Investigation of initiation of reverse transcription in retroviruses using vectors with two primer -binding sites

Initiation of reverse transcription in retroviruses occurs on a specific place in viral genome, called primer-binding site (PBS). Cellular tRNA is annealed to the complementary PBS and is used as a primer. We constructed murine leukemia virus (MLV)-based vectors containing two PBSs, one in normal position and another in the middle of the vector. Green fluorescence protein (GFP) gene was inserted between the two PBSs. The internal PBS was derived from a spleen necrosis virus (SNV), which uses the same tRNA-Pro as a primer. We have shown that the internal PBS was functional for initiation of reverse transcription. Replication of vectors containing two functional PBSs is expected to result in deletion of sequences between the two PBSs if initiations on these two sites occur simultaneously. The deletion was detected in 20--30% of infected cells by the GFP-negative phenotype and by direct Southern blotting analysis of DNA of infected cells. This indicated that a single virion has the capacity to initiate reverse transcription more than once. In order to fund the efficiency of initiation of a single PBS we constructed a mathematical model, which provided a relationship between several parameters of retroviral replication and the outcome of reverse transcription of vectors with two PBSs. Using this model we found that efficiency of initiation at MLV and SNV PBS is 35--50%. Next, we constructed human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1)-based vectors with two PBSs by inserting human immunodeficiency virus type 2 (HIV-2) PBS in the middle. Again, the internal PBS was found functional and simultaneous initiations were occurring in 22--24% of all infections. This system was used to analyze the effects of mutations within HIV-2 PBS region on the efficiency of initiation. By using wild type HIV-1 PBS (present in the same vector) as internal control we were able to get accurate quantitative measurements of initiation efficiency at mutant HIV-2 PBS. Our results indicated that U5-IR stem of HIV-2 plays a very important role in initiation. Also, additional interactions between tRNA and viral genome, proposed for HIV-1, were found to be important for HIV-2 initiation, indicating that these two viruses use similar mechanisms to achieve specific and efficient initiation of reverse transcription

Frequent dual initiation of reverse transcription in murine leukemia virus-based vectors containing two primer-binding sites

AbstractRetroviruses package two copies of viral RNA into each virion. Although each RNA contains a primer-binding site for initiation of DNA synthesis, it is unknown whether reverse transcription is initiated on both RNAs. To determine whether a single virion is capable of initiating reverse transcription more than once, we constructed a murine leukemia virus-based vector containing a second primer-binding site (PBS) derived from spleen necrosis virus and inserted the green fluorescent protein gene (GFP) between the two PBSs. Initiation of reverse transcription at either PBS results in a provirus that expresses GFP. However, initiation at both PBSs can result in the deletion of GFP, which can be detected by flow cytometry and Southern blotting analysis. Approximately 22–29% of the proviruses formed deleted the GFP in a single replication cycle, indicating the minimum proportion of virions that initiated reverse transcription on both PBSs. These results show that a significant proportion of MLV-based vectors containing two PBSs have the capacity to initiate reverse transcription more than once

Access to Scientific Publications: The Scientist's Perspective

BACKGROUND: Scientific publishing is undergoing significant changes due to the growth of online publications, increases in the number of open access journals, and policies of funders and universities requiring authors to ensure that their publications become publicly accessible. Most studies of the impact of these changes have focused on the growth of articles available through open access or the number of open-access journals. Here, we investigated access to publications at a number of institutes and universities around the world, focusing on publications in HIV vaccine research--an area of biomedical research with special importance to the developing world. METHODS AND FINDINGS: We selected research papers in HIV vaccine research field, creating: 1) a first set of 50 most recently published papers with keywords "HIV vaccine" and 2) a second set of 200 articles randomly selected from those cited in the first set. Access to the majority (80%) of the recently published articles required subscription, while cited literature was much more accessible (67% freely available online). Subscriptions at a number of institutions around the world were assessed for providing access to subscription-only articles from the two sets. The access levels varied widely, ranging among institutions from 20% to 90%. Through the WHO-supported HINARI program, institutes in low-income countries had access comparable to that of institutes in the North. Finally, we examined the response rates for reprint requests sent to corresponding authors, a method commonly used before internet access became widespread. Contacting corresponding authors with requests for electronic copies of articles by email resulted in a 55-60% success rate, although in some cases it took up to 1.5 months to get a response. CONCLUSIONS: While research articles are increasingly available on the internet in open access format, institutional subscriptions continue to play an important role. However, subscriptions do not provide access to the full range of HIV vaccine research literature. Access to papers through subscriptions is complemented by a variety of other means, including emailing corresponding authors, joint affiliations, use of someone else's login information and posting requests on message boards. This complex picture makes it difficult to assess the real ability of scientists to access literature, but the observed differences in access levels between institutions suggest an unlevel playing field, in which some researchers have to spend more efforts than others to obtain the same information

Glycan profiles of gp120 protein vaccines from four major HIV-1 subtypes produced from different host cell lines under non-GMP or GMP conditions

Envelope glycoprotein (Env) of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) is an important target for the development of an HIV vaccine. Extensive glycosylation of Env is an important feature that both protects the virus from antibody responses and serves as a target for some highly potent broadly neutralizing antibodies. Therefore, analysis of glycans on recombinant Env proteins is highly significant. Here we present glycosylation profiles of recombinant gp120 proteins from four major clades of HIV-1 (A, B, C, and AE) produced either as research-grade material in 293 and CHO cells or as two independent lots of clinical material under GMP conditions. Almost all potential N-linked glycosylation sites were at least partially occupied in all proteins. The occupancy rates were largely consistent among proteins produced under different conditions, although a few sites showed substantial variability even between two GMP lots. Our data confirmed previous studies in the field showing high abundance of oligomannose on Env protein, with 40-50% of glycans having Man5-Man9 on all four proteins under all production conditions. Overall the differences in occupancy and glycan forms among Env from different subtypes produced under different conditions were less dramatic than anticipated and antigenicity analysis with a panel of six monoclonal antibodies showed that all four gp120s maintained their antibody-binding profiles, including antibodies that recognize glycan forms. Such findings have major implications to the final production of a clinical HIV vaccine including Env glycoprotein components. IMPORTANCE HIV-1 Env protein is a major target for the development of an HIV-1 vaccine. Env is covered with a large number of sugar-based glycan forms - about 50% of the Env molecular weight is composed of glycans. Glycan analysis of recombinant Env proteins is important to understand its roles in vial pathogenesis and immune responses. The current report presents the first extensive comparison of glycosylation patterns of recombinant gp120 proteins from four major clades of HIV-1 produced in two different cell lines, grown at either laboratory condition or at 50L GMP scale across different lots. Information learned in this study is valuable for the further design and production of HIV-1 Env proteins as the critical components of HIV-1 vaccine formulations

HIV monoclonal antibodies: a new opportunity to further reduce mother-to-child HIV transmission.

Yegor Voronin and colleagues explore how monoclonal antibodies against HIV could provide a new opportunity to further reduce mother-to-child transmission of HIV and propose that new interventions should consider issues related to implementation, feasibility, and access. Please see later in the article for the Editors' Summary

Genetic Drift of HIV Populations in Culture

Populations of Human Immunodeficiency Virus type 1 (HIV-1) undergo a surprisingly large amount of genetic drift in infected patients despite very large population sizes, which are predicted to be mostly deterministic. Several models have been proposed to explain this phenomenon, but all of them implicitly assume that the process of virus replication itself does not contribute to genetic drift. We developed an assay to measure the amount of genetic drift for HIV populations replicating in cell culture. The assay relies on creation of HIV populations of known size and measurements of variation in frequency of a neutral allele. Using this assay, we show that HIV undergoes approximately ten times more genetic drift than would be expected from its population size, which we defined as the number of infected cells in the culture. We showed that a large portion of the increase in genetic drift is due to non-synchronous infection of target cells. When infections are synchronized, genetic drift for the virus is only 3-fold higher than expected from its population size. Thus, the stochastic nature of biological processes involved in viral replication contributes to increased genetic drift in HIV populations. We propose that appreciation of these effects will allow better understanding of the evolutionary forces acting on HIV in infected patients

Simian Immunodeficiency Virus Variants That Differ in Pathogenicity Differ in Fitness under Rapid Cell Turnover Conditions

Simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) has been shown to progress through a number of changes that lead to the emergence of pathogenic viral variants in macaques initially infected with a mildly cytopathic variant, SIVMneCL8. One of these late-stage isolates, SIVMne170, replicates to high levels in vivo and causes a rapid disease course when reintroduced into naïve macaques, resulting in a viral set point up to 3,000-fold higher than the set point of the parental virus, SIVMneCL8. However, in cell culture both viruses replicate with similar kinetics. One major difference between in vivo and in vitro cultures is the life span of the infected cells. Here, we manipulated the life span of infected cells in vitro, and we show that the fitness of SIVMne170 in cultures with a limited cell life span dramatically increased compared to its fitness in cultures with a nonlimited life span of cells. The increase in fitness was at least partially due to the fact that the rapid turnover system eliminates the negative influence of the cytopathic effects associated with replication of SIVMne170. Because the relative fitness of SIVMneCL8 and SIVMne170 observed in the rapid turnover system more accurately reflects their fitness in vivo, the system represents an improved approach to comparing relative fitness of viruses

Frequent Dual Initiation in Human Immunodeficiency Virus-Based Vectors Containing Two Primer-Binding Sites: a Quantitative In Vivo Assay for Function of Initiation Complexes

We previously demonstrated that murine leukemia virus (MLV)-based vectors containing two primer-binding sites (PBSs) have the capacity to initiate reverse transcription more than once (Y. A. Voronin and V. K. Pathak, Virology 312:281-294, 2003). To determine whether human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-based vectors also have the capacity to initiate reverse transcription twice, we constructed an HIV type 1 (HIV-1)-based vector containing the HIV-1 PBS, a green fluorescent protein reporter gene (GFP), and a second PBS derived from HIV-2 3′ of GFP. Simultaneous initiation of reverse transcription at both the 5′ HIV-1 PBS and 3′ HIV-2 PBS was predicted to result in deletion of GFP. As in the MLV-based vectors, GFP was deleted in approximately 25% of all proviruses, indicating frequent dual initiation in HIV-based vectors containing two PBSs. Quantitative real-time PCR analysis of early reverse transcription products indicated that HIV-1 reverse transcriptase efficiently used the HIV-2 PBS. To investigate tRNA primer-RNA template interactions in vivo, we introduced several mutations in the HIV-2 U5 region. The effects of these mutations on the efficiency of reverse transcription initiation were measured by quantitative real-time PCR analysis of early reverse transcription products, with initiation at the HIV-1 PBS used as an internal control. Disruption of the lower and upper parts of the U5-inverted repeat stem reduced the efficiency of initiation 20- and 6-fold, respectively. In addition, disruption of the proposed interactions between viral RNA and tRNA(Lys3) thymidine-pseudouridine-cytidine and anticodon loops decreased the efficiency of initiation seven- and sixfold, respectively. These results demonstrate the relative influence of various RNA-RNA interactions on the efficiency of initiation in vivo. Furthermore, the two-PBS vector system provides a sensitive and quantitative in vivo assay for analysis of RNA-RNA and protein-RNA interactions that can influence the efficiency of reverse transcription initiation