Geometry of Pentaphenylantimony in Solution: Support for a Trigonal Bipyramidal Assignment from Xray Absorption Spectroscopy and Vibrational Spectroscopic Data

Pentaphenylantimony (SbPh5) has been previously crystallized in either a square pyramidal or trigonal bipyramidal geometry. Investigation of the solution-state structure of SbPh5 has been hampered by the extreme fluxionality of this compound, but previous vibrational spectroscopic studies concluded that it maintains a square pyramidal geometry in solution. This non-VSEPR-compliant geometry, which is also assumed by BiPh5 in the solid state, stands in contrast to the trigonal bipyramidal geometries of PPh5 and AsPh5. A range of phenomena have been invoked to explain this discrepancy, most notably, the increased importance of relativistic effects as group 15 is descended. We present crystallographic, spectroscopic, and computational data revealing that SbPh5 in fact assumes the VSEPR-compliant trigonal bipyramidal geometry in solution. In particular, Sb X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) was used to obtain geometry-sensitive spectra that do not suffer from the slow spectroscopic time scale that has prevented NMR studies from elucidating the structure of this fluxional molecule. Sb K-edge and LIII-edge XAS spectra of crystalline solids featuring SbPh5 in either a square pyramidal (nonsolvate) or trigonal bipyramidal (cyclohexane hemisolvate or THF hemisolvate) form were compared to spectra of SbPh5 in solution. The solution-state spectra agree with those from solids containing trigonal bipyramidal SbPh5. The most diagnostic spectroscopic feature was the distribution of intensity in the Sb LIII pre-edge features. These distributions were rationalized using time-dependent density functional theory calculations that take into account spin-orbit coupling. Our use of Sb XAS not only resolves a long-standing physical inorganic question but also demonstrates more widely the utility of XAS in establishing the structures of fluxional main-group compounds. This conclusion was further supported by solid- and solution-state Raman data. Finally, we note that the present high-resolution diffraction data allow τ for nonsolvated SbPh5 to be revised to 0.216