Impact of three different peak picking software tools on the quality of untargeted metabolomics data

Data quality and control parameters are becoming more important in metabolomics. For peak picking, open-source or commercial solutions are used. Other publications consider different software solutions or data acquisition types for peak picking, a combination, including proposed and new quality parameters for the process of peak picking, does not exist. This study tries to examine the performance of three different software in terms of reproducibility and quality of their output while also considering new quality parameters to gain a better understanding of resulting feature lists in metabolomics data. We saw best recovery of spiked analytes in MS-DIAL. Reproducibility over multiple projects was good among all software. The total number of features found was consistent for DDA and full scan acquisition in MS-DIAL but full scan data leading to considerably more features in MZmine and Progenesis Qi. Feature linearity proved to be a good quality parameter. Features in MS-DIAL and MZmine, showed good linearity while Progenesis Qi produced large variation, especially in full scan data. Peak width proved to be a very powerful filtering criteria revealing many features in MZmine and Progenesis Qi to be of questionable peak width. Additionally, full scan data appears to produce a disproportionally higher number of short features. This parameter is not yet available in MS-DIAL. Finally, the manual classification of true positive features proved MS-DIAL to perform significantly better in DDA data (62 % true positive) than the two other software in either mode. We showed that currently popular solutions MS-DIAL and MZmine perform well in targeted analysis of spiked analytes as well as in classic untargeted analysis. The commercially available solution Progenesis Qi does not hold any advantage over the two in terms of quality parameters, of which we proposed peak width as a new parameter and showed that already proposed parameters such as feature linearity in samples of increasing concentration are advisable to use

Postmortem metabolomics: strategies to assess time-dependent postmortem changes of Diazepam, Nordiazepam, Morphine, Codeine, Mirtazapine and Citalopram

Postmortem redistribution (PMR) can result in artificial drug concentration changes following death and complicate forensic case interpretation. Currently, no accurate methods for PMR prediction exist. Hence, alternative strategies were developed investigating the time-dependent postmortem behavior of diazepam, nordiazepam, morphine, codeine, mirtazapine and citalopram. For 477 authentic postmortem cases, femoral blood samples were collected at two postmortem time-points. All samples were quantified for drugs of abuse (targeted; liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry LC-MS/MS) and characterized for small endogenous molecules (untargeted; gas chromatography-high resolution MS (GC-HRMS). Trends for significant time-dependent concentration decreases (diazepam (n = 137), nordiazepam (n = 126)), increases (mirtazapine (n = 55), citalopram (n = 50)) or minimal median postmortem changes (morphine (n = 122), codeine (n = 92)) could be observed. Robust mathematical mixed effect models were created for the generalized postmortem behavior of diazepam and nordiazepam, which could be used to back-calculate drug concentrations towards a time-point closer to the estimated time of death (caution: inter-individual variability). Significant correlations between time-dependent concentration changes of morphine, mirtazapine and citalopram with individual endogenous molecules could be determined; no correlation was deemed strong enough for successful a posteriori estimation on the occurrence of PMR for specific cases. The current dataset did successfully lead to a significant knowledge gain in further understanding the time-dependent postmortem behavior of the studied drugs (of abuse)

Postmortem Metabolomics: Strategies to Assess Time-Dependent Postmortem Changes of Diazepam, Nordiazepam, Morphine, Codeine, Mirtazapine and Citalopram

Postmortem redistribution (PMR) can result in artificial drug concentration changes following death and complicate forensic case interpretation. Currently, no accurate methods for PMR prediction exist. Hence, alternative strategies were developed investigating the time-dependent postmortem behavior of diazepam, nordiazepam, morphine, codeine, mirtazapine and citalopram. For 477 authentic postmortem cases, femoral blood samples were collected at two postmortem time-points. All samples were quantified for drugs of abuse (targeted; liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry LC-MS/MS) and characterized for small endogenous molecules (untargeted; gas chromatography-high resolution MS (GC-HRMS). Trends for significant time-dependent concentration decreases (diazepam (n = 137), nordiazepam (n = 126)), increases (mirtazapine (n = 55), citalopram (n = 50)) or minimal median postmortem changes (morphine (n = 122), codeine (n = 92)) could be observed. Robust mathematical mixed effect models were created for the generalized postmortem behavior of diazepam and nordiazepam, which could be used to back-calculate drug concentrations towards a time-point closer to the estimated time of death (caution: inter-individual variability). Significant correlations between time-dependent concentration changes of morphine, mirtazapine and citalopram with individual endogenous molecules could be determined; no correlation was deemed strong enough for successful a posteriori estimation on the occurrence of PMR for specific cases. The current dataset did successfully lead to a significant knowledge gain in further understanding the time-dependent postmortem behavior of the studied drugs (of abuse)