The Impact of Second-Shell Nucleotides on Ligand Specificity in Cyclic Dinucleotide Riboswitches

Ligand specificity is an essential requirement for all riboswitches. Some variant riboswitches utilize a common structural motif, yet through subtle sequence differences, they are able to selectively respond to different small molecule ligands and regulate downstream gene expression. These variants discriminate between structurally and chemically similar ligands. Crystal structures provide insight into how specificity is achieved. However, ligand specificity cannot always be explained solely by nucleotides in direct contact with the ligand. The cyclic dinucleotide variant family contains two classes, cyclic-di-GMP and cyclic-AMP-GMP riboswitches, that were distinguished based on the identity of a single nucleotide in contact with the ligand. Here we report a variant riboswitch with a mutation at a second ligand-contacting position that is promiscuous for both cyclic-di-GMP and cyclic-AMP-GMP despite a predicted preference for cyclic-AMP-GMP. A high-throughput mutational analysis, SMARTT, was used to quantitatively assess thousands of sites in the first- and second-shells of ligand contact for impacts on ligand specificity and promiscuity. In addition to nucleotides in direct ligand contact, nucleotides more distal from the binding site, within the J1/2 linker and the terminator helix, were identified that impact ligand specificity. These findings provide an example of how nucleotides outside the ligand binding pocket influence the riboswitch specificity. Moreover, these distal nucleotides could be used to predict promiscuous sequences

The Impact of Second-Shell Nucleotides on Ligand Specificity in Cyclic Dinucleotide Riboswitches

Ligand specificity is an essential requirement for all riboswitches. Some variant riboswitches utilize a common structural motif, yet through subtle sequence differences, they are able to selectively respond to different small molecule ligands and regulate downstream gene expression. These variants discriminate between structurally and chemically similar ligands. Crystal structures provide insight into how specificity is achieved. However, ligand specificity cannot always be explained solely by nucleotides in direct contact with the ligand. The cyclic dinucleotide variant family contains two classes, cyclic-di-GMP and cyclic-AMP-GMP riboswitches, that were distinguished based on the identity of a single nucleotide in contact with the ligand. Here we report a variant riboswitch with a mutation at a second ligand-contacting position that is promiscuous for both cyclic-di-GMP and cyclic-AMP-GMP despite a predicted preference for cyclic-AMP-GMP. A high-throughput mutational analysis, SMARTT, was used to quantitatively assess thousands of sites in the first- and second-shells of ligand contact for impacts on ligand specificity and promiscuity. In addition to nucleotides in direct ligand contact, nucleotides more distal from the binding site, within the J1/2 linker and the terminator helix, were identified that impact ligand specificity. These findings provide an example of how nucleotides outside the ligand binding pocket influence the riboswitch specificity. Moreover, these distal nucleotides could be used to predict promiscuous sequences

The Impact of Second-Shell Nucleotides on Ligand Specificity in Cyclic Dinucleotide Riboswitches

Ligand specificity is an essential requirement for all riboswitches. Some variant riboswitches utilize a common structural motif, yet through subtle sequence differences, they are able to selectively respond to different small molecule ligands and regulate downstream gene expression. These variants discriminate between structurally and chemically similar ligands. Crystal structures provide insight into how specificity is achieved. However, ligand specificity cannot always be explained solely by nucleotides in direct contact with the ligand. The cyclic dinucleotide variant family contains two classes, cyclic-di-GMP and cyclic-AMP-GMP riboswitches, that were distinguished based on the identity of a single nucleotide in contact with the ligand. Here we report a variant riboswitch with a mutation at a second ligand-contacting position that is promiscuous for both cyclic-di-GMP and cyclic-AMP-GMP despite a predicted preference for cyclic-AMP-GMP. A high-throughput mutational analysis, SMARTT, was used to quantitatively assess thousands of sites in the first- and second-shells of ligand contact for impacts on ligand specificity and promiscuity. In addition to nucleotides in direct ligand contact, nucleotides more distal from the binding site, within the J1/2 linker and the terminator helix, were identified that impact ligand specificity. These findings provide an example of how nucleotides outside the ligand binding pocket influence the riboswitch specificity. Moreover, these distal nucleotides could be used to predict promiscuous sequences

Transition State Charge Stabilization and Acid–Base Catalysis of mRNA Cleavage by the Endoribonuclease RelE

The bacterial toxin RelE is a ribosome-dependent endoribonuclease. It is part of a type II toxin–antitoxin system that contributes to antibiotic resistance and biofilm formation. During amino acid starvation, RelE cleaves mRNA in the ribosomal A-site, globally inhibiting protein translation. RelE is structurally similar to microbial RNases that employ general acid–base catalysis to facilitate RNA cleavage. The RelE active site is atypical for acid–base catalysis, in that it is enriched with positively charged residues and lacks the prototypical histidine-glutamate catalytic pair, making the mechanism of mRNA cleavage unclear. In this study, we use a single-turnover kinetic analysis to measure the effect of pH and phosphorothioate substitution on the rate constant for cleavage of mRNA by wild-type RelE and seven active-site mutants. Mutation and thio effects indicate a major role for stabilization of increased negative change in the transition state by arginine 61. The wild-type RelE cleavage rate constant is pH-independent, but the reaction catalyzed by many of the mutants is strongly dependent on pH, suggestive of general acid–base catalysis. pH–rate curves indicate that wild-type RelE operates with the p<i>K</i>_a of at least one catalytic residue significantly downshifted by the local environment. Mutation of any single active-site residue is sufficient to disrupt this microenvironment and revert the shifted p<i>K</i>_a back above neutrality. pH–rate curves are consistent with K54 functioning as a general base and R81 as a general acid. The capacity of RelE to effect a large p<i>K</i>_a shift and facilitate a common catalytic mechanism by uncommon means furthers our understanding of other atypical enzymatic active sites

Bacterial Toxin RelE: A Highly Efficient Ribonuclease with Exquisite Substrate Specificity Using Atypical Catalytic Residues

The toxin RelE is a ribosome-dependent endoribonuclease implicated in diverse cellular processes, including persistence. During amino acid starvation, RelE inhibits translation by cleaving ribosomal A-site mRNA. Although RelE is structurally similar to other microbial endoribonucleases, the active-site amino acid composition differs substantially and lacks obvious candidates for general acid–base functionality. Highly conserved RelE residues (Lys52, Lys54, Arg61, Arg81, and Tyr87) surround the mRNA scissile phosphate, and specific 16S rRNA contacts further contribute to substrate positioning. We used a single-turnover kinetic assay to evaluate the catalytic importance of individual residues in the RelE active site. Within the context of the ribosome, RelE rapidly cleaves A-site mRNA at a rate similar to those of traditional ribonucleases. Single-turnover rate constants decreased between 10²- and 10⁶-fold for the RelE active-site mutants of Lys52, Lys54, Arg61, and Arg81. RelE may principally promote catalysis via transition-state charge stabilization and leaving-group protonation, in addition to achieving in-line substrate positioning in cooperation with the ribosome. This kinetic analysis complements structural information to provide a foundation for understanding the molecular mechanism of this atypical endoribonuclease

Structural and Biochemical Characterization of Linear Dinucleotide Analogues Bound to the c-di-GMP-I Aptamer

The cyclic dinucleotide c-di-GMP regulates lifestyle transitions in many bacteria, such as the change from a free motile state to a biofilm-forming community. Riboswitches that bind this second messenger are important downstream targets in this bacterial signaling pathway. The breakdown of c-di-GMP in the cell is accomplished enzymatically and results in the linear dinucleotide pGpG. The c-di-GMP-binding riboswitches must be able to discriminate between their cognate cyclic ligand and linear dinucleotides in order to be selective biological switches. It has been reported that the c-di-GMP-I riboswitch binds c-di-GMP 5 orders of magnitude better than the linear pGpG, but the cause of this large energetic difference in binding is unknown. Here we report binding data and crystal structures of several linear c-di-GMP analogues in complex with the c-di-GMP-I riboswitch. These data reveal the parameters for phosphate recognition and the structural basis of linear dinucleotide binding to the riboswitch. Additionally, the pH dependence of binding shows that exclusion of pGpG is not due to the additional negative charge on the ligand. These data reveal principles that, along with published work, will contribute to the design of c-di-GMP analogues with properties desirable for use as chemical tools and potential therapeutics

Nuclease-Resistant c‑di-AMP Derivatives That Differentially Recognize RNA and Protein Receptors

The ability of bacteria to sense environmental cues and adapt is essential for their survival. The use of second-messenger signaling molecules to translate these cues into a physiological response is a common mechanism employed by bacteria. The second messenger 3′–5′-cyclic diadenosine monophosphate (c-di-AMP) has been linked to a diverse set of biological processes involved in maintaining cell viability and homeostasis, as well as pathogenicity. A complex network of both protein and RNA receptors inside the cell activates specific pathways and mediates phenotypic outputs in response to c-di-AMP. Structural analysis of these RNA and protein receptors has revealed the different recognition elements employed by these effectors to bind the same small molecule. Herein, using a series of c-di-AMP analogues, we probed the interactions made with a riboswitch and a phosphodiesterase protein to identify the features important for c-di-AMP binding and recognition. We found that the <i>ydaO</i> riboswitch binds c-di-AMP in two discrete sites with near identical affinity and a Hill coefficient of 1.6. The <i>ydaO</i> riboswitch distinguishes between c-di-AMP and structurally related second messengers by discriminating against an amine at the C2 position more than a carbonyl at the C6 position. We also identified phosphate-modified analogues that bind both the <i>ydaO</i> RNA and GdpP protein with high affinity, whereas symmetrically modified ribose analogues exhibited a substantial decrease in ydaO affinity but retained high affinity for GdpP. These ligand modifications resulted in increased resistance to enzyme-catalyzed hydrolysis by the GdpP enzyme. Together, these data suggest that these c-di-AMP analogues could be useful as chemical tools to specifically target subsections of second-messenger signaling pathways

Fluoride export (FEX) proteins from fungi, plants and animals are 'single barreled' channels containing one functional and one vestigial ion pore

<div><p>The fluoride export protein (FEX) in yeast and other fungi provides tolerance to fluoride (F^-), an environmentally ubiquitous anion. FEX efficiently eliminates intracellular fluoride that otherwise would accumulate at toxic concentrations. The FEX homolog in bacteria, Fluc, is a ‘double-barreled’ channel formed by dimerization of two identical or similar subunits. FEX in yeast and other eukaryotes is a monomer resulting from covalent fusion of the two subunits. As a result, both potential fluoride pores are created from different parts of the same protein. Here we identify FEX proteins from two multicellular eukaryotes, a plant <i>Arabidopsis thaliana</i> and an animal <i>Amphimedon queenslandica</i>, by demonstrating significant fluoride tolerance when these proteins are heterologously expressed in the yeast <i>Saccharomyces cerevisiae</i>. Residues important for eukaryotic FEX function were determined by phylogenetic sequence alignment and functional analysis using a yeast growth assay. Key residues of the fluoride channel are conserved in only one of the two potential fluoride-transporting pores. FEX activity is abolished upon mutation of residues in this conserved pore, suggesting that only one of the pores is functional. The same topology is conserved for the newly identified FEX proteins from plant and animal. These data suggest that FEX family of fluoride channels in eukaryotes are ‘single-barreled’ transporters containing one functional pore and a second non-functional vestigial remnant of a homologous gene fusion event.</p></div

Growth rescue of <i>fex1Δfex2Δ</i> yeast expressing previously uncharacterized FEX-like genes.

<p>(A) The strains were grown on YPD and YPD containing 5 mM NaF to determine rescue phenotype. Plant <i>FEX-At</i> is a putative FEX gene from <i>A</i>. <i>thaliana</i> cloned into the p426GPD vector. Animal <i>FEX-Aq</i> is a putative FEX gene from <i>A</i>. <i>queenslandica</i> cloned into the p426GPD vector. Yeast rescue plasmid (pRS416-<i>FEX1</i>) was used as a positive control and empty vector (p426GPD) was used as a negative control. (B) Quantification of the growth tolerance to NaF of yeast strains described in A.</p

Model of Fex1p from <i>S</i>. <i>cerevisiae</i>.

<p>Comparison of the residues in two pores for Fex1p-<i>Sc</i> (red residues are in N-terminal domain and blue are in C-terminal domain) and Fluc-<i>Bp</i> (white). Residues in Pore II and not Pore I of FEX are similar to bacterial Fluc.</p