Development of a Large-Eddy-Simulation approach with Telemac-3D

Water Qualit

The Efficiency of a Fence of Tidal Turbines in the Alderney Race: Comparison between Analytical and Numerical Models

Assessing the efficiency of a tidal turbine array is necessary for adequate device positioning and the reliable evaluation of annual energy production. Array efficiency depends on hydrodynamic characteristics, operating conditions, and blockage effects, and is commonly evaluated by relying on analytical models or more complex numerical simulations. By applying the conservations of mass, momentum, and energy in an idealized flow field, analytical models derive formulations of turbines’ thrust and power as a function of the induction factor (change in the current velocity induced by turbines). This simplified approach also gives a preliminary characterization of the influence of blockage on array efficiency. Numerical models with turbines represented as actuator disks also enable the assessment of the efficiency of a tidal array. We compare here these two approaches, considering the numerical model as a reference as it includes more physics than the analytical models. The actuator disk approach is applied to the three-dimensional model Telemac3D in realistic flow conditions and for different operating scenarios. Reference results are compared to those obtained from three analytical models that permit the investigation of the flow within tidal farm integrating or excluding processes such as the deformation of the free surface or the effects of global blockage. The comparison is applied to the deployment of a fence of turbines in the Alderney Race (macro-tidal conditions of the English Channel, northwest European shelf). Efficiency estimates are found to vary significantly from one model to another. The main result is that analytical models predict lower efficiency as they fail to approach realistically the flow structure in the vicinity of turbines, especially because they neglect the three-dimensional effects and turbulent mixing. This finding implies that the tidal energy yield potential could be larger than previously estimated (with analytical models)

Dynamique des côtes sableuses et phénomènes d'auto-organisation

Méandres fluviaux sur les continents, dunes de sable sur le plateau continental, barres en croissant et baïnes en domaine littoral sont les exemples les plus visibles des figures sédimentaires dites périodiques. Le long des plages, la dynamique de ces figures résulte d'interactions entre l'hydrodynamique, le transport de sédiments et l'évolution morphologique. La connaissance de ces phénomènes permet de comprendre les courants côtiers (en termes de sécurité de la baignade, par exemple) et de prévoir les tendances d'évolution des littoraux

The Potential of Tidal Energy Production in a Narrow Channel: The Gulf of Morbihan

The tidal currents of the Gulf of Morbihan reach up to 3.5 m/s within a narrow (200 m large) channel connecting the sea to the inner part of the gulf. In this study, a Telemac2D model validated with a large dataset of field measurements is used to assess the resources of the gulf. The results show that two sites have the potential to host up to 48 turbines (diameter of 8 m). If the entire width of the channel is occupied by turbines, significant increases in current speed are expected to occur on each side of the main channel. Simulations also show that flow changes differ between ebbing and flooding tides. During ebbing tide, the changes are limited in amplitude and remain localised within the channel. During flooding tide, the changes are more significant, especially in the vicinity of one of the two sites where the water passing through the site is flushed into a large and shallow basin. In this area, energy extraction significantly modifies the spatial distribution of the current velocities. We consider different scenarios of tidal energy extraction. The results show that flow perturbation can be significantly reduced using a lower density of turbines, that extracting tidal energy at one site slightly reduces the resource of the other, and that the deployment of two turbines (testing conditions) has a negligible effect on ambient current speeds

Influence of the 18.6-year lunar nodal cycle on the tidal resource of the Alderney Race, France

Resource assessment is an important phase of tidal energy projects. Extensive literature is nowadays available on this topic with most studies focussing on the time-scales of the tide or the spring-neap cycle. The evolution of the resource over longer time scales has yet received very little attention in the scientific literature. In the present contribution, we investigate the effect of the 18.6 year lunar nodal cycle on the depth-averaged current of the Alderney Race (France). Firstly, we identify the major constituents of the study zone with the UTide Matlab functions. Two datasets are used: a 36.5 day time-series of depth-averaged current and elevations acquired in the Alderney Race and a 24 year times-series of tidal heights acquired in a neighbouring harbour. The analysis shows that the tide is mostly controlled by the semi-diurnal constituents M2, S2 and N2. Secondly, we verify the ability of UTide functions to predict the changes in amplitude of the major components over decadal time-scale. Thirdly, we predict the tidal resource of the Alderney Race over the period 2014 – 2034 and analyse the yearly changes within this period. The results show that the change of resource is of the order of +/-10% and that the next decade (2020–2029) will be characterised by a significant reduction of the resource

Use of Large-Eddy Simulation for the bed shear stress estimation over a dune

Environmental flows are generally characterized by complex bed morphology and high current speeds. Such configurations favor the formation of vortex structures that strongly affect hydrody-namics and sediment transport. Large-Eddy Simulation (LES) enables investigation of the dynam-ics of the largest turbulence scales and, thanks to enhanced calculation resources, has now become applicable for simulating environmental flows. In this paper, a LES approach is developed in a CFD code (TELEMAC-3D), which was originally developed to simulate free surface flows using RANS methods. The present developments involve implementing subgrid models, boundary con-ditions and numerical schemes suitable for LES. The LES version of TELEMAC-3D was validated by comparing results on the model with experimental data for flow past a cylinder. Then, the model was applied to a test case representing flow over dunes. After validating the hydrodynamics, the model was used to assess the bottom shear stress, using both a RANS and a LES approach. Com-parison highlighted the potential contribution of LES to investigating the hydrodynamic forces acting on the bottom

On nodal modulations of tidal-stream energy resource in north-western Europe

Estimation of tidal-stream turbine loading and energy yield requires a thorough understanding of the hydrodynamic processes that influence tidal currents over a wide range of timescales. In this study, we focus on the long-term variability of the tidal-stream energy resource associated with the 18.6-year lunar cycle. Three sites in north-western Europe, with strong potential for tidal array development, are considered; the Alderney Race (English Channel), the Fromveur Strait (western Brittany) and the Ramsey Sound (Irish Sea). The investigation relies on harmonic analysis and associated predictions of depth-averaged tidal currents. Results show that the variability in predicted annual power densities is comparable at the three measurement locations. This variability reaches +/- 10% over the 18.6-year lunar cycle, and is mainly associated with M2 nodal modulations which dominate the tidal signal in north-western European shelf seas. Maximum and minimum power density occur in 2015 and 2024, respectively. 2015 is characterized by (i) reduced spring-neap variabilities and diurnal inequalities of tidal currents, and (ii) increased tidal asymmetries (between peak ebb and flood), whereas 2024 shows reverse effects. This cycle also influences the annual maximum/mean current magnitudes. The differences in maximum speeds between 2015 and 2024 are of 0.16–0.17 m/s at the three sites, which represents 4-5% of the peak speeds. The simple approach considered here may be applied in broader locations as a preliminary assessment of the long-term variability of the available tidal stream energy resource. The modulations predicted from harmonic analysis are finally expected to be on the high side of the forecasting range. Indeed, the results of an 18-year numerical simulation performed on the Alderney Race suggested a reduced effect of the 18.6-year lunar cycle on the resource

Turbulence characterization at a tidal energy site using large-eddy simulations: case of the Alderney Race

International audienceSites suitable for the deployment of tidal turbines generally show a combination of complex seabed morphologies and extreme current magnitudes. Such configurations favour the formation of vortices, which can be very powerful. Anticipating the vortex effect on the turbine performance and/or lifespan requires refined description of the turbulence. Thanks to increased calculation resources, large-eddy simulation (LES) can now be applied to natural flow. An LES approach developed within the TELEMAC-3D open-source software is presented here. After validating the model with in-situ measurements, the model is applied to characterize the flow statistics of the Alderney Race. This article is part of the theme issue ‘New insights on tidal dynamics and tidal energy harvesting in the Alderney Race’

Blockage Corrections for Tidal Turbines—Application to an Array of Turbines in the Alderney Race

Tidal turbines are located in shallow water depths in comparison to their dimensions (15 m-diameter turbines in 40 m depths, typically). Constrained vertically by the water depth and laterally by neighbouring turbines, the flow within a tidal farm is subjected to blockage effects that influence the performance of individual devices. The Betz limit (which is the maximum power extractable from an unconstrained flow) can, therefore, be exceeded as demonstrated by Garrett and Cummins. Thus, beyond a significant blockage ratio, blockage effects should be considered when assessing the energy production of a tidal farm. The actuator disk method is particularly suited to simulate the flow field within an array of turbines under realistic tidal flow conditions. However, the implementation of actuator disks in coastal numerical models relies on relationships that neglect the blockage effects on the thrust and power of devices. We propose here an actuator disk formulation corrected to integrate these effects. This modified formulation, based on the model of Whelan et al., is integrated into a regional implementation of a three-dimensional model Telemac3D targeted towards the Alderney Race (English Channel). The method is applied to two hypothetical tidal farms with aligned and staggered arrangements, respectively. Blockage corrections of the thrust and power coefficients are found to have counterbalanced effects on the array production. Thrust correction results in a noticeable flow reduction within the array. However, the associated decrease of the array production is counterbalanced by the increase of the turbine power coefficient. Blockage corrections were, therefore, found to result in a slight increase, by 3%, of the array production over a mean spring tidal cycle