7 research outputs found
'Foreigners are stealing our birth right': Moral panics and the discursive construction of Zimbabwean immigrants in South African media
We examine 575 randomly selected articles on Zimbabwean immigrants from the South African
Media (SAM) database to expose discourses of exclusion and the production of the psycho-social
condition - moral panic. We use critical discourse analysis, notions of remediation and immediacy
to scrutinize discourse structures and other discursive strategies designed to conceal mediation
and authorial prejudices, and to make the reader 'experience' the actual content. In addition to
making the anti-immigrant rhetoric appear legitimate, and the danger immediate and real, we
argue that the apparent seamless content is often biased by selection and structured in such a way
as to deny voice to immigrants and their advocates. Among other things, we conclude that since
the readers' interpretations are filtered through lenses of subjectivities defined by communicative
contexts characterized by job scarcity, poverty, crime and wanting healthcare, the news content
heightens anxiety and miseducates more than it enlightens readers on migration issues. Hence
there is a danger of SAM becoming unwitting conveyors of the same vices they preach against.IS
'Kids sold, desperate moms need cash': Media representations of Zimbabwean women migrants
The article draws on 575 randomly selected articles from the South African Media database
to explore the representation of Zimbabwean women migrants. Using critical discourse analysis
(CDA), the article shows that some of the dominant construction types depict a picture of caricatured,
stereotypical and stigmatised Zimbabwean migrant women without voice and individuality. In turn,
the diversity of their actualities is not captured in the process of constructing the twin images of
Zimbabwean women as victims and as purveyors of decadent and other negative social ills in
society. We conclude that Zimbabwean women migrants appear in the SA media primarily in three
negative images: suppliers of sexual services, as un-motherly, and as victims. We also conclude
that there is need for media to capture the voices of migrant women recounting their everyday lived
experiences in different political and socio-economic contexts in order to account for the migrant
women's voices of resilience, defiance and victimhood and of agency, against the normalising and
marginalising influences of political institutions and national border controls. This would also help
capture the transformative nature of migration to the women, the 'home' in Zimbabwe and the 'home'
in South Africa.IS
“Two Steps Forward, One Step Back”: Zimbabwean Migration and South Africa’s Regularising Programme (the ZDP)
South Africa’s announcement and implementation of a legalising amnesty
under the Zimbabwe Documentation Project (ZDP) in 2010 was lauded as a step away
from the laissez-faire approach to Zimbabwean immigration. The amnesty, granting
migrants stay, work, study and business operation rights in the country on 4-year
permits, was clouded by uncertainties and exclusions and implementation hassles. This
article explores this legalising amnesty in relation to trends in Zimbabwean immigration
over the years, noting in particular the complexity and fluidity in migration
patterns. The article highlights these complexities and how they expose the limitations
of any ad hoc and short-term approach to managing complex immigration flows. It
argues that such an approach fails to recognise differences in migration trends over time
and space, sources of migration and migrant’s strategies, and, more importantly, that
these factors result in different migrants with differing needs. As way of conclusion, the
article suggests that any progressive immigration strategy on Zimbabwean immigration
should not only build on the BTemporary Immigration Exemption Status for
Zimbabweans^ of 2009 and embrace ideals of diversity, inclusivity and openness but
also draw upon existing efforts at regional cooperation and integration.http://link.springer.com/journal/121342018-05-30hb2016Anthropology and Archaeolog