Correlating atom probe tomography with x-ray and electron spectroscopies to understand microstructure-activity relationships in electrocatalysts

The search for a new energy paradigm with net-zero carbon emissions requires new technologies for energy generation and storage that are at the crossroad between engineering, chemistry, physics, surface and materials sciences. To keep pushing the inherent boundaries of device performance and lifetime, we need to step away from a cook-and-look approach and aim to establish the scientific ground to guide the design of new materials. This requires strong efforts in establishing bridges between microscopy and spectroscopy techniques, across multiple scales. Here, we discuss how the complementarities of X-ray- and electron-based spectroscopies and atom probe tomography can be exploited in the study of surfaces and sub-surfaces to understand structure-property relationships in electrocatalysts

Surface composition of AgPd single-atom alloy catalyst in an oxidative environment

Single-atom alloys (SAAs) have recently gained considerable attention in the field of heterogeneous catalysis research due to their potential for novel catalytic properties. While SAAs are often examined in reactions of reductive atmospheres, such as hydrogenation reactions, in the present work, we change the focus to AgPd SAAs in oxidative environments since Pd has the highest catalytic activity of all metals for oxidative reactions. Here, we examine how the chemical reactivity of AgPd SAAs differs from its constituent Pd in an oxidative atmosphere. For this purpose, electronic structure changes in an Ag0.98Pd0.02 SAA foil in 1 mbar of O2 were studied by in situ x-ray photoemission spectroscopy and compared with the electronic structure of a Pd foil under the same conditions. When heated in an oxidative atmosphere, Pd in Ag0.98Pd0.02 partly oxidizes and forms a metastable PdOx surface oxide. By using a peak area modeling procedure, we conclude that PdOx on Ag0.98Pd0.02 is present as thin, possibly monolayer thick, PdOx islands on the surface. In comparison to the PdO formed on the Pd foil, the PdOx formed on AgPd is substantially less thermodynamically stable, decomposing at temperatures about 270 °C lower than the native oxide on Pd. Such behavior is an interesting property of oxides formed on dilute alloys, which could be potentially utilized in catalytic oxidative reactions such as methane oxidation

Spinodal decomposition in alkali feldspar studied by atom probe tomography

We used atom probe tomography to complement electron microscopy for the investigation of spinodal decomposition in alkali feldspar. To this end, gem-quality alkali feldspar of intermediate composition with a mole fraction of aK=0.43 of the K end-member was prepared from Madagascar orthoclase by ion-exchange with (NaK)Cl molten salt. During subsequent annealing at 550∘C and close to ambient pressure the ion-exchanged orthoclase unmixed producing a coherent lamellar intergrowth of Na-rich and K-rich lamellae. The chemical separation was completed, and equilibrium Na–K partitioning between the different lamellae was attained within four days, which was followed by microstructural coarsening. After annealing for 4 days, the wavelength of the lamellar microstructure was ≈17nm and it increased to ≈30nm after annealing for 16 days. The observed equilibrium compositions of the Na-rich and K-rich lamellae are in reasonable agreement with an earlier experimental determination of the coherent solvus. The excess energy associated with compositional gradients at the lamellar interfaces was quantified from the initial wavelength of the lamellar microstructure and the lamellar compositions as obtained from atom probe tomography using the Cahn–Hilliard theory. The capability of atom probe tomography to deliver quantitative chemical compositions at nm resolution opens new perspectives for studying the early stages of exsolution. In particular, it helps to shed light on the phase relations in nm scaled coherent intergrowth

Isolated Pd atoms in a silver matrix: Spectroscopic and chemical properties

Over the past decade, single-atom alloys (SAAs) have been a lively topic of research due to their potential for achieving novel catalytic properties and circumventing some known limitations of heterogeneous catalysts, such as scaling relationships. In researching SAAs, it is important to recognize experimental evidence of peculiarities in their electronic structure. When an isolated atom is embedded in a matrix of foreign atoms, it exhibits spectroscopic signatures that reflect its surrounding chemical environment. In the present work, using photoemission spectroscopy and computational chemistry, we discuss the experimental evidence from Ag0.98Pd0.02 SAAs that show free-atom-like characteristics in their electronic structure. In particular, the broad Pd4d valence band states of the bulk Pd metal become a narrow band in the alloy. The measured photoemission spectra were compared with the calculated photoemission signal of a free Pd atom in the gas phase with very good agreement, suggesting that the Pd4d states in the alloy exhibit very weak hybridization with their surroundings and are therefore electronically isolated. Since AgPd alloys are known for their superior performance in the industrially relevant semi-hydrogenation of acetylene, we considered whether it is worthwhile to drive the dilution of Pd in the inert Ag host to the single-atom level. We conclude that although site-isolation provides beneficial electronic structure changes to the Pd centers due to the difficulty in activating H2 on Ag, utilizing such SAAs in acetylene semi-hydrogenation would require either a higher Pd concentration to bring isolated sites sufficiently close together or an H2-activating support

Probing catalytic surfaces by correlative scanning photoemission electron microscopy and atom probe tomography

The chemical composition and the electronic state of the surface of alloys or mixed oxides with enhanced electrocatalytic properties are usually heterogeneous at the nanoscale. The non-uniform distribution of the potential across their surface affects both activity and stability. Studying such heterogeneities at the relevant length scale is crucial for understanding the relationships between structure and catalytic behaviour. Here, we demonstrate an experimental approach combining scanning photoemission electron microscopy and atom probe tomography performed at identical locations to characterise the surface's structure and oxidation states, and the chemical composition of the surface and sub-surface regions. Showcased on an Ir-Ru thermally grown oxide, an efficient catalyst for the anodic oxygen evolution reaction, the complementary techniques yield consistent results in terms of the determined surface oxidation states and local oxide stoichiometry. Significant chemical heterogeneities in the sputter-deposited Ir-Ru alloy thin films govern the oxide's chemistry, observed after thermal oxidation both laterally and vertically. While the oxide grains have a composition of Ir0.94Ru0.06O2, the composition in the grain boundary region varies from Ir0.70Ru0.30O2 to Ir0.40Ru0.60O2 and eventually to Ir0.75Ru0.25O2 from the top surface into the depth. The influence of such compositional non-uniformities on the catalytic performance of the material is discussed, along with possible engineering levers for the synthesis of more stable and reactive mixed oxides. The proposed method provides a framework for investigating materials of interest in the field of electrocatalysis and beyond

Lattice Oxygen Exchange in Rutile IrO2 during the Oxygen Evolution Reaction

The development of efficient acidic water electrolyzers relies on understanding dynamic changes of the Ir-based catalytic surfaces during the oxygen evolution reaction (OER). Such changes include degradation, oxidation, and amorphization processes, each of which somehow affects the material’s catalytic performance and durability. Some mechanisms involve the release of oxygen atoms from the oxide’s lattice, the extent of which is determined by the structure of the catalyst. While the stability of hydrous Ir oxides suffers from the active participation of lattice oxygen atoms in the OER, rutile IrO2 is more stable and the lattice oxygen involvement is still under debate due to the insufficient sensitivity of commonly used online electrochemical mass spectrometry. Here, we revisit the case of rutile IrO2 at the atomic scale by a combination of isotope labeling and atom probe tomography and reveal the exchange of oxygen atoms between the oxide lattice and water. Our approach enables direct visualization of the electrochemically active volume of the catalysts and allows for the estimation of an oxygen exchange rate during the OER that is discussed in view of surface restructuring and subsequent degradation. Our work presents an unprecedented opportunity to quantitatively assess the exchange of surface species during an electrochemical reaction, relevant for the optimization of the long-term stability of catalytic systems