Effect of Facial Encumbrance on Excimer Formation and Charge Resonance Stabilization in Model Bichromophoric Assemblies

Excimer formation and charge resonance stabilization in covalently linked bichromophoric systems with flexible spacers are important processes relevant to biochemistry and functional materials. Requiring a π-stacked cofacial arrangement of a pair of aromatic molecules at a van der Waals contact, the underlying geometrical reorganization that accompanies these events continues to be debated. Here we use a variety of methods including two-color resonant two-photon ionization spectroscopy (2CR2PI), ion yield measurements, hole-burning spectroscopy (HB), and laser-induced fluorescence (LIF) excitation and emission spectroscopy to compare the gas-phase spectroscopy and dynamics of the van der Waals dimers of fluorene, 9-methylfluorene (MF), and 9,9′-dimethylfluorene (F1). The goal of this work is to probe the influence of methyl substitution on the dynamics of excimer formation and charge resonance (CR) stabilization. The fluorene dimer, (F)2, displays lifetime broadened electronic spectra and the dominance of excimer emission, consistent with a rapid (picoseconds) formation of a π-stacked excimer upon electronic excitation. Ion yield measurements of (F)2 reveal a lowering of the ionization potential (IP) by some 0.38 eV relative to the monomer, reflecting significant CR stabilization. These trends are mirrored in the 9-methylfluorene dimer, (MF)2, as one face of the π-system remains open. In contrast, the electronic spectrum of the dimethyl-substituted dimer, (F1)2, shows narrow features representing a single band system, and analysis of the torsional structure in dispersed fluorescence spectra identifies this as emission from the locally excited state of a tilted (non-π-stacked) dimer, with no evidence of excimeric emission. The structure of this dimer reflects the increased importance of C–H/π interactions in the dimethyl-substituted system, as increased steric constraints block a cofacial approach. The IP of (F1)2 shows CR stabilization which is roughly 1/2 of that in π-stacked (F)2 dimer. Extensive theoretical calculations support these findings and show the importance of sandwich-type configurations for excitonic delocalization and CR stabilization

Cofacially Arrayed Polyfluorenes: Spontaneous Formation of π-Stacked Assemblies in the Gas Phase

Understanding geometrical and size dependencies of through-space charge delocalization in multichromophoric systems is critical to model electron transfer and transport in materials and biomolecules. In this work, we examine the size evolution of hole delocalization in van der Waals clusters of fluorene (i.e., (F)n), where a range of geometries are possible, reflecting both π-stacking and C–H/π interactions. Using mass-selected two-color resonant two-photon ionization spectroscopy (2CR2PI), we measure electronic spectra and vertical ionization potentials (IPs) in the gas phase. Results are compared with model covalently linked assemblies (denoted Fn), exhibiting a sterically enforced cofacial (i.e., π-stacked) orientation of chromophores. For both systems, an inverse size dependence (i.e., 1/n) of IP vs cluster size is found. Surprisingly, the values for the two sets fall on the same line! This trend is examined via theory, which emphasizes the important role of π-stacking, and its geometrical dependencies, in the process of hole delocalization in multichromophoric assemblies

Strength of π-Stacking, from Neutral to Cation: Precision Measurement of Binding Energies in an Isolated π-Stacked Dimer

π-Stacking interactions are ubiquitious across chemistry and biochemistry, impacting areas from organic materials and photovoltaics to biochemistry and DNA. However, experimental data is lacking regarding the strength of π-stacking forces—an issue not settled even for the simplest model system, the isolated benzene dimer. Here, we use two-color appearance potential measurements to determine the binding energies of the isolated, π-stacked dimer of fluorene (C13H10) in ground, excited, and ionic states. Our measurements provide the first precise values for π-stacking interaction energies in these states, which are key benchmarks for theory. Indeed, theoretical predictions using ab initio and carefully benchmarked DFT methods are in excellent agreement with experiment

The Role of Torsional Dynamics on Hole and Exciton Stabilization in π‐Stacked Assemblies: Design of Rigid Torsionomers of a Cofacial Bifluorene

Exciton and charge delocalization across π‐stacked assemblies is of importance in biological systems and functional polymeric materials. To examine the requirements for exciton and hole stabilization, cofacial bifluorene (F2) torsionomers were designed, synthesized, and characterized: unhindered (model) MeF2, sterically hindered tBuF2, and cyclophane‐like CF2, where fluorenes are locked in a perfect sandwich orientation via two methylene linkers. This set of bichromophores with varied torsional rigidity and orbital overlap shows that exciton stabilization requires a perfect sandwich‐like arrangement, as seen by strong excimeric‐like emission only in CF2 and MeF2. In contrast, hole delocalization is less geometrically restrictive and occurs even in sterically hindered tBuF2, as judged by 160 mV hole stabilization and a near‐IR band in the spectrum of its cation radical. These findings underscore the diverse requirements for charge and energy delocalization across π‐stacked assemblies

π-π stacking vs. C–H/π interaction: Excimer formation and charge resonance stabilization in van der Waals clusters of 9,9′-dimethylfluorene

Studies of exciton and hole stabilization in multichromophoric systems underpin our understanding of electron transfer and transport in materials and biomolecules. The simplest model systems are dimeric, and recently we compared the gas-phase spectroscopy and dynamics of van der Waals dimers of fluorene, 9-methylfluorene (MF), and 9,9′-dimethylfluorene (F1) to assess how sterically controlled facial encumbrance modulates the dynamics of excimer formation and charge resonance stabilization (CRS). Dimers of fluorene and MF show only excimer emission upon electronic excitation, and significant CRS as evidenced in a reduced ionization potential for the dimer relative the monomer. By contrast, the dimer of F1 shows no excimeric emission, rather structured emission from the locally excited state of a tilted (non π-stacked) dimer, evidencing the importance of C–H/π interactions and increased steric constraints that restrict a cofacial approach. In this work, we report our full results on van der Waals clusters of F1, using a combination of theory and experiments that include laser-induced fluorescence, mass-selected two-color resonant two-photon ionization spectroscopy, and two-color appearance potential measurements. We use the latter to derive the binding energies of the F1 dimer in ground, excited, and cation radical states. Our results are compared with van der Waals and covalently linked clusters of fluorene to assess both the relative strength of π-stacking and C–H/π interactions in polyaromatic assemblies and the role of π-stacking in excimer formation and CRS

How outcome prediction could affect patient decision making in knee replacements : a qualitative study

Background There is approximately a 17 % dissatisfaction rate with knee replacements. Calls for tools that can pre-operatively identify patients at risk of being dissatisfied have been widespread. However, it is not known how to present such information to patients, how it would affect their decision making process, and at what part of the pathway such a tool should be used. Methods Using focus groups involving 12 participants and in-depth interviews with 10 participants, we examined how individual predictions of outcome could affect patients’ decision making by providing fictitious predictions to patients at different stages of treatment. A thematic analysis was used to analyse the data. Results Our results demonstrate several interesting findings. Firstly, patients who have received information from friends and family are unwilling to adjust their expectation of outcome down (i.e. to a worse outcome), but highly willing to adjust it up (to a better outcome). This is an example of the optimism bias, and suggests that the effect on expectation of a poor outcome prediction would be blunted. Secondly, patients generally wanted a “bottom line” outcome, rather than lots of detail. Thirdly, patients who were earlier in their treatment for osteoarthritis were more likely to find the information useful, and it was more likely to affect their decision, than patients later in their treatment pathway. Conclusion This research suggest that an outcome prediction tool would have most effect targeted towards people at the start of their treatment pathway, with a “bottom line” prediction of outcome. However, any effect on expectation and decision making of a poor outcome prediction is likely to be blunted by the optimism bias. These findings merit replication in a larger sample size

C–H/π and C–H–O Interactions in Concert: A Study of the Anisole–Methane Complex using Resonant Ionization and Velocity Mapped Ion Imaging

Noncovalent forces such as hydrogen bonding, halogen bonding, π–π stacking, and C–H/π and C–H/O interactions hold the key to such chemical processes as protein folding, molecular self-assembly, and drug–substrate interactions. Invaluable insight into the nature and strength of these forces continues to come from the study of isolated molecular clusters. In this work, we report on a study of the isolated anisole–methane complex, where both C–H/π and C–H/O interactions are possible, using a combination of theory and experiments that include mass-selected two-color resonant two-photon ionization spectroscopy, two-color appearance potential (2CAP) measurements, and velocity mapped ion imaging (VMI). Using 2CAP and VMI, we derive the binding energies of the complex in ground, excited, and cation radical states. The experimental values from the two methods are in excellent agreement, and they are compared with selected theoretical values calculated using density functional theory and ab initio methods. The optimized ground-state cluster geometry, which is consistent with the experimental observations, shows methane sitting above the ring, interacting with anisole via both C–H/π and C–H/O interactions, and this dual mode of interaction is reflected in a larger ground-state binding energy as compared with the prototypical benzene–methane system