Ideal point error for model assessment in data-driven river flow forecasting

When analysing the performance of hydrological models in river forecasting, researchers use a number of diverse statistics. Although some statistics appear to be used more regularly in such analyses than others, there is a distinct lack of consistency in evaluation, making studies undertaken by different authors or performed at different locations difficult to compare in a meaningful manner. Moreover, even within individual reported case studies, substantial contradictions are found to occur between one measure of performance and another. In this paper we examine the ideal point error (IPE) metric – a recently introduced measure of model performance that integrates a number of recognised metrics in a logical way. Having a single, integrated measure of performance is appealing as it should permit more straightforward model inter-comparisons. However, this is reliant on a transferrable standardisation of the individual metrics that are combined to form the IPE. This paper examines one potential option for standardisation: the use of naive model benchmarking

Neuroemulation: definition and key benefits for water resources research

Neuroemulation is the art and science of using a neural network model to replicate the external behaviour of some other model and it is an activity that is distinct from neural-network-based simulation. Whilst is has become a recognised and established sub-discipline in many fields of study, it remains poorly defined in the field of water resources and its many potential benefits have not been adequately recognised to date. One reason for the lack of recognition of the field is the difficulty in identifying, collating and synthesising published neuro-emulation studies because simple database searching fails to identifying papers concerned with a field of study for which an agreed conceptual and terminological framework does not yet exist. Therefore, in this paper we provide a first attempt at defining this framework for use in water resources. We identify eight key benefits offered by neuro-emulation and exemplify these with relevant examples from the literature. The concluding section highlights a number of strategic research directions, related to the identified potential of neuroemulators in water resources modelling

Two decades of anarchy? Emerging themes and outstanding challenges for neural network river forecasting

This paper traces two decades of neural network rainfall-runoff and streamflow modelling, collectively termed "river forecasting." The field is now firmly established and the research community involved has much to offer hydrological science. First, however, it will be necessary to converge on more objective and consistent protocols for: selecting and treating inputs prior to model development; extracting physically meaningful insights from each proposed solution; and improving transparency in the benchmarking and reporting of experimental case studies. It is also clear that neural network river forecasting solutions will have limited appeal for operational purposes until confidence intervals can be attached to forecasts. Modular design, ensemble experiments, and hybridization with conventional hydrological models are yielding new tools for decision-making. The full potential for modelling complex hydrological systems, and for characterizing uncertainty, has yet to be realized. Further gains could also emerge from the provision of an agreed set of benchmark data sets and associated development of superior diagnostics for more rigorous intermodel evaluation. To achieve these goals will require a paradigm shift, such that the mass of individual isolated activities, focused on incremental technical refinement, is replaced by a more coordinated, problem-solving international research body

Development and evaluation of neural network models to estimate daily solar radiation at Córdoba, Argentina Desenvolvimento e avaliação de modelos de redes neurais para estimação da irradiação solar diária em Córdoba, Argentina

The objective of this work was to develop neural network models of backpropagation type to estimate solar radiation based on extraterrestrial radiation data, daily temperature range, precipitation, cloudiness and relative sunshine duration. Data from Córdoba, Argentina, were used for development and validation. The behaviour and adjustment between values observed and estimates obtained by neural networks for different combinations of input were assessed. These estimations showed root mean square error between 3.15 and 3.88 MJ m-2 d-1 . The latter corresponds to the model that calculates radiation using only precipitation and daily temperature range. In all models, results show good adjustment to seasonal solar radiation. These results allow inferring the adequate performance and pertinence of this methodology to estimate complex phenomena, such as solar radiation.<br>O objetivo deste trabalho foi desenvolver modelos de redes neuronais, do tipo retropropagação, para a estimação da irradiação solar, a partir de dados de irradiação solar extraterrestre, amplitude térmica, precipitação, nebulosidade e razão de insolação. O treinamento e a validação foram realizados com dados correspondentes a Córdoba, Argentina. O comportamento e ajuste entre os valores observados e os estimados pelas redes foram avaliados para diferentes combinações das variáveis de entrada, que apresentaram valores do erro quadrático médio entre 3,15 e 3,88 MJ m-2 d-1 . Este último valor corresponde ao modelo que calcula a irradiação somente utilizando precipitação e amplitude térmica diária. Os resultados exibem em todos os modelos um ajuste apropriado ao comportamento sazonal da irradiação solar e permitem concluir a pertinência e o adequado desempenho desse método para estimar fenômenos complexos como a irradiação solar