The Perpetrator in Focus: Turn of the Century Holocaust Remembrance in "The Specialist"

In his controversial 1998 film, The Specialist, Israeli director Eyal Sivan casts the Holocaust in a new light when he represents it through the eyes of the Nazi perpetrator. Sivan and his scriptwriter, human rights activist Rony Brauman, re-assemble and manipulate footage originally filmed by Leo Hurwitz for Capital Cities Broadcasting of Adolf Eichmann’s trial by an Israeli court in Jerusalem in 1961. Specifically, Sivan recycles the video footage of the trial into a 16mm film that critiques, not the heinous nature of Eichmann’s crimes, nor the depravity of the man who committed them, but the system of regulation that constructed and judged Eichmann. While the video footage was originally filmed as a document of the trial, Sivan radically redeploys the same images in a narrative that exposes the manipulations of the court, its representations and the continued injustice of such institutions and representations today, 45 years later. According to The Specialist, Eichmann’s actions are not on trial; they are a foregone conclusion. To prove Eichmann’s guilt or innocence was not the point of the trial in the first place, and it is certainly not the goal of The Specialist. Through its careful weaving of fragments of the proceedings, over the course of its narrative, The Specialist reveals the relationship of otherness — the differences and identicalities — between Adolf Eichmann, the ‘deportation specialist’ and Attorney General Gideon Hausner for the prosecution. Simultaneously, the film considers the relationship between Eichmann and the crimes of the National Socialist Party as they were forged by the Israeli court

Alternate modules are subsymplectic

In this paper, an alternate module $(A,\phi)$ is a finite abelian group $A$ with a $\mathbb{Z}$-bilinear application $\phi:A\times A\rightarrow \mathbb{Q}/\mathbb{Z}$ which is alternate (i.e. zero on the diagonal). We shall prove that any alternate module is subsymplectic, i.e. if $(A,\phi)$ has a Lagrangian of cardinal $n$ then there exists an abelian group $B$ of order $n$ such that $(A,\phi)$ is a submodule of the standard symplectic module $B\times B^*$.Comment: 22 page

Sampling community discourses as a method for assessing "public opinion"

In working with the topics of racial discrimination and household energy reductions it is clear that just measuring attitudes is no longer sufficient. We need a fuller social context to understand what is said about these topics, as the same words can be used for many reasons. I am working with four new methods for "sampling community discourses" on topics such as racial prejudice, to replace or supplement the measurement of attitudes. The initial analysis is whether the talk functions to get someone to do something directly, to get someone to believe the 'facts', or whether the talk functions for the establishment or maintenance of social relationships. Many problems remain, especially the representativeness of the sampling and keeping as much of the context of the talk as possible

Seminal fluid and cytokine control of regulatory T-cells in murine pregnancy.

For successful pregnancy, the maternal immune system must tolerate the presence of a fetus that expresses alloantigens. The appropriate and timely acquisition of this state of tolerance is critical and emerging evidence suggests that it needs to be present from the time the embryo implants into the uterus. Recently it has been demonstrated that a subpopulation of lymphocytes termed CD4⁺CD25⁺ regulatory T cells (Treg cells) are required for immune tolerance of the fetus during pregnancy. Despite their importance the factors that control regulatory T cells during pregnancy, and in particular in the peri-implantation period, are poorly understood. Using mouse models we have assessed the role of the ejaculate and its components (sperm and seminal plasma) in coordinating Treg cells in the period prior to embryo implantation. We have also used mice with a null mutation in the interleukin 10 (IL-10) gene to assess the role of this cytokine in coordination of Treg cell populations in later pregnancy. Experiments in the peri-implantation period just prior to implantation (day 3.5 postcoitum) showed that there was a significant increase (approximately 2-fold; p<0.05) in the total number of (CD4⁺Foxp3⁺) Treg cells in the iliac lymph nodes (LNs) that drain the uterus, but not in the distal inguinal LNs. This appeared not to be the result of a selective expansion in Treg cells but due to expansion of the entire CD4⁺ cell pool, since the percent of CD4+ cells expressing Foxp3 in any of the lymphoid tissues studied did not increase in response to mating. In addition, there was a similar increase in the density of these cells in the uterus just prior to implantation at day 3.5pc (p<0.05). By using males deficient in the sperm or seminal plasma components of the ejaculate we could show that the increase in both the lymph node and uterine Treg cell populations occurred in response to seminal plasma. The role of seminal plasma in regulating expression of mRNAs encoding migratory molecules in the peri-implantation uterus, and the involvement of these genes in recruiting Treg cells following mating, was then assessed. We analysed the mRNAs for the chemokines Ccl4, Ccl5, Ccl19, Ccl22, the chemokine receptors Ccr4, Ccr5, Ccr7 and the integrin Cd103 using qRT-PCR. We showed a significant elevation in Ccl19 and Ccr5 mRNA at day 3.5pc following mating to intact males. However the increase in mRNA was independent of factors associated with seminal fluid and might instead be regulated by ovarian steroid hormones. Using IL-10 null mutant (IL-10-/-) mice it was then shown that the cytokine IL-10 is involved in controlling Treg cell numbers in mid gestation. At gestational day (gd) 9.5, in IL-10-/- mice, there was an approximate 40% elevation in the proportion of CD4⁺ cells expressing Foxp3 compared with wild‐type control mice (p<0.01). This was seen in both the iliac LNs and inguinal LNs. In addition, there was a greater than 10-fold increase (p<0.0001) in the total number of Treg cells in the uterine-draining iliac LNs of IL-10-/- mice compared to wild-type mice. This was not seen in the inguinal LNs. Experiments comparing allogeneic and syngeneic mated mice showed that the proportional changes seen in the CD4⁺ cell population was dependent on fetal alloantigens, although the elevation in total numbers still occurred in the absence of fetal alloantigens. This study begins to unravel the process by which Treg cell populations are expanded and recruited into the uterus prior to embryo implantation and later in gestation. A greater understanding of this process may aid in the diagnosis and prevention of a range of pregnancy pathologies associated with immune dysregulation, such as preeclampsia and recurrent spontaneous abortion.Thesis (Ph.D.) -- University of Adelaide, School of Paediatrics and Reproductive Health, 201

Subsidiarity: Implications for New Zealand

Subsidiarity requires taking decisions at the level of government best placed to do so, but does not say what that level is. Rather, it gives a broad framework within which to have the debate. Implementing subsidiarity means (1) allocating roles appropriately between levels of government, (2) co-ordinating implementation of decisions, and (3) managing accountability and participation. Subsidiarity does not, however, tell us how to achieve these goals. It is therefore more about how a decision is made than about what the specific decision is. Europe, the United States and Australia have adopted varying solutions to these issues. New Zealand’s ability to influence the trans-Tasman outcome is likely to be limited. The main implications for New Zealand are in designing trans-Tasman institutions and allocating responsibilities between central and local government.Subsidiarity, Harmonisation

Property Rights and Environmental Policy: A New Zealand Perspective

This paper is intended to lay out a preliminary foundation for applying a property rights perspective to environmental policy issues facing New Zealand. It does not attempt to apply such an approach to any specific issue. Rather it summarises the core principles behind effective rights regimes (illustrated by the evolution of rights over time), reviews how such regimes have been applied to environmental issues internationally, and describes current natural resource rights regimes in New Zealand. The purpose of applying property rights to the environment can vary widely and reflect quite different perspectives. Regulation by any form, however, whether command-and-control or market-based, creates or modifies property rights. While private property rights will not always be appropriate, the alternatives redefine and reallocate rights rather than eliminating them. A common or public property right remains a right held by someone. The choice is not therefore whether to modify property rights to improve environmental outcomes, but how to do so in a way that optimises national welfare. However, if more use of market-based instruments is appropriate, then the work required to create the legal, institutional and scientific framework to successfully implement them (including trading off social, economic and environmental outcomes) should not be under-estimated. Fishing and water rights demonstrate these difficulties and the payoff (for fisheries at least) that can be achieved.Property Rights, Transferability, Market Based Instruments (MBI), Environmental Policy, New Zealand

Protection against Government Takings: Compensation for Regulation?

The paper responds to recent debate in New Zealand on the power of the government to take private property, directly or through regulatory constraints. This aspect of regulation has received less attention in New Zealand than it warrants. This paper addresses the issue of which protections against takings are appropriate, and the role of compensation as a protective device. A taking can be broadly defined an act by which a government assumes or assigns control over all or part of a property right held by a private party. Government regulation is typically not treated as a taking. In practice, compensation is normally required only for physical takings, such as the acquisition of land, and is not available for takings through regulation, such as restricting the right to use land in a particular way. New Zealand has three options for improved protection against takings: a tighter regime for scrutinising the quality of regulation, more restricted takings powers, and extended compensation provisions. The desirability and practicality of a greater role for compensation requires, however, more detailed consideration. The paper aims to stimulate further debate in this area as an aspect of the wider debate on regulatory quality.Eminent Domain; Compensation; Regulatory Takings; Police Power; Public Works; Land Use

Theory vs Reality: Making Environmental Use Rights Work in New Zealand

The potential advantages in flexibility and efficiency of environmental use rights (such as permits and quotas) over prescriptive regulatory approaches have been well surveyed, and are being advocated in New Zealand now as a tool for achieving sustainable development. So why have they not been more widely adopted here? How can government help remove barriers and improve both economic and environmental outcomes in New Zealand? At the structural level the barriers tend to be well known, or presumed, as a lack of statutory frameworks or central government guidance, and information costs involved in defining the resource and in determining an appropriate rights framework to optimise its use. Even given these structural and technical barriers there remains the task of explaining why, since those barriers are not insuperable, little progress has occurred. Other factors include the extent to which such responsibility in New Zealand is delegated by central government, competing priorities for regional governments, lack of pressure on resources (eg; water in much of New Zealand), the difficulty of making contentious choices and strength of existing interests, reluctance to acknowledge any private rights to some resources, the relative ease of using existing regulatory tools, and low benefits relative to costs in small markets particularly where geographical distinctions exist such as for water and certain types of pollution. This suggests that the best focus for central government may be on better guidance, filling gaps in legislative frameworks, and providing or encouraging provision of the necessary institutions and systems in ways that allow economies of scope and scale. It is unclear how much scope there is for improvement but getting rid of unnecessary barriers, as long as it is done without unnecessary elaboration or restriction, will help secure whatever gains are out there to be had.Water, Property Rights, Transferability, Market Based Instruments

Adaptive Governance and Evolving Solutions to Natural Resource Conflicts

New Zealand is facing increasing challenges in managing natural resources (land, freshwater, marine space and air quality) under pressures from domestic (population growth, agricultural intensification, cultural expectations) and international (climate change) sources. These challenges can be described in terms of managing ‘wicked problems’; i.e. problems that may not be understood fully until they have been solved, where stakeholders have different world views and frames for understanding the problem, the constraints affecting the problem and the resources required to solve it change over time, and no complete solution is ever actually found. Adaptive governance addresses wicked problems through a framework to engage stakeholders in a participative process to create a long term vision. The vision must identify competing goals and a process for balancing them over time that acknowledges conflicts cannot always be resolved in a single lasting decision. Circumstances, goals and priorities can all vary over time and by region. The Resource Management Act can be seen as an adaptive governance structure where frameworks for resources such as water may take years to evolve and decades to fully implement. Adaptive management is about delivery through an incremental/experimental approach, limits on the certainty that governments can provide and stakeholders can demand, and flexibility in processes and results. In New Zealand it also requires balancing central government expertise and resources, with local authorities which can reflect local goals and knowledge, but have varying resources and can face quite distinct issues of widely differing severity. It is important to signal the incremental, overlapping, iterative and time-consuming nature of the work involved in developing and implementing adaptive governance and management frameworks. Managing the expectations of those involved as to the nature of the process and their role in it, and the scope and timing of likely outcomes, is key to sustaining participation.Adaptive capacity; governance; resilience