Comparative whole-genome analysis of clinical isolates reveals characteristic architecture of Mycobacterium tuberculosis pangenome.

The tubercle complex consists of closely related mycobacterium species which appear to be variants of a single species. Comparative genome analysis of different strains could provide useful clues and insights into the genetic diversity of the species. We integrated genome assemblies of 96 strains from Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBC), which included 8 Indian clinical isolates sequenced and assembled in this study, to understand its pangenome architecture. We predicted genes for all the 96 strains and clustered their respective CDSs into homologous gene clusters (HGCs) to reveal a hard-core, soft-core and accessory genome component of MTBC. The hard-core (HGCs shared amongst 100% of the strains) was comprised of 2,066 gene clusters whereas the soft-core (HGCs shared amongst at least 95% of the strains) comprised of 3,374 gene clusters. The change in the core and accessory genome components when observed as a function of their size revealed that MTBC has an open pangenome. We identified 74 HGCs that were absent from reference strains H37Rv and H37Ra but were present in most of clinical isolates. We report PCR validation on 9 candidate genes depicting 7 genes completely absent from H37Rv and H37Ra whereas 2 genes shared partial homology with them accounting to probable insertion and deletion events. The pangenome approach is a promising tool for studying strain specific genetic differences occurring within species. We also suggest that since selecting appropriate target genes for typing purposes requires the expected target gene be present in all isolates being typed, therefore estimating the core-component of the species becomes a subject of prime importance

The heatmap shows 74 HGCs absent from reference strains Mtb ATCC H37Ra and Mtb ATCC H37Rv but present in most of the clinical isolates.

<p>Predicted annotation of each of the cluster family is also represented. The genes validated using PCR are also shown adjacent to the annotations.</p

Genome Assembly Statistics of the eight Indian strains sequenced and assembled as part of the present study.

<p>Genome Assembly Statistics of the eight Indian strains sequenced and assembled as part of the present study.</p

Overlap of accessory orthologous clusters shared within each strain pair.

<p>The diagonal represent the number of clusters present in any given strain and divides the data into exactly similar halves. Color key indicates the distribution of clusters. The sharing is irrespective of the cluster being present in any other strain. The minimum number of shared clusters is 109 clusters between Mcan CIPT 140070008 and Mbovis BCG Phipps and maximum (521) is between Mbovis BCG Sweden and Mbovis BCG Prague9.</p

Molecular function GO annotations of the soft-core component.

<p>GO annotation for Biological process and Cellular component is provided in <a href="http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0122979#pone.0122979.s005" target="_blank">S5</a> and <a href="http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0122979#pone.0122979.s006" target="_blank">S6</a> Figs.</p

Summary of sequence annotation statistics from BLAST2GO.

<p>Representative sequences from all the 8,099 HGCs were subjected to annotation out of which 47.77% (3,869) sequences were annotated with GO slim terms, 26.63% (2,157) sequences were without any BLAST hits, 23.43% (1,898) sequences had only blast results but didn’t had annotation and 1.65% (134) sequences retrieved mapping results but were without GO slim terms. A small fraction of 0.5% (41) sequences failed to fetch BLAST results.</p

Core and accessory genome size evolution.

<p>(A) Each point indicates the number of HGCs conserved in a genome. The red line indicates an exponential decay function based on the median values of core HGCs when each time a new genome is added to the analysis. (B) Accessory genome of MTBC. The MTBC has an open pangenome model.</p

(A) PCR validation of the 10 candidate genes (subset of 74 clusters identified) in 8 Indian clinical isolates (OSDD strains) and reference strains ATCC H37Ra and ATCC H37Rv.

<p>Arrow heads indicate the variably sized products in ATCC H37Ra and ATCC H37Rv genomes. Gene 4 and Gene 8 shares partial homology with laboratory strains and showed the presence of a differently sized product in ATCC H37Rv and ATCC H37Ra. (B) The alignment of Gene 4 against reference genomes showed an insertion of 175bp sequence in Gene 4 of OSDD strains with respect to reference strains. (C) The alignment of Gene 8 against reference genomes showed a deletion of 1,352bp sequence in Gene 8 of OSDD strains.</p

Core-gene Tree.

<p>The un-rooted MTBC tree was created from alignment of 971 orthologous core-genes from 96 strains. A tree with Bootstrapped values is presented in <a href="http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0122979#pone.0122979.s003" target="_blank">S3 Fig</a> (details in text).</p

Salient features of the 96 <i>M</i>. <i>tuberculosis</i> complex genomes used in the present study.

<p>*—Denotes MDR strains,</p><p>~—Denotes XDR strains.</p><p>Salient features of the 96 <i>M</i>. <i>tuberculosis</i> complex genomes used in the present study.</p