An Assessment of PIER Electric Grid Research 2003-2014 White Paper

This white paper describes the circumstances in California around the turn of the 21st century that led the California Energy Commission (CEC) to direct additional Public Interest Energy Research funds to address critical electric grid issues, especially those arising from integrating high penetrations of variable renewable generation with the electric grid. It contains an assessment of the beneficial science and technology advances of the resultant portfolio of electric grid research projects administered under the direction of the CEC by a competitively selected contractor, the University of California’s California Institute for Energy and the Environment, from 2003-2014

Synchrophasors: Multilevel Assessment and Data Quality Improvement for Enhanced System Reliability

. This study presents a comprehensive framework for testing and evaluation of Phasor Measurement Units (PMUs) and synchrophasor systems under normal power system operating conditions, as well as during disturbances such as faults and transients. The proposed framework suggests a performance assessment to be conducted in three steps: (a) type testing: conducted in the synchrophasor calibration laboratory according to accepted industrial standards; (b) application testing: conducted to evaluate the performance of the PMUs under faults, transients, and other disturbances in power systems; (c) end-to-end system testing: conducted to assess the risk and quantify the impact of measurement errors on the applications of interest. The suggested calibration toolset (type testing) enables performance characterization of different design alternatives in a standalone PMU (e.g., length of phasor estimation windows, filtering windows, reporting rates, etc.). In conjunction with the standard performance requirements, this work defines new metrics for PMU performance evaluations under any static and dynamic conditions that may unfold in the grid. The new metrics offer a more realistic understanding of the overall PMU performance and help users choose the appropriate device/settings for the target applications. Furthermore, the proposed probabilistic techniques quantify the PMU accuracy to various test performance thresholds specified by corresponding IEEE standards, rather than having only the pass/fail test outcome, as well as the probability of specific failures to meet the standard requirements defined in terms of the phasor, frequency, and rate of change of frequency accuracy. Application testing analysis encompasses PMU performance evaluation under faults and other prevailing conditions, and offers a realistic assessment of the PMU measurement errors in real-world field scenarios and reveals additional performance characteristics that are crucial for the overall application evaluation. End-to-end system tests quantify the impact of synchrophasor estimation errors and their propagation from the PMU towards the end-use applications and evaluate the associated risk. In this work, extensive experimental results demonstrate the advantages of the proposed framework and its applicability is verified through two synchrophasor applications, namely: Fault Location and Modal Analysis. Finally, a data-driven technique (Principal Component Pursuit) is proposed for the correction and completion of the synchrophasor data blocks, and its application and effectiveness is validated in modal analyzes

Methodology and Tools for Field Testing of Synchrophasor Systems

The electrical power grid, as one of today’s most critical infrastructures, requires constant monitoring by operators to be aware of and react to any threats to the system’s condition. With control centers typically located far away from substations and other physical grid equipment, field measurement data forms the basis for a vast majority of control decisions in power system operation. For that reason, it is imperative to ensure the highest level of data integrity as erroneous data may lead to inappropriate control actions with potentially devastating consequences. Performance of one of the most advanced monitoring systems, the synchrophasor system, is the focus of this thesis. This research will look at testing techniques used for performance assessment of synchrophasor system performance in the field. Existing methods will be reviewed and evaluated for deficiencies in capturing system performance regarding data quality. The focus of this work will be on improving synchrophasor data quality, by introducing new testing methodology that utilizes a nested testing approach for end-to-end testing in the field using a portable test set and associated software tools. The capability of such methods and these tools to fully characterize and evaluate the performance of synchrophasor systems in the field will be validated through implementation in a large-scale testbed. The purpose of this research is to specify, develop and implement a methodology and associated tools for field-testing of synchrophasor systems. To this day, there is no dedicated standard for field-testing of synchrophasor systems. This resulted in an inability to define widely accepted procedures to detect deterioration of system performance due to poor data quality and caused communication failures, unacceptable device and subsystem accuracy, or loss of calibration. This work will demonstrate how the new approach addresses the mentioned performance assessment gap. The feasibility of implementation of the proposed test procedures will be demonstrated using different test system configurations available in a large-scale testbed. The proposed method is fully leveraging the benefits of a portable device specifically developed for field-testing, which may be used for improvement of commissioning, maintenance and troubleshooting tests for existing installations. Use Cases resulting from this work will illustrate the practical benefits of the proposed methodology and associated tools

Novel performance evaluation of information and communication technologies to enable wide area monitoring systems for enhanced transmission network operation

This thesis was submitted for the award of Doctor of Philosophy and was awarded by Brunel University London.The penetration of renewable energy sources has increased significantly in recent years due to the ongoing depletion of conventional resources and the transition to a low carbon energy system. Renewable energy sources such as wind energy are highly intermittent and unpredictable in nature, which makes the operation of the power grid more dynamic and therefore more complex. In order to operate the power system reliably under such conditions, Phasor Measurement Units (PMUs) through the use of satellite technology can offer a state-of-the-art Wide Area Monitoring System (WAMS) for improving power system monitoring, control and protection. They can improve the operation by providing highly precise and synchronised measurements near to real-time with higher frequency and accuracy. In order to achieve such objectives, a high-speed and reliable communications infrastructure is required to transfer time-critical PMU data from remote locations to the control centre. The signals measured by PMUs are transmitted across Local and Wide Area Networks, where they may encounter excessive delays. Signal delays can have a disruptive effect and make applications at best inefficient and at worse ineffective. The main research contribution of this thesis is the performance evaluation of communication infrastructures for WAMS. The evaluation begins from inside substations and continues over wide areas from substations to control centre. Through laboratory-based investigations and simulations, the performance of communications infrastructure in a typical power system substation has been analysed. In addition, the performance evaluation of WAMS communications infrastructure has been presented. In the modelling and analysis, an existing WAMS as installed on the GB transmission system has been considered. The actual PMU packets as received at the Phasor Data Concentrator (PDC) were captured for latency analysis. A novel algorithmic procedure has been developed and implemented to automate the large-scale latency calculations. Furthermore, the internal delays of PMUs have been investigated, determined and analysed. Subsequently, the WAMS has been simulated and detailed comparisons have been performed between the simulated model results and WAMS performance data captured from the actual WAMS. The validated WAMS model has been used for analysing possible future developments as well as to test newly proposed mechanisms, protocols, etc. in order to improve the communications infrastructure performance

Physics-Based and Data-Driven Analytics for Enhanced Planning and Operations in Power Systems with Deep Renewable Penetration

This dissertation is motivated by the lack of combined physics-based and data-driven framework for solving power system challenges that are introduced by the integration of new devices and new system components. As increasing number of stochastic generation, responsive loads, and dynamic measurements are involved in the planning and operations of modern power systems, utilities and system operators are in great need of new analysis framework that could combine physical models and measuring data together for solving challenging planning and operational problems. In view of the above challenges, the high-level objective of this dissertation is to develop a framework for integrating measurement data into large physical systems modeled by dynamical equations. To this end, the dissertation first identifies four critical tasks for the planning and operations of the modern power systems: the data collection and pre-processing, the system situational awareness, the decision making process, as well as the post-event analysis. The dissertation then takes one concrete application in each of these critical tasks as the example, and proposes the physics-based/data-driven approach for solving the challenging problems faced by this specific application. To this end, this dissertation focuses on solving the following specific problems using physics-based/data-driven approaches. First, for the data collection and pre-processing platform, a purely data-driven approach is proposed to detect bad metering data in the phasor measurement unit (PMU) monitoring systems, and ensure the overall PMU data quality. Second, for the situational awareness platform, a physics-based voltage stability assessment method is presented to improve the situational awareness of system voltage instabilities. Third, for the decision making platform, a combined physics-based and data-driven framework is proposed to support the decision making process of PMU-based power plant model validation. Forth, for the post-event analysis platform, a physics-based post-event analysis is presented to identify the root causes of the sub-synchronous oscillations induced by the wind farm integration. The above problems and proposed solutions are discussed in detail in Section 2 through Section 5. The results of this work can be integrated to address practical problems in modern power system planning and operations

Distributed simulation of power systems using real time digital simulator

The simulation of power system behavior, especially transient behavior, helps us in the analysis and planning of various power systems. However, power systems are usually highly complex and geographically distributed. Therefore system partitioning can be used to allow for sharing resources in simulation. In this work, distributed simulations of power system models have been developed using an electromagnetic transient simulator, namely Real Time Digital Simulator (RTDS). The goal is to demonstrate and assess the feasibility of both non-real-time and real-time simulations using the RTDS in a geographically distributed scenario. Different protocols and options used in the communication between power systems have been studied and analyzed. In this work, a test bed has been developed for data transfer between a power system simulated in RTDS at Mississippi State University and the power system simulated in RTDS at Texas A&M University. Different protocols, available for the interface and communication in the RTDS, have been studied and applied in this work. Finally, a locally distributed wide area control test bed was developed and simulated

Synchrophasors: Multilevel Assessment and Data Quality Improvement for Enhanced System Reliability

. This study presents a comprehensive framework for testing and evaluation of Phasor Measurement Units (PMUs) and synchrophasor systems under normal power system operating conditions, as well as during disturbances such as faults and transients. The proposed framework suggests a performance assessment to be conducted in three steps: (a) type testing: conducted in the synchrophasor calibration laboratory according to accepted industrial standards; (b) application testing: conducted to evaluate the performance of the PMUs under faults, transients, and other disturbances in power systems; (c) end-to-end system testing: conducted to assess the risk and quantify the impact of measurement errors on the applications of interest. The suggested calibration toolset (type testing) enables performance characterization of different design alternatives in a standalone PMU (e.g., length of phasor estimation windows, filtering windows, reporting rates, etc.). In conjunction with the standard performance requirements, this work defines new metrics for PMU performance evaluations under any static and dynamic conditions that may unfold in the grid. The new metrics offer a more realistic understanding of the overall PMU performance and help users choose the appropriate device/settings for the target applications. Furthermore, the proposed probabilistic techniques quantify the PMU accuracy to various test performance thresholds specified by corresponding IEEE standards, rather than having only the pass/fail test outcome, as well as the probability of specific failures to meet the standard requirements defined in terms of the phasor, frequency, and rate of change of frequency accuracy. Application testing analysis encompasses PMU performance evaluation under faults and other prevailing conditions, and offers a realistic assessment of the PMU measurement errors in real-world field scenarios and reveals additional performance characteristics that are crucial for the overall application evaluation. End-to-end system tests quantify the impact of synchrophasor estimation errors and their propagation from the PMU towards the end-use applications and evaluate the associated risk. In this work, extensive experimental results demonstrate the advantages of the proposed framework and its applicability is verified through two synchrophasor applications, namely: Fault Location and Modal Analysis. Finally, a data-driven technique (Principal Component Pursuit) is proposed for the correction and completion of the synchrophasor data blocks, and its application and effectiveness is validated in modal analyzes

Security Analysis of Phasor Measurement Units in Smart Grid Communication Infrastructures

Phasor Measurement Units (PMUs), or synchrophasors, are rapidly being deployed in the smart grid with the goal of measuring phasor quantities concurrently from wide area distribution substations. By utilizing GPS receivers, PMUs can take a wide area snapshot of power systems. Thus, the possibility of blackouts in the smart grid, the next generation power grid, will be reduced. As the main enabler of Wide Area Measurement Systems (WAMS), PMUs transmit measured values to Phasor Data Concentrators (PDCs) by the synchrophasor standard IEEE C37.118. IEC 61850 and IEC 62351 are the communication protocols for the substation automation system and the security standard for the communication protocol of IEC 61850, respectively. According to the aforementioned communication and security protocols, as well as the implementation constraints of different platforms, HMAC-SHA1 was suggested by the TC 57 WG group in October 2009. The hash-based Message Authentication Code (MAC) is an algorithm for verifying both message integrity and authentication by using an iterative hash function and a supplied secret key. There are a variety of security attacks on the PMU communications infrastructure. Timing Side Channel Attack (SCA) is one of these possible attacks. In this thesis, timing side channel vulnerability against execution time of the HMAC-SHA1 authentication algorithm is studied. Both linear and negative binomial regression are used to model some security features of the stored key, e.g., its length and Hamming weight. The goal is to reveal secret-related information based on leakage models. The results would mitigate the cryptanalysis process of an attacker. Adviser: Yi Qia

Performance Improvement of Wide-Area-Monitoring-System (WAMS) and Applications Development

Wide area monitoring system (WAMS), as an application of situation awareness, provides essential information for power system monitoring, planning, operation, and control. To fully utilize WAMS in smart grid, it is important to investigate and improve its performance, and develop advanced applications based on the data from WAMS. In this dissertation, the work on improving the WAMS performance and developing advanced applications are introduced.To improve the performance of WAMS, the work includes investigation of the impacts of measurement error and the requirements of system based on WAMS, and the solutions. PMU is one of the main sensors for WAMS. The phasor and frequency estimation algorithms implemented highly influence the performance of PMUs, and therefore the WAMS. The algorithms of PMUs are reviewed in Chapter 2. To understand how the errors impact WAMS application, different applications are investigated in Chapter 3, and their requirements of accuracy are given. In chapter 4, the error model of PMUs are developed, regarding different parameters of input signals and PMU operation conditions. The factors influence of accuracy of PMUs are analyzed in Chapter 5, including both internal and external error sources. Specifically, the impacts of increase renewables are analyzed. Based on the analysis above, a novel PMU is developed in Chapter 6, including algorithm and realization. This PMU is able to provide high accurate and fast responding measurements during both steady and dynamic state. It is potential to improve the performance of WAMS. To improve the interoperability, the C37.118.2 based data communication protocol is curtailed and realized for single-phase distribution-level PMUs, which are presented in Chapter 7.WAMS-based applications are developed and introduced in Chapter 8-10. The first application is to use the spatial and temporal characterization of power system frequency for data authentication, location estimation and the detection of cyber-attack. The second application is to detect the GPS attack on the synchronized time interval. The third application is to detect the geomagnetically induced currents (GIC) resulted from GMD and EMP-E3. These applications, benefited from the novel PMU proposed in Chapter 6, can be used to enhance the security and robust of power system