample of large-scale data at high speed, or equivalently, enabling stream processing to employ human intelligence. It also leads to a substantial expansion of the capabilities of data processing systems. Engineering a CSP system requires the combination of human and machine computation elements. From a general systems theory perspective, this means taking into account inherited as well as emerging properties from both these elements. In this paper, we position CSP systems within a broader taxonomy, outline a series of design principles and evaluation metrics, present an extensible framework for their design, and describe several design patterns. We showcase the capabilities of CSP systems by performing a case study that applies our proposed framework to the design and analysis of a real system (AIDR) that classifies social media messages during time-critical crisis events. Results show that compared to a pure stream processing system, AIDR can achieve a higher data classification accuracy, while compared to a pure crowdsourcing solution, the system makes better use of human workers by requiring much less manual work effort

Crowdsourcing for Top-K Query Processing over Uncertain Data

Querying uncertain data has become a prominent application due to the proliferation of user-generated content from social media and of data streams from sensors. When data ambiguity cannot be reduced algorithmically, crowdsourcing proves a viable approach, which consists of posting tasks to humans and harnessing their judgment for improving the confidence about data values or relationships. This paper tackles the problem of processing top- K queries over uncertain data with the help of crowdsourcing for quickly converging to the realordering of relevant results. Several offline and online approaches for addressing questions to a crowd are defined and contrasted on both synthetic and real data sets, with the aim of minimizing the crowd interactions necessary to find the realordering of the result set

On optimality of jury selection in crowdsourcing

Recent advances in crowdsourcing technologies enable computationally challenging tasks (e.g., sentiment analysis and entity resolution) to be performed by Internet workers, driven mainly by monetary incentives. A fundamental question is: how should workers be selected, so that the tasks in hand can be accomplished successfully and economically? In this paper, we study the Jury Selection Problem (JSP): Given a monetary budget, and a set of decision-making tasks (e.g., “Is Bill Gates still the CEO of Microsoft now?”), return the set of workers (called jury), such that their answers yield the highest “Jury Quality” (or JQ). Existing JSP solutions make use of the Majority Voting (MV) strategy, which uses the answer chosen by the largest number of workers. We show that MV does not yield the best solution for JSP. We further prove that among all voting strategies (including deterministic and randomized strategies), Bayesian Voting (BV) can optimally solve JSP. We then examine how to solve JSP based on BV. This is technically challenging, since computing the JQ with BV is NP-hard. We solve this problem by proposing an approximate algorithm that is computationally efficient. Our approximate JQ computation algorithm is also highly accurate, and its error is proved to be bounded within 1%. We extend our solution by considering the task owner’s “belief” (or prior) on the answers of the tasks. Experiments on synthetic and real datasets show that our new approach is consistently better than the best JSP solution known.published_or_final_versio

On Extracting Data from Tables that are Encoded using HTML

Tables are a common means to display data in human-friendly formats. Many authors have worked on proposals to extract those data back since this has many interesting applications. In this article, we summarise and compare many of the proposals to extract data from tables that are encoded using HTML and have been published between 2000 and 2018. We first present a vocabulary that homogenises the terminology used in this field; next, we use it to summarise the proposals; finally, we compare them side by side. Our analysis highlights several challenges to which no proposal provides a conclusive solution and a few more that have not been addressed sufficiently; simply put, no proposal provides a complete solution to the problem, which seems to suggest that this research field shall keep active in the near future. We have also realised that there is no consensus regarding the datasets and the methods used to evaluate the proposals, which hampers comparing the experimental results.Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad TIN2013-40848-RMinisterio de Economía y Competitividad TIN2016-75394-